2 ms·
> Mexico has a slightly lower GDP per capita ($10k) than China ($12k) as per 2021 according to the world bank GDP/GDP per Capita =/= Household Income GDP is a
by alephnerd 3y ago
> Mexico has a slightly lower GDP per capita ($10k) than China ($12k) as per 2021 according to the world bank
GDP/GDP per Capita =/= Household Income
GDP is a representation of economic production (ie. how much shit you can produce).
Economic Productivity doesn't neccesarily scale with Wage Growth, hence why you see America's GDP per Capita approach $80k/yr yet median income around $60-70k/yr
> Mexico has a median household income of $3.5K compared to China's $4.8K [2].
CEIC Data's numbers are off on both matters.
The datasets I've included in my citations are those from the Govt of China (National Bureau of Statistics of China [0]) and the Govt of Mexico (National Institute of Statistics and Geography [1]).
The Chinese numbers I provided were released last year in 2022 and the Mexican numbers I provided were for 2020 (Mexico computes median income every 2 years)
In my experience CEIC Data's datasets are entirely off. Furthermore, digging into their datasets, it appears they aren't translating numbers correctly.
Some countries like Mexico and Italy report Median household income on a quarterly cadence, which CEIC doesn't take into account and explains why Italy's household income is listed at $15k despite the numbers provided to the EU are much higher.
> Your numbers are way off
In the future, when discussing economic metrics, I recommend sourcing directly from that Nation or State's Statistical Agency. The data they provide is more up to date and provides relevant context that 3rd party scrapers like CEIC or Statisa don't provide. Learning to speak/read Mandarin or Spanish helps as well, as policy discussions in China and Mexico tend to occur in those languages respectively.
[0] - http://www.stats.gov.cn/ http://www.stats.gov.cn/
[1] - https://www.inegi.org.mx/ https://www.inegi.org.mx/
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYou are comparing numbers taken from two different sources using two different methodologies, that isn't going to work. You need to take from one data set or do a lot of work to adapt "Govt of China" numbers and "Govt of Mexico" numbers. > In the future, when discussing economic metrics, I recommend sourcing directly from that Nation or State's Statistical Agency. This doesn't work. You are basically taking apples from one place and comparing them to oranges from another place. Unless you are willing to do a few years of meta-research to see how the numbers really compare with each other, they can't be compared in any meaningful way. You are basically stating that all agencies that compare China and Mexico GPD/per capita along with incomes are wrong? Because I don't think you can find an aggregated data set out there anymore that has Mexico richer than China by most income and per-capita measures (and anyways, this only happened a couple of years ago, a couple of years in the future it will be no contest).
- alephnerd 3y ago> two different sources using two different methodologies, that isn't going to work They use the same methodology and provide the USD conversion they used. This is all in the docs. Don't argue with an ex-Policymaker who's job was devoted to analyzing and distilling policies from these metrics > agencies that compare China and Mexico GPD/per capita When comparing development and quality of life, Median Income is generally the goto, along with Health metrics, Internet Penetration, Education Access, etc. GDP per capita was NEVER meant to compare quality of life, as it is Gross Domestic PRODUCTION. If ownership of production was 100% distributed equally, then GDP per Capita would be the same as your Median Income, but such is not the case.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoEven comparing average income, for all aggregated data sets, China comes out a $1 or 2k or so ahead of mexico per year. E.g. https://wisevoter.com/country-rankings/median-income-by-country/ https://wisevoter.com/country-rankings/median-income-by-coun...