5 ms·
A terrifying side-effect of AI is that everything is now potential "training data" and there's financial incentive to vacuum up any and all possible data. The s
by xnx 3y ago
A terrifying side-effect of AI is that everything is now potential "training data" and there's financial incentive to vacuum up any and all possible data. The situation on Windows is much worse than Chrome extensions (which have been attempting this for awhile) because of the near non-existent permission limits on Windows. I was shocked to learn just yesterday that Nvidia drivers were doing this. It feels extremely gross, like someone has broken into your home.
- bogwog 3y agoThis might actually be a good thing. For the longest time, very few people cared about privacy issues, which is why we live in a privacy hellscape today. If AI fears can motivate people to start taking privacy issues seriously, then we might actually see some strong privacy legislation, or more privacy-focused businesses to meet new demand. (or maybe I'm just being overly optimistic)
- distant_hat 3y agoThese are really niche issues and most people aren't even aware, let alone care about this. The only real solution to this is some kind of legislation that makes it difficult to carry on with business as usual. I wonder how this data collection squares with GDPR?
- bogwog 3y ago> These are really niche issues and most people aren't even aware, let alone care about this. Everyone seems to be aware of the protests in Hollywood, and I don't think it's too much of a stretch to tie that to privacy issues. Those AI models taking artists' jobs were trained with data scraped from the internet. Even if you aren't an artist, there's a risk that the data these companies collect on you will be used to train an AI model that will take your job, so you shouldn't be giving it away for free.
- ollien 3y agoI do think that's a bit of a stretch. Regardless of your opinions on the ethics of AI companies training on scraped data, how is scraping publicly available artistic works a privacy issue? Me, personally, I might call it unethical and undesirable, but I wouldn't call it an issue of "privacy" on its face.
- barbariangrunge 3y agoThere’s no union of people vs surveillance tech to act on our behalf
- landemva 3y ago> The only real solution to this is some kind of legislation that makes it difficult to carry on with business as usual. I have watched the voluntary full body scans at TSA checkpoints for years and have concluded people do not care to opt out of any data collection. The people don't care, or how many people do you see opting out of full body scans at TSA? People gleefully pose for TSA's new and voluntary facial recognition. People go along with coercion even by government, so why do you think we can rely on government to solve privacy issues?
- dijit 3y agoHa! I get so much shit from my partner because I refuse to go through those scanners. I don't make a big scene about it, but it's fun to note how much social pressure there is to just follow. Most Airports are actually totally fine with the opt-out, except the British ones for some reason. "You won't always be able to opt out y'know" - yes mate, but then I probably won't fly anymore.
- JohnFen 3y ago> "You won't always be able to opt out y'know" What a strange thing to say. Maybe not, but you are able to opt out right now, and that's what matters most at that moment.
- kube-system 3y ago> how many people do you see opting out of full body scans at TSA They're all in the pre-check line.
- landemva 3y agoAn airline put me in precheck a few years ago due to FF status. Now it requires an application to government and fingerprint. And global entry (immigration) wants an eyeball scan. Biometric collection to avoid a TSA massage is not privacy.
- kube-system 3y ago
- thefurdrake 3y agoI'm still holding out from the days when basically everyone on the internet understood you shouldn't post intimate details about your life online (the age before social ~~cancer~~ media). I long for a return to common sense. Maybe AI will do the trick, but I doubt it. Plenty of people are happy with behavioral prediction if it means convenience without caring about the implications.
- tivert 3y ago> I long for a return to common sense. Maybe AI will do the trick, but I doubt it. Plenty of people are happy with behavioral prediction if it means convenience without caring about the implications. The general population isn't going to care about "privacy" in the abstract, that kind of thinking reserved for an activist fringe. IMHO, the only way any progress will every be made on such abstract things is activists influencing government to force the changes. The general population will respond to realistic fear and danger, though (e.g. witness all the rituals people do to avoid identity theft). Maybe the best way forward is to cultivate fear in people of losing their livelihood to AI, and present these privacy invasions as an attack on that front.
- xnx 3y ago> The general population isn't going to care about "privacy" in the abstract, Totally agree. It's better to frame it in terms of "Nvidia tracks every porn site you visit and what you do there" or "company x knows everything you buy online and sells it to anyone who can pay".
- smoldesu 3y agoWell, be careful how you word it. At the core of the problem, nobody has control over their devices. If you beat a drum complaining about Nvidia having DMA access then you have to go after Apple and Microsoft next, which would probably lead to most people getting confused. If they found out about PRISM or XKeyscore, they would probably feel hopeless and give up. Treating privacy in the abstract is how you help people meaningfully resist it. In the literal sense, we can do very little to ensure our privacy on consumer hardware.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoIt's great that the bourgeoisie are treating workers so poorly: maybe soon we can start eating them in public! I don't feel optimistic about any of this. What we know already is that safety should not be determined by the boundary of "what people take seriously".
- barrysteve 3y agoIt goes without saying at this time, an internet connected computer is a privacy liability.
- pkulak 3y agoInternet-connected Windows computer.
- yomlica8 3y agoI feel like most people just want to pretend the privacy respecting alternatives don't even exist so they can give up. See the endless parade of excuses about why people can't help but use Chrome still. The battle is well and truly lost on Windows but the line is mostly being held on linux still.
- squarefoot 3y ago> Internet-connected Windows computer. Plus any Internet connected and proprietary (as in closed) device. AI will be trained on home appliances usage, what fridges contain, washing machine cycles, robot lawnmowers cleans, and of course phones, TVs and cars usage. Pretty much every connected and proprietary device, from vehicles down to electric toothbrushes, will phone home usage data that will be used to train AI, besides of course users profiling for marketing purposes. An old tagline once said something like "Windows, security, networking; choose only two, you can't have them all". Now it would be "proprietary, privacy, connected; ...".
- amelius 3y ago> A terrifying side-effect of AI is that everything is now potential "training data" and there's financial incentive to vacuum up any and all possible data. Good thing that extensive user-tracking by advertising companies already prepared us for it!
- jwells89 3y agoDesktop software has been a consistent and egregious offender when it comes to overstepping bounds for a long, long time… especially big corporate desktop software (hi Adobe). It’s honestly kind of shocking that all desktop OSes didn’t gain something like mobile permissions over a decade ago. macOS has some as do a few configurations of Linux, and yeah Windows is happy to hand over not only your farm but also a few acres from that of your neighbors’ farm to anybody who even suggests slight interest. I know there’s been much consternation over permissions, sandboxing, etc and how they complicate software development and power user workflows, but I don’t see a path forward where they aren’t necessary.
- fsflover 3y ago> It’s honestly kind of shocking that all desktop OSes didn’t gain something like mobile permissions over a decade ago. Consider Qubes OS if you need to isolate the apps on desktop. I'm a happy daily driving user.
- gunapologist99 3y agoI wish the advances in Qubes would eventually make it out of Qubes and be available in other distros.
- fsflover 3y agoWhat's wrong with Qubes itself?
- ikekkdcjkfke 3y ago"Agree to continue"