8 ms·
This story of decentralization has played out before. The hazard is that private grid infrastructure becomes affordable by the upper class, they stop soliciting
by hinkley 3y ago
This story of decentralization has played out before. The hazard is that private grid infrastructure becomes affordable by the upper class, they stop soliciting politicians to maintain infrastructure. Once the middle class can afford it, then the votes evaporate, and the lower class is absolutely fucked. A half rotten water supply or electric grid becomes fully rotten every time there’s stress on the system.
Phasing out natural gas in new construction is going to cause this passion play in slow motion. Have you priced out induction stoves? Phew.
- franl 3y agoWhat are some examples of this type of decentralization scenario playing out before? What you’re saying makes sense to me, but my hope would be that the decentralization would serve more as a supplement than a replacement - therefore still requiring ongoing maintenance and investment to main infra. The alternative without these microgrids and other microinfra is almost guaranteed to result in the half or fully rotten systems you predict as the prevailing recent political climate doesn’t give much confidence in terms of getting such massive projects planned and completed successfully (US-centric response).
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> What are some examples of this type of decentralization scenario playing out before? I am not very knowledgeable about this, but the public/private school debate seems to be one possibility.
- burkaman 3y ago> Phasing out natural gas in new construction is going to cause this passion play in slow motion. Have you priced out induction stoves? Phew. More than two thirds of US households already have electric stoves, and normal non-induction electric stoves are about the same price as gas ones. A ban on gas stoves would only affect rich people for the most part.
- DoingIsLearning 3y ago> A ban on gas stoves would only affect rich people for the most part. And professional kitchens. For the record I agree with phasing them out but I can see restaurant chefs fighting hard against it.
- mschuster91 3y agoMostly the old guard who doesn't want to adapt to induction ovens and Döner Kebab shops where there really is no replacement for a proper gas grill. At least here in Europe, many restaurants are switching because the writing is on the wall that natural gas will get very expensive very soon.
- cbluth 3y agoSo soon it that became expensive since the last year or so
- burkaman 3y agoSure, but all actual bans in the US so far have made exceptions for commercial kitchens.
- bluGill 3y agoIndication stoves are claimed to be as good as gas. However the cheapest induction stove in the US is 3x the price of the cheapest gas or electric. And if you go stove shopping you with find lots of options for gas or regular electric, but often only one induction model - if you want some combination of features and are willing to pay - you often still can't get it with induction. (dual ovens, number of burners, burner configuration, non-standard widths - there are lots of options that are at least interesting to someone who is cooking)
- mrDmrTmrJ 3y agoRespectfully - all of these "issues" get solved when you go from ~1%->100% market share. 100x increases in manufacturing volumes will do amazing things for final cost. Expanded market share to 100% will lead to every features imaginable being offered to the market. Ending gas stoves, and gas distribution in general, is a huge win. Just as phasing out incandescent light bulbs was a huge win. Each "infrastructure grid" that we run to every building (Electricity, Water/Sewer, Roads, IT, natural gas) is overwhelmingly expensive to build and maintain. And if you don't maintain it - you blow up San Bruno[1]. It would be great to delete one! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Bruno_pipeline_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Bruno_pipeline_explosion
- maliker 3y agoWhen solar was becoming affordable, there was a lot of talk in the industry about "grid defection" exactly as you describe, but it didn't come to pass. Now that energy storage is getting radically cheaper too, I think there's a decent chance that what you predict could happen. It would be... enormously bad. And I agree load growth plays a part in all this. The big growth will come from electric vehicles--once cars are all electric, that will roughly double the electricity demand.
- hadlock 3y agoRoofs generally last for 30 years. In my neighborhood at least, which was all built-out in a 3 year period in the mid-1970s, most of the roofs were replaced about 10-15 years ago (they're rated for 30 years, but everyone pushes their luck as far as possible). Because they replaced their roof pre-~2014 it wasn't cheap or common to do so and thus very little solar was installed at that point. Those who have had their roof replaced in the last 5-7 years went ahead and put solar on top. My guess would be that when the neighborhood "cycles" through new roofs again in ~15 years, more than half will elect to put in solar or solar/battery combo. We are due for a new roof in 2-3 years and plan on doing solar at that time, and possibly even battery.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThe 2022 Inflation Reduction Act has provisions where low-income households can get an electric or electric induction stove fully reimbursed, up to $840. Middle-income households can get half the price of the stove reimbursed. Apparently, individual states have to do stuff, so it might be like the medicaid expansions where some states opt out of providing stuff for poor people to make a political point.
- thegaulofthem 3y ago> opt out of providing stuff for poor people to make a political point. I would certainly hope my state isn’t giving out tax-payer funded luxury stoves. There is no such thing as “free” here.
- arcticbull 3y agoMy Bosch 36" mid-range induction cook top was about $2500. High-end ones are like $4000-8000 or even more. So nobody's getting a luxury anything for $850.
- nuancebydefault 3y agoI really do not get this. We have twice a 300 euros AEG in two kitchens already running 10 years. How many pits do you cook on simultaneously?
- arcticbull 3y agoMine has 2 round elements and one rectangular flex element. Generally 1-2.
- mcpackieh 3y agoOne for simmering sauce, one for boiling pasta, and a third for frying up some sausage, veggies, etc. Three at a time isn't unreasonable if you know how long everything takes and do it in parallel to all finish at the same time.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Phasing out natural gas in new construction is going to cause this passion play in slow motion. Have you priced out induction stoves? Phew. Two things here. For one, natural gas has to be removed from the market as the supply of gas is finite, it's bound to raise in price anyway due to CO2 taxes, it emits toxic particulates associated with lung disease, it's more efficient to run a heat pump than burn any kind of fossil fuel, and it's a major fire/explosion hazard particularly when maintenance is neglected. The other side is, if you're worried about electricity going down, you can always grab a gas cylinder for a camping stove and live off of that for a week and more - personally, I have an Enders Explorer portable grill that can double as a stove and two 5kg cylinders of gas, mostly to run outdoor BBQs but also usable in case of a prolonged grid outage.
- tick_tock_tick 3y ago> natural gas has to be removed from the market as the supply of gas is finite I'd drop this argument your other points are good but while gas might technically be finite it's not on any timescale that matters here.
- hinkley 3y agoIt's also, head and shoulders above all other fossil fuels, highly amenable to being synthetically produced using renewable resources.
- mschuster91 3y ago... which is still insanely wasteful because methane synthesis from scratch is just 50-60% efficient, and capacities are going to be limited - we need all the synth-fuel we can get for long distance air flight and transoceanic ships because these two usecases can't reasonably be shifted towards electric propulsion. Making synth-methane just to burn it in a stove which loses a lot of heat to the environment compared to an induction stove. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/d42473-022-00166-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/d42473-022-00166-2
- bluGill 3y ago
- black_13 3y ago[dead]
- Kon-Peki 3y ago> the lower class is absolutely fucked Is it ironic that the technology is being developed and tested in poor neighborhoods? [0] > Honghao Zheng, an analytics manager for Chicago's electric company, ComEd, described the microgrid as the seed of something bigger. Moving from a centralized energy model to a decentralized one is the goal, he said. > Zheng said what's novel about the Bronzeville project is that this grid, unlike others, is not a "one-way street" of power — it's designed to be able to "cluster" with other microgrids, such as the one at the nearby Illinois Institute of Technology. Later this year ComEd plans to test the grids' "island" function, meaning its ability to disconnect from the larger grid. > "This is only a starting point," Zheng said. "We are also thinking about how to expand this kind of innovative technology." A microgrid as it's known right now disconnects itself into an island that provides power for everything inside of it when the larger grid goes down. But what they're building now is a cluster of microgrids such that one microgrid can send its excess power to neighboring microgrids so they all have power. If this all works out then the rich folks aren't simply isolating themselves, they are also providing resiliency to their less-fortunate neighbors. [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/chicago-bronzeville-neighborhood-microgrid-sustainable-energy-future-2023-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/chicago-bronzeville-neighbor...
- bratgpttamer 3y agoUntil someone introduces a bidding mechanism, anyway. "Man, we had no power for DAYS and I only got $14.75 from that stupid electric grid thing"
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThis is what happens when general public service infrastructure becomes so bloated and ineffectual that even at huge scale it can not compete with small scale alternatives. At some point it becomes more efficient to put in a natural gas/water/electric storage in your back yard than pay for public service delivery.
- eldaisfish 3y agoThis is needlessly dramatic and negative. The electric grid is what it is today because several problems can only be addressed at scale. There is no way that individuals will accept all the reliability, maintenance and risk that comes with running their own electrical infrastructure. More importantly, location is a very important metric here. I always feel that comments on solar or renewable energy on this site come from a California-centric perspective. In almost all regions of the planet, power generation at scale provides security, resilience, stability, reliability and other metrics that are always superior to smaller, individual power generation sources.
- pictureofabear 3y agoYou're citing a separate problem... the lack of representation for the lower class. This has nothing to do with decentralization.
- throw10920 3y ago> This story of decentralization has played out before. Citation needed. This reads just like a really strong defense of centralized systems, ignoring the robustness and economic benefits of a decentralized grid, purely to push a political agenda.
- coderenegade 3y agoI'm willing to bet most people on here have never actually experienced living with decentralized infrastructure, and only have an abstract understanding of what it entails. I live on the edge of a state forest where the only centralized service we have is electricity (we still have solar). We have gas bottles for cooking and hot water, and when one runs out we switch it over and get it replaced. For sewerage we get the septic tank pumped, and for water we collect rainwater. If we have a dry year or use too much, we have to pay for water cartage. If the pump goes down, I'm either fixing it myself or paying someone else to fix it on short notice. Now, I chose this and it's how I grew up, so I wouldn't have it any other way. But the beauty of centralized systems is that they offset these burdens to an authority that handles all of that for you. If I were unable to pay for a new pump, well, I would have no water. A centralized system paid for by taxes guarantees that everyone will always have access to water under fairly mild conditions. The failure of centralized systems and people resorting to locally decentralized solutions isn't indicative of decentralized solutions being better, but more a failure of governance and bureaucracy. I mean, there's a reason we all moved from decentralized systems (like getting water from a well) to centralized systems in the first place. That's not to say that decentralized anything doesn't also have advantages, only that the distinction really matters, and people should be sure of what it is they're advocating for when they want to decentralize infrastructure like electricity and water that are vital for survival.
- throw10920 3y agoWhat? Nobody is saying that decentralized systems can't have centralized backups, or that you can't have a hybrid system. Your whole comment is predicated on a false dichotomy.
- archi42 3y agoNatural gas stoves are unhealthy[1]. Poor people already have worse health than rich people for a multitude of reasons [2]. So if more poor people get access to places with electrical stoves, their health improves. I only looked at walmart.com: Cheapest gas stove was 122US$, cheapest induction 222US$. If the 100US$ difference is relevant, you're neither building a house nor looking to rent an apt without a kitchen anyway. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=natural+gas+stove+health https://www.google.com/search?q=natural+gas+stove+health [2] https://www.google.com/search?q=health+of+poor+people https://www.google.com/search?q=health+of+poor+people e.g. https://health.gov/healthypeople/priority-areas/social-determinants-health/literature-summaries/poverty https://health.gov/healthypeople/priority-areas/social-deter...
- gottorf 3y agoIt's unhelpful to link to Google searches as sources; the first page of results is usually just news or blog articles very thin on facts. The risks to health of natural gas stoves (basically, just the production of NO2 and particulate matter) are almost all due to insufficient ventilation. Houses will need more and better (active) ventilation going forward anyway, as increasing insulation standards for homes mean they don't "breath" as much as they used to. So there's other ways to mitigate those health risks that don't involve banning something that many people enjoy using. Poor people as a whole indeed do have overall worth health than rich people, but switching to electric stoves won't move the needle almost at all. Gas stoves are most linked to pediatric asthma[0], but in terms of stuff that affect poor people more than rich people, that's hypertension, arthritis, smoking, and obesity[1], none of which care what kind of stove you cook with at home. [0]: https://rmi.org/gas-stoves-health-climate-asthma-risk/ https://rmi.org/gas-stoves-health-climate-asthma-risk/ [1]: https://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2016/16_0088.htm https://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2016/16_0088.htm