3 ms·
It's all about risk. Currently the loans don't factor in the associated risks, and therefore are unlimited streams of funny money. The expected value of the de
by echelon 3y ago
It's all about risk. Currently the loans don't factor in the associated risks, and therefore are unlimited streams of funny money.
The expected value of the degree, the cost of the degree program, chance of graduation, chance of employment, student risk factors (grades, attendance), etc. are important, yet not considered.
When pricing is artificially kept independent of the underlying risk model, it leads to the kind of huge distortion we see today.
All of this is immediately obvious, of course. But the counter argument has weight too -- that putting risk into the equation isn't equitable. Poor and underserved students won't receive the same access.
A healthy medium might be to allow federal loans to continue for only programs with an expected value in four years that exceeds that of the degree program cost plus loan interest plus double the cost of living. Basically, just STEM, nursing, radiology, etc. at mostly community colleges and state universities. If you want an art school history major, you need a real loan.
- haldujai 3y ago> Basically, just STEM, nursing, radiology, etc. So "Basically, STEM or STEM-adjacent"? (depending how consider nursing) > The expected value of the degree To society or the individual? Calculated how? > If you want an art school history major, you need a real loan. So only rich people are allowed to be educated in the humanities unless you're willing to get what will be a very expensive and likely cost-prohibitive private loan? This seems like a step backwards. > A healthy medium might be to allow federal loans to continue for only programs with an expected value in four years that exceeds that of the degree program cost plus loan interest plus double the cost of living So basically only engineers? This wouldn't apply to anyone getting a graduate degree or even most other professions. A mathematician from MIT entering academia wouldn't meet this calculation. Neither would almost all physicians, even if you ignore years spent in residency, unless they're moving somewhere with a very low COL. Respectfully, as someone with a humanities undergraduate and two graduate STEM degrees, I find your proposition incredibly shortsighted and fails to consider the individual and societal value of non-STEM degrees beyond direct salary. I would argue my undergraduate degree has provided me far more value, financial and otherwise, than either of my other degrees.
- lsmeducation 3y agoHow much is the cost of your undergraduate major on average nationwide? Do you believe it is accurately priced in comparison to a STEM major? It’s a pricing issue. If we don’t agree it’s a pricing issue, then let’s pay everyone the same salary regardless of profession. There’s ideological value in everything, but we’re talking business here. The colleges CHARGE you something. They don’t gift you anything out of virtue. So talk money. I’d be willing to even accept a Nicotine warning label of sorts that colleges tell an English major at the start (and the parents). “hazardous warning label: hey, we are going to charge you 15k a year for this. you won’t likely make more than X in the real world with this degree. You cool with it? No refunds.”
- haldujai 3y agoI don't know the national average of my major. I paid something around 35-40k/year in tuition for an english literature degree. My MD and MS (CS) were more expensive but also done later. All undergraduate degrees in the US have a pricing issue. I don't believe anyone should be paying 30-60k/year for one. > There’s ideological value in everything, but we’re talking business here. No, we're talking about university education which should not be a business. I don't consider an undergraduate degree training for a specific job, that's what technical colleges are for. If you want to argue we shouldn't subsidize university in general I could understand that but think it's a bad idea. I don't agree that STEM degrees are inherently more valuable than the humanities from a general education perspective which is what I view undergraduate degrees as. If we treat it as a business we should only subsidize courses essential for the workplace. Why am I subsidizing a web developer or a physician taking undergraduate calculus and physics? Having worked as both I have needed neither. > “hazardous warning label: hey, we are going to charge you 15k a year for this. you won’t likely make more than X in the real world with this degree. You cool with it? No refunds.” I think it's common knowledge that STEM graduates earn more, this was the case when I was in high school during the 2000s.
- lsmeducation 3y agoNo, we're talking about university education which should not be a business. Money and loans are involved, people pay, and people get paid. If we go even further on the money part, many consider it an investment. Anyways. Perhaps we should make the core liberal arts courses free of charge, and then create a pricing model for professional courses where the pricing model is more realistic about what is being offered, for what price, where the question truly becomes “is this worth it?”. That way we can finally separate the holiness of a core education away from specialized professional paths.