7 ms·
So here's the backstory. Santorum has a microscopically thin but nonzero chance of winning the Republican primaries. To do so, either Romney has to all but dis
by philwelch 15y ago
So here's the backstory.
Santorum has a microscopically thin but nonzero chance of winning the Republican primaries. To do so, either Romney has to all but disappear as a candidate or he has to do extremely well in the upcoming primaries. Even then, the most likely outcome is a "brokered convention", where literally anything is possible, up to and including nominating someone who isn't even running yet.
Santorum knows that he has to win the GOP base this way. And he'll never win the libertarianish part of the GOP base to begin with (they're voting for Ron Paul), nor will he win over the sane people (they're either voting for Romney or staying home in a fog of crippling depression). So his only chance is to maximize turnout from crazy, evangelical, right-wing loonies of the type rarely seen outside flyover country.
If he somehow wins the nomination, expect him to quietly forget half of these crazy promises. If he loses, his political career is over. So he has to go pretty crazy.
- lukifer 15y agoI think evangelicals have caught on to the fact that they have been pandered to and then ignored by mainstream Republicans, and they're sick of it; in Santorum, they see someone who holds their beliefs unambiguously. While I would expect that he would go quiet over these issues in a general election, I have no doubt that he would attempt to implement bible-based policy in the unlikely event that he is elected.
- cpeterso 15y agoI think this long GOP primary is a sign that both evangelicals and libertarians are realizing that the "deal" they made with the "big tent" GOP has had a poor ROI.
- blvr 15y ago>I have no doubt that he would attempt to implement bible-based policy in the unlikely event that he is elected. People thought George Bush would do the same.
- hobin 15y agoAnd he did. He banned federal funding for stem-cell research for biblical reasons. It might not have made the USA a theocracy, but he actually came pretty close with many of his decisions.
- chernevik 15y agoAlas, Rick Santorum ("Putting the 'No' in 'Nuance' since 1991") will be with us long after he's turned over the hole cards of his busted straight of a Presidential bid. Look at the careers of Sarah Palin, Pat Buchanan, Howard Dean, Jon Stewart, Rush Limbaugh, Rob Reich, et cetera et cetera ad absurdum. Once a politician discovers some capacity to generate an audience, they go on raising money ($ for consultant buddies), selling books (royalties), speaking (speaker fees) . . . . No one expects these people to ever affect anything. But they can reliably, bankably, generate attention. Maybe they start out trying to influence opinion, but over time the audience retention imperative drives that to the background. That's one reason why this sort is so reliably brain-dead. Saying something their audience doesn't expect to hear subjects said audience to the pain of unguided thought; do this too often and that audience withers, because they're tuning in for validation of opinion, not formation of new opinion. A general campaign introduces Santorum to zero marginal conversative audience and takes up valuable time. If he won the nomination, his first move would be to demand a recount. [EDIT: Yes, I meant Jon Stewart. I regard him and Limbaugh as a species of politician -- they make their living motivating political activity of a particular bent. They didn't build their audiences via electoral politics, but once built their audience relationship / maintenance dynamics are very similar to the others named.]
- guga31bb 15y ago> Look at the careers of Sarah Palin, Pat Buchanan, Howard Dean, John Stewart, Rush Limbaugh, Rob Reich, et cetera et cetera ad absurdum. Once a politician [...] Who is John Stewart? If you're referring to the comedian Jon Stewart, when was he ever a politician? I don't think it's fair to lump him in with people like Palin, Dean, etc. Stewart has never held public office and made a career of poking fun at politicians and the media who cover them.
- icebraining 15y agoAnd to be fair, as much I disagree with the man, Rush Limbaugh isn't a washed-up politician turned commentator either, he was always a radio guy.
- smsm42 15y agoIntellectually, I understand all this. However when I read a pile of steaming bull manure that is presented to me at the link as a political argument, I literally feel sick a little. And that given that I am a libertarian (not a Ron Paul kind, but still) and so have significant affinity to some of the GOP positions and thus my prejudices lie rather in favor than against GOP candidates. I am not an US voter, but if I were, I would not be able to vote for a person that publishes such a vile idiocy under his name. I'm sure he could appeal to the same base without this - there must be other issues and things he could use as his special advantage. I don't believe one has to go that stupid.
- philwelch 15y ago> I am not an US voter, but if I were, I would not be able to vote for a person that publishes such a vile idiocy under his name. Unless you live in US flyover country and are intimately familiar with the types of people who live there, you won't understand Santorum. It's just a cultural gap. For what it's worth, I could name some popular opinions and ideas in, for instance, Europe that are just as shocking and repugnant to me.
- jvrossb 15y agoI don't think American culture is as uniform as you're implying it is. I'm from the bay area in california and Santorum's positions seem very foreign to me, but everyone in my circles around here at least thinks they "get" Santorum - it is accepted wisdom that's he's a crazy idiot. I don't think someone who isn't a U.S. voter is automatically more at a disadvantage than most Americans when it comes to understanding what's going on this election season. Curious to hear some European opinions that are shocking to you. I wonder if they would be shocking to Americans in general and I wonder if Europeans would agree that those opinions and ideas are uniformly European.
- dagw 15y agoCurious to hear some European opinions that are shocking to you. One European idea (as practised in a reasonable sub set of Europe) that I can see many Americans finding shocking are the legal limits to free speech. Gun control is another one which would shock at least a fair number of Americans (again this varies a bit across Europe, but is always far stricter than in the US). Various ideas on taxation is a third, depending slightly on your political leaning. The lax (from a US perspective) attitude towards punishing criminals as yet another.
- caycep 15y agoIs he angling for a Kingmaker position instead, i.e. extract certain concessions from Romney given that he controls a large chunk of delegates?
- aaronbrethorst 15y agoNo, I sincerely doubt it. Ron Paul, on the other hand, is doing exactly this. Word is that he's angling to get Rand Paul a leg up for a run at the Presidency in either 2016 or 2020.
- Drbble 15y agoI don't see how Ron Paul losing more publicly than ever will help Rand's career.
- aaronbrethorst 15y agoThe road to 1144 delegates for Romney is getting trickier and trickier with every passing primary contest[1]. It's possible to imagine a number of scenarios where Romney, in order to clear the magic number on the first ballot at the convention in Tampa, engages in horse trading with Paul in order to put him over the top. [1] http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/03/07/no-clear-path-to-victory-for-romney.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/03/07/no-clear-pa...
- Jach 15y agoI thought the conspiracy was a V.P. bid with Romney. I'm not sure if that's more or less made-up than the Rand Paul thing though.
- philwelch 15y agoHe's trying to maximize his delegates going forward; that will give him all kinds of leverage in case of a Romney win or even a brokered convention.
- angrycoder 15y ago> If he somehow wins the nomination, expect him to quietly forget half of these crazy promises. If he loses, his political career is over. So he has to go pretty crazy. Here's the real backstory. You have Santorum mixed up with Romney. Santorum really believes all this stuff, he isn't just saying it to get elected. He is about as puritanical in his beliefs as you can get. While I respect him for being so open and being who he is, I frankly find it frightening that he is winning primaries.
- EREFUNDO 15y agoI concur, Santorum is a sincere candidate compared to Romney. Hitler was sincere too. Sincerity is an overrated virtue.....
- tsunamifury 15y agoAside from the ridiculously crass comparison to Hitler, you are patently wrong. Hitler was a liar to the core. He framed the Invasion of Poland as a 'defensive war' which he convinced many Germans into believe Poland was actually invading Germany! He spun deceptions regularly and was known for his ability to convince or make others look the other way while he planned military actions and genocide. Just because he was outspoken about his hate for the Jewish people does not at all make him 'sincere'.
- EREFUNDO 15y agoI did not say sincerity is not a virtue, I said it is overrated. I don't think Santorum is even close to being Hitler, I believe he is overall an honest man who believes that he will do good for the country. My problem with him is that he is so certain with his beliefs. He's too dogmatic for my taste. “The most harm of all is done when power is in the hands of people who are absolutely persuaded of the purity of their intentions” – Milton Friedman
- EREFUNDO 15y agoYeah you're right. I don't think Hitler was sincere when he negotiated with Neville Chamberlain on the annexation of the Sudetenland in Czechoslovakia. No one was listening to Churchill who has been warning for years about Hitler. Who would listen to a drunk discredited politician? This time pragmatism failed.
- rabidsnail 15y agoUnconstitutional crazy positions are the best ones, because the supreme court gives you a get out of jail free card.
- lotharbot 15y agoThis is a great point. I would much rather have a president with a handful of crazy, completely wrong, clearly unconstitutional ideas than a president with a handful of just slightly wrong ideas that might actually pass. Congress and SCOTUS will block the truly crazy stuff; it's the borderline stuff that's dangerous.
- hobin 15y agoWell, yes. The problem is that a president with crazy and completely wrong ideas is also more likely to have a whole bunch of just-slightly-wrong ideas because of his (or her) complete lack of rationality.
- rabidsnail 15y agoYou're assuming politicians are sincere.
- jinfiesto 15y agoYou nailed it. I'm a Republican, but the candidates this time around are really depressing. I don't identify with the Tea Party ("angry" does not a political platform make,) but wish Ron Paul would win the primaries. I don't think he will. If Santorum manages to win the general election, ritual suicide will become a serious option.
- jonnathanson 15y agoAgreed. While it's often hard to distinguish Santorum's genuine beliefs from his pandering to the redneck vote, the distinction is somewhat irrelevant. He now stands for that base, and he needs it as a bargaining chip in pretty much any outcome that can occur between now and the convention. At a brokered convention, he'll be able to cash in that voting base for a cabinet or advisory position (probably not a vice presidential slot, but at least something) on Romney's ticket. If Romney ends up beating him outright before the convention, then he'll cash it in for a lucrative talkshow deal, a la Mike Huckabee. At the very least, and certainly in any event, he'll be able to sell a mountain of books. The point is, from a game-theoretical standpoint, there is no benefit to Santorum in backing down from his rhetoric at this juncture. He's in an especially lucrative position because Romney is so perfectly ill-positioned to win over the base Santorum has carved out for himself. (In the eyes of the evangelical, white, working-class base, Romney is every bit the "snob" that Obama is).