4 ms·
contained details that would likely make patients identifiable to themselves. IMHO the real question of privacy is whether they would be identifiable to others
by userbinator 3y ago
contained details that would likely make patients identifiable to themselves.
IMHO the real question of privacy is whether they would be identifiable to others, not to themselves.
- batch12 3y ago> IMHO the real question of privacy is whether they would be identifiable to others, not to themselves I disagree. Just because my headless naked body can't easily be traced to me doesn't mean my privacy isn't violated if pictures are shared without my explicit concent.
- Bukhmanizer 3y ago> can't *easily* be traced to me Yeah, it would be identifiable to others, so that’s a violation of your privacy. A more accurate analogy is if someone shared a picture of the back of your own hand or something that would be basically impossible for anyone but you to recognize. I’m not saying it is or is not a violation of your privacy, but your example is flawed.
- waffleiron 3y agoIf I was in a situation where I have not given consent to take that picture, and I see that shared, it would make me wonder if any other pictures I didn’t agree to were also taken. See Ryan Calo’s work: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1641487 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1641487
- lobochrome 3y agoHow so? Because of the "easily" qualification? Is this ironic? If it can't be traced to you it is by definition perfect privacy.
- JamisonM 3y agoIf there is a publicly available picture of you that you did not consent to be published and literally nobody can currently identify it as you that is still a privacy violation. It is a violation because of the lack of consent, but it is also a violation because now you have to live with the fact that maybe some other information can link you to that picture in the future. There is no such thing as perfect privacy if any link can be created in the future, and the fear of the creation of that link going forward is itself a problem for the subject.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThe lack of consent makes it a consent violation, not a privacy violation.
- toofy 3y agodepending on jurisdiction and contexts i think it would likely make it both.
- haldujai 3y ago> literally nobody can currently identify it as you that is still a privacy violation. In this hypothetical it is not a privacy violation under HIPAA (US) or PHIPA (Ontario, Canada) as consent would not be required. Whether such a level of deidentification is possible is a different question and I agree it’s best to avoid the situation altogether. > if any link can be created in the future An example of this is CT/MRI scans of the head that were shared in open databases. The technology now exists to make a 3D rendering of the patients face which was not anticipated 15 years ago when these datasets were made.
- JamisonM 3y ago"In this hypothetical it is not a privacy violation under ... PHIPA (Ontario, Canada) as consent would not be required." That is not categorically true, PHIPA requires research ethics board to review research disclosures to determine if consent is required. So what is "too much" information that might violate privacy under Ontario law is a moving target, as our ability to violate privacy with less and less information progresses the standard should be more and more restrictive. Research use of course does not mean that the data needs to be public, as in my example, and raw data is often not made public. In your example it was, if that same database were created today I am confident the ethics board enlisted to review the disclosure would disallow it.