8 ms·
Peter Pan copyright
- version_five 3y agoI'm sure someone has already pointed out the irony of a story about a kid that refuses to grow up being granted perpetual copyright. I would have rather the government (through a third party) estimated the present value of the hypothetical royalties and set up an endowment if they wanted to support this hospital, rather than pervert copyright law for special interests.
- cryptonector 3y agoMost of the relevant copyrights are expired everywhere. The last ones expire this coming December.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoExcept in the UK, where a 1988 act provides special copyright status to "Peter Pan" that gives GOSH royalties for performances and adaptations, publications and broadcasts forever.
- cryptonector 3y agoOh, thanks for that correction.
- barbazoo 3y agoIt would really suck if all of a sudden the government would have to make sure the hospital is fully funded. /s
- hgsgm 3y agoStrange because in the UK, hospitals are allegedly fully funded by the government.
- chris_wot 3y agoNot after over a decade of Tory rule.
- rjmunro 3y agoThe hospital is "fully" funded, which means they pay for doctors and treatments and stuff, but most (maybe all) UK hospitals have a charity arm that pays for some extras, like refurbishment of rest and waiting areas and things like toys for kids to play with. Because Great Ormond Street is the UKs top children's hospital, kids get referred there from all over the country so their charity also fund places for families to stay nearby and sometimes pay for travel. Great Ormond Street's charity raises enough money to also make grants for research into childhood disease and stuff. https://www.gosh.org/what-we-do/ https://www.gosh.org/what-we-do/
- rvnx 3y ago"The various uses of Peter Pan that have given the hospital money throughout most of the years since Barrie's death in 1937, will continue in the UK at least thanks to former prime minister Jim Callaghan. Encouraged by his wife Audrey, who was a chairwoman of Great Ormond Street, Callaghan successfully campaigned to get the UK's 1988 copyright act amended to give the hospital the unique right to royalties from stage performances of Peter Pan and any adaptation of the play forever." Very convenient.
- thathndude 3y agoA little marital cronyism! Gotta love it. To be clear, I’m fully in support of the cause. But this is still cronyism.
- rvnx 3y agoCool word to learn as non-native English speaker! Never heard of it before. I thought you were mentioning Cryonism, or Crayonism. I wondered what kind of religion that was.
- Jochim 3y agoIt's the word that's used in place of "corruption" when speaking of one's own country. Corruption is a rude and dirty word. It's use would besmirch the good reputation of those engaging in it. Cronyism is considered much more polite.
- mnw21cam 3y agoCronyism is a specific subclass of corruption.
- ekianjo 3y agoHow is that even legal?
- boomboomsubban 3y agoThe UK passed a law saying it is?
- bckygldstn 3y agoYep, here it is! https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/part/VII/crossheading/provisions-for-the-benefit-of-the-hospital-for-sick-children https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/part/VII/crossh...
- ekianjo 3y agoCan they pass a law to cancel all copyright as well?
- boomboomsubban 3y agoYes, though as they signed the WIPO copyright treaty that would piss off ~80% of the world.
- CameronNemo 3y agoUK has no (codified) constitution. They can just write whatever weird shit they want and call it law, for the most part. Parliamentary sovereignty is often seen as a central element in the British constitution, although its extent is contested. It means that an Act of Parliament is the highest form of law, but also that "Parliament cannot bind itself". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_Kin...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chris_wot 3y ago
- thathndude 3y agoAnd it only took damn-near a century after the author’s death for it to expire. Copyright law on both sides of the pond is asinine. The supporters of copyright fear monger and present a parade of horribles that will flow if excessive copyright isn’t allowed. (Folks will “abuse” the Mickey Mouse character via pornography, etc). But I think history has, and will continue to, prove out that these are BS and that it’s all just a cash grab.
- concordDance 3y ago> Folks will “abuse” the Mickey Mouse character via pornography, etc Clearly these people haven't actually looked at cartoon porn sites.
- rjmunro 3y agoThat's not even copyright, that's Trademarks and maybe registered design patents. If I draw fan art of Mickey Mouse, it's copyright me, not Disney. If I sell it or use it for promoting something, then it's probably a violation of Disney's trademarks - trademarks are there to make sure you don't think something was made by one entity when it was actually made by another. Trademarks don't expire after 50 or 80 years or whatever. They exist as long as the holder continues to assert them.
- msla 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_and_Wendy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_and_Wendy > Disney was a long-time licensee to the animation rights, and cooperated with the hospital when its copyright claim was clear, but in 2004 Disney published Dave Barry's and Ridley Pearson's Peter and the Starcatchers in the U.S., the first of several sequels, without permission and without making royalty payments. In 2006, Top Shelf Productions published Lost Girls, a sexually explicit graphic novel featuring Wendy Darling, in the U.S., also without permission or royalties.
- swayvil 3y agoHey I read Lost Girls. It's by Alan Moore (Watchmen, Swamp Thing...). It's good.
- Jiro 3y agoIs a well-written Naruto fanfiction featuring Naruto and Sasuke having sex good? Because that's what this is the pre-Internet equivalent of.
- patmorgan23 3y agoI'm not seeing your point. Writing is writing, it's not good or bad because it's fan fiction or inspired/derived from another writer's work. And there are plenty of great works of writing that feature sexually explicit scenes.
- josefx 3y agoDidn't Fifty Shades of Grey start out as a Twilight fanfic?
- tialaramex 3y agoYes, interestingly it's not even notably good fan fic. So this suggests that there was an underserved audience. That is to say there were a lot of people (mostly women, statistically) who wanted to read about this messed up romance where the very rich guy with mummy issues treats our heroine poorly and she's ok with that because of the money. In some larger cultural sense that's not great, but nobody else was writing the stories they wanted to read.
- gnfargbl 3y agoSurely UK law doesn't carve out a special provision for Great Ormond Street to receive royalties for Peter Pan? Oh hang on, yes it apparently does: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/schedule/6 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/schedule/6
- masfuerte 3y agoThere's also a special law for IP related to the Olympics, though I think that's quite common internationally. Not that it makes it any better.
- zarzavat 3y agoAlso, perversely the KJV of the Bible has perpetual copyright in the UK. Not sure if God sees any of the royalties.
- bombcar 3y agoAt least arguably the Crown paid for that translation.
- orra 3y agoQuite. And if you'll excuse the pedantry, the KJV is patented, under a “letters patent” issued by The King. I point this out because these days the term patent almost always implies an invention. It's an interesting counterexample.
- helsinkiandrew 3y ago> Not sure if God sees any of the royalties God didn't write it - it was written by a committee of 47 scholars overseen by the Archbishop of Canterbury at the behest of King James the first, so the Church of England/UK State should get royalties. Although presumably most of the plot was copied from previous authors.
- karaterobot 3y agoThat does not seem to have stopped them from making endless film adaptations of the book. Feels like there's been a new one every five years for my entire life. I appreciated the comic book adaptation called Peter Panzerfaust, where the Lost Boys were a resistance cell in WWII, and Captain Hook was a Nazi officer. I assume that doesn't require licensing, because it just uses the ideas without reusing any specific, named elements. It would be better to make something completely original rather than just adapting old material, but that's evidently not possible anymore. So, the next best thing is to recontextualize it and change the idea enough, which not only makes for something novel, but also dodges these ridiculous legacy licensing issues in certain cases.
- RajT88 3y agoBangarang! In seriousness, this seems to be due to the risk aversion in the film industry which started in the 2000's: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_works_based_on_Peter_Pan https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_works_based_on_Peter... Hardly the only casualty (see: spider man).
- muzani 3y agoNazi Hook is interesting because of the hidden theme behind Peter Pan. Wendy is really the protagonist of the story (hence the original name Peter and Wendy). She enters a dream world where Peter represents her child side that refuses to grow up and Hook represents the adult side. Hook and Wendy's father are voiced by the same people in the movies and plays. So a Nazi Hook might represent Wendy's subconscious pressure to become Nazi? Intriguing idea. Though possibly it doesn't realize the subtone of the original.
- Archelaos 3y agoThat "Peter Pan" is permanently copyrighted in the UK is just an eccentricity. I might even like the Brits precisely because of their eccentricity. The reason I do not like copyright law is not because of its eccentric, but because of its normal rules with far too long protection periods.
- Ylpertnodi 3y ago>I might even like the Brits precisely because of their eccentricity. Eccentricities: plural. Thanks for the kind thoughts, though.
- rrook 3y ago> Adjective. deviating from the recognized or customary character, practice, etc.; irregular; erratic; peculiar; odd Perfectly valid usage.
- margalabargala 3y agoWhile you are correct that "eccentricity" as an adjective is a correct usage, OP used it as a singular noun in the preceding sentence, making it ambiguous whether they are appreciating the British for their eccentricities, or for the particular mentioned eccentricity. If OP's intended meaning matches the adjective as you describe, then it would be clearer communication to use "eccentricity" in this context.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoIt's not really ambiguous at all, unless one is being pedantic. "I like the Brits because of their eccentricity" is perfectly normal English, referring to their overall quality of being eccentric.
- whycome 3y agoThe sentence before it with “an”
- alberth 3y agoI always find it interesting how people want to eliminate (or radically shorten) copyright for books, and forget that copyright also applies to software code (something they don’t want eliminated or shortened).
- kmeisthax 3y agoYou have this backwards. Anticopyright sentiment started with software developers who did not want to be locked out of modifying their own computers. Free Software came first, Free Culture later on.
- User23 3y agoFree Software isn’t against copyright law. Copyleft couldn’t exist without copyright.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoSome of the early Free Software ideologues specifically referred to copyleft as a way of using the copyright system against itself, but ultimately they would have preferred no copyright at all.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> Some of the early Free Software ideologues specifically referred to copyleft as a way of using the copyright system against itself, but ultimately they would have preferred no copyright at all. If they really preferred no copyright as an ideal, they would have created a free software license that imitates the no-copyright state as far as possible in the given system: A license that does allow to distribute compiled code (executable binaries) without the necessity to provide the source code, but which also does not forbid any person to redistribute, modify, reverse-engineer, ... these binary files without having to ask for permission (with a virality in the latter conditions). Perhaps such a license would also contain clauses that by using the software, you give any other user of this piece of software for any applicable software patent (to handle the situation regarding software patents, which is a topic separate from copyright, but still relevant to FOSS). I am not aware of the existence of any such an open-source license.
- User23 3y agoThis kind of thing requires a teleological analysis. Is it really so bad for a children’s book to serve as a perpetual annuity for a children’s hospital? It certainly serves the public purpose better than a certain mouse empire that’s dictated US copyright law from its quasisovereign territory in central Florida for the better part of a century. Should we morally lump them together?
- Affric 3y agoNo, can you see? It would be far better for the copyright system to exist wholly designed for profit and us fighting to destroy it rather than one part of the system being designed to benefit a children’s hospital and us still fighting to destroy the whole system! Anything less is copyright realism!
- gbear605 3y agoIf the hospital needs to be funded, then the British government should properly fund it, based on a progressive tax code. If the hospital doesn’t need the funding from the royalties, then it’s a meaningless regressive tax that, if anything, harms children to some amount, since they can’t enjoy any works that would have otherwise been freely created but can’t be. Disney is certainly morally much worse than a children’s hospital, but that doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t criticize the hospital. And I doubt the comments here are hurting the hospital in any way, for that matter.
- pard68 3y agoDo I weep at how broken it is or laugh at the absurdity?
- MarcScott 3y agoOnly on HN would people complain about a kids' hospital getting a little extra money from the copyright of a book, which was the author's intention. As it happens, I'm off to GOSH this morning, to teach kids on the dialysis ward how to use Scratch.
- fakedang 3y agoOoooh nice! I remember when I celebrated Halloween there with my ex a few years back, when she worked there. Lots of fun memories. To the other HNers, I can tell you that GOSH is one of the more deserving places for a perpetual copyright.
- Brotkrumen 3y agoAs has been pointed out: Give them perpetual funding according to the needs of the children, not pervert unrelated systems to provide an unstable income stream.
- fakedang 3y agoYour mistake is in equating a voluntary donation by a private individual out of his own goodwill to government funding. As a private individual, if I wanted to simply give money from my work to an institution, the government should have no say in how returns from my work should be used, except if it is in the spirit of facilitating my intended purpose. The status quo is exactly what JM Barrie had intended.
- slim 3y agowhen someone uses children to get money, I'm mores suspicious, not less
- mock-possum 3y agoI think the issue is more that this kind of stunt is necessary at all - that a private memorial for a man’s money should be needed to preserve the lives of children. That hospital should be fully funded through taxes. The government should be taking care of those kids, not the Peter Pan Estate.