3 ms·
"Employee benefits? No no, they aren't employees, they are contractors who operate with a dramatically higher degree of autonomy... Except when we fire--er, uni
by Terr_ 3y ago
"Employee benefits? No no, they aren't employees, they are contractors who operate with a dramatically higher degree of autonomy... Except when we fire--er, unilaterally sever relations, because they are being autonomous in ways we wouldn't accept from employees." /s
- justrealist 3y agoOur discourse on this topic is horribly stunted by everyone — on both sides — insisting that there are only two God-ordained classes of employment: "employees" and "contractors". We would have infinitely more sophisticated discourse if we allowed for the possibility that our taxonomy does not capture the reality we live in, where there are intermediate classes of labor which should have some (but not all) the rights, protections, and expectations accorded to full-time employees.
- jfghi 3y agoWorst of both worlds?
- Terr_ 3y agoNovel categories for niche situations might be nice to have, but the lack of some Perfect Category isn't the main cause of the disagreements/injustice going around. No matter how many are invented, we'd almost certainly still have the problem of people mis-categorizing for profit. > Our discourse on this topic is horribly stunted by [...] insisting that there are only two Most of these cases involve resolving how (or whether) a current situation must be brought into alignment with current laws, rather than how laws could look in 10+ years, so I think it's reasonable for much of the discourse to reflect that. Sure, we could dramatically overhaul national employment laws and legal theory, but that's not what courts are supposed to do during a lawsuit, and it's usually outside the scope of what many local/state legislatures are prepared and willing to tackle.
- justrealist 3y ago> Sure, we could dramatically overhaul national employment laws and legal theory, but that's not what courts are supposed to do during a lawsuit, and it's usually outside the scope of what many local/state legislatures are prepared and willing to tackle Literally what you are saying is "well that might be a better place to be, but the courts can't do it, and also it's too hard for the legislatures". If you truly believe that making good laws is too complicated for the government to handle, then people and corporations are perfectly within their moral rights to ignore the bad laws and to do everything in the power to evade the consequences. You've lost the mandate of heaven, it's time to start over.
- Terr_ 3y agoMore like: "You shouldn't be surprised that changing X doesn't come up so often, given that a majority of discussions involve timelines where X cannot be implemented or groups that simply don't have authority to change X."
- lokar 3y agohttps://content.next.westlaw.com/practical-law/document/Icaea096c1c5311ecbea4f0dc9fb69570/Dependent-Contractor?viewType=FullText&transitionType=Default&contextData=(sc.Default) https://content.next.westlaw.com/practical-law/document/Icae...
- XorNot 3y agoSuch as? What's a practical example of this that doesn't just result in negative outcomes for workers?
- Phlarp 3y agoBut won't someone think of the shareholders? Surely we can't deprive them of positive financial outcomes over something as silly as a living wage for workers?
- totetsu 3y agoDon’t the words follow the laws, and weren’t employment laws fraught for and won because ambiguity over labour was socially undesirable.?
- justrealist 3y agoI don't even know what point is being made here, but it's ridiculous to claim that people in the 1930s or whatever crafted the perfect labor/employer social contract which would be applicable ad infinitum.
- skybrian 3y agoThe nature of gig work is that you always need to be looking for your next gig. The problem they talk about here is getting cut off from the matchmaking service, not that one customer doesn’t like you.
- marcus0x62 3y ago> The problem they talk about here is getting cut off from the matchmaking service, Some people call that “getting fired.”
- rusk 3y ago“Matchmaking service”
- flextheruler 3y agoA lot of drivers I see are on multiple different gig apps they use interchangeably. There are like 3 food delivery apps and then 2 ride sharing apps. Anyone doing gig work full time is probably on all the apps. Also I don’t think they permanently end the relationship until they’ve investigated it. No way they permanently cut drivers just for an accusation of a rider. That’s obviously a bit different from a regular job.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoThat's not the case in Finland. In Finland the "independent contractors" who make food deliveries are expected to commit to a certain amount of work at a regular interval (you know, like 8 hours per day for 5 days a week or so). There is a lot of competition for these courier gigs, so the companies can choose who they allow to get gigs.
- bawolff 3y ago> Except when we fire--er, unilaterally sever relations, because they are being autonomous in ways we wouldn't accept from employees." Unilaterally firing is much more inline with being a contractor than an employee.