5 ms·
The same happened to Amsterdam. Almost none of the people that I know that were born there could live there today. Rich outsiders are buying up desirable proper
by jacquesm 3y ago
The same happened to Amsterdam. Almost none of the people that I know that were born there could live there today. Rich outsiders are buying up desirable property all over the world and it is a real problem. They also definitely will use this disaster to grab what they can, mitigating circumstance is that the fact that this may happen again is maybe causing them to pause from doing so: but that in turn should worry the residents as well.
I suspect that climate change and the resulting rash of natural disasters (though, technically they are man made it is hard to identify what would have happened normally and what not) will make whole swaths of the planet unfit for human habitation. The refugee crisis that could cause is one that will upset all kinds of apple carts. None of that diminishes this tragedy, and it also doesn't reduce my loathing of the people that would try to profit from a thing like this.
- weeksie 3y agoMunicipalities all over the world refusing to build enough housing (and hotel space) is what's pricing people out. These are all pretty simple problems to solve but there's fractal resistance to making enough room. In New York we built like 100k new units in the 2010s but we grew by 500k people and still, the default position of people who theoretically advocate for cheaper housing is to block new development.
- ethanbond 3y agoBoth are problems
- the_lego 3y agoThis is like proposing to dig a bigger basement to fit more flood water. No matter how much you dig, there will always be more water in the ocean to flow in. In the case of New York, it will never have "enough" housing - what will instead happen is, eventually, it will become so overgrown that it will be unattractive for new arrivals.
- fragmede 3y agoWhere it's the people that attract new arrivals, you may not want to move there, but there are plenty of people who do. Look at world class cities filled with skyscrapers (or even those not), they're still growing, not shrinking.
- brightball 3y agoI wonder what it would take to just start forming new towns? You don't hear much about that anymore.
- marssaxman 3y agoWhere would you put them? Every habitable corner of the globe has people living in it already.
- supportengineer 3y agoLeading to San Francisco you can drive on a freeway for almost 50 miles and see practically zero houses on either side of the road.
- baggy_trough 3y agoThat is not anywhere close to the truth.
- marssaxman 3y agoI suppose you are technically correct in that there are national parks and other wilderness areas we could choose to destroy, but that provides a pretty obvious answer to the previous question.
- baggy_trough 3y agoNew towns could be placed on, for example, farmland. There isn't any reason that a town has to use completely empty and undeveloped land. There is also an abundance of habitable land with nobody living there or using it, as a road trip around North America will attest.
- marssaxman 3y agoMy experience road-tripping around North America has shown me exactly the opposite: there are people living everywhere it is feasible to live, and then some. Anywhere there is water, there are people drinking it; anywhere there is flattish ground with any amount of water that can be piped in, there are people farming it; anywhere there are trees, people are logging them; anywhere there is grass, cows are grazing it. If land has no people, there is always some good reason nobody wants to live there. My experience is biased toward the west side of the continent; perhaps things are different elsewhere.
- happytoexplain 3y agoYou make it sound like the opposition to expansion don't know that there is housing demand in their areas - that the solution is "simple" and they are just dummies. But this feels kind of dishonest. There is a conflict between people who want to live in an area and people who don't want that area to become overcrowded (and then there's the myriad of second-order problems that stem from those two outcomes). That's the problem statement in a nutshell, and it's unfortunately complex both logistically and emotionally (and therefore politically, too), which is a disastrous combination. One of the hallmarks of that combination is that each side at even the highest levels of discourse tend to exhibit very little respect for the other (no sympathy, no benefit of the doubt, etc). One of the few things both sides should be able to agree on is that it's awful when wealthy outsiders start buying property.
- weeksie 3y agoSorry, that is a very narrow point of view that's only popular as of relatively recently. People who block housing in cities because they don't want the cities to be "overcrowded" are ridiculous because: 1. Cities are by definition dense areas 2. If you don't want to live somewhere dense, move where fewer people want to live 3. Your right to your own property doesn't extend past it 4. You are destroying productivity and allowing landlords to extract excess productivity from the whole population, so the effect is almost definitely not the one that you think it is. For smaller communities in ecologically fragile areas, there are more nuanced arguments, but even then those people should prefer managed density because: 1. Density keeps sprawl at bay and is better for the environment 2. Residents won't be able to afford to live on their little patch unless they own the land 3. Even then their area will become a museum around them and they certainly won't be able to preserve the idyll they wish to. In any case, most of the supply problems can be solved without major changes to what people often refer to as "neighborhood character". Everything from ADUs to just allowing a few extra stories does quite a bit to increase the capacity of an urban area.
- scoofy 3y agoThis is exactly the perspective of folks that aren't feeling the pain from the housing crisis (and are in fact benefiting from it). >There is a conflict between people who want to live in an area and people who don't want that area to become overcrowded Yes. Obviously. >That's the problem statement in a nutshell, and it's unfortunately complex both logistically and emotionally (and therefore politically, too), which is a disastrous combination. This is already a bipartisan issue. You can see folks like Darrell Owens arguing for it on the far-left, Ezra Klein from a moderate-left position, and Chuck Marohn arguing for changes on the right. It's only disastrous if your goal is to preserve the status quo of low density (sub)urban housing in the face of massive inequality in this housing costs. This is a classic scenario of a political minority (non-homeowners) facing a ton of pain that is trivially politically solvable, but not being able to do anything about it unless they become they eventually become the political majority... and now they are. And, more importantly, this scenario is does not lead to mean-reversion. We are in the middle of a political cascade. As the millennials become the dominant voting demographic, we should expect the pendulum to accelerate rapidly in the other direction... and that's exactly what we are seeing. For those homeowners who are suddenly feeling uncomfortable about the political winds on this topic... buckle up. If this is really a cascade (and I think it's obvious that it is), we should expect these changes to accelerate for the foreseeable future. I believe it would be prudent start planning for the changes instead of fighting them.
- throwaway290 3y agoWhere are they from? Is it oligarchs flush with dirty money from some developing countries?
- DocTomoe 3y agoMostly USA, so ... pretty much, yes.
- gruez 3y ago>Almost none of the people that I know that were born there could live there today. Is that bad? Should you have a right to live where you were born in perpetuity? What about everyone else that wants to live in Amsterdam? If housing is limited and we need to ration it, why should it go towards people who were born there? Doesn't that create a class of landed gentry that have the "right" to live in amsterdam and everyone else who doesn't?
- politelemon 3y ago> What about everyone else that wants to live in Amsterdam? What about them?
- gruez 3y agoMaybe read the rest of the comment? >If housing is limited and we need to ration it, why should it go towards people who were born there? Doesn't that create a class of landed gentry that have the "right" to live in amsterdam and everyone else who doesn't?
- the_lego 3y ago> Is that bad? Yes. A home is not an economic asset like any other. It is the biggest link to one's community and people. Healthy communities cannot form from transient populations.
- gruez 3y ago>Healthy communities cannot form from transient populations. That sounds more like you're more against airbnb and other short term rentals rather than "Rich outsiders are buying up desirable property all over the world" or thinking that "I know that were born there could live there today" is some sort of wrong in and of itself.
- the_lego 3y agoA few tourists doesn't mean the community itself is transient. Even a great many tourists doesn't mean that, if the locals are mostly static. They form a community, and watch the tourists come and go.
- piffey 3y agoCities need to be enacting high tax rates on non-primary residences, luxury residences, and investment properties. If I remember right, Italy does this well with little to no tax on your primary residence, then if you choose to purchase a vacation home or a luxury property like a villa your tax rate soars. Going into the climate crisis this will enable cities to take those high property taxes on unnecessary housing and apply it to affordable public housing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fuzzfactor 3y ago>the fact that this may happen again is maybe causing them to pause Filtering more so for those who could afford to remotely lose a future home there when it's not their primary residence, and they have nothing invested in the community other than money. Not very much different than the well-heeled investing in second homes, displacing the traditional working population in the most hurricane-vulnerable South Florida locations over the decades when the transition from small quaint resort towns accelerated into more widely popular destinations. After a different culture eventually takes over the government, then the previous culture can be further economically influenced to their disadvantage and regulated into obscurity. >that in turn should worry the residents as well.