5 ms·
People want to focus on themselves. Career goals. Trips. Wealth. Fun. There are so many more outlets for dopamine in the modern world, and with the internet we
by echelon 3y ago
People want to focus on themselves. Career goals. Trips. Wealth. Fun.
There are so many more outlets for dopamine in the modern world, and with the internet we can post about it and share it with our peers instantly.
Children lock you into a life of servitude. They're "expensive furniture for tiny apartments" as Peter Zeihan says, no longer "free labor for the farm". Unlike dogs, you can't leave them at home unattended.
This isn't just Japan. This is everywhere.
- fartsucker69 3y agoiq 30 post nobody asked. people asked about why specifically japan stands out here, it is a big statistical outlier.
- echelon 3y agoIt's the start of a trend that will touch every nation, because the underlying cause is the same.
- highwaylights 3y agoThis seems like a very narrow take and doesn't match up to my experience at all. It also doesn't speak to the specific circumstances in Japan either. I'm sure "herbivore men" exist in the West, but they're not common enough that we have a term for it that I know of. (Sure there are incels, but that's something different).
- deanmoriarty 3y ago> People want to focus on themselves. Career goals. Trips. Wealth. Fun. As a non-Japanese couple in our late 30s who decided not to have kids, I confirm those are exactly our reasons. While I generally love kids and will be a good uncle, I just can't fathom the financial/emotional/time burden required to raise a couple of them for 18 years. I have just one life and this is my ride. If regret will eventually show up, I'll deal with it.
- barbacoa 3y ago>couple in our late 30s who decided not to have kids I fear for people who choose this path. Being childless in your 30s sounds like a blast. But that's just one stage of your life. How fun is life going to be when you're 40+? Or when your health begins to decline? Maybe it will be worth it, maybe not. When I visit older relatives who are childless (at least to me) their lives come off as hollow and sad.
- echelon 3y ago> When I visit older relatives who are childless (at least to me) their lives come off as hollow and sad. My grandfather willingly moved to Florida, away from the family. We'd be expected to visit for holidays, of course, but he wanted to play tennis in the sun.
- nunez 3y agoSame. We're in our late 30s and are definitely not having any. That said, I believe that a couple that is 1000% sure they want to have children and know what they are getting into should absolutely do it. The issue is that there are so many parents/future parents locked into the "you'll never be ready" or "you can never be too sure" mentality and fail to fully grasp what you're sacrificing and leaving behind when you become a parent.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think that the prevailing view of parenting vs individual actualization isn't particularly accurate. Having children is also an opportunity for personal development and growth, just of a different flavor and different direction. Of course there isnt a single answer, but I think people should question the implicit assumption that the "best ride", most fun, ect is the childfree one.
- veave 3y agoIn HN people don't only downvote things that are incorrect but also things they wished were incorrect.
- brianwawok 3y agoVery much true. God help you if your belief in a topic doesn’t align with 20 something Bay Area view.
- igetspam 3y agoWe also downvote sh*tposting
- andyjohnson0 3y agoJapan may be becoming more individualistic, but it is still highly collectivist by the standards of many parts of the world. So I'm unconvinced that individualism is the cause here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mcntsh 3y agoYou can't really leave dogs at home unattended either. You can't really take them on airplanes on vacation, you can't take them into many hotel rooms. You'll have a hard time getting a rental with them. You can't insure them on your health insurance and they end up costing a lot with medical problems. You can't claim them on your taxes. I always thought dogs were somehow less convenient than kids. At least society is built around the parent/kid dynamic somewhat.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"You can't really leave dogs at home unattended either." Yes. Yes you can...
- mcntsh 3y agoNot for long. They need to use the bathroom and eat. They make noise and destroy things.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"They need to use the bathroom and eat." You put food in a bowl and leave it on the floor. They eat it when they are hungry. It's quite simple... Bathroom? If you feed them at the same time every day, the usually go to the bathroom at the same time every day. You build habits. They go out before you go to work, and then when you come home, they go out and relieve themselves. There are also grass pads for smaller dogs that can be left inside the home. These are not difficult problems. "They make noise and destroy things" If yours does, you have a sh*tty dog that probably isn't being taken care of correctly. Most cared for dogs just sit around, sleep, and wait for their owners to get home.
- mcntsh 3y agoI've had dogs, lived with people with dogs, lived in apartments with neighbors with dogs. I know how it's "supposed to be" and I know how it "actually is."
- ahallock 3y agoI feel like this is the most selfish thing ever. The only reason you're here enjoying these dopamine outlets is because someone decided to bring you into the world. We should pay it forward. Quite a few of my liberal friends are childless, which is odd because who's going to carry on their values?
- Jyaif 3y ago> who's going to carry on their values? It's natural selection, applied to values/religion/etc...
- orwin 3y agoConservative's children! (it's a joke, sorry). Nobody owes you to make children. It's your own choice. But it's quite fun (and not that expensive in my country).
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI can understand selfishness. The part that is incomprehensibly bizarre to me is that the only long-term 100% positive experience in my life has been my children. I don't think it could possibly be otherwise. How do these people invert that so thoroughly, that they believe that it's not just negative from time to time, but overwhelmingly so and constantly? I hate to stoop to pop psychology, but that's some sort of profound multi-generational trauma going on, isn't it?
- igetspam 3y agoWhy is your experience the only one? Congratulations on feeling good about your decision but you're not everyone and your opinion is narrow and selfish.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think it is a fascinating question! Its not saying that there is only one possible experience, but asking where the pessimism is coming from.
- officeplant 3y agoParents had 4 kids by 35, I'm almost 36 and don't even want the added stress of being a responsible dog owner. Even if the world was on a more positive trend upwards I can't imagine myself being inclined to bring children into this hellscape.
- beedeebeedee 3y agoThis may describe your experience, but it is not a good description of what is going on Japan. What is going on in Japan is much more rooted in economic insecurity and a disillusionment with the expectations of society.
- circlefavshape 3y ago> Children lock you into a life of servitude. Little children do, but they don't stay little
- igetspam 3y agoBecause one day they'll be 30!
- codedokode 3y agoWhy doesn't the government pay for the time spent raising children (for example at 3x minimum wage), and cover expenses (e.g. rent, food, clothes, education, school uniform etc.)? I think then for some women it would be more profitable to raise kids rather than work at Walmart for example. If that is too expensive for the budget then you could grant citizenship to families with many children from developing countries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rasz 3y agoPoland does, at ~0.3 of minimum wage. Still very controversial.
- vorpalhex 3y agoI'm probably a bit older than you, my peer group is either having kids or they are never going to have kids. We are on that precipice. The people who really don't want kids, the ones sterilizing themselves, are all depressed. They have miserable lives. They aren't traveling and having great vacations, they aren't becoming CEOs, they aren't living in the lap of luxury. They're mostly alone. Oddly, the people who have kids travel a lot more despite it being much harder with a kid. We have a lot of family demanding we visit and who wants to visit. We have a lot of things to show the kids. The folks with kids are generally the ones with more illustrious careers, the ones higher up the food chain. Some of that may be that it's easier to have kids when you have more money. Wealth is not just money. It is the whole of your circumstance. Your home and whether you want to be in it, whether you like your life partner, and how your family unit gets along. You need enough money for things of course. Your theory sounds great on paper, but I don't think it holds up.
- orwin 3y agoI only have one sterilized friend (he's 32) and he definitely living the best life out of everyone I know. He has a sailing ship, two girls (that I know of). We went to the Canarias together in mars before he left for the Antilles, I think he was in Miami recently and he's sailing back with new friends this month. But I earn more money, and have a child on the way. Hopefully that means I'm worth more!