6 ms·
Cancel Zoning If we want to fix the housing-affordability crisis zoning must go
- boilerupnc 3y agohttps://archive.is/VCDBk https://archive.is/VCDBk
- fosk 3y agoThe US needs to build more, not cancel zoning. With one of the lowest density in the world (36/km²) this should be a NON issue. I don’t understand why we are stuck in this loophole of zones, affordable housing and so on. There is plenty of space! The government could build those homes too if they really cared about it. Heck! Soviet Russia built a bunch of complexes for people to live in, sure they won’t be pretty, but better than sleeping outside. But somehow we can’t build them here in the US and we’d rather spend years and decades discussing existing zoning laws when new ones could be established pretty much all over the nation.
- voisin 3y ago> The US needs to build more, not cancel zoning. With one of the lowest density in the world (36/km²) this should be a NON issue. The reason more isn’t being built is zoning.
- tptacek 3y agoThe subtext of the comment you're replying to is that the cities people want to live in are all full up, and people who want to live there should just go make new cities somewhere else.
- nimbleplum40 3y agoThey really aren’t though. Even New York is filled with tons of somewhat wasted space and excessive car infrastructure. Especially in the outer burrows.
- voisin 3y agoZoning keeps every city from being denser than it could be. Zoning is the problem. There’s no such thing as a city that is full up.
- bigfryo 3y agoIt is not just zoning, it's also permits and building codes
- voisin 3y agoNo project has ever been cancelled due to building codes. Permitting can be time consuming (though largely this is a function of zoning and what variances the developer is looking for in order to get to an economic density - which is nearly never “as of right - and what level of community involvement exists in approving these variances) but rarely would permitting on its own be a barrier (it would be the underlying zoning and the NIMBYism that prevents the variances).
- gbacon 3y agoSoviet Russia isn’t the example to follow.
- Pxtl 3y agoI'll take Khrushchyovkas over tent cities any day.
- tptacek 3y agoHow about we have neither? That sounds good to me.
- fosk 3y agoFollow Japan then https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danchi https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danchi Seriously, this problem doesn’t exist in other places. It has been solved 70 years ago in rest of the civilized world.
- Analemma_ 3y agoJapan is an excellent example to follow, but that’s mostly because they a) don’t treat housing as an investment, Japanese homes basically get written off after 30-50 years and b) don’t have any local control over zoning: if the national or prefectural government says housing is going here, any locals who object can go pound sand. Both of these would be excellent norms to import into America, but it would come with fierce resistance from the most-likely-to-vote segments of society. I don’t see it happening.
- tptacek 3y agoIt already is happening. It happened in California, for instance.
- cycrutchfield 3y agoThe problem isn’t lack of space for housing, the problem is lack of housing in places people actually want to live.
- causality0 3y agoI do wonder why the work from home revolution hasn't produced a big population of people willing to live in the middle of nowhere. Is it because the people able to WFH were already urbanites not willing to live anywhere they can't walk to a Starbucks?
- voidfunc 3y agoHave you been to the middle of nowhere? It's not glamorous and has a lot of downsides including regressive politics, shitty health care, crappy food options, no nightlife other than the bar that all the local townies drink in before going home to drunkenly beat and abuse their wives etc. So yea, not surprised folks are signing up in droves to go live in Middle of Nowhere America.
- mikhailt 3y agoTo work from home, you still need quality internet. The further out you get from the city, the worse the quality tend to be. No sane ISP is going to invest in fiber connections to "middle of nowhere". ISPs invest in areas where the money is likely to be in. That's not even including the other challenges that the other person wrote; sparse areas tend to have less investments in their infrastructure as well. People live closer to the city for all sorts of reasons; health cares systems are better, more public infrastructure in place (think cops, libraries, public transportation, etc).
- Libcat99 3y agoNew homes, apartments, etc need to be built where people need the, not wherever there is open space. Building a giant apartment building in the middle of nowhere serves no purpose if there are no jobs there. And the reason we can't build where people need them is mostly zoning.
- pxue 3y agoIf you build an apartment in the middle of Wyoming. Who would move there?
- whycome 3y ago> I don’t understand why we are stuck in this loophole of zones, affordable housing and so on. There is plenty of space! Sounds like you’re in favour of cancelling zoning. Cancelling just means a reevaluation of how and where we allow housing developments on existing space. It means cancelling that ineffective structure system and replacing it with something more appropriate. It means getting to actually build housing on space that didn’t allow it for reasons we’re now questioning and challenging.
- gumballindie 3y ago> With one of the lowest density in the world (36/km²) this should be a NON issue. The issue is traditional working practices. People are forced to cluster in large cities, as opposed to spreading around, particularly where jobs can be done remotely. There's literarly no need to have software engineers, marketing and sales people, customer support, accountants, etc in city offices. This is an issue all over the world where work hasn't adopted modern practices.
- ericmay 3y agoI get where you’re coming from here, but outside of a few major metro areas most people are spread around, which is precisely the problem. Driving 20 miles (or 30 minutes) to your place of work is not clustering and is causing us all sorts of economic problems. Just Wednesday my dental hygienist told me she drives around an hour to get to the office. That’s an anecdote of course, but that’s a normal thing for Americans. That’s a huge problem. To your point about big single offices where all of these workers are “in the city” which mostly are spread out suburban office parks, I would agree, which is why we need less sprawl and more people living closer together and clustering around the cities that they are residing in.
- tptacek 3y agoSo far on this thread as solutions to the housing crisis we've seen: * Building houses on federally-owned land in the middle of rural Oregon * Switching everybody to a plant-based diet * Allowing all the white-collar knowledge workers to work remotely so they'll migrate out of the cities. I'm sure we'll get other creative ideas too. But eliminating single-family zoning seems a lot simpler.
- astura 3y agoThe reason there isn't more building is because of zoning. In my neighborhood alone multiple requests for re-zoning for higher density was rejected and building didn't happen because of that.
- tiahura 3y agoAnyone who thinks zoning is the issue should take a trip to Houston to get straightened out.
- ethanbond 3y agoSome types/applications of zoning are part of the issue. Not the only one, to be sure. e.g. desirable markets literally don’t have enough people to build the houses. But zoning is often abused as a way to protect and increase the value of landowners’ assets at everyone else’s expense.
- quacked 3y agoWhat a nightmare of a city. I tell people who haven't been there that it's a city-size concrete strip mall built on a swamp. The worst part is that it could be paradise, with smarter building. The JSC and Rice campuses are both quite nice.
- ethbr1 3y agoCan't speak to Houston, but this rings true for Dallas for me. Everything is everywhere, in exactly the same way. City-sized concrete strip mall, indeed. Zoning has its faults. But lack of coherent zoning also has its faults.
- tptacek 3y agoZoning is the issue. My wife is from Houston; I have certainly been there. I don't like Houston. What major lesson am I missing? Nothing about Houston redeems single-family zoning for me.
- bdcravens 3y agoThe bigger question is among cities with Houston's population, what is Houston doing wrong that other such cities are doing right? Almost always the comparisons are to much smaller cities, which is intellectually dishonest.
- kthejoker2 3y ago
- honksillet 3y agoSomething rarely mentioned is how much land the federal government owns. Maybe the feds don’t need to own 50% of Oregon and 80% of Nevada.
- tptacek 3y agoThe federal government owns land that nobody wants to build housing on. It's not enough just to have a house; housing is only viable in places where there is an economy to support the people who will live in the house.
- gbacon 3y agoThat’s an extraordinarily broad assertion.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sojournerc 3y agoOk, go experiment for us. Live in a house by yourself in the desert 50 miles from anywhere and see how well you thrive.
- thisgoesnowhere 3y agoAlso living super far away from others is bad in a multitude of ways, we need density not housing.
- gbacon 3y agoYou wrote about what "we" need without identifying whom else that statement represents. You may prefer higher-density housing. It may even be the case that a majority of people near where you live prefer high-density housing. This is not a universal preference nor objectively better. Those who do not share your particular taste do not necessarily prefer "living super far away from others" either. Let's begin by acknowledging the vast middle ground between the two extreme positions and also downsides of population density. What does utopia look like for mice? According to a researcher who did most of his work in the 1950s through1970s, it might include limitless food (of course!), multiple levels and secluded little rodent condos. These were all part of John Calhoun’s experiments to study the effects of population density on behavior. But what looked like rat utopias and mouse paradises at first quickly spiraled into out-of-control overcrowding, eventual population collapse and seemingly sinister behavior patterns. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/how-mouse-utopias-1960s-led-grim-predictions-humans-180954423/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/how-mouse-utopias-...
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoThe article cites multiple YIMBY laws and political accomplishments. Has there been enough time passed to determine if these laws and abolishment’s of wasteful land use has resulted in less homelessness, more affordability, etc? I’m legitimately curious here. I’m also curious what the perhaps unintended side effects are of this. I can imagine eg. Where you don’t have to mandate two parking spaces for a 2 bedroom apartment, the landscape of the city changes additionally where car owners feel less welcome (less parking available) which might be actually a great thing, but I want studies to prove this out. To be clear, I support policies that theoretically decrease homelessness and increase affordable housing. I too have difficulties acquiring housing. I want to know these policies actually have evidence now that they’ve been enacted.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y ago> car owners feel less welcome Think of the car owners feelings! But seriously, having fewer parking spaces can incentivize better non-car transportation options (public transport and bike lanes/paths for example). Turns out that higher density areas with non-car transportation options are hugely popular and pleasant places to live.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoI am not disagreeing! I’m merely pointing out that more than housing might be impacted by removing wasteful space use like mandated parking, and I wished there was a study to track that.
- quacked 3y agoAmerica adds between 600k-1.2M immigrants per year, and that's the officially counted ones. That's a surefire way to add strain to a limited supply. This is occurring in Aus, Canada, and the UK as well.
- lumost 3y agoBut supply is artificially constrained in most jurisdictions. Assuredly we can produce a cost effective good in 2023 which has been built for thousands of years.
- cycrutchfield 3y agoSounds like increasing supply is a good idea then?
- bdcravens 3y agoIn Texas at least those are the ones building the housing.
- bentt 3y agoI saw some article yesterday about this palatial new high school in Texas and the headline was something FREEDOM and TEXAS... but being in the Northeast, one of the biggest differences between here and there is the labor pool. In Texas, there is a near limitless supply of immigrant labor. Mexicans have built so much of California and Texas. They should get credit for what they've accomplished. If you want to see the opposite of that, come to Vermont. Even if we can get a building approved there's nobody around to build it, and even if there was the cost of their labor is beyond the economic capacity of the region. The sooner we start issuing work visas for construction, the faster we will get out of the housing crisis.
- prepend 3y agoI’m fairly certain construction in New England has a lot of Latin American labor involved. Or at least this is based on looking at the construction crews I saw working around New York City and Boston the last times I was there over the past few decades.
- bentt 3y agoSure, the major metro areas eat up whatever supply of cheaper immigrant (read: LatAm) labor is available. They're not making their way into the rest of the region... ironically, because there's nowhere to live!
- bdcravens 3y agoWhen I bought my new home last year in a suburb northwest of Houston, all of the workers I've seen, both during construction and during warranty work, have almost all been Hispanic. Texas is a red state of course, and there's a lot of irony in how proud Texans are of their Tex-Mex cuisine and low housing prices.
- HPsquared 3y agoThat would explain low prices in Texas... how about California?
- 3y ago
- jl6 3y agoIs this the same zoning that prevents building toxic waste dumps next to hospitals or rendering plants next to schools?
- tptacek 3y agoNo. It's the zoning that mandates minimum-lot-sized single family residents on most of the country's urban residential areas. Nobody seriously advocates cancelling SimCity-style R/C/I zoning.
- HPsquared 3y agoResidential and commercial should be closer together. Why not have apartments and office in the same building?
- tptacek 3y agoWe should do that. But it's not principally the thing we're talking about when we discuss restrictive zoning. We're talking about a housing crisis, which is caused by restrictions on where and what housing can be built, not a commercial crisis.
- astura 3y agoMixed use zoning exists.
- tptacek 3y agoIt's widely prohibited. Residents (reasonably) resist new commercial developments on their blocks, and there isn't meaningful advocacy to overrule them on that. But, more importantly, residents almost universally resist increased housing density of any sort (any sort of development that increases the number of people who can live in an area), and so you also see resistance to any housing being built on commercially-zoned land.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoI'm not sure it's a silver bullet. When developers are allowed to build apartments, they build luxury apartments. As long as profit is the motive, the affordability half is likely to be neglected. I also feel like building more rental properties serves the property owners more than it does the "dweller".
- dicomdan 3y agoLuxury just means new. Prices are high because supply is low.
- ethbr1 3y agoLuxury definitely means 'on the higher side of the price range' and 'not affordable housing'. Which is what you'd expect to happen in a free market. Absent a reason, why would developers voluntarily choose to build an option that would make them less money?
- slyall 3y agoIf people can't afford $1m apartments then developers will build cheaper ones if they can make the numbers work.
- ethbr1 3y agoOr, they build nothing and allocate capital to a different city where luxury apartments are still selling.
- slyall 3y agoIn which case another developer will build them. Assuming the numbers make sense. Either way refusing to allow apartments to be built because you fear they will be "luxury" is dumb. It just means that the only people who get to live there are the really rich who can afford a full-sized house.
- 3y ago
- Apreche 3y agoYou still need zoning otherwise people are going to build a poison-spewing factory right next to your house. Eliminating zoning entirely is reactionary and going too far. What we do need is to just pull zoning back. Really it’s just a few changes. Don’t require single family homes with yards. Allow high density residential and also allow mixed zoning where you have apartments on top of small commercial spaces. Also, remove parking minimums. That’s really going to cover 90% of the issues.
- tptacek 3y agoThe article is about restrictive residential zoning, not about industrial zoning.
- tonetheman 3y ago[dead]
- holbrad 3y agoIf Americans think zoning is bad and crippling house building, wait until they hear about the British planning system. Where every single building needs state permission and full review to be built. Which takes months to years per building, instead of days or weeks. In completely unrelated news the UK has some of the most expensive smallest housing in Europe.
- post-factum 3y agoCzech Republic enters the party…
- pandaman 3y agoIt's the same in the US: in a township you need to pull permits to build anything substantial. Usually there are default permitted things with footprint and height restriction so you can build a gazebo or a swing in your backyard but is there any place in the developed world where you can build anything without permission in a city?
- vaxintar 3y agoZoning changes between countries, states, provinces, districts, cities, municipalities, and neighborhoods! In my country, there's an even longer list of exceptions to the zoning rules, and that's just at the federal level. I bet in some jurisdictions, a city council can modify these rules by simply adding an exception for a specific area, block, or development. City planning has to be one of the most underestimated tasks for city officials. No one can really predict what will happen to a city in the near future. Just think about how many cities were *totally* unprepared for COVID in 2020. An official might have an idea as of how the city should grow in the next 10 years, but in lots of places there's an equilibrium easily disrupted by political shifts, economic downturns, or simply global dynamics that have faster impacts than what city officials can anticipate or comprehend.
- tptacek 3y agoSingle-family zoning in America isn't really a city planning decision the way we think it is; virtually all American single-family zoning occurred in the early 20th century as a reaction to Buchanan v. Warley, which outlawed racial zoning codes; single-family zoning was a way to retain prohibitions on Black residents without having the zoning code literally say that.
- dpierce9 3y agoZoning plays a key role in building because it derisks investing in building capital. If I know that all the parcels around me are residentially zoned then I can build a house with confidence knowing that someone isn’t going to put a fertilizer plant next door. Obviously some places don’t have it and it works out fine: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Fertilizer_Company_explosion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Fertilizer_Company_expl... Getting rid of zoning doesn’t suddenly make more trades. Plumbers, roofers, and electricians are in short supply because the gfc wiped them out. Why not better, simpler zoning with well understood and simple rules for changing the zoning?
- tptacek 3y agoThis article is about restrictive residential zoning, not about SimCity still R/C/I zoning.
- phmqk76 3y agoDumb, dumb, dumb. Building more =/= Cancel Zoning. And guess what? When WWII ended and people flooded into NYC, rents began to rise rapidly. You know what NYC did in 1947? Rent control. That year, there were 2 million rent controlled units, and the middle class took off like a rocket ship. You want to reduce rents? Rent control. Building expensive “luxury” apartments everywhere isn’t going to do jack shit about pricing. Set maximum rents, and provide low interest HUD loans to ensure the production of new units because the private market can’t or won’t build anything affordable if it can make bigger profits by charging more. This isn’t complicated.
- thatswrong0 3y agoThe 1950s were a good time to be a white American pretty much anywhere, not just New York City. So it’s definitely more complicated than that lol
- phmqk76 3y agoThat’s a bit of a non sequitur, isn’t it? NYC was confronted with a problem of rapidly rising rents, and instead of handwringing and eliminating zoning and engineering huge tax breaks, they enacted rent control. Why don’t we have the courage to act?
- tptacek 3y agoNYC is one of the epicenters of the housing crisis. Rent control doesn't make new housing, builders do, and zoning keeps them from doing it. You can advocate for rent control once the housing gets built.
- phmqk76 3y agoYou can’t, though. The price you seek to rent the units for dictates your profit margins, which impacts the financing sought. If you’re taking out a 10% construction loan and are building into your business plan $3,000 a month for your two bedroom, you can’t turn around and rent it out for $1,000 a month because city ordinances say so after the fact. That’s why rent control needs to happen now, and then a public finance corporation needs to be established to provide financing to build new units if the market won’t. It’s not rocket science, it’s just not politically expedient, so it’s not talked about.
- 7e 3y agoHousing is always expensive because human wants are infinite. Specifically the want to live in desirable places and the want to breed, breed, breed like rats. The more housing we build the more humans will reproduce to fill those houses.
- hackeraccount 3y agoHuman wants are infinite in expression as well as desire. People really do want to breed; what's it going to be then? Infinite resources on 1 child or finite resources on an infinite number of children? The same with the most desirable place to live? Is it an infinitely desirable spot or an infinite amount of space? In any case unlimited wants in a finite system will always create compromises; especially if there are multiple actors.