4 ms·
I don't work for google. I use Google, I have multiple Gmail as well as hosted by Google workspace domains. Overall I think this is reasonable. I can't see why
by ggm 3y ago
I don't work for google. I use Google, I have multiple Gmail as well as hosted by Google workspace domains.
Overall I think this is reasonable. I can't see why people are upset, when the general burden to make it "live" is low.
There are specific corner case problems: people who cannot login for various reasons, can't get Google humans to help, and who get mail forwarded so are limping along. And, there are a surprisingly high number of people who seem to trip up over account recovery. If I had one criticism of google here, it's that they're judge, jury and executioner. There's no appeal mechanism for ordinary mortal. It's capricious, sometimes squeaky wheels get oiled, sometimes not.
I pay for google 1 and I takeout periodically.
Don't depend on "free" for critical functions.
- srik 3y ago> Google also reserves the right to delete data in a product if you are inactive in that product for at least two years. This part is unreasonable no? I sometimes don't use a product for a while, like google drive for instance, and the prospect of coming back to it and discovering that all my data has been deleted is a bit on the dreadful side. I don't want to have to keep track of which product Ive been using and how long since I last signed into all the time.
- ggm 3y agoYes. I think it's pretty Awful. "Reserves the right" isn't "will" but it becomes clear it could be "at will"
- Dalewyn 3y agoIf you care about having your data stored permanently, I think it is fair to say you should pay for it (eg: Google One subscription) or buy something on the Google Play Store as listed under the inactivity exceptions policy. If you expect to get something served to you for free forever, Google has a bridge to sell you.
- flangola7 3y agoWe already pay with our data. None of these services are free and you know it.
- Dalewyn 3y agoConsider, with how much data Google has, that they don't care about having your data, especially if it's clearly been untouched for years. Though either way, my point stands: If you value Google storing your data, pay for it. If you don't, that implies you don't actually care about your data because you refused to place any explicit value on it.
- flangola7 3y agoNo, my point stands. We already paid, and continue to pay, Google. Google is wanting to double dip.
- omoikane 3y agoAre you finding the "delete data" part unreasonable, or the "two years" part? If it's the duration, I am curious what time limit you might find reasonable. If it's the "delete data" part, I can see why a company might not serve a piece of data in perpetuity when an user appear to have abandoned it, unless we want the company to assume ownership of that data.
- ggm 3y agoI think, it's the "can't keep all alive by using one sub product" part. If I use e.g. email, my drive should be fine. From this, it's not even clear if adding and removing content to drive via email would maintain drive for "activity"
- omoikane 3y agoMy reading of https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/12418290 https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/12418290 is that any activity on the account that required login counts as activity, independent of which sub-product is being used. Although it would help if they could clarify.
- az226 3y agoI think the product is the bad part. Should be if an account is inactive then they can delete data not if a product hasn’t been used. If you use gmail, your gdrive shouldn’t empty even if it has been 2+ years since you used the drive.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- palijer 3y ago>Don't depend on "free" for critical functions. All the cards are stacked against the users though. It's not that easy for a non-tech person to use any sort of email/photo library etc that isn't free from Google/Apple etc. Even self hosting email is impossible now. You won't be able to send emails because nothing trusts you. If Google intentionally incentivized everyone to move their entire digital lives into their platform for profit, they should have some sort of responsibility for that. There have absolutely been significant impact to people's lives because they've gotten locked out of their account for reasons that even Google can't explain, and there is no recourse or action they can take.
- ggm 3y agoI think we're in the fine grained differences between "should" and "must" I definitely think they should have better account recovery process, if need be for $, prove identity and get your data as takeout if they want to decline service but I would be amazed if any part of the current agreement we make with them could be said to obligate it. As a defacto monopoly I do tend to think they should be made to have some process. Which jurisdiction?
- distantsounds 3y agosinging up for email isn't difficult. neither is paying for a place to store your photos. Google is just that much easier so anything require beyond that is now all of a sudden too difficult for the average user. that's on you and your own inherent laziness to take the easy way out.
- epylar 3y agoSome people have mental or physical chronic illnesses that make these things legitimate barriers.
- soraminazuki 3y ago> for reasons that even Google can't explain, and there is no recourse or action they can take. It's even worse. When it was publicized that Google wrongfully flagged multiple accounts and tipped the police for child porn, they refused to reinstate those accounts. Instead, they chose to retaliate by further defaming the account owners on the record. That was after the police cleared their names and they haven't made a single apology to this day. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32560361 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32560361
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"Don't depend on "free" for critical functions." Yet that is exactly what so-called "tech" companies enable, and arguably encourage, millions of people to do. They certainly do not discourage people from using their websites and apps, for any purpose, from what I have seen. That would make no sense. Imagine Google showing a warning along the lines of "Do not use Gmail for important purposes." Instead the message might be "Here is something to enhance security". These companies have conflicts of interest vis-a-vis computer users. It's like an opioids company tasked with preventing addiction. The best they can do is promote treatment of addiction. This is a poor analogy because selling drugs is regulated. Handing out free email accounts, in order to conduct commercial surveillance, is not.
- zarzavat 3y agoIt’s fair to delete data. It’s not fair to delete the account. People have email addresses linked up to all kinds of other accounts. Sometimes my only way into an old non-Google account is a gmail address I made a long time ago. Often there is no way to change the email address linked to an account.
- isodev 3y ago> Don't depend on "free" for critical functions. It's not free at all, Google uses every bit of data you reveal to them to power their ad business. It's a form of payment even if we don't talk about it this way. This line of thinking also reveals an explanation for this new "Inactive Account" policy. Google doesn't care to keep old data — one needs to either feed them new signals they can sell / use to train their AIs or else... your account gets deleted.