3 ms·
Oh man, another one of these "America is going to collapse or has collapsed" articles. The evidence shows the opposite: by almost every metric, the US is in a
by paulpauper 3y ago
Oh man, another one of these "America is going to collapse or has collapsed" articles. The evidence shows the opposite: by almost every metric, the US is in a better position and stronger compared to the rest of the world, but also stronger on an absolute basis too such as real GDP, corporate profits, stock market gains, low unemployment rate, tech/innovation (such as electric cars, AI, etc.), etc. Even in regard to inflation or unrest, things are still worse elsewhere, such as protests in France, or even higher inflation in Germany, the UK, and Turkey. if America does collapse, it will only be after the rest of the world or conditional on the rest of the world collapsing too and likely first.
Anyone who has strong conviction otherwise of collapse can put up money right now and bet on such as outcome, such as with put options on the S&P 500 , or puts on the dollar , or shorting the S&P 500 and going 'long' foreign markets. Many have, and it put it bluntly, has ended badly.
- myshpa 3y agoThe article is not solely about the US.
- distortionfield 3y agoBut the comparison is clearly the main case in their argument.
- jltsiren 3y agoIf America does collapse, it will likely be for political reasons. Maybe the people in power will let it crash and burn for some misguided principle, or they will do something immensely stupid with unforeseen consequences. American economy is strong, and the society is robust enough, but there are serious risks due to the combination of dysfunctional politics and a high degree of centralization.
- tivert 3y ago> and the society is robust enough, but there are serious risks due to the combination of dysfunctional politics Aren't America's dysfunctional politics evidence against the idea that "[American] society is robust enough"? Politics and society are not distinct entities in a democracy.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoEconomically we seem to have primed ourselves for a kind of crackup boom. One cycle from now, or mabe half, the relevant numbers may not add up anymore. Politics have exacerbated, and have not fixed, the math our nation is built on. If you hope in that moment of crisis politicians will ride to the rescue with a googleplex stimulus plan, this is precisely the problem.
- paulpauper 3y agodysfunctional politics may actually be a positive. Stalin and Hitler were very effective politicians , and look where that ended
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y ago> if America does collapse, it will only be after the rest of the world or conditional on the rest of the world collapsing too and likely first. If other countries aren't positively affected by the positive picture you describe of the US (looks like they are negatively impacted), then why should they be negatively affected when, if, the US does indeed collapse? Shouldn't it be the opposite? They'll become positively impacted? I think they are better equipped and better prepared in the events of a possible collapse of the US, or perhaps the USD You describe a situation without taking into account nor caring about the events, then you draw a conclusion, that's unfair an disingenuous, COVID alone should have been an eye opener for the less pessimistic
- paulpauper 3y agoCOVID alone should have been an eye opener for the less pessimistic Covid agrees with my thesis. the US pulled ahead of the rest of the world during and after Covid, in terms of GDP, stock market recovery, unemployment, etc. Other countries fared worse economically, had worse restrictions that lasted longer. China has still not recovered.
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoIt doesn't, you completely ignore how much the FED have printed, you totally ignore how much more in debt the US is, and finally, you completely ignore how half of the world decided to ditch the USD and form a new global alliance called the BRICS+ It's easy to print money, the latency is probably very high, for how long can the US keep faking its metrics, with the USD loosing its global reserve status.. waking up will be difficult https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bretton_Woods_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bretton_Woods_system
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> half of the world decided to ditch the USD and form a new global alliance called the BRICS+ Are you still talking about the Covid response? Not much actually changed since 2019 with the BRICS. Oops - I should say not much positive changed for the BRICS since 2019. Russia, though, got itself into a war that is causing massive economic damage. So this looks like you're just throwing out a bunch of arguments, hoping something will stick in a reader's mind, but without much concern for reality.
- digdugdirk 3y agoNow plot those metrics against real average wages, and a different picture begins to emerge.
- lusus_naturae 3y agoUm, the avg. us wage is much higher than most countries in the world, https://www.worlddata.info/average-income.php https://www.worlddata.info/average-income.php When I find some article a little opinion-heavy, I look for something that quantify what's being said.