5 ms·
The Chinese economy is running on vapors and if it gets any worse they'll need a distraction.
by jacquesm 3y ago
The Chinese economy is running on vapors and if it gets any worse they'll need a distraction.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe right time to leave Taiwan is sometime between now and when the first shot is fired.
- audunw 3y agoIf you want to leave Taiwan in the case China invades, the right time is when China makes actual preperations for an invasion. For China to execute an invasion, or even just a blockade, requires a lot of preperations that will be easily visible on satellite images. It'd be easier to see coming that Russias invasion of Ukraine, and if you remember the US told us with near certainty that Russia was going to invade just before they did. Most people with insight into Taiwan-China relations consider a blockade the likely first move. Perhaps even the only viable one. Considering the number of US citizens living/working in Taiwan, they'd probably escalate slowly in a way that would signal foreigners that they should leave the island. If no US citizens is hurt in the first strike, there's a chance US won't bother getting involved. But if China, without any warning, just lobs some missiles at major cities, and US citizens gets killed, what do you think the result would be? Seriously, we've been through this before the last time DPP was in power. The moment KMT was elected the aggressions stopped. If you look deeper at their signs of aggression, it becomes clear they're mostly for show. To keep DPP and its voter just scared enough to not make major moves towards formal independence. You know when you should actually get worried? When China starts to pick small winnable fights aimed towards training their military in real conflicts. They have zero practical experience. The PLAs last real fight was their skirmish with Vietnam that they lost with great humiliation. They need to escalate gradually to weed out issues caused by corruption and complacency. And Russia has now shown that even that might not be enough when it comes to the final big conflict. The problem for China here is that they have no viable small neighbors to pick at. Maybe Kinmen and Matsu islands, or some of Taiwans tiny remote islands with military bases. But that's very risky because it'd likely make people think they've triggered a full conflict with Taiwan which would trigger a rapid arms build-up in Taiwan along with possible crippling sanctions against China. Ideally they'd pick a fight somewhere else to make people think they're not yet focused on Taiwan. Like Russia with Georgia and Syria. China's viable strategy for taking Taiwan is just a giant contradiction: they need to go straight for Taiwans main island in a surprise attack in a way that minimizes the chance of US involment to have a remotely decent chance of success. But that excludes the possibility of gaining real practical experience they desperately need for that very same invasion, and it maximizes the risk of collateral damage to innocent US citizens.
- jacquesm 3y agoChina has already done several 'exercises' with substantial build up of material and troops, those would be very hard to distinguish from the real thing. So what constitutes 'actual preparations' is going to be hard to define short of playing it safe and leaving now.
- tim333 3y agoIt'd be quite hard for China to get far with invading. Anti ship missiles are pretty good these days - look at Russia having to keep it's fleet a good distance from Ukraine to avoid them being sunk.
- jacquesm 3y agoDo you think it is a given that they'll attack Taiwan and if not what do you think is the likelihood that this will happen?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI don't know. I didn't think a Russia Ukraine conflict was going to happen until troop buildups were on satellite imagery (at which point we facilitated friends' extended Ukrainian family's departure to the US). A Taiwanese friend in the Midwest is bringing their entirely family over preemptively. Really up to your resources and risk tolerance. How much is Xi like Putin? How much does the CCP want reunification (regardless of reason, internal or messaging)? How much will they attempt to distract from their economy slowly collapsing? I cannot say. I can only share my thoughts on how to best prepare in order to derisk. Can't change the weather, find shelter until the storm passes.
- red-iron-pine 3y agothe buildups weren't a surprise or a sign. there had been previous buildups, often as part of regular exercises, usually accompanied with diplomatic signaling. no signals meant something was up. for example, Ukraine cut off the upstream water supply and power to Crimea and Russia marshaled troops to demand they get turned back on. it did, discussion over, troops go home. the real kicker, IIRC, was that the Red Cross/Red Crescent confirmed reports that there had been requests for a blood across Russia, and that they were delivering a lot of blood to the front. something large, like 5000 units or more. exercises can sometimes see casualties -- live fire drills involve risk -- but not 5000 units of blood level of casualties. donated blood is also only good for like 30-40 days, so if it was moving they planned on using it... there will be similar signals before a real shooting war with Taiwan kicks off.
- gustavus 3y agoRegardless of whether or not Xi wants to reunify China there is still risk. A talk I watched a while ago basically pointed out that China is making a turn towards authoritarianism right now as several major challenges are piling up, i.e. the demographic pyramid, the COVID response that caused massive problems, the Evergreen issues, companies moving out of China, etc. In response to this a turn towards authoritarianism is greatly facilitated by creating an external enemy that can provide purpose, whilst also providing an outlet and reason for why things are going poorly, and forcing people to rally behind a leader. All these things combine to make attempting to attack Taiwan very appealing for the CCP and Xi. The problem is the US has to stick to Taiwan, because if we don't hold fast in Taiwan then we also lose Korea, Japan and possibly Singapore as an ally. Things look grim for all involved. I only pray we can figure out a way to peacefully navigate this, because a war of the scale being discussed is going to be globally devastating.
- tenpies 3y agoAlso unlike for Ukrainians, where you leave to might be incredibly important. How many Western countries are CCP-infiltrated to the point where a VIP Taiwanese could be at risk even there? Canada for example seems to be completely beholden to the CCP, from the Prime Minister's Office down to city-level CCP police stations. Also, Canada is famously lax on violent crime so a quick car accident or getting one of the persons with extraordinary judicial privilege to kill you is all it takes.
- hnfong 3y agoI think the GP is saying the average commoner should leave before a war starts. If you're a politically important person, well, good luck if war breaks out. During times of peace, the risk isn't as great -- I know a couple "VIP Hong Kongers" who are still abroad and alive (and not like, living in a super reclusive lifestyle), and if CCP wanted they could do the things you mentioned. AFAIK it's generally considered something of a last resort since the CCP wants people to view them as civilized and respecting the rule of law (I know this isn't their image in the West, and they're trying to change it, with mixed success). Which is why I think it's only a real risk if war breaks out.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 3y agoIt's only running on vapors when compared to itself, though. It's still vastly outperforming e.g. the US. We'd kill for 4.5% growth.
- willcipriano 3y ago> We'd kill for 4.5% growth. Speak for yourself. I'm not a member of the cult of the always upward line. Regular people don't really benefit from this growth.
- astrange 3y agoThey very much do. The CCP is in power entirely because economic growth has been so consistently good. The people would've gotten rid of them otherwise. And in the US, do you remember 2008-2010? That's what no growth is like. It means you don't have a job.
- willcipriano 3y ago> It means you don't have a job. Only when paired with unlimited immigration, population is on the decline otherwise, no job growth plus a falling population is a great situation for workers.
- astrange 3y agoImmigrants are a positive demand shock and make it more likely that you have a job. No growth may be good for retirees. It's bad for workers though.
- willcipriano 3y ago> Immigrants are a positive demand shock Ask low skill workers how that's been working out for them. The effects of this positive demand hasn't made it to them, instead they control less of the economy year after year.
- Workaccount2 3y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 3y agoIf you have something to say then say it.
- Workaccount2 3y agoChina has been on the "brink of collapse" for over 15 years now. Wake me up when it actually happens.
- jacquesm 3y agoI am not aware of China having been 'on the brink of collapse for over 15 years now', in fact they were doing quite well, right up to COVID. And since then it has been a fairly long series of bad news, resulting in mass unemployment and significant economic slowdown, in part due to the reduced demand from the rest of the world. https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/baltic https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/baltic Is an interesting chart, it shows a significant slowdown in Western demand which combined with the COVID aftereffects in China itself is having a serious effect on the economy. Whether it is enough to push China into a deep recession is anybody's guess but that is mostly because the figures of industrial output produced by the authorities are hard to confirm, so people tend to take them with a very large grain of salt. I don't think China's economy will crash hard unless either Europe's or the US's goes into a deep recession too but I can't rule that out either and I suspect that China will go down a lot harder in case that does happen because the internal economy is relatively weak compared to their exports. This is a serious vulnerability in their setup.
- Workaccount2 3y agoMy comment doesn't come from a place of careful analysis of China's economy. It comes from a place of headlines and online strangers over the last 15 years saying "China is toast next year" and it just never happens.
- outside1234 3y agoThis is the big worry we should all have and why we need to get our supply chain out of China + Taiwan as fast as possible