6 ms·
Do you think it is a given that they'll attack Taiwan and if not what do you think is the likelihood that this will happen?
by jacquesm 3y ago
Do you think it is a given that they'll attack Taiwan and if not what do you think is the likelihood that this will happen?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI don't know. I didn't think a Russia Ukraine conflict was going to happen until troop buildups were on satellite imagery (at which point we facilitated friends' extended Ukrainian family's departure to the US). A Taiwanese friend in the Midwest is bringing their entirely family over preemptively. Really up to your resources and risk tolerance. How much is Xi like Putin? How much does the CCP want reunification (regardless of reason, internal or messaging)? How much will they attempt to distract from their economy slowly collapsing? I cannot say. I can only share my thoughts on how to best prepare in order to derisk. Can't change the weather, find shelter until the storm passes.
- red-iron-pine 3y agothe buildups weren't a surprise or a sign. there had been previous buildups, often as part of regular exercises, usually accompanied with diplomatic signaling. no signals meant something was up. for example, Ukraine cut off the upstream water supply and power to Crimea and Russia marshaled troops to demand they get turned back on. it did, discussion over, troops go home. the real kicker, IIRC, was that the Red Cross/Red Crescent confirmed reports that there had been requests for a blood across Russia, and that they were delivering a lot of blood to the front. something large, like 5000 units or more. exercises can sometimes see casualties -- live fire drills involve risk -- but not 5000 units of blood level of casualties. donated blood is also only good for like 30-40 days, so if it was moving they planned on using it... there will be similar signals before a real shooting war with Taiwan kicks off.
- gustavus 3y agoRegardless of whether or not Xi wants to reunify China there is still risk. A talk I watched a while ago basically pointed out that China is making a turn towards authoritarianism right now as several major challenges are piling up, i.e. the demographic pyramid, the COVID response that caused massive problems, the Evergreen issues, companies moving out of China, etc. In response to this a turn towards authoritarianism is greatly facilitated by creating an external enemy that can provide purpose, whilst also providing an outlet and reason for why things are going poorly, and forcing people to rally behind a leader. All these things combine to make attempting to attack Taiwan very appealing for the CCP and Xi. The problem is the US has to stick to Taiwan, because if we don't hold fast in Taiwan then we also lose Korea, Japan and possibly Singapore as an ally. Things look grim for all involved. I only pray we can figure out a way to peacefully navigate this, because a war of the scale being discussed is going to be globally devastating.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoHow such a war plays out is anyone's guess. After seeing Russia's disasterous show in Ukraine, the 2nd best military in the world right now is China. But that says a lot. Those exercises they do encircling Taiwan are plans at best and in the words of Muhammad Ali, "everyone has a plan until you get punched in the face." Any attempted invasion would mean the end of China.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> Any attempted invasion would mean the end of China. That is too definitive. As you say, it really depends on what happens, it could mean the end of China, which is why I'm hoping the PRC doesn't even try, but they could also succeed without much resistance if the Americans stay put in the ryukyus and the Taiwanese can't offer much resistance.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoAny attempted invasion would have nukes used on the invasion craft. Not pretty.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> Any attempted invasion would have nukes used on the invasion craft. Not pretty. That would be MAD, I doubt the USA would go that far. But a couple of aircraft carriers and a few F-35s and F-22s...no problem.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoNukes these days are about strategic destruction of economic assets, not blanket salting the earth. MAD was only really a problem in the 60s and 70s when delivery systems were fuzzy and they were going for a wide berth. A nuclear exchange today would be much more precise. Not a complete volley to glass everything. Not to mention, anti missile tech has been black tech for years. Here's a video of a mkv defense tool made by Lockheed back in 2008 https://wwe.youtube.com/watch?v=KBMU6l6GsdM&pp=ygUhTG9ja2hlZWQgZmxvYXRpbmcgZGVmZW5zZSByb2NrZXQg https://wwe.youtube.com/watch?v=KBMU6l6GsdM&pp=ygUhTG9ja2hlZ... This is the stuff they show off. Imagine the stuff they haven't shown yet. I am not worried at all.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoLike Ukraine, it also depends heavily on US political and military actions. I expect an invasion would be triggered if the US were to significanty expand the Taiwan Relation Act, or intitiate a new mutual defense treaty.
- Melting_Harps 3y ago> I didn't think a Russia Ukraine conflict was going to happen until troop buildups were on satellite imagery. I still can't believe this, even locals didn't take it serious when Russia put troops on the border of Belarus in the late Spring and early Summer when Isreal and Palestein where bombing eaching other so it loss the covers. I was in Ukraine in the Fall, during the Belarusian and Polish proxy war and crossed the border and even the Polish President felt it was very likely to lead to escalation. It was so surreal, and I cannot explain it, but it was almost overnight how the sentiment changed when that happened in W. Ukraine. I'm not a sage at these things, but most don't realize that after large economic catastrophes (like COVID was) that nation's are prone to go to senseless wrs in order to keep their imaginary bookkeeping afloat. Russia threw the entire sink at this in order to justify it, from nazi pedophiles to liberation etc... and most Russians (barring the short lived protests and subsequent exodus) just went along with it--I should note that WMD-fevor took the US and led it down a long road of apathy as well. Still, it was more sureal what happened after the invasion; lots of Europe just went on like it wasn't happening. People still went on vacation, races in Europe still went on etc... this was all on the backdrop of the Russians occupying and digging up Chernobyl and shelling Zaporizhzhia (Europe's largest nuclear plant). And then blew the dam and caused the largest man-made environmental disaster in living memory and the war just went on. If I'm honest, I'm still processing this and it's still utterly insanity to me that this is taking place in my Lifetime after having heard 'never again' being forced down my throat since I was a child and being told that immense sacrifice was made in Europe so this would never happen again. But in reality was inevitable because the West keeps funding these despots and allowing corps to offshore to them to labour arbitrage in the futile attempt of 'endless efficiency' or what ever BS they sell it as and then seeing the light and drafting legislation that creates windfalls for them Domestically in the end anyway. Again, it all feels Kafkaesque and I don't know how to remedy this melancholy and depressing listlessness that comes with it. Has Humanity really sunk this low?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- qwytw 3y ago> WMD-fevor took the US and led it down a long road of apathy as well To be fair the conventional part of the Iraq war was an overwhelming victory and even if we look at the entire period between 2003 and 2011 less than 10x American soldiers died than just Russians alone in the first year of the war in Ukraine. The number of casualties on both sides just seems inconceivable high compared to any war any(?) western power fought in since Korea. Less Americans died during the entire 15 or so years in Vietnam. During the Afghanistan war (which supposedly had a significant role in bringing the USSR down) the Soviets suffered at most half as many losses as just in a year now... Considering all of this I find the general apathy of most Russians extremely bizarre... If Russia really suffered over 250k casualties there must be several millions of people whose family members or close friends were killed during the war yet nobody seems to care that much.
- qwytw 3y ago> happen until troop buildups were on satellite imagery Taiwan is an island though. Which makes it significantly harder and costlier to invade. Even without direct US involvement occupying it militarily would be never tricky (as long as Taiwan doesn't surrender in the early stages) especially if they don't want to raze every building/factory/etc. to the ground.
- hotdogscout 3y agoA U.S. Air Force general issued a memo [based on his gut] instructing officers to prepare for a possible military conflict with China over Taiwan in 2025. https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-relations/Taiwan-tensions/U.S.-general-predicts-China-conflict-over-Taiwan-in-2025 https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-relations/Tai...
- dilippkumar 3y agoThis is the best presentation I've seen on China's war preparations. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=98kMSEkPiLo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=98kMSEkPiLo
- jacquesm 3y agoOk, I watched the whole thing including the Q&A, I think it makes a lot of valid points but suffers from lumping in weak and strong elements as though they have equal weight and there is unnecessary sniping at the democrats/'left' which mars an otherwise reasonably well made case. Most of the stuff presented I was already aware of but seeing it all laid out at once does make me wonder if I have been underestimating how far along this all is and whether or not at some level in the Chinese hierarchy a plan has already been set in motion. Disturbing.
- Analemma_ 3y agoUnfortunately, I think the probability is pretty significant. Metaculus currently predicts a 1-in-3 chance of invasion by 2035, which sounds about right to me, maybe even a little low. A whole lot of signs/incentives pointing in that direction: - China's grim demographic trends mean that there will never be a better time than now: it only gets harder, with fewer fighting-age men available, the longer they wait. - The "decade of concern" [0] means that the U.S. armed forces will be uniquely unprepared to defend Taiwan in the 2020's and early 2030's because of a generational equipment overhaul, but will be better-positioned after that. - China is very aware that America's huge industrial mobilization for WWII is what pulled it out of the Great Depression. - The years of 10% annual economic growth are gone - not even necessarily because of mismanagement (although there's been plenty of that too), but because growth eventually taps out to developed-country levels. War is excellent for shoring up stagnating support with both the general public and hardliners. [0]: https://scholars-stage.org/welcome-to-the-decade-of-concern/ https://scholars-stage.org/welcome-to-the-decade-of-concern/
- mr_00ff00 3y ago> China is very aware that America's huge industrial mobilization for WWII is what pulled it out of the Great Depression. I don’t think this is a valid point. 1. China’s economy is not anywhere near as bad as the US and the Globe in the Great Depression 2. Despite the fact people say this fact, it’s debated among economists if this is true. Many say the production of the war just “hid” the economic issues and that the depression didn’t truly end until after the war. And most importantly: 3. That is very anecdotal. There are many many many examples of nations in economic turmoil and a major war making things way worse. See: Russia in World War I
- hnfong 3y agoI'm wondering whether "waging a war to get out of an economic depression" is just a falsehood repeated many times. If it is generally feasible to use war as a way to fix an economy, why can't nations just declare war on an imagined enemy (eg. shoot nukes at Mars or send stormtroopers to the Moon)? Arguably the space race was just doing that, but it didn't seem to fix the economy of the Soviet Union. In the case of WWII, it seems to me, as a layman, the post-war dominance of the US came from the fact that the US didn't engage in the war until the very end, and economies of other developed nations were simply decimated by the war and recovered less quickly than the US. Maybe war can boost GDP numbers in the short term, but it's quite obvious that from history, at least if you lose a war, it's going to set back your economy, and in no way going to make it better.