4 ms·
This is a very popular idea, but it doesn’t make a huge amount of _sense_. Most office-oriented employers don’t own much if any real estate; they lease it. And
by rsynnott 3y ago
This is a very popular idea, but it doesn’t make a huge amount of _sense_. Most office-oriented employers don’t own much if any real estate; they lease it. And unless they’re really huge, what _they_ do has very little influence on the price of real estate generally; they’ve no individual incentive here. Arguably a mild counter—incentive; it’s generally to their benefit, as renters of real estate, if future real-estate costs drop.
Now, of course, you could argue that it’s pension funds and things exerting control via ownership, but again, this is a bit of a stretch; it’d require a lot of coordination, and there’s no evidence it’s happening. And this would only be a real possibility, at most, for active funds; index funds can’t really threaten to sell a company’s stock if it doesn’t do what they want. And, if this was a thing, you’d expect that the Shadowy Fund Conspiracy would have made more of an effort to save _retail_, whose bleeding out over the last few decades has been a constant problem for commercial real estate.
(Also, in most cases, it’s mostly _different funds_; even within a single fund provider, the fund that owns lots of commercial real estate and the fund that owns lots of tech company are generally different funds, with different fund managers, designed for people with different risk profiles. This would make the sort of coordination imagined here even more fraught.)
I get why people like this idea; it’s a just-so story. But it’s very hard to see how it would work.
I suspect companies are pushing for this because their leaderships genuinely believe it is good for productivity, though as far as I can see there’s an absence of hard evidence. (I personally strongly dislike working from home, and got back to an office as soon as it was allowed, but the idea that it hurts productivity doesn’t gel with what I’ve seen, at all.)
- missedthecue 3y agoWouldn't it make more sense for the wall street shareholders of the companies to end the office leases and put the resulting freed-up money into extra dividends? I agree, it sounds like a conspiracy theory. Not a lot of evidence.
- lumost 3y agoThe divergence between small and large firms tells the story here. Small firms don't own their real estate and are cutting as fast as they can. Large firms who own are forcing their employees back to the office. We'll see in 20 years which is the better play.
- moonchrome 3y agoI also believe COVID fucked productivity globally and executives thought it was a temporary thing due to measures in place. But I feel like COVID situation triggered stuff that either accelerated existing trends or introduced new problems, and I don't think there's going back. People quoting productivity drops from new hires during COVID omit insane hiring in tech - implying that remote work is to blame and not their structure inability to scale to utilize those unprecedented numbers of new hires productively. Especially since most of the hiring was aimless "we need to grow headcount to capture the market growth". People getting paid serious money to literally sit around. That's going to cascade in other ways - I feel like entire industry standard of acceptable delivery sinked Getting people back to the office sounds like a nice narrative because it's relatively easy to fix and corelate. It's also, conveniently, entirely not the fault of upper management for insane over hiring and underutilization.
- nicwolff 3y agohttps://www.bls.gov/charts/productivity-and-costs/nonfarm-business-sector-indexes.htm https://www.bls.gov/charts/productivity-and-costs/nonfarm-bu... Non-farm labor productivity – the red line, representing output per hour worked – _shot_ up when we all worked remotely. Total productivity dipped because there were many fewer workers working many fewer hours (the green line). Both are roughly back on their pre-pandemic curves now.
- gdubs 3y agoYou're missing an obvious real estate incentive: where people live. Often in very nice school districts, which they don't want to see depreciate in value due to an outflow of people to different communities. People moving into rust belt cities and revitalizing them is great for the nation, but may come at the expense of someone who's highly leveraged into a $6m 3 bedroom in the Bay Area. If productivity were the goal, then open plan offices would have been abandoned a decade ago after the nth study showing how poor they are for worker health, happiness, and productivity.
- hodgesrm 3y agoThe "elites" in the Bay Area live in places that don't have office space like Atherton, Ross, and Hillsborough. [0] They also aren't experiencing much outflow. [0] https://www.kron4.com/news/real-estate/nearly-50-bay-area-zip-codes-make-list-of-most-expensive-in-united-states-report/ https://www.kron4.com/news/real-estate/nearly-50-bay-area-zi...
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoPeople want to see “the elites” as one homogeneous cabal out to protect themselves at the expense of the little guy. In reality, it’s a bunch of self-interested individuals whose incentives don’t overlap here. The companies using office space have no reason to waste money helping out their landlords, and would much rather profit by screwing them over. As you say, this theory does not make much sense.
- zer8k 3y agoWhen they talk about "the elites" they are talking about a cabal and yes, it does exist. Vanguard and Blackrock created this environment by simply owning more real estate (via other companies) than anyone else. This, combined with their ESG score, is absolutely toxic to "the little guy". They tell their constituent publicly held companies that they're losing big on real estate and the next day 2,000 articles on the reason remote work is terrible come out. This is further compounded by one of the major avenues of reaping back money from startups is VC owned property. There isn't conspiracy here. Blackrock in particular is well known as a major buyer of real estate holding companies. Expand that from strictly finance to other facets of life and you'll fine similar cabals. Groceries? Yep. News? Yep. They do exist, and it's not simply self interested self-made individuals at the helm. They are a product, not the genesis, of the very real so-called Illuminati you occasionally hear about. EDIT: Fastest downvotes in the west wow. Open-minded HN showing their open-minded progressive mindset again.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoPlease tell me more about the naked shorts and the hedgies.
- karpatic 3y agoIt's just a matter of time gamestop's volume dries up. It's a long game and we keep setting records as people continue to register shares directly with computershare.
- birksherty 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- theonlybutlet 3y agoGenerally apart from break clauses (usually midway through a lease) companies are liable for the full lease cost and can't give early notice for termination. In accounting terms, leases according to IFRS 16 are recognized as a lease liability and a contra right of use asset for the full term of the lease. I'm not 100% certain on the rationale of an impairment (as it could be construed as no longer useful) but if these companies aren't using these properties, auditors may force them to impair their leases, meaning large write offs and accounting losses.
- worrycue 3y agoWon't they just do whatever is most profitable? If continuing to pay even if you aren't using the estate is more profitable that's what they will do - they can still let employees work from home; would save on the air conditioning and lighting bill.
- theonlybutlet 3y agoYeah, it's not so much the lease liability that's the issue. It's the right of use asset that was recognized. It's a book loss, not impacting actual cash flow. https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2021/07/impairment-rou-assets-talkbook.pdf https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2021/07/impa...
- JeremyNT 3y agoIt seems far more likely to me that the managerial (not capital) class is driving the efforts. It requires no conspiracy: if you imagine that prestige and promotions for middle managers are more about appearances than data (true in my experience), bringing people back to the office is a way to improve one's own standing. It's pretty easy to walk through a cube farm and observe the workers who report to you, and make the case that you are vital to their efforts. Looking at a list on Slack is just far more abstract.