6 ms·
Mexico gdp per capita, $10,000 USA: $70,000 It's going to be a heinously asymmetric exchange. Good longterm trade demands equity. Not equality, but some basic
by ggm 3y ago
Mexico gdp per capita, $10,000
USA: $70,000
It's going to be a heinously asymmetric exchange. Good longterm trade demands equity. Not equality, but some basic equity. Australia's experience with US trade negotiations is that it's highly distorted and suits America better. The TPP was shedloads better without the US, for everyone else.
I'm not saying it's a bad aspiration, just "be careful what you wish for"
That said, NAFTA wasn't bad for Mexico. There's hope.
- midoridensha 3y ago>The TPP was shedloads better without the US, for everyone else. The US shouldn't have been allowed to negotiate anything in the TPP; they should have just been allowed to sign on or not, after everything had been negotiated among all the other nations.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThe first thing to understand about trade is that it is always beneficial for both parties. Because each side can simply decline a transaction that doesn't help them.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoCountries aren't Borg ships. Trade between countries have beneficiaries and victims in both countries. The victims usually have zero say in the trade so, no, they can't simply decline a transaction that harms them.
- worrycue 3y agoThey can decline the whole agreement. Thus the agreement has to be a win for them too else there is no reason to sign.
- sidkshatriya 3y agoThis is assuming that every trade delegation can accurately predict all the impacts into the future. This is especially difficult now because the pace of change in the world is only increasing. In general trade is a good thing. It must be encouraged but everything is not so open and shut.
- worrycue 3y agoInaccurate predictions go “both ways” and applies to both countries.
- notnaut 3y agoThe benefits and consequences of which are entirely asymmetrical. There’s a reason poor people engage in significantly higher rates of some of the worst “trade decisions” in the form of gambling. On top of that, when your pool of resources are closer to skim, poor trade decisions result in health-harmful effects, which continue to contribute to poor decision making.
- BurningFrog 3y agoWho are the victims when someone buys something from someone in another country? How is that different from when they buy from someone in the same country?
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThe typical argument is in a closed market everyone buys something produced locally by local labor. In an open market the lowest cost supplier wins. Which will mean when costs of production are asymmetric, the supplier in the more expensive market loses. So while a single transaction has occurred, someone loses because of the trade agreement. This is because in a market that’s not theoretical there are actual people losing out. But this is the typical argument against free trade and protectionism - I assume it’s not new? I’m sympathetic fwiw. But I think maximizing trade is generally good and don’t want to see a reversal. The real issue in my mind is trade allows for environmental, labor, and other regulatory arbitrage. If the benefits in pricing were just market based I’d be down with it no matter the pain. But that’s not really what’s going on. The regulatory arbitrage is a race to the bottom not just in wages or other spaces that in my belief stabilize over time, in irreversible spaces like destruction of the earth.
- sidkshatriya 3y agoWhat you’re saying is correct but a tad bit theoretical. If a country is flooding your market with goods your manufacturers cannot possibly compete with, it leads to the destruction of your manufacturing capacity. So while the consumers are better of in the short/medium run in your country they are left vulnerable in the long run. The issue is balancing the short term positive impact of trade with the long term strategic impacts on your economy. Customs duties can help level the playing field a bit and allow local manufacturing to adjust. Sometimes local manufacturing can never adjust and as a country you need to make the tough decision that it’s ok for those factories to close permanently.
- bootsmann 3y agoComparative advantage is a thing, an economy can function perfectly fine without a local source of steel manufacturing. I don’t understand why people fetishize manufacturing of cheap consumer goods as a sector that is more essential than anything else.
- jakeinspace 3y agoBecause if that trade partner unilaterally shuts off trade with you due to a dispute or war, then you are hosed. They can probably find other buyers for their steel, but you will have to pay a lot more, if you can find enough at all.
- yaa_minu 3y agoThis problem seems completely unrealistic because then you simply buy through the countries they haven't banned? What you're suggesting will only work if said country is a global superpower that can bully every country to tow the line. At the end of the day, no country can produce all the "critical" things it needs so this national security defence of restrictions on trade seems like a very unwise insurance to buy in almost all cases except maybe your millitary supply chain.
- edgyquant 3y ago
- CPLX 3y agoThis is fucking ridiculous, and I have a degree in economics. Even in the sort of useless basic neoclassical models there are a million exceptions to this rule like incubation of infant industries, resource extraction, national defense and health, and so on. And nobody sane even believes that stuff any more. Trade can benefit societies or destroy them. Details matter.
- ChainOfFools 3y agoI happen to have a client right now who is in the midst of a massive downturn in business but is also obligated to pay for our services at a rate negotiated more than a year ago when they were in the midst of a brisk upswing in business; an upswing that had been going on for several years with no obvious indication that it would ever change. Our services, though immensely useful, are not absolutely necessary for their business to function and frankly are much more of a burden than a benefit for them at this point. Yet they cannot refuse to do business with us, and must pay for services that are unnecessary every month until either this obligation becomes part of what kills them, or their fortunes return to the state they were in a year ago. I'm sorry, but your belief is simplistic, shallow and naieve to the realities of business and trade as they are actually practiced.
- wsgeorge 3y ago> Yet they cannot refuse to do business with us... I obviously know little about business and "trade", because this strikes me as odd. I mean, I get that it's contractual, but how could a well-written contract not anticipate a time when doing said business with you would be detrimental to the company forced to pay... And, long term, such a situation hurts both parties, because if "this obligation becomes part of what kills them", the business on the receiving end also loses a customer.
- bombcar 3y agoIt’s how SaaS and most business contracts operate. Only tiny personally negotiated ones will have downturn provisions - and many companies have never experienced a downturn.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SanderNL 3y agoIncidentally, how do you handle such a situation? I'm a bad business man and would probably let them off the hook for a while so they can recover. In my dreamworld this will build significant amounts of longterm goodwill.
- pxue 3y agoYou ever heard of the opium trade force on China?
- lmpdev 3y agoThe crux of your argument doesn't hold water outside of economics circles. The power imbalance between parties makes "simply declining" as real a possibility as Plato's Forms. In a perfect world with almost all degrees of freedom removed, yes, you're correct. But the world is not perfect, ensuring a beneficial transaction to both parties for every transaction is simply intractable without infinite time/computational resources to brute force a solution, every time. To expand on the dogmatic proclamations economists are prone to making, this is why almost all natural and formal scientists have conscious or unconscious disdain for the claim that economics has a claim to the same epistemological rigour as other sciences. You can't extrapolate results and lemmas from within a domain of discourse to the outside world. Even the best economic models and the real world are not isometric. Implying that they are has so far resulted in some fantastic and incomprehensibly efficient systems but also an untold amount of human suffering.
- ethanbond 3y agoAll of that is true and yet it is still mostly true that most transactions are beneficial to both parties — or at least appears more beneficial than known alternatives which is in practice a synonym of “beneficial.”
- abduhl 3y agoSorry, this is just drivel. Trade happens between individuals or businesses, not countries. If the numbers don’t make sense for a business they will certainly “just decline,” although the numbers might make sense for another business. The large disparity in wealth actually helps the economically weaker party oftentimes because a X% increase in cost will often mean less to the wealthy purchaser (who will mark up the product accordingly) than to the poor seller relatively.
- rajamaka 3y agoIs this ChatGPT generated?
- jncfhnb 3y ago“Give me 10 dollars or I shoot you in the head” “Give me 10 dollars or I stop supporting your industry and threaten famine” Trade includes leverage and threats
- notnaut 3y agoThere is a significant pillar of free trade called “grifting” that this seems to ignore.
- JustLurking2022 3y agoIt's good for someone on each side, but necessarily the population at large on each side... Plenty of dictators will happily sell off their country's natural resources to line their own pockets, and the same general principal holds true for many other types of transactions.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThe only parties to a trade are the buyer and the seller. If both don't think they'll be better off doing the trade, it won't happen. No one else is materially affected. You can think of this as how trade creates wealth!
- slv77 3y agoThis assumes that both parties are rational agents acting with full knowledge, no coercion and no externalities. The rational agent in economics is similar to the spherical cow in physics. Great for modeling but pretty useless to a cowboy.
- BurningFrog 3y agoI think you missed the word "think".
- goodbyesf 3y ago> The first thing to understand about trade is that it is always beneficial for both parties. Not true. There can be winners and losers in 'trading' and usually there are. For example, the native americans and europeans being a prime example. > Because each side can simply decline a transaction that doesn't help them. Not if one side is much stronger and liable to invade or punish you. The past 500 years is essentially a story of europeans invading/'exploring' to get better 'trade terms' from natives, africans, indians, chinese, ottomans, japanese, etc. The biggest winners of trade in the last 500 years were europeans and the biggest losers are everyone else.
- syntaxing 3y agoTrade is always better without the US until someone needs the US military. Then if the US doesn’t step in, someone is gonna complain about the morality of it. You can’t have it both ways.
- threeseed 3y agoEvery trading relationship will favour the stronger side. EU and China in particular have been far more aggressive than the US has in pursuing their interests against smaller countries. Australia in particular has been subject to unprecedented economic coercion and manipulation by China. It's not pretty. But still trading ultimately does benefit both sides.
- roenxi 3y agoYeah, for example China's position of overwhelming strength vs. weak little USoA meant that China's wages have risen by an order of magnitude and their technology catapulted into the present century, building them in to the world's largest economy. China has gotten far more out of trading with the US than the US has, and that is accounting for the significant amount of free stuff that China effectively donated to the US in exchange for worthless paper. Trade relations favour the side who adopts the most liberal economic posture.
- twelve40 3y agoi don't necessarily disagree, but why do you think it absolutely has to be symmetric in order for both parties to gain? When Japan was allowed on the US market, around 1960, their GDP per capita was like $400 vs. $3000 in the US. both turned out alright.
- ggm 3y agoIf referring to me I said equity not equality. The gdp difference makes it implausible for the balance of trade to reflect domestic patterns. It will be cheap labour in Mexico and goods imported to the USA at lower tarrifs. Like NAFTA, it will have internal opposition.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> I said equity not equality I have never seen these terms used in international relations. In American English, I take them to be synonymous with equality outcome versus equal opportunity. How does that map to entire nations?
- didibus 3y agoNormally equity refers to everyone getting their fair share. It's never been synonymous with equality of outcomes. For example, equal opportunity might dictate that you consider both women and men for a job position, giving women equal opportunity. But equity demands that they'd be paid the same for the same work.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> equity demands that they'd be paid the same for the same work Which is equality of outcomes. (What “fair” means is the entire debate. Redefining fair as equitable doesn’t move us forward. Maybe we have this contortion because equality of outcomes became synonymous with communism, so now we get equity and equality with no bearing for those terms’ histories.) This redefinition of “equity” is modern and regional to parts of America. It sounds like it’s based on equity in law [1], but it’s not. That newness and regionality makes it difficult to predict what someone launching it into a new domain, like international relations, means, hence why I asked. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_(law) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_(law)
- wslh 3y ago> Mexico gdp per capita, $10,000 USA: $70,000 Honest and direct question: how much drug trafficking adds to the GDP of a country? [1] I think we need a realpolitik/freakonomics approach to these discussion to get the whole picture and take decisions. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/24/do-mexican-drug-cartels-make-billion-year/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/24/do-mexica...
- alephnerd 3y ago> Honest and direct question: how much drug trafficking adds to the GDP of a country $0. The underground economy isn't included in GDP calculations. This was a major reason why China and India both tried to force cashless transactions so as to tamp down on the more egregious forms of tax evasion.
- wslh 3y agoI mean, the real GDP. I understand that the GDP does not include illegal activities. Even if not, money laundering is included in the GDP [1]. [1] The Relationship between Economic Growth and Money Laundering, a Linear Regression Model
- alephnerd 3y ago> the real GDP Probably somewhere around a 30-50% increase in true GDP based on similar investigations done in India and China.
- ochoseis 3y agoAs Mexico develops their economy and skills specialize, then wages will go up (they can’t even refine their own oil right now). Low skill manufacturing will then push farther south. Overall a win for the western hemisphere.
- ftyers 3y agoIsn't there a refinería at Salina Cruz?
- ethagknight 3y agoSimilar to poor southern US states being forced to do business with Californians and NY because all the copyrights and government blessings are controlled by Californians and New Yorkers. Want to borrow money? Got to get permission from NY. Want to use software? Got to pay a certain couple company's tax. Parody of course... but highlights the complexities of trade arrangements as well as the absurdity of simply writing off a trade agreement as only harmful to the poorer entity.
- jxf 3y agoThose states are also huge net receivers of federal investment, too.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- lotsofpulp 3y agoNot similar at all. The federal government is very clear that only they can affect interstate commerce. Businesses can register in however many states they want, and state governments have no say on how the business is conducted in other states.
- aristus 3y agoIn reality, producing different product variants is infeasible and so bigger states drive standards. That's why cars used to be marketed as having "California emissions", and why textbook companies kowtow to Texas.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat is not the same as a poor southern state having to pay CA or NY. That is a business deciding to choose certain economies of scale. And California and New York’s population is not that big, the US south has quite a lot of people, and the #2 and #3 states in terms of population, so I doubt the premise that CA/NY standards are “taxing” consumers in the US south as implied earlier.
- dudeinjapan 3y agoChina did pretty well in last 30 years despite inequality with US. Trade with the US and those GDP gaps tend to narrow in the long term.
- e12e 3y ago> Mexico gdp per capita, $10,000 > USA: $70,000 China: $12,000?
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThe biggest loser out of this isn't necessarily the US, it's Canada, who was US's biggest trading partner until 2014 when China displaced us. I guess this makes us 3rd. The two economies are highly integrated, especially in the auto sector where parts move back and forth multiple times for a single vehicle, and manufacturing plants in Ontario playing the role of slightly-cheaper-skilled labour integrated into a continent-wide system. But the trend in the last 20 years has been a one-two-punch with the movement of manufacturing capital to China, but also to Mexico, putting Canadian workers in secondary industries at a disadvantage. Didn't help that the previous conservative government heavily promoted primary industry (primarily raw oil exports) over secondary; pushing resource exports over manufacturing, letting the dollar rise, etc. And then after that, Trump stirred up a trade war around steel and other exports, etc. That has improved, and with a weaker dollar, Biden in power, and cooling relations with China... manufacturing has started to improve here again. But it's not a long term good situation, I think.