12 ms·
Santorum Pledges Pornography Blackout Using Lawsuits & SOPA-style ISP Filtering
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Qweef 15y agoExcellent use of tax dollars, freedom of speech, and small government.
- gfodor 15y agoIf Rick Santorum becomes president, I think the eradication of porn from the Internet will be a quaint footnote compared to the other draconian things that'll come to pass.
- philiphodgen 15y agoHeh. Yesterday the Senate passed a bill saying the gov't can take away your passport if you owe more than $50K in tax. What do you want to bet that the actual law will say ". . . if the IRS claims you owe more than $50K." Draconian comes in all flavors. We aren't waiting for the Santorum bus to drive up. It's already here.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- electromagnetic 15y agoIf Rick Santorum becomes president, I think the attempt at eradication of porn will be the headline of a very short presidency. The porn industry isn't unified and has virtually no lobbying power, when (depending on the reports you read) it brings in 1/3 of the revenue of the movie industry, without ever getting a box office receipt. When you're talking about ending an industry, not only in the US but trying to ban the global industry, you're not only going to align them against you very quickly, but I bet they would be willing to spend a lot of money to smear campaign you into the ground. Oh and look, they have exceptionally hot women that (depending on the studies) approx. 40-50% of them have worked as prostitutes. Basically, Rick Santorum would be facing an industry with the money and the means to line you up for a massive scandal that would completely destroy a "conservative family man" image.
- saraid216 15y agoUm. How would it be short? Do you expect insurrection over porn? Impeachment? I certainly agree that the porn industry would be pissed, but exactly what do you expect it to do?
- swordswinger12 15y agoClinton was very nearly impeached for the Lewinsky scandal. Don't forget the first rule of American politics: With money, all things are possible.
- frisco 15y agoClinton was nearly impeached for perjury, not the scandal itself. Unfortunately, the one bad thing Santorum doesn't appear to be is dishonest.
- swordswinger12 15y agoTrue, but given the boundless ingenuity of the smut industry, I'm sure they can think of something if they're backed into a corner by Santorum. (hehe)
- electromagnetic 15y agoI thought I alluded to what they can think of quite clearly by stating some studies suggest 40-50% of women in the porn industry do or have worked as prostitutes or escorts. I wouldn't even be surprised if the porn industry helped line him up just so they could knock the entire republican party out of the election in one messy sex scandal. Honestly if I had at stake what the porn industry does. I'd be thinking "regardless of if Obama wins this one or not, next election there's a huge chance it's going to be republican so lets end Santorum once and for all". No one, no matter how ardent a republican is going to vote for a 'happily married father of 8' if he's caught sleeping with an 18 year old porn star.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bickfordb 15y agoConsider all the lawyer jobs that will be created!
- chrishough 15y agoAnother crazy Republican out to destroy our freedoms. What a loser.
- seanp2k2 15y agoFrom the title, it sounds like Santorum just lost (lol)
- boubountu 15y agoSantorum looks both gay and addicted to porn.
- ugh 15y agoI … don’t … understand? So everyone and their mother are complaining about big government and one of the two guys who has good chances of becoming the nominee is in favor of doing draconian (fascist, even) big government stuff. What?! American voter, what’s going on? I’m only confused. I have given up making sense of it.
- swalkergibson 15y agoIt's the neo-conservative campaign slogan. Get out of my business, and get into my bedroom!
- iwwr 15y agoThe neocon motto is: "Tell them what they want to hear, so long they keep paying for the empire"
- InclinedPlane 15y agoI think you're mistaking "neo-conservative" with social conservative.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThis is old hat. Leftists want the government to leave people's private lives alone and stick their fingers in everyone else's business lives. Conservatives want the opposite.
- MartinCron 15y agoTo be clear, he's advocating cracking down on "obscenity" and not "pornography". With the notion that pornography can be legal but obscenity is, by definition, illegal. The fact that we still have obscenity laws on the books is, well, obscene. It's all moot, though, as there's no chance he'll get the nomination, let alone the presidency.
- Zirro 15y agoHas any kind of border between "normal" pornography and obscene been defined?
- protomyth 15y agoIn the US it is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_v._California http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_v._California http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test
- nostromo 15y agoYes, it's called the "Miller test" and it was created before the internet: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test The big question here is what the hell are "community standards" when talking about the internet?
- Zirro 15y agoI see. Well, the "community standards" on 4chan for example, or even among younger generations in general today are likely to be different from the casual Internet-users. I suppose Santorum would go by the "community standards" of his voters, no matter if they are Internet-users or not.
- Lazare 15y agoSort of. Obscenity is relative; it's something that offends the prevalent morality of the time and thus what is obscene differs by both time and place. Or for a related definition it must be material "utterly without redeeming social importance". Of course, what is "socially important" is very much changable and ill-defined. As a result, the question of what is and what isn't rarely easily answerable. In the US, these days, child porn is obscene (but is also illegal several times over via other laws, so that hardly matters) and even a textual and fictional account of the rape of a child might be obscene if it seems to a jury that it was meant purely to titillate. On the other hand, an autobiography of someone who was abused as a child, or a textbook meant for social workers discussing how to help the victim of child abuse would not be obscene (assuming, of course, a jury agrees on what the material in question is). Depictions of bestiality and other similar acts are probably obscene, but maybe not - it all depends on what a jury says. And there are different rules at the national level and in the various states. Sex toys are never obscene at the national level, but are obscene in Alabama. On the other hand, nothing is obscene in Oregon. tl;dr summary: Has a border been defined? No. :)
- protomyth 15y agoThis type of stuff is why I expect Romney to be the actual nominee. Going by everything else, I would seriously doubt they put Santorum in the VP slot. I do wish we could get a TRUE small government candidate from either party.
- uiri 15y agoRon Paul Not that he has a real chance at the nomination, but there you go. Most people don't actually want a small government. They want a government which fixes the problems that they perceive in society (whether that be porn, guns, abortion or health care).
- protomyth 15y agoI just keep thinking of the lead up to WWII and WWII, and think Ron Paul would not be a good person for the job.
- jpadkins 15y agoThey would happened the same exact way if Ron Paul was president at the time. We would have stayed out of it until attacked, Congress would declare war, and then we would win and come home in 4 years. (or 2 in the case of WWI) Those wars are very different than Vietnam of Afghanistan.
- protomyth 15y agoNo, he would have never done the lend-lease in WWII, and it is unlikely we would have been targeted in WWI.
- Osiris 15y agoI agree. I am baffled by people that talk about the need for fewer environment regulations and smaller government, but then they push for large military spending, the creation of the DHS and TSA, and advocating things like this. To me, many conservative commentators sound more like they want an Orwellian society than a free society: Don't get in the way of business and only think and do what we want you to think and do. I appreciate Ron Paul in that when he says small government, he means it, including giving us freedoms that social conservatives believe are morally objectionable.
- saryant 15y agoHe's just trying to bait Romney. Nothing to see here.
- grammr 15y agoSeveral of the most popular porn sites are in the Alexa top 100 (ish) in the U.S. You don't get that kind of traffic without having a massive number of Americans watching porn regularly. There's a perception that watching porn is taboo, but that's probably because it's not a socially acceptable topic of conversation. Everyone does it or has done it. There is absolutely no way that this idiotic pledge of his can have a net positive gain for him. If anything, this will probably encourage otherwise non-voters to vote against him.
- zerostar07 15y agoIndeed, with Utah being #1 in porn consumption, how did his advisors ever justify these proposals? http://www.sltrib.com/business/ci_11821265 http://www.sltrib.com/business/ci_11821265
- Zimahl 15y agoMaybe no one else will but you have to call it like it is: this is just pandering to the extreme conservative base of the GOP. "The Obama Administration has turned a blind eye to those who wish to preserve our culture from the scourge of pornography and has refused to enforce obscenity laws." You mean the obscenity laws that SCOTUS keeps beating down? They have limited the FCC now so you will at least be able to hear accidental cussing on TV without the stations paying insane fines. The Superbowl/Janet Jackson 'nipple-slip' punishment has been completely reversed. Since porn is on the internet, it is NOT easily accessible to minors. Outside of the few corner cases (public wifi mostly) it's not that easy for minors to get access. At that point it's up to parents to limit exposure through the readily available software. "Santorum’s administration could take American-based porn distributors to court for violating obscenity laws, said Volokh, and have them shuttered." They failed with magazines, why would the internet be any different? It's only a different medium in that the content is delivered more easily. That doesn't make it more obscene. All this talk is why Santorum might win the nomination but lose a landslide of an election. While centrist Republicans might vote for him just because he is GOP, his extreme views turn the independents and undecideds off and that's who you need to win an election.
- frankydp 15y agoExtreme social conservatives. You can be extremely conservative in regards to individual freedom without having all the completely counter-conservative opinions of the evangelical enforcement agency. Not trolling just a semantic that bothers me. PS The internet would be different in court in the same way that I don't get sued for leaving my newspaper on the restaurant table for someone else after I am done with it, where if I leave a copy of a movie on the internet for others I potential get extradited. Only half joking. It would be the same insane confuse the jury trials we have now.
- rflrob 15y ago> Since porn is on the internet, it is NOT easily accessible to minors. That seems to be entirely beside Santorum's point. His particular brand of politics is largely against any kind of sexual freedom. Gay rights, abortion, even contraception is something they would like the government to legislate against. To them, porn is not bad because kids might see it; porn is bad, full stop.
- mynameishere 15y agoHe's feeding slop to the low-IQ quartile of voters, nothing more. That said, I remember advocating a simple manner of obliterating the porn industry a long time ago. (Not porn, mind you, but rather the nasty business of actually producing it.) Just reduce copyright protection of pornographic material to 1 day. After this, what's currently piracy would become ultra-cheap, legal trade, and it would be quickly unprofitable to finance new material.
- philwelch 15y agoThere are plenty of exhibitionists who would mass-produce it for free.
- jonursenbach 15y agoThey're already doing that now, just look at all the NSFW subreddits.
- rflrob 15y agoStrictly speaking, you could probably even revoke copyright protection for porn entirely. The relevant clause of the constitution reads, "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." IANAL, but it seems like you could take an originalist interpretation and say porn is in no way a useful art, and that even if it were, while congress has the power to do so, it can probably choose not to exercise that power provide protection to some suitably broad class of works.
- prodigal_erik 15y agoThey're still trying to figure out whether porn reduces rape. If so, that would make porn more useful than the average work of fiction, which is merely entertaining.
- Moto7451 15y agoSeeing as the various x rated tube sites have a business model thats based around the swapping of copyrighted material plus a freemium/premium option for those willing to dish out money directly or sign up for a sister site, I'm willing to bet that a one day copyright window wouldn't really make a big deal. In reality, I think the practical shelf life/copyright life of a video is a day anyways and then it ends up on a tube site or torrent. I barely watch a hollywood movie more than once, how many people who use pay sites bother going to the archives? There are probably just enough people willing to pay for day one access that it keeps the industry going.
- kellenfujimoto 15y agoIf Santorum is elected president, I will throw up.
- funkah 15y agoThis country is focusing on everything but our actual problems.
- wpietri 15y agoWhich reminds me of this fine graph: http://www.calamitiesofnature.com/archive/?c=550 http://www.calamitiesofnature.com/archive/?c=550 It shows the American states on a scatterplot. Color is voting preference; the X and Y axes show search frequency for "god" and "free gay porn".
- Drbble 15y ago"oh god oh god oh god" is frequently heard in porn movies...
- philwelch 15y agoSo here's the backstory. Santorum has a microscopically thin but nonzero chance of winning the Republican primaries. To do so, either Romney has to all but disappear as a candidate or he has to do extremely well in the upcoming primaries. Even then, the most likely outcome is a "brokered convention", where literally anything is possible, up to and including nominating someone who isn't even running yet. Santorum knows that he has to win the GOP base this way. And he'll never win the libertarianish part of the GOP base to begin with (they're voting for Ron Paul), nor will he win over the sane people (they're either voting for Romney or staying home in a fog of crippling depression). So his only chance is to maximize turnout from crazy, evangelical, right-wing loonies of the type rarely seen outside flyover country. If he somehow wins the nomination, expect him to quietly forget half of these crazy promises. If he loses, his political career is over. So he has to go pretty crazy.
- lukifer 15y agoI think evangelicals have caught on to the fact that they have been pandered to and then ignored by mainstream Republicans, and they're sick of it; in Santorum, they see someone who holds their beliefs unambiguously. While I would expect that he would go quiet over these issues in a general election, I have no doubt that he would attempt to implement bible-based policy in the unlikely event that he is elected.
- cpeterso 15y agoI think this long GOP primary is a sign that both evangelicals and libertarians are realizing that the "deal" they made with the "big tent" GOP has had a poor ROI.
- blvr 15y ago>I have no doubt that he would attempt to implement bible-based policy in the unlikely event that he is elected. People thought George Bush would do the same.
- hobin 15y agoAnd he did. He banned federal funding for stem-cell research for biblical reasons. It might not have made the USA a theocracy, but he actually came pretty close with many of his decisions.
- veidr 15y agoObviously, the notion that Santorum could somehow scrub out the tubes and eliminate Internet porn is laughable. However, it is unfortunately very plausible, if he or some other religious extremist became president, that hundreds or thousands of citizens (a more or less random selection from the millions that occasionally view porn) might be arrested, caged, fined, and otherwise abused as part of a dysfunctional and technically incompetent 'war on porn'. (The morality of it is interesting, too: what's worse, jerking off while watching a blowjob video, or apprehending a human being under threat of violence and putting them in a cage?)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Cabal 15y agoThis sort of thing makes me wonder what those of us in the lifestyle would be subjected to under such a president. Midnight raids in our homes?
- SODaniel 15y agoSantorum, I am sorry but what a Fking joke this man is.
- petedoyle 15y agoNeither the dailycaller.com article nor the statement on ricksantorum.com mention SOPA or ISP filtering. They also don't mention creating new laws (which a president cannot do as part of the executive branch). Santorum's statement mentions that he'd appoint an Attorney General (also in the executive branch) that would enforce existing obscenity laws. Its fine to disagree with Santorum on this, but its a bit misleading to say he'd force ISPs to filter content (or that he'd have the power to do so).
- kochb 15y agoYou're right, claiming Santorum openly supports SOPA style content filtering is hyperbole with no basis in his actual statement (http://www.ricksantorum.com/enforcing-laws-against-illegal-pornography http://www.ricksantorum.com/enforcing-laws-against-illegal-p...). Admittedly though, it is a potential outcome.
- jmspring 15y agoTrue. Santorum is just the most recent incarnation of the moral majority that want to dictate how you should act in your private life. Part of the same group that screams about the government intruding on gun rights, religious rights, etc. A hypocrite. While, I am hopeful he won't get the votes to event be considered for the GOP nominee, I do hope someone like Larry Flynt will crawl out and destroy yet another moralist. What happens between consenting adults in their private lives has nothing to do the government. A long time optimist (and citizen of) that people in the US will do the right thing, I am glad that I have an exit opportunity to saner parts of the world. The fact that Santorum and his brand of politics has traction , on some level, scares me.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoWhat happens between consenting adults in their private lives has nothing to do the government. Most people who say this don't really believe this. Should I be allowed to pay a consenting adult $3/hour to clean my bedroom, while I talk about how much I dislike people of $PROTECTED_CLASS? [edit: to clarify my position, I have no objection to any consensual activities between adults. This includes gay sex, low wage labor, unlicensed medicine, etc.]
- InclinedPlane 15y agoTo all of you Democratic party muckers out there who have been registering as Republicans and voting for Santorum in primaries in the hopes that he will be a much weaker candidate against Obama (see, for example: http://tinyurl.com/DailyKOSClownShow http://tinyurl.com/DailyKOSClownShow). Fuck. You. That is all.
- martythemaniak 15y agoOne of the most dangerous ideas in politics today is that "The truth lies somewhere in the middle", which is what allows lunatics such as this to be taken seriously.
- patrickod 15y agoIt saddens me that, even in a quest to convert the hardcore/crazy right-wing that Santorum would even consider pledging things like this. Not only will such a law never come to fruition but it makes a mockery of politics to even suggest such things. Call me a naive idealist if you will but I'd like to think that Presidential candidates would try and campaign on real issues, not fire and brimstone nonsense.
- robomartin 15y agoOne day I would love to be able to vote for a President who does not believe that the earth is 6000 years old and that a supernatural being materialized the Universe in seven days. I mean, we give these guys nuclear launch codes! I'm sorry if this offends some but this god bullshit really needs to disappear from our culture before humanity can truly begin to move to a higher level. Most people would laugh their asses off (and be horrified) if a candidate for President expresses obedience and belief in Thor. What's the difference between Thor and all the other supers? I was once called up for jury duty. When it came time to be sworn in for the initial selection I told the judge that I could not swear on the bible. He asked me why. I told him that I happen to know that the Principle of Conservation of Energy is true and that I could not, in good conscience swear on something that blatantly violates it in so many ways. He actually chuckled. I then offered that, if belief in the supernatural was a prerequisite to be selected into a jury I would gladly swear by Thor to tell the truth and nothing but the truth, etc. I told him that I like that story a little better because of the cool hammer. I was respectfully excused. Ironic, being that they were after the truth. But I digress, I agree with the fiscal conservatism of the Republican ticket but their hyper-religious bend and ridiculous social stance sure turns me off. Santorum is insane. Where is Joe Piscopo when you need him?
- ars 15y ago> I happen to know that the Principle of Conservation of Energy That is the most ironic attack on religion I have ever seen considering that the big bang was a huge violation of conservation of energy. (Science currently has no explanation for it. It may someday, but right now it's completely unknown.) Religion actually affirms conservation of energy by saying the energy came from outside the system, and that the nature of this outside system is unknown. The main difference is that Religion hold that the nature of this outside system will never be known, and Science holds that we may someday know it, but currently do not.
- lotharbot 15y ago> "Religion hold that the nature of this outside system will never be known" Many religions claim to already know (some part of) the nature of whatever it is outside the physical universe. They just claim that the information comes from something other than observation of physical processes.
- plink 15y agoDoes the chiaroscuro effect in that photo come from a torchlight procession in front of his dais?
- rickdale 15y agoWell, I guess its time to get a bigger hard drive and start downloading as much as possible before July. Hooray for porn!
- cellularmitosis 15y agoI wonder how conservatives would feel about something like reddit gonewild, which is still pron (well, just nudes), but has the distinction of clearly being consensual and positive for the women participating in it.
- zaroth 15y agoYou gotta love how the comment thread on that site nests so deep it ends up like 10px wide.
- Confusion 15y agoWell, that makes sure that half the men that previously would have voted for him will still pay lip service to him, but won't actually vote for him. He thoroughly misunderstands what voters actually want.
- NameNickHN 15y agoI wonder what took them so long to crack down on pornography. It's been a while since the Prohibition got rid of all the alcohol. Maybe they were too exhausted from putting all those copyright violators behind bars. But since sharing of movies, music and books has been so successfully staunched recently, it seems to be time to tackle the next big thing. Go Santorum.