3 ms·
I don't agree with lumping the RIAA in with municipal water or electricity. Utilities can be much cheaper and more efficient with a local monopoly than if they
by freehunter 15y ago
I don't agree with lumping the RIAA in with municipal water or electricity. Utilities can be much cheaper and more efficient with a local monopoly than if they were in competition. Imagine if water delivery was a free market: you'd have a half dozen or so companies pumping water to you, and unlike with rotatable Internet protocols, they wouldn't be able to use each others lines. You'd have to have the same amount of water lines run to your house as there were competing companies. Same with the choice of electricity: they can all use one line, but in the end it has to be traceable back to the one company who shilled out the watts for your benefit. Imagine if there were three or four competing power plants serving your neighborhood, all running at 1/3 capacity (plant efficiency doesn't scale down nicely).
No, utilities need to be monopolized for efficiency. With rotatable protocols though, you can trace who sent what to whom. That's where competition is a good thing. That's why local monopolies on ISPs are ridiculous, same with monopolies on content distribution.
- ilaksh 15y agoI don't want companies competing to send me electricity or water. I want to produce my own electricity and water.
- freehunter 15y agoWell then you get into the difficulty of actually achieving this. Lets take a mid-size metropolitan area, with a population density of 500 people per square mile. How does everyone in the apartment buildings generate their own electricity or pump their own water? And if a 1000-person apartment complex begins pumping water from directly beneath themselves, what happens when the water is gone? And where does the water go when it has been used? Where does the runoff from the streets go? Is there a water treatment plant, and if so, who resells that water? Or do we just keep pumping water from the ground in one area and dumping it back in another, until the ground is dry under the city? How many solar panels would be on a building if everyone had to generate their own power? How many wind turbines? How many generators? Where would this space come from, and who would pay for it? What if those panels or turbines could not generate enough on one specific day? Is there a contingency plan? Even if you think the current market of ISPs and content distribution is bad, don't delude yourself into thinking the Internet would exist without cities. With cities comes a need for utility management. If everyone had enough land to generate their own power and water, your Internet bills would be worlds more expensive and your control over entertainment products would be far less (what local bands will you see when your nearest neighbor is three miles away and there's no centralized location to perform?) Let me know if I've completely misunderstood your statement.
- ilaksh 15y agoI think the technical realities might not be as impossible as you assume. I don't know to what degree those ideals might be achieved, but I think those should be the aims.
- freehunter 15y agoI just realize that autocorrect changed routable to rotatable. I meant routable, as in able to be routed through a router.