3 ms·
New finding boosts Panspermia theory that life on Earth originated in deep space
- scentoni 3y agoSome ingredients of life likely came from deep space. That doesn’t mean that life did.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoTo be pedantic, all ingredients of life - and everything else - comes from deep space! That we find organic molecules in space isn't that surprising either, carbon does like to bond with other atoms.
- progrus 3y ago“Confirmations should count only if they are the result of risky predictions; that is to say, if, unenlightened by the theory in question, we should have expected an event which was incompatible with the theory - an event which would have refuted the theory.”
- supazek 3y agoThe Science is settled. We ARE stardust! I’m going to grab my boyfriend and get down to the local craft brewery to celebrate!
- api 3y agoI’ve always wondered if the idea that life originated on Earth might not be the last geocentrism. Edit: I’ve always found this fascinating: https://phys.org/news/2013-04-law-life-began-earth.html https://phys.org/news/2013-04-law-life-began-earth.html
- Tagbert 3y agoAn earth origin of our life assumes that life could appear anywhere that conditions are favorable. There would be not single center of life just of our type of life. Panspermia allows for life to arise from somewhere else that could, itself, be a center of life.
- jshmrsn 3y agoWikipedia defines panspermia as living organisms being spread throughout the universe. An unreviewed paper about carbonic acid in outer space does not directly have a connection to panspermia. The topic of panspermia is being pushed by the article.
- dvh 3y agoThe DNA indicates single common ancestor, with panspermia shouldn't there be multiple common ancestors?
- crthpl 3y agoNot if only one species came to earth.
- almostnormal 3y agoMultiple ancestors on earth would likely have had a common ancestor elsewhere and would probably be difficult to distinguish from a single ancestor on earth.
- mattmaroon 3y agoSuch clickbait. The earth itself originated in deep space. Does anyone believe carbonic acid (which is formed anywhere CO2 and water are together) exists only here? How does finding one molecule living beings use in space further at theory about life when nobody would deny it’s out there? Can you just tell us we found carbonic acid in space without trying to make it into some huge discovery it isn’t?
- fsloth 3y agoIf carbonic acid has not been found before in space then this is an actual discovery. It dies not suffice to reason about something to prove it’s existence, you also must actually do the leg work of proving it. This is the main difference in scientific age and the ages that preceded it - logical reasoning is not sufficient.
- mattmaroon 3y agoIt’s a discovery, it’s just not one that changes your handicapping of the odds of if life exists elsewhere or came from elsewhere. The headline is just taking a discovery and making it click bait.
- budnitz 3y agoFor context, it's worth checking out the 1952 Miller-Urey Experiment that demonstrates how amino acids could have been created in a primitive Earth environment without any of the carbonic acid seeding that the article suggests occurred.
- nologic01 3y agoPanspermia seems to have for us today the psychological role that atomic "theory" had for Democritus and ancient greeks: it was a logical argument, back then not at all supported by experiment, that helped organize thoughts and pinned them on a plausible starting point. In analogy, the mystery around how life may have come about is helped by removing Earth-centricity as a constraint and thinking in broader biophysical patterns. It also provides motivation and inspiration for research angles that might otherwise not be in our scientific crosshairs.
- photochemsyn 3y agoEarth's early atmosphere is estimated to have had several hundred times as much CO2 as it does now, which would have dissolved in the ocean, and then you can get a whole host of simple organic molecules - alchols, hydrocarbons, aldehydes and so on - via reactions catalyzed by volcanic particles. Space carbonic acid not required (and it forms from CO2 in water anyway). See for example Synthesis of prebiotic organics from CO2 by catalysis with meteoritic and volcanic particles (2023) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37231067/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37231067/
- thangalin 3y agoPages 10 to 13 in my book delves into life's origins on Earth: * https://impacts.to/downloads/lowres/impacts.pdf https://impacts.to/downloads/lowres/impacts.pdf Sources: * https://impacts.to/bibliography.pdf https://impacts.to/bibliography.pdf It's certainly possible that amino acids had extraterrestrial origins. IMO, Occam's Razor suggests that the Miller-Urey experiment provides a simpler answer: the building blocks of life formed on early Earth.