8 ms·
NetMaker: Connect Everything with a WireGuard VPN
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jeroenhd 3y agoThe feature list reminded me of Tailscale so I went looking and found this on their website: https://www.netmaker.io/resources/tailscale-vs-zerotier https://www.netmaker.io/resources/tailscale-vs-zerotier Their comparison graph at the bottom seems to indicate that the differentiating features between their product and Tailscale is that you can't self-host (ignoring the existence of headscale) and that WireGuard support is limited. I believe the latter point refers to the default Tailscale configuration that connects every node with every other node, whereas NetMaker allows different network configurations. However, Tailscale ACLs should allow you to reconfigure the network into shape you want, so I'm not sure if that criticism still applies. Their claim that "data will pass through their relay (DERP) servers fairly regularly" also seems suspect, as that's only the case for networks where UDP traffic doesn't flow between clients despite STUN/TURN, which is very rare in practice. The only advantage I can find is that NetMaker has a richer free plan and that they use the WireGuard kernel module where possible. I'm not sure why they didn't lead with that.
- webstrand 3y agoTailscale doesn't offer an official self-hosted control server, right? That seems to be an advantage of NetMaker. It has no equivalent to tailnet lock, though, as far as I can tell.
- phoenk 3y agoIt isn't official, but headscale exists: https://github.com/juanfont/headscale https://github.com/juanfont/headscale
- shrubble 3y agoYou seem very familiar with this topic... have you ever evaluated 'tinc'?
- yardstick 3y agoTinc is dormant these days. Very little development going on. Cool concept, but limited performance and limited uptake. Their approach to mesh was neat at the time.
- jasonjayr 3y agoDormant, or stable? I've been running a tinc mesh network for eons w/ my systems and it's never given me any trouble. I use git to check in the 'hosts/' folder and add/remove hosts as needed, pull down to all the nodes, and they can all connect. I do wish the encryption + transport could be as performant as wireguard, but for my needs, I haven't been pushing it hard enough that it's a concern for me.
- yardstick 3y agoI somewhat agree with you. I went with Dormant as 1.1 has been in development for years and no official stable release. Changes to 1.1 are the odd PR here and there, nothing really from the main author anymore. Yeah things like improving the encryption I would expect even with a stable but active product like this. Especially given ChaCha20’s widespread adoption and optimisation these days. Likewise I would have liked to have seen decent tinc phone clients (ios, Android). But this is a failing of a lot of VPN clients. Just look at the release interval on their news page. Honestly I think the likes of WireGuard, Tailscale, etc took the steam out of the developer. It’s a shame because I do prefer to have a diverse range of VPNs rather than just OpenVPN, IPsec, WireGuard. 1. https://www.tinc-vpn.org/news/ https://www.tinc-vpn.org/news/
- gsliepen 3y agoIt's not so much the other VPN products out there, rather no time and no other core developers. There have been lots of people contributing, some much more than others, but usually it was just to scratch their itch, after which they move on (which is perfectly fine). I'm not sure how to revitalize development if there is not a large interest from developers, and I don't want to turn this into something commercial like OpenVPN did.
- bjconlan 3y agoIs the kernel module how they claim the 5x performance over tailscale? I haven't really done any real tailscale performance metrics but can't see how else they can claim this (unless there is infrastructure performance differences).
- FabHK 3y agoThey do highlight that they use kernel space Wireguard as opposed to Tailscale which uses user space Wireguard. https://medium.com/netmaker/battle-of-the-vpns-which-one-is-fastest-speed-test-21ddc9cd50db https://medium.com/netmaker/battle-of-the-vpns-which-one-is-... https://techoverflow.net/2022/08/19/iperf-benchmark-of-zerotier-vs-netmaker-vs-tailscale-vs-direct-switched-connection/ https://techoverflow.net/2022/08/19/iperf-benchmark-of-zerot...
- rudasn 3y agoAfaik, tailscale recently made changes to their go user space implementation that actually made their version faster than the kernel implementation, at least in some cases. I remember reading a blog post on tailscacles' website about it and how they are pushing their changes upstream (wg kernel and official wg go user space implementation). Can't find the post now though.
- CalebJohn 3y agoI think this is the post you're referring to. https://tailscale.com/blog/more-throughput/ https://tailscale.com/blog/more-throughput/
- rudasn 3y agoYes that's the one.
- intelVISA 3y agoGo is a bit too slow for performant networking - not sure why people are hell-bent on forcing it into such spaces where it doesn't fit.
- GhostWhisperer 3y ago1. thanks for linking that 2. the comparison: - protocol: wireguard is now baseline - speed: netmaker is faster because it uses kernel wg - this is not going to hold true for all system configurations, certainly doesn't for macos - flexibility: feels like it does the same as tailscale, marketed slightly different as they list common use-cases – egress and ingress gateways; network shaping with acls is also possible in ts; maybe someone will write-up an unbiased comparison on self hosting - price: ts offer seems to be good enough for most users and their limits are "soft" anyway – i pay $45 a year because i want sustainable, not free looking for reasons to change and don't find any
- yardstick 3y agoWhat’s your approach to routing the mesh? Static? BGP? Something else?
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoi don't route any traffic besides the odd exit-node, and tailscale takes care of that for me the exit-node routing is for firewall circumvention - if i find myself unable to connect to git over ssh, i simply activate routing through the exit-node and continue working the exit-node sits at home where i set the rules
- ignoramous 3y ago> - speed: netmaker is faster because it uses kernel wg - this is not going to hold true for all system configurations, certainly doesn't for macos Unless something changed super recently, tailscale (per their own claims) are faster than (linux) kernel wg: https://tailscale.com/blog/throughput-improvements/ https://tailscale.com/blog/throughput-improvements/ Surprisingly, we improved the performance of wireguard-go (running in userspace) enough to make it faster than WireGuard (running in the kernel) in the best conditions. But, this point of comparison likely won’t be long-lived: we expect the kernel can do similar things.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y ago
- afeiszli 3y agoHi, worth noting another point on this. Netmaker has "Client Gateways", which allow you to generate and modify raw WireGuard config files. This is extremely useful for integrating custom WireGuard setups. For instance, generate a config file, modify it, put it on a router, and boom, site-to-site. https://www.netmaker.io/features/ingress https://www.netmaker.io/features/ingress
- afeiszli 3y agoI think it's worth doing your own investigation on how often traffic is getting relayed via Tailscale. We don't have numbers on it, but have had users who experienced very high latency with Tailscale, and after doing some traffic analysis, discovered it was getting relayed halfway across the country. Tailscale does a fantastic job at NAT traversal, but it's still a worthwhile consideration.
- latchkey 3y agoDigging through their repo on github... I'm really disappointed at the lack of `_test.go` files. This is a security product, I'd be terrified something bad could happen.
- nusak 3y agothe majority of testing is done with integration tests which are in a different repo
- latchkey 3y agoGolang is relatively easy to unit test if the code is architected to enable it (with di-like patterns) and from experience, that will catch things that integration tests can easily miss. I would rather see both sets of tests for something dealing with security.
- afeiszli 3y agoIt's definitely lacking on the unit-testing side and we should do more there, but we think integration tests are the more important of the two in this scenario, because the most fragile bits are the interactions between client-client and client-server. It's a lot harder to self-contain those tests without deploying the platform and clients on various infrastructures.
- latchkey 3y agoi'd argue that is exactly what you want to unit test. any breakage of client->unit test client or server->unit test server, should be a big no no. otherwise you easily risk backwards compatible issues.
- hackermeows 3y agoWhy is this better than running wireguard directly on a cheap instance .
- zupzupper 3y agoThese over the top services handle node discovery and meshing for you, instead of you having to feed configurations manually down to each device you want to hook up to wireguard. Convenience features etc
- notarget137 3y agoFor a non-network person that is surely a convinience. I prefer pushing my configs through ansible and not thinking about it.
- LeBit 3y agoBut then you cannot scale. You do not see the problem because you probably manage less than 5 nodes.
- afeiszli 3y agoNetmaker guy here, and I'll be the first to tell you that if you have a static setup of, let's say 5 machines or less, then there's no need for something as complex as Netmaker. It's really useful for people who have many machines, or machines that will move around dynamically. Or, if you need to route traffic through a NAT gateway. A static setup is fine for technical people and small networks, it's just not scalable. As an analogy, you wouldn't run Kubernetes if you just need to deploy 3 docker containers, but as the complexity grows, you need a management system.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoWireGuard to this date prefers A records over AAAA records which means if I'm on an 464xlat network I end up connecting over a ISP's owned proxy. Many people have complained, and there is zero response to it. Tailscale does it a LOT better.
- minimalist 3y agoRelated, from earlier this year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35584533 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35584533 Wherein the author compares Yggdrasil, tinc, Tailscale, Zerotier, Netmaker, Nebula, and ends up prefering Yggdrasil. Actually, it was this comparison that made me look into Netmaker and prefer it and I've been running it without issue for experimentation. I hope the author revisits NM. I agree that the project is moving quickly, which results in having to stay on top of changes to your configuration with releases, but they're still on 0.xx releases so it's to be expected. Since Netmaker is just vanilla wireguard with some route coordination and STUN/TURN, it's reasonable for me to wrap my head around system. Docs are written for self-hosters. These are all good signs.
- tetris11 3y ago> route coordination After reading the readme on the Github, it's still not clear to me whether it proxies everything through its own servers or not
- geek_at 3y agoNot when using the selfhosted version https://www.netmaker.io/pricing https://www.netmaker.io/pricing
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aborsy 3y agoThe use of relays is common when you connect to the VPN in the enterprise networks that often allow only outgoing 80/443. Also, you may not use the relays all the time, but you may use them sometimes throughout the day. If there is a vulnerability, one connection may be enough to compromise the security.
- afeiszli 3y agoNetmaker also has a relay setup, when you don't want to do P2P: https://www.netmaker.io/features/relay https://www.netmaker.io/features/relay
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoit's going to need a comparison page i already have tailscale setup on all devices
- FabHK 3y agoThis article (titled "Tailscale vs ZeroTier") actually compares Tailscale, ZeroTier, and Netmaker: https://www.netmaker.io/resources/tailscale-vs-zerotier https://www.netmaker.io/resources/tailscale-vs-zerotier
- jbverschoor 3y agoThe quality of information is very limited. It's as if the author hasn't used ZeroTier... ZeroTier operates on a different layer, and is therefore capable of much more than anything wireguard.
- LeBit 3y agoLike what?
- jbverschoor 3y agoZerotier isn’t limited to IP, but will happily do other protocols as well. It’s more like a virtual private smart switch
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoyea, i saw it a bit later, thanks for linking i don't really see any material difference between netmaker and tailscale
- marcrosoft 3y agoScrolling marquee, what year is it?
- brunoqc 3y agoAnother one to look for is webmesh. I hope they make an Android client soon.
- FabHK 3y agoFirst question I have: On what devices/OSs is it supported? The only resource I find is this: https://docs.netmaker.io/architecture.html#compatible-systems-for-netclient https://docs.netmaker.io/architecture.html#compatible-system... No mobile, no NAS yet?
- yegle 3y agoHow can I connect my Android or IOS device to my Netmaker VPN? Currently meshing one of these devices is not supported, however, it will be soon. For now, you can connect to your VPN by making one of the nodes an Ingress Gateway, then create an Ext Client for each device. Finally, use the official WG app or another WG configuration app to connect via QR or download the device’s WireGuard configuration. So no mobile for now.
- afeiszli 3y agoNAS should work if it's linux or freebsd based. For mobile you (currently) have to use our "client gateway", which accesses the network just using a regular WireGuard config file, which you can scan from the Netmaker UI using the WireGuard app on your phone. But it works well. However, we've got a mobile app in the works.
- joeframbach 3y agoA pain point I still haven't resolved with WG is this. From my phone, I want to access my homelab through the WG server at home, but everything else through an external WG VPN somewhere else. My homelab ip range is 10.10.0.0/24 or whatever, but the external VPN is some other range. Wireguard doesn't seem to like this. The alternative is to route my phone to home for 100% of traffic, and my home router would egress through the external VPN. But I don't want my home network to be the bottleneck, I don't exactly have the best Internet service at home. From a cursory search through NetMaker docs, I didn't see anything that explicitly shows how to configure vpns, or, I don't know what to call it, bridging multiple wireguard networks.
- winecamera 3y agoAssuming your Wireguard server at home is running Linux, you can achieve this by adding a second routing table and adding routing policies.
- _rs 3y agoIs it not possible to configure this on the phone itself?
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoNo as on most phones you cannot set up static routes.
- rudasn 3y agoWhat's your setup right now? A single wg interface/config on your phone, with two peers, one for home wg and one for remote vpn, with AllowedIPs on the home peer as 10.10.0.0/24 and AllowedIPs on the remote vpn peer as 0.0.0.0/24? Have you tried excluding the cidr of your home wg from the AllowedIPs of the remote vpn? Like not having 0.0.0.0/24, but one or more entries that end up excluding local cidrs.
- joeframbach 3y ago
- irjustin 3y agoI've been using Netmaker for a few months now and it is incredible. Bastion VPN management for all our enviornments. The only thing we havne't gotten to work is full 0.0.0.0 forwarding. Docs say it's possible (tho not fully common use case), but we always get hangs when attempting. Usually we have to use sshuttle Other than that - incredible.
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoyou're using it for office network or server infra? did you compare it to others, what made you go with netmaker?
- irjustin 3y agoServer infra on AWS. Admitttedly we didn't test any others because after looking at Netmaker we were satisfied.
- abwizz 3y agotry mss clamping
- afeiszli 3y agoThanks for the feedback. Just wondering, with 0.0.0.0, are you accessing using "external clients" or the regular netclient?
- irjustin 3y agoLove the product! Sorry for the late reply. > are you accessing using "external clients" or the regular netclient? "External Clients" on OSX Wireguard. [More Info] The use case that we have is when we need access an Akami Network through a whitelisted IP during development. Our AWS networks have a Priv Subnet w/ a static IP NAT and a Public Subnet, both prod and staging. Since wanted our all our local machine's traffic to go through the AWS NAT we hoped for: Local -> Bastion EC2 (Public Subnet) -> EC2 (Private Subnet) -> NAT -> Internet. So to get setup, we tested: Local -> Bastion EC2 (Public Subnet) -> Internet. When we set the Bastion EC2 to have Egress of 0.0.0.0 the Wireguard's Handshake would never complete, just hang. Let me know if there's anything else I can provide.
- Dalewyn 3y ago[flagged]
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoyour not the first to complain about it[0], the tone is uncalled for - you can just cmd + w that tab and move on + use it as a signal when picking your service provider [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37143046 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37143046
- Dalewyn 3y agoI can close the tab easily enough, yes. If I was a prospective customer though, he just lost a potential sale. Also, flagging? I'm not surprised, of course; this place is as left as it gets.
- camdenlock 3y agoWTF does “left” have to do with it?
- Dalewyn 3y ago[flagged]
- mynameisvlad 3y agoOr maybe, just maybe, posting a comment that is egregiously outside the guidelines of the site means that people will see it and appropriately flag it. Not everything is political and it’s showing that that is what you immediately jumped to. > Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes. > Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. That tramples curiosity. > Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—e.g. article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting. > Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.
- brabel 3y agoTangent question about WireGuard: I use the VPN at work, but the DNS does not seem to be working properly on MacOS. The VPN is configured to use an internal IP for DNS, like 192.168.10.200, but when the VPN is on, that address is not routing properly (it seems the route is not going through the VPN so nothing is found, even if the VPN config does include that IP range). Anyone knows how to get this sort of stuff fixed?
- rudasn 3y agoMaybe it's because you have the dns ip on the allowed ips list, causing the dns queries to go through the tunnel? tcpdump or a similar tool may be helpful in this case to see where / how traffic is handled.
- chinathrow 3y agoI have to connect a Mac on latest OS to a Windows 7 PC on the same LAN to get access to an established VPN (L2TP/IPsec) on that machine. I have never seen a confusing space as the VPN world. While I can connect e.g. to a SoftEther VPN Server on the windows box just fine, the installation breaks the established VPN connection to the external L2TP VPN. Installed Wireguard and have absolutely no idea on how to configure that thing without investing hours...
- GhostWhisperer 3y agothis is where services like netmaker and tailscale come in, they're supposed to just work™
- chinathrow 3y agoGoing to have a look at them, thank you.
- Bluecobra 3y agoThis should be a simple problem to solve without an additional VPN. On the Mac, you should be able to add a static route for the VPN destination and point it to the IP if the Windows box. This is assuming that Windows firewall isn’t blocking the incoming connection from your Mac.
- chinathrow 3y agoI will try that, but I have not much hope - why would Windows act as a router directly?
- Bluecobra 3y agoGood point, you might need to enable IP forwarding in the registry : https://www.wikihow.com/Enable-IP-Routing-on-Windows-10 https://www.wikihow.com/Enable-IP-Routing-on-Windows-10
- javitury 3y agoFor the particular case of creating a wireguard mesh network in kubernetes, I've been quite happy with Kilo[0]. Does anyone with experience in both kilo and netmaker know how they compare? [0]: https://kilo.squat.ai/ https://kilo.squat.ai/
- afeiszli 3y agoKilo is cool! And works. It will be similar, just sort of depends on what you're comfortable with and what sort of management features you need. Some people like a UI where they can see all their nodes and troubleshoot without having to SSH, which is a primary advantage, but Kilo is probably better for smaller setups that are purely for Kubernetes.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoI remember looking at both and deciding on Netmaker at the time. Netmaker should be able to do a strict superset of what kilo does. I was able to get Netmaker running on Kubernetes by injecting the client onto each node via a daemonset.
- darthrupert 3y agoThis thing seems to open a whole lot of attack vectors in addition to wireguard's ports. Is it worth it?
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoif you can point out the vectors that worry you maybe other will be able to address them sooth your worries
- darthrupert 3y agoWireguard requires an open UDP port, by default 51820. NetMaker, at least based on the quick install manual, asks you to open up the following: - 443, 80 (tcp) - 3479, 8089 (TURN, TURN api) - 8085 (exporter EE) - 1883, 8883, 8033, 18083 (if using EMQX) But perhaps none of these are required for actual WAN/Wireguard connections and one needs only limited access to these ports in order to configure the software.
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoi use fireguard through tailscale to access multiple machines over ssh, with their setup i was able to reduce exposure as i no longer need to open a port on the router tailscale does this with their DERP servers i doubt netmaker doesn't have an alternative to connect machines behind nat routers; that would be a serious disadvantage for soho setups
- yeck 3y agoIs "fireguard" a typo or a distinct thing?
- GhostWhisperer 3y agotypo, thanks for pointing it out
- afeiszli 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jdthedisciple 3y agoWhile the website is an amazing show-off of modern web design, I'm not sure why I would need this as opposed to the dead simply good old tiny WireGuard client which just works perfectly.
- GhostWhisperer 3y agopeople that want to connect: roaming machines, machines behind nat i use it to connect a notebook to a machine that sits behind nat, and to circumvent firewall rules before i had to maintain an open port on the router, and a dyndns like process to connect to the machine behind nat, now not only is that machine no longer exposed on the internet i also don't have to keep the separate configs for the same machine (local and remote) in regards to circumventing firewall rules it's just git with keys vs git over http, i just proxy jump through the home machine and call it a day
- ttyprintk 3y agoTheir angle is SSO and 2FA for auth, targeted at enterprise customers who often need to meet compliance.
- LeBit 3y agoBecause you can't mesh at scale with wireguard (unless you have an infinite amount of monkeys).
- barrotes 3y agoMaybe a dumb question, but what are the advantages of such products compared to just configuring a "plain" wireguard server i.e. on OpenBSD? I'm not a network expert and still it was pretty simple. Do these products offer more features? What kind of features?
- xena 3y agotl;dr: you don't have to configure wireguard yourself and it can help you meet acronym compliance
- lost_tourist 3y agothis would be the big one for me. I'd be more likely to trust their configuration (security wise) than my own.
- LeBit 3y agoTry to build a mesh with wireguard. You will soon find you have a combinatorial problem. If you have 10 nodes and want to add an 11th node, you will have to update the 10 already existing nodes. These projects are automating the configuration of the nodes. You simply configure a new node and the other nodes are informed of the presence of the new guy.
- icedchai 3y agoI’ve built a 3 node wireguard mesh network, by hand, and it did get tedious!
- Lucasoato 3y agoWouldn’t it be better if companies invested more in improving Wireguard and other open source solutions? How can you trust another company for such an important security service like VPN? What if one of their employees sells you out to the best offer? In the build vs buy equation, often people forget that if you don’t own the keys of your door, you risk someone locks you out.
- Bluecobra 3y ago> How can you trust another company for such an important security service like VPN? It’s pretty easy, you just look at Gartner’s Magic Quadrant and pick one in the upper right hand corner. Any VPN solution can have vulnerabilities and any (same) company would keep it up to date. A lot of hardware firewalls have ASICS to accelerate VPN traffic and this may be a requirement to handle the amount of traffic a company might have.
- afeiszli 3y agoWorth noting, the WireGuard creator has specifically mentioned these sort of management features (user auth, automated configuration and coordination, ACL's) as out-of-scope of the WireGuard project. He wanted to keep it as simple as possible, and left it to 3rd parties to develop VPN platforms using WireGuard.
- rubatuga 3y agoNot really, WireGuard is a protocol for direct encrypted transfer of bits on the L3 layer. Do something simple and do it well.
- yewenjie 3y agoHas anyone tried hosting "dark" APIs at scale via any of these options?
- PLG88 3y agoDefine 'scale'? The earlier mentioned OpenZiti has a bunch of deployments for making APIs 'dark'... in fact, here is a blog from a community memeber - https://medium.com/@rcarrascosps/how-to-create-apis-as-dark-services-using-mulesoft-with-netfoundry-io-20de63cde426 https://medium.com/@rcarrascosps/how-to-create-apis-as-dark-.... Disclaimer, I work for NetFoundry, the company behind open source OpenZiti.
- ranting-moth 3y agoPersonally I find the landing page confusing. Some marketing text and I don't understand why this is better than just vanilla wireguard?
- xpe 3y agoFirst, I get that the landing page didn't answer your questions. Building the right "first" page for the right customer... that's a potential opportunity in of itself! Second, did you find https://docs.netmaker.io/about.html https://docs.netmaker.io/about.html ? It might help.
- afeiszli 3y agoYou might find the github or docs more helpful, which are more geared to a technical audience: - https://github.com/gravitl/netmaker https://github.com/gravitl/netmaker - https://docs.netmaker.io/ https://docs.netmaker.io/
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoYou can think of Netmaker as essentially a mesh network configuration manager that uses Wireguard under the hood to create the mesh network. It’s easy enough to connect two machines with wg. But when you need to manage fleets of them, you need something that automates discovery, onboarding and off boarding of machines, etc (Not associated with Netmaker at all, that’s just my interpretation from using their offering for awhile)
- aceix 3y agoSigned up for a few of these tools and I prefer Netmaker. May be biased but the way things are presented makes it easy to understand imo.
- GhostWhisperer 3y agowhich ones did you try and what was your take on each? i only tried one, after seeing it mention on hn and elsewhere multiple times by people i trust, but i'm curious about what hn users experience with other services
- gabrielseibel 3y agoI found it easy to setup a remote access connection to my homelab using it
- TechnicalBassy 3y agoOne thing I like about Netmaker is it establishes VPN tunnels between devices in a peer-to-peer manner using the Wireguard protocol and has an interface to manage it all.
- GhostWhisperer 3y agothat's just how wireguard based vpns work, including tailscale
- OfferFun6595 3y agoNetmaker is legit and backed by Y Combinator. It's based on Wireguard (like Tailscale) and is focused primarily around Kubernetes use. In my opinion, it is a better solution than any other zero trust networking solution due to it offering built in ACLs and traditional Wireguard/VPN features as well as the P2P encrypted mesh overlay. You may find it easier to work with zerotier or tailscale, but NetMaker is something to keep an eye on. I met the founder at KubeCon last year and he's a really approachable and nice guy. You can always reach out to him directly if you have specific questions or concerns.
- GhostWhisperer 3y agoyea, tailscale is pretty cool any idea how one would go about connecting two networks? a tailnet and a netmaker-net?
- Ellentonnq 3y ago[dead]
- LiamCooper234 3y agoDoes netmaker have the equivalent of tailscale's DERP servers yet that run on port 443 and proxy connections through https/websocket to bypass restrictive firewalls? Userland wireguard perf is worse than kernel wireguard but I don't want to give up DERP servers.
- PsychoOil 3y agoI used for awhile. it served my need pretty well. It can do fancy things but it's definitely geared towards more of a power user base. I think it's main appeal over all of the other solutions (i hope this is still the case) is that it uses kernel level wireguard instead of userland wireguard so for performance it is unrivalled. It's what I would pick if I was setting up a mesh for servers that constantly talked to each other and exchanged a lot of data
- DevelopmentNice 3y agoI like it. Use it to get around my CGNAT with StarLink (client running on home lab, docker client running on VPS with a docker instance of Nginx proxy manager joined to the netmaker client docker network so I can proxy back to my home lab).
- GhostWhisperer 3y agodid you try tailscale? they've been around for awhile and should be able to handle the same scenario
- nubukjatw 3y agoGreat stuff here
- steakscience 3y agoHow is it 5x faster than Tailscale when Tailscale also runs on Wireguard?
- linsomniac 3y agoI believe that tailscale recently (~3 months ago?) made some significant performance improvements and this comparison was from before that. But, they can have performance differences because, I believe, on Linux netmaker uses the kernel Wireguard where tailscale uses a user-space go implementation.
- farukhkhan21 3y agoI have used netmaker and their netclients inside my kubernetes cluster to have access to all k8s pods over a secure wireguard tunnel. No need to worry about ssl certificates on my admin dashboards for my longhorn, pihole, portainer, linkerd and other admin dashboards. Also, no need to k8s port forward everytime I wanna access a specific service inside the cluster network. Netmaker and kubernetes for secure and manageable cluster network access is unbeatable I think.