6 ms·
What Will the World Look Like with Less Babies?
- dilawar 3y ago__deleted__
- dumdumchan 3y agoCan you share your opinions on appendix and cancer?
- jacob171714 3y agoSo you're gonna stop using modern medicine that interferes with the natural ways of things?
- dilawar 3y agoI am not American. I didn't want this comment to be seen through Pro-Blah and Pro-Bluh lense. I am going to delete it.
- arrosenberg 3y agoLess crowding at national parks, hopefully.
- a_e_k 3y agoFewer!
- Razengan 3y agoWhat?
- croes 3y agoIt fewer babies not less babies https://www.quora.com/Which-is-correct-less-people-or-few-people https://www.quora.com/Which-is-correct-less-people-or-few-pe...
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoBabies are countable, so the preferred grammar is "fewer babies".
- OnlyMortal 3y ago“Less” versus “Fewer”.
- hermannj314 3y agoA discrete countable amount (i.e. fewer babies) is preferred over saying 'less babies' based on rules written by now dead English professors. Honestly, I could not care fewer.
- midoridensha 3y ago"Less babies" is grammatically incorrect. The proper wording is "fewer babies".
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoPeople who eat chocolate ice cream, or order Hawaiian pizza, are incorrect. The proper ice cream is pistachio, and the proper pizza is pepperoni New York Style.
- midoridensha 3y agoI agree; grammar rules should be abandoned. From now on, I'm going to use the word "less" to mean a larger number of something. If you can't understand me, it's your fault.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agohttps://youtu.be/Ab4WIVqPpjM https://youtu.be/Ab4WIVqPpjM
- Razengan 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0zNWswcqMg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0zNWswcqMg
- a_e_k 3y agoI wasn't going to post that... but I certainly was thinking of it! (Sadly, that particular video misses Davos later correcting Jon in turn.) Weird Al, too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RGWiTvYZR_w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RGWiTvYZR_w
- locopati 3y agoprescriptivist!
- Terr_ 3y ago> No one really knows why birth rates are dropping so fast. [...] Many people have theories but if you critically examine them they fall apart. > [#1] People do not have money for kids. [#2] The Government isn’t Providing pro-natal policies. [#3] This is happening only in societies that are not religious. [#4] Women are working and not having kids. That seems like an incomplete list. For example, how about this one: Industrialization lowers infant mortality with better medical care and creates alternate safety-nets to keep old people without kids from dying in a ditch. Gradually culture changes as people adjust to this, and they stop feeling the need for spare-kids as a hedge against death or to have large broods as a retirement plan. > It feels like we’re permanently entering a time where population will shrink. Much of the world's population boom in the last century was from lowered infant mortality [0] and people spending more time alive and being counted. [1] It should be no surprise that both of those hit diminishing returns: It is impossible to save more than 100% of the babies, and immortality is a hard problem to solve. [0] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/WLD/world/infant-mortality-rate https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/WLD/world/infant-morta... [1] https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy
- coffeebeqn 3y agoPro-natal policies are a drop in the bucket compared to the fact that basics like housing costs 10x more than with the previous high-baby-having generations
- bobthepanda 3y agoAlso the standard of raising kids has risen a lot as well. It is fairly easy to have a lot of malnourished illiterate children, but people choose to have healthy kids they send to college, which is a lot more time consuming and expensive.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> basics like housing costs 10x more than with the previous high-baby-having generations Thank you. I'm a millionaire. I want kids. I see no near-term path to having them without their costs rivaling that of financing multi-million dollar boats [1]. The fundamental problem is children are extremely expensive, particularly for the ambitious. (I'm putting aside the enormous liabilities that arise from e.g. one's child being disabled or trans or simply rebellious in some parts of the country.) [1] https://cpag.org.uk/sites/default/files/CPAG%20Cost%20of%20a%20Child%202012_1.pdf https://cpag.org.uk/sites/default/files/CPAG%20Cost%20of%20a... page 8
- DeathArrow 3y agoThis is a rather serious issue but very few people care. It is at least as important as global warming. Media and politicians don't care at all.
- croes 3y agoWhy is it serious?
- mo_42 3y agoBecause it's exponential decay: population_n = population_0 * 0.55^n (made-up exponent).
- awb 3y agoIn any oscillating trajectory you’d see exponents above and below 1. Tomorrow’s birth rate is not impacted by today’s. But the fear is that today’s birth rate will continue forever until societal collapse, which seems unlikely.
- nly 3y agoAging population, lower economic growth (less consumer demand for goods and services).
- zelos 3y agoLess pollution, less global warming, lower use of resources, less conflict.
- pyuser583 3y agoCounties with declining populations tend to become industrial catastrophes. Japan and Fukushima come to mind. Russia does too. Russia and Ukraine both have abysmal fertility rates. I don’t see less conflict there. Or between China and Taiwan.
- wiseowise 3y agoPeople finally started to realize that they have only one life and wasting half of it to raise another human is wasteful.
- HideousKojima 3y agoI wonder how your parents feel about your attitude, lucky for you they didn't share it.
- croes 3y agoHad they, it couldn't matter to him.
- wiseowise 3y agoAre you making some kind of an argument? Because I don’t see it.
- asimovfan 3y agoThis argument does not invalidate the original comment. I think my parents were stupid to have me and could have enjoyed their life better. I think i had two of the top 10 parents worldwide but still, it was a decision made with naivety and stupidity of youth.
- foogazi 3y ago> I think my parents were stupid to have me On what do you base this thought ?
- asimovfan 3y agoThe changes they had to make in their lives to accommodate my existence
- DeathArrow 3y agoJudging only by your comments, I might be tempted to agree. But your parents didn't have a crystal ball at the time they conceived you, so I disagree.
- femto 3y ago> Why Is This Happening? Maybe it's a reduction in security? https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/family-consequences-job-insecurity-fertility-and-marriage https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/family-consequences-job-insec... Children are a long term commitment. Being richer won't necessarily make a person have more children if they are uncertain whether the riches will continue. A $1000/month car, per the article, can be disposed of if things go bad. Children can't (unless you are in a Monty Python movie. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWWAC5ZMKeM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWWAC5ZMKeM )
- tetris11 3y agoThe $1000 dollar a month argument is weak though. If I have a job that pays $4000 a month but it requires driving 100km to get there, then a reliable car is a good investment. Not buying a car and raising kids instead (who require more than $1000 a month) would require me either having a great parental network to fall back on (e.g. parents, a village) or having those kids taken away from me as I fail to meet their needs (Also the article did not at all address the clickbait title that made me read it. Okay, we will have more pets maybe. Anything else?)
- nly 3y agoWell I can't speak for anybody else, but me and my partner are pushing mid to late 30s and simply haven't got there because of cost and lack of financial stability. It's difficult to impossible to survive on a single income like my parents did to raise me, and the cost of childcare is the same as losing one income regardless. For better or worse the economy has been reshaped around the assumption of dual income, full time working couples.
- silisili 3y agoYou're right. My wife and I have done the math multiple times, and we'd actually -lose- money if she went back to work. I remember childcare being rather communal in the US, where I lived, as recently as the early 90s. Now that the media and social media has turned everyone against each other, the only way out seemingly is to subsidize child care.
- nly 3y agoWell, a support network is one thing. My grandparents certainly babysat me on occasion, but me and my partner are quite far away (over an hours drive) away from any close family. Naturally my parents are also a lot older than my grandparents were as well, so it would be less fair on them. I really don't think the phenomenon of people having fewer kids or having kids later is a mystery!
- silisili 3y agoWhen I was growing up in the 80s, working class neighborhood, most wives had a part time job. Whoever was off that day would watch the kids. I remember sitting in random houses with 7 or so other kids, eating mac n cheese or bologna sandwiches, waiting for our moms to come pick us up after work. As an adult with my own kid now, it would seem such an idea is a pipe dream.
- nly 3y agoYeah, the decline in neighbourlyness would be an even more interesting phenomenon to study. My person hunch is back in the day there was a more "we're all in the same boat" feeling at the street level, where everyone had similar socioeconomic backgrounds whereas now that's not true at all. In the past, in the UK, everyone living in a road may have had the same landlord (the local council) but now you can have multi-millionaire with a £50K car living next door to someone in an identical house who is renting privately, on housing benefit, taking the bus to their minimum wage job, and struggling to feed their kids. People are much more willing to give and receive help from their "peers"
- rklaehn 3y agoWhat's surprising about people having less kids if the prevailing ideology in the west since many decades is basically malthusianism? People are getting told from an early age that humans are a pest and that the world would be better off without them.
- defrost 3y agoBetween four and six billion humans seems like a good target. There were only 2.5 billion in 1950, since then automation has advanced leaps and bounds meaning an advanced lifestyle with fewer workers and less resource drain is entirely possible with a more sustainable population size.
- rklaehn 3y agoWhy? There are huge stretches of the world that are basically uninhabited. Even in densely populated places like Europe there are large areas with low population density. People are crowding in cities and then complaining that there are too many people. Resource drain is no longer an issue once we got an economy running on photovoltaics and nuclear energy. Everything can be recycled given enough energy.
- defrost 3y ago> There are huge stretches of the world that are basically uninhabited. Like the proposed site for Resolution Copper, say? Nobody there save the people that got pushed aside when Europeans arrived in the US and I guess there's no issue with pushing them on again, treaties are meaningless and 8 billion people need their appliances. > Resource drain is no longer an issue once we got an economy running on photovoltaics Quickly now, just how much additional copper, lithium, vanadium, iron, aluminium, etc do we need to get there? And once we are there will this be just like building roads to fix traffic only to find that traffic increases to swamp the new roads? Last question, do you have any actual experience with 800 million tonne per annum resource mining (that's just iron ore mined in my state alone) or is your experience of life limited to ordering stuff and having it turn up? Your comment has the whiff of Magical Tech thinking to it.
- rklaehn 3y ago> Your comment has the whiff of Magical Tech thinking to it. Well, your post has the whiff of malthusian doomerism to it. Look up the Simon-Ehrlich wager. Ehrlich was wrong in every single respect. There are more people, yet they are economically better off. And nothing has run out. And yet the ideology of Ehrlich and Malthus has prevailed in the west. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon%E2%80%93Ehrlich_wager https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon%E2%80%93Ehrlich_wager
- dumdumchan 3y ago> fertility rates tend to fall below the level needed to maintain the population, 2.1 children per woman. Why 2.1 and not 2?
- cedilla 3y ago0.1 kids per woman are expected to die without procreating.
- yakubin 3y agoSome percentage of children are going to die before getting a chance to have their own children.
- xadoc 3y ago"The United Nations Population Division defines sub-replacement fertility as any rate below approximately 2.1 children born per woman of childbearing age, but the threshold can be as high as 3.4 in some developing countries because of higher mortality rates. Taken globally, the total fertility rate at replacement was 2.33 children per woman in 2003" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility
- bambataa 3y agoTo account for people who die before reproducing.
- taneliv 3y agoI think at least infant mortality and gender imbalance at birth (more boys are born than girls) require it to be above 2.
- jacob171714 3y agoYou've got a like 1/9 chance of dying by 21 I've heard. It's probably wrong but a decent amount of people die before they are able to have kids so they add a 0.1 to the replacement level.
- glimshe 3y ago
- silisili 3y agoOne thing I've been considering is the existence of the 401k or basically the Bogle strategy as a whole. Both expect yearly gains over time, due to increasing amounts going into the pools. But what happens when the elders start drawing down that money, and there isn't a base to replace it? Going forward, we could actually see such values shrink, I think? The uber rich aren't Bogleheads, after all.
- nly 3y agoIt's unlikely. As people live longer but want to retire at a similar age to their parents demand for risk assets is going to be even higher in the future. I mean, as much as interest rates have dramatically risen recently, real yields on 30 year UK government debt (as measured by the inflation-linked gilt yield) are at ~1%. That's just not going to cut the mustard given how little people are able or willing to save in to their retirement fund. To give you an idea, the difference between a 1% real return and a 4% real return, investing monthly over a 30 year horizon, is having 64% more in retirement.
- jay00 3y agoI believe one reason that is rarely talked about is that having children later in life makes you more tired than if you had them in your 20s. In the times when people were having more children, they were having them early. We all now how it is easier to shrug off a sleepless night in your 20s than in your 30s. We use that advantage to stay out drinking more when we are young, but it was probably evolved to help stay up at night when children were crying. So I think our cultural child bearing age is now misaligned from our biological adaptations, it feels exhausting to have children in your 30s
- sukki07 3y ago+1 for 'We all now how it is easier to shrug off a sleepless night in your 20s than in your 30s.'
- DeathArrow 3y ago>I believe one reason that is rarely talked about is that having children later in life makes you more tired than if you had them in your 20s I had my first kid at 38 and second at 41. Age didn't stop me.
- jay00 3y agoCongrats!
- Balgair 3y agoAfter our first, I felt like I gained superpowers (okay, not super, somehowpowers?). Especially with the lack of sleep. Even a month beforehand, that lack of sleep would have wrecked me. I mean, it still did, but somehow I just no longer cared. With my kid in my arms, the lack of sleep just seemed like a thing that was happening, the anxiety or 'wrongness' about not sleeping was gone. My body for sure still felt the effects. But my mind was cleared of the issues surrounding the lack of sleep. There was my child, needing help of some sort or another, and here I was, the parent. End of story. Gone were the thoughts that a lack of sleep would ever stop me from doing what needed to be done for my kid. Weather that be food, or my job, or groceries, or cleaning, whatever. If my kid needed me to get it done, it just got done, all the complaints in my mind about being too tired seemed, well, childish. I don't want to denigrate any parent. It's a tough thing to do. And it is exhausting. But, at least for me, once I became a parent, I just stopped caring that I was exhausted. When that screaming pooping little money sucker comes toddling over to you with a huge smile on the face after you walk in the room from work or wherever, all those worries and fears just somehow melt away and you just think to yourself how lucky you are to have any of it. I guess what I'm saying is that if you think you want to have kids, don't let your lack of energy due to age be a factor. Kids give you the energy.
- vidarh 3y agoIt's not costs per se as we see fertility rates drop in tandem with rising wealth. But indirectly, probably, in the form of raised expectations. You want to give your kids at least what you had as a child, ideally more, and that gets increasingly tied to high costs.
- just-tom 3y agoIs this concerning? I actually worry that the global population is constantly growing and in the future there won't be enough resources for eveybody. In what ways this is bad for society?
- DeathArrow 3y agoIt's not about global population. It's about the western civilization.
- sukki07 3y agoIMHO it is rising individualism triggerred from FOMO from social media where in you believe you still have something left to experience outside in the world and which cannot be done once you have small kids. Another one probably is how people with kids narrate their experience , where in they mention all the sleepless nights , limitations and costs , without telling about the postive aspects like happinesss , satisfaction and a stronger sense of purpose. Can't blame them given these aspects are very subtle and difficult to tell/narrate.
- rklaehn 3y agoYes, this is very true. If you listen to some people you would think that once you have kids your life is basically over. You will never be able to spend any time on yourself anymore. This is just not true - at least if you refuse to become an extreme helicopter parent. I have four kids. I had a ~10 year break where I very rarely made it to parties and music festivals, and my life was mostly work and kids. I had a great time and have never regretted my decision to have kids, but there were some things I missed. Now we start doing these things again, sometimes with the kids, sometimes because the kids are big enough to be alone or because we can afford a babysitter. Here is one egoistic argument for having kids: the world is going to become very confusing in a decade or two. There will come the time where you can't keep up anymore. Then you will be happy to have somebody that loves you unconditionally that can make decisions for you. I trust my kids way more to take care of me when I am old and confused than any institution or person motivated by money.
- wink 3y agoI don't think that's a 100% yes or no argument (especially not beforehand( but I'd say I know more parents that are actually really hard to get a hold of since the first kid, as in... you try to work with their schedule and there's nothing and then you basically stop seeing them unless you'd live close by and have kids the same age. Might be an atypical case here but it's my experience.
- highwaylights 3y agoThis article is selectively excluding large chunks of the planet. It mentions the developed world, but then continues to suggest that birth rates are falling below 2 everywhere when they most certainly are not. Niger: 6.89 Nigeria: 5.31 Mali: 6.04 Somalia, Chad, DR Congo are all over 6. There are going to be young people around when you get old, they’re just going to originate from different parts of the world. Assuming you don’t die suddenly then when you get to the end of your life someone is going to have to care for you whether you have children to do that or not.
- DeathArrow 3y ago>This article is selectively excluding large chunks of the planet. If someone writes an article about cats would you complain it's not saying anything about dogs?
- highwaylights 3y agoAbsolutely, if the article proceeds to infer that all pets scratch up houses and can’t be taught to poop outdoors.
- walterbell 3y agoHN ranking history for this thread: https://hnrankings.info/37072547/ https://hnrankings.info/37072547/
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoI'm not really concerned about this. I think the people like myself who really want to have babies are going to have babies one way or another. And it's not a question of "is it right" that they have more, or less, or quite the same stuff that I grew up with -- I didn't grow up with much, and I have even less now than I did then in some important senses, but I love life all the same if not more and I think my kids will too. And I even think this would be true regardless of whether we were living together in a cramped apartment in the inner city together or a big mansion out in the suburbs. An apartment looks twice as big when you're half the size of an adult. What matters is whether the kids feel like they're loved and cherished and desired, desired to be there, desired to be part of the family. In my darker moments I wonder if perhaps, when I was younger and less keen on having kids myself, it was because I was myself missing so desperately that last part. But I found it in the arms of my beloved, and I think there are many like me.
- hellothere1337 3y agoOn one hand the guys on top are telling us that we're destroying the planet and we should reduce carbon emissions by any means necessary (dont touch their private airplanes and yachts though). On the other hand the same guys are saying we're rapidly going to collapse because we're not birthing enough consumers. Hilarious really
- Cloudef 3y agoI want children, my gf wants children (3 even), but from financial stability point it does not seem very realistic right now.
- DeathArrow 3y agoWell, I always wanted children. I had them when the time was right.
- Cloudef 3y agoAnd that's how it should be. I'm just wondering if it's increasingly going to be for the lower middle class that the time will never be right.
- bjarneh 3y ago> Another argument is that women are working and do not have time to have kids. Isn't that a valid argument still (despite his Swiss semi-counter-example)? Many jobs are complicated these days and require education + experience, making it very hard for women who want to work and become economically independent to have kids early in life; when they are most fertile. I also think his Swiss example is somewhat misleading, since he argues that Switzerland has few women working (56%), and also a low birthrates (1.4). So at least 44% of the women have time to have babies, then Swiss birthrates should be high. But a friend of mine is from Switzerland, and his wife stopped working after they had a child (she has a PhD in biology as well, so highly educated). Schools typically send children home for 3 hours in the middle of the day (lunch/siesta or whatever you want to call it). Somebody has to be home, and that very often ends up being the mother. And after you've been out of the working life for a long period of time, getting back can be difficult. I.e. it could be that one of the reasons the Swiss women are hesitant to have children, is that they know that it will most likely end their career; so the implication could go the other way.
- DeathArrow 3y agoThere are two main reasons: selfishness and ideology. Which are both promoted now by media, activists, social media.
- M95D 3y ago> No one really knows why birth rates are dropping so fast. Did anyone think to ASK THE PEOPLE why they choose not to have children? Or that would be too difficult for today's journalists and bloggers? My case: 1) It's very difficult to raise even one child. It would degrade my quality of life a lot. 2) I hate children. I see around me lots of parents who love being parents and I simply can't understand them. This would probably make me a bad parent. 3) [The main reason.] If I had a child I would want him/her to have a better life than mine. EVERY parent wants that. But that's not possible, because my life is great! Let me focus on 3), because this explains the difference between countries. When the parent's life sucks (Africa), there's lots of hope and possibility of a better life for the child. When the parent's life is great (Europe, America, Japan) with very grim predictions about the future without oil, why would anyone have children?