8 ms·
Pornhub Sues Texas over Age Verification Law
- dontupvoteme 3y agoIs this going to pose a problem for sites like InternetArchive who may have archived NSFW content?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- getarofilter 3y ago[dead]
- verdverm 3y ago> In the complaint, the plaintiffs write that ... on-device content filtering would be a better method of restricting access to porn for children, they write. “But such far more effective and far less restrictive means don’t really matter to Texas Wait... what? On device filtering is a better, less restrictive means to accomplish this? Are those behind the on-device CSAM scanning behind this too? --- edit, thank you to all those who clarified that this is different from on device scanning and that is in fact a better solution
- Guvante 3y agoParents installing things on devices accessible to minors is certainly less restrictive given it doesn't impact anyone else.
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoYes, it's a better, less restrictive means to accomplish this. Because it means that instead of Pornhub having to identify a person's identity and all the expenses and privacy issues that entails, it happens in the home, by a parent, with an application that restricts access to certain content. Pornhub doesn't need to know who you are and the government doesn't need to know what you're doing.
- programmarchy 3y agoThis is like saying strip clubs shouldn't need to ID minors attempting to enter the building i.e. parents should be fully responsible for restricting a minor's access strip clubs. I think it's reasonable to conclude strip clubs also bear a responsibility to prevent minors from entering. This is just the porn industry shirking its responsibility.
- verdverm 3y agoMy understanding is that this is like checking an ID for the club when the club uses an ID scanner to validate. In this case the device is presenting the club with the answer rather than the club having to make the query
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoIt's not like that at all, because a website is nothing like a strip club regardless of what content it contains. Yes, the parents should be responsible for their own home networks and what travels across them. If the technology doesn't exist or isn't sufficient, then a market will be created to fill that need in short order. This legislation is not about children accessing smut. It's about the government knowing which adults are accessing smut. That some children attempt to gain access is simply a convenient excuse and a way to rationalize the intrusion into privacy.
- true_religion 3y agoShould parents also be responsible for their physical home and what travels into it? Because sex workers do make out calls. Should 16 year olds be able to call for strippers for their birthday parties, and the onus put on their parents to stop their entry? I’d think you would say no. The problem with the law as it stands isn’t the concept. It’s that it’s difficult to execute to the point where it basically bans free porn sites. Pay sites can still live because asking for ID and credit cards is something they can do and check manually. However free sites can’t do that. If the government provided some mechanism to automatically validate that a persons is over 18, when making an HTTP request then that would be fine. It would be no worse than having ID scanners at a club.
- barkerja 3y agoThey are likely referring to features such as iOS' parental controls, which can limit adult websites. To take things even further, some ISP providers provide parental controls which block at the DNS level. Pornhub is correct; they shouldn't be the one doing the blocking or verification. Leave that up to those that have control over the devices.
- explaininjs 3y agoIt means requiring the age restricted device to validate against the existing rating headers “Adult” websites already set, versus requiring the client to upload their personal information to validate their own identity to the “Adult” site. FWIW, iOS already does this. If you have parental controls enabled and a http request is made with a response that sets ‘rating: RTA-whatever’, webkit will refuse to render it. This is a good thing. The texas law blows, same general category of “harass the user instead of embrace the platform” as cookie banners.
- hedora 3y agoYeah. I’d love it if I could buy a device for my grade schoolers that auto-locked the screen if it saw that the next frame of whatever youtube kids video is being played contains porn or vivisections or whatever is sneaking past Google’s censors this week. This could happen on-device, and be an opt-in, paid feature. (The above are real examples, so we simply haven’t given them access to youtube yet.)
- dontupvoteme 3y agoIs there that much porn on youtube? and even gore? I remember people warning starkly against blindly scraping imgur as it had a lot of CP, but I had hoped Google had better image/video processing for it.
- polski-g 3y agoWhile that may be true, it is not unconstitutional to write dumb laws. I'm not sure how they have a case here.
- danShumway 3y ago1st Amendment exceptions do sometimes hinge on whether or not less burdensome alternatives were explored first. IANAL, but "you didn't even think if there were other ways to accomplish the same goals" can be a factor in deciding whether speech restrictions are over-burdensome. If I remember correctly, this came up a couple of times during Covid over religious gathering restrictions -- the question was less "can the government ever restrict a religious gathering" and more "is it actually necessary for you to do this? Have you taken steps to minimize the burden, is the burden imposed greater than the state's specific need for this restriction?" How a judge would rule on that in this case... :shrug:, but it doesn't seem to be an uncommon argument. There have been Supreme Court ruling that boil down to, "it's not unconstitutional necessarily but you did it wrong and we think you were too slapdash doing it, so try again."
- dragonwriter 3y ago> While that may be true, it is not unconstitutional to write dumb laws. It was when the kind of “dumb” is a more intrusive (on fundamentlal rights) than necessary means of serving a compelling government interest that would otherwise be sufficient to warrant some intrusion on fundamental rights. Or when it is an intrusion on fundamental rights without such an interest at all.
- Guvante 3y agoRequiring a site to display what you say is a pretty high bar. That is pretty obviously breaking the first amendment right to say what you want to say. Doesn't mean it can't happen but legally the bar is quite high to justify that.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoNot really. Cigarettes were forced to cover, like, 40% of their box with warnings about their ability to cause cancer, harm fertility, and impair breathing capacity. The FDA strictly regulates what medicines, as well as unapproved medicinal products, are allowed to say on their box. Multivitamin? You can say it supports health, but not that it improves health. General electronics? You'd better have that FCC logo on it, showing that it was tested and certified, if it has any wireless radios in it. And if you're in Europe, CE belongs on basically everything. Fireplaces? Anything with fire? Plumbing? Power conversion? Power delivery? Better have a certification from a Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory (NRTL), like UL or CSA. Why are websites of any kind unique? In principle, the government can compel speech on products.
- Guvante 3y agoWhy do you assume your examples didn't pass the high bar I mentioned? Don't pretend that the cigarette labeling was as simple as this bill. That was an incredibly complex process that took decades. Restricting what can be said is not the same as forcing speech. (This is in reference to your FDA comment which is a different topic) You added more examples all of which have significant effort and legal backing to their enforcement. Most notably most of those examples come from working with the industry to create standards for safety. All of them were developed working with the impacted industries and had solid justifications for why the labelling requirement is needed. Especially anything involving natural gas. If you fuck up the natural gas line going into your house that doesn't just impact you it impacts anyone within several hundred yards of your house. Similarly electrical requirements are either the federal government giving away access to a public good (frequencies of light for exclusive use) in exchange for certain restrictions on devices or electrical things that are quite dangerous again. Actual proven safety is different than "I decided it was harmful" and pretending that they are the same is ignorant at best.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoIt’s been fascinating watching age in relation to sex do a 180 in just a couple short decades. When I was 13, no one blinked an eye at porn usage. Suddenly the question is one of the most important in mainstream debate. Funny how that works. I’m not necessarily saying that the old ways were better, just that it’s interesting how much can change in one lifetime. I wonder what we consider harmless today that will be taboo in two decades.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoI'm betting on leggings at this point.
- ptsneves 3y agoI am fine if you wear leggings if you are fine with me staring as you pass by. That is the only way I can reconcile my freedom loving self with my monkey self.
- n42 3y agoYou don’t love freedom as in liberty; you love freedom as in lack of consequence. To put it another way; if you really loved freedom, you wouldn’t be “granting” freedom to wear leggings in return for our own to call you a creep.
- true_religion 3y agoI think you misunderstand. People are free to wear leggings. However, he is also free to shame them. He’s granting them the “freedom” from shame, and in return they won’t shame him by calling him a creep. If he has to become a creep, he won’t change himself he’ll try to change others by calling them names too.
- ptsneves 3y agoHonestly I believe this is the core of woke/anti woke culture wars. Either side wants it their way, albeit that leads to conflict. Both sides need to compromise and accept the costs of eachother’s world views. That is the consequence the previous commenter missed. It costs and it should cost on both sides. There can be no freedom in 0 degrees of freedom.
- earthboundkid 3y agoSeems like a dumb idea from the ACLU/PornHub POV. The Supreme Court is 6-3 conservative. You're going to lose the case and entrench a precedent that you don't like. It's better to just wait it out and hope that the Supreme Court turns over in 5 years than to do the suit when you will 100% lose.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoEven dumber, from their perspective, because there are a mountain of historical rulings that say porn is not protected by free speech. While that's been mostly ignored and all-but-overruled relatively recently (other than exposing it to minors); considering the court has been more amicable to older rulings...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Even dumber, from their perspective, because there are a mountain of historical rulings that say porn is not protected by free speech. There are a mountain of historical rulings saying that obscenity isn’t protected speech, but the sonewhat fuzzy legal definition if obscenity is (at least in its normal application) narrower than the commom term “pornography”. Moreover, and more specifically related, mandatory age verification laws for adult content online have been struck down twice by the US Supreme Court as First Amendment violations, first when it struck them down as part of striking down most of the Communications Decency Act of 1996 (leaving Section 230 intact but pretty much nothing else from that law), and again when it struck down the Child Online Protection Act of 1998. EDIT: Correction: COPA was struck down by a Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court declined to hear the government’s appeal, there was no Supreme Court ruling on the merits; the end result is the same, but only the CDA was actually struck down at the Supreme Court level.
- earthboundkid 3y agoWho can forget the time Ted Cruz was looking at porno in the Supreme Court basement? https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/06/ted-cruz-memoir-supreme-court-119529/ https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/06/ted-cruz-mem...
- officeplant 3y agoYep, if I try to visit any legit porn site in Louisiana it starts asking for my state ID and to join some god forsaken for profit data broker program with my real name. Or I just use a VPN/TOR.
- olalonde 3y agoA more effective approach might be for browsers to introduce a "Child-Safe Mode." In this mode, the browser could attach an "X-Child-Safe" header to every HTTP request. Websites with adult content could then recognize this header and redirect or block access as necessary. Of course, the onus would still be on parents to ensure their children's devices are set to this mode.
- giantg2 3y agoUntil they write a script to proxy the traffic and strip that header.
- olalonde 3y agoSure but that's also a problem with a state mandated age verification system.
- bryanlarsen 3y agohttps://www.rtalabel.org/index.php?content=howto https://www.rtalabel.org/index.php?content=howto Pornhub et al sets this meta attribute; child mode on Android and iOS respect it.
- olalonde 3y agoAh interesting, I didn't know that existed.
- jpcfl 3y ago> the plaintiffs write that the act employs “the least effective and yet also the most restrictive means of accomplishing Texas’ stated purpose of allegedly protecting minors,” and that minors can easily use VPNs or Tor; on-device content filtering would be a better method of restricting access to porn for children, they write. “But such far more effective and far less restrictive means don’t really matter to Texas, whose true aim is not to protect minors but to squelch constitutionally protected free speech that the State disfavors.” Wow, this is a weak case. I guess the good lawyers won't stoop to the level of arguing against keeping porn away from children. A security guard would be more effective than a lock at deterring intruders from breaking into my house, but I still have a lock. They also imply that Texas lawmakers aren't interested in protecting children, which is absurd. I have no sympathy for these creeps. I doubt they have any interest in keeping kids off their sites (probably the opposite), so they're just projecting and trying to deflect any responsibility.
- wonderwonder 3y agoOr what if they don't want to have to track adults who use their site? What if they think it's the parents responsibility to ensure their kids don't visit the site and they view what they produce as constitutionally protected speech. No need for the government to be given a nice formatted list of all the porn each TX adult is consuming. That information is also guaranteed to be a hacking target or be selectively leaked to prove a point by someone with a moral axe to grind
- jpcfl 3y agoParents do have a responsibility to ensure their children don't access harmful content, just like they have a responsibility to protect them from drugs and alcohol. But if there's a store down the street where kids can easily get booze, then that kinda makes it impossible as a parent. In this case it's worse--that "store" is right in the kid's pocket.
- dontupvoteme 3y agoWebsites aren't stores. I see your point but I can't find a great analogy - I feel it's more like a kid hanging around/texting with bad apples or something like that I am not sure how well this will work anyway to keep suggestive content away from children, even big sites like YouTube seem to sometimes tend towards it on the regular front page from time to time
- thih9 3y ago> if their site consists of 33.3 percent or more material How is that going to be counted? Per item? Or based on the actual amount of explicit content? I.e. are a porn movie and a regular movie with a single explicit scene treated the same way? What about written content, is non-stop erotica treated the same as Milan Kundera? And what if media gets mixed? E.g. an art book with act photography, or a documentary from an exhibition could present multiple works.