8 ms·
An airline said her bag was lost, her tracker said otherwise. She flew to get it
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- sandworm101 3y agoLong ago I read about cruise ship passengers sending their luggage via FeDEX to the ship. In that case it was to avoid airport workers pilfering the bottles of pills that many cruise ship passengers need for a long voyage. If I could, I would send my bags by almost any other means than "checking" the bag with the airline. Every other service has a legal obligation to deliver the goods, or at least try to get my bag to the destination, rather than pawn it off on a fly-by-night local delivery van service. I had a choice last year to take a 4-hour flight via commercial airline, or an 8-hour flight in the back of a military transport. Everyone else opted for the 4-hour commercial flight. But for me, I would rather spend an extra four hours sleeping in the back of a C-130, sleeping literally on top of my luggage, than risk losing yet another bag to an airline.
- gunapologist99 3y agoSending three boxes of t-shirts to Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas, I found out that FedEx actually has an office in the hotel/resort. Fedex wouldn't deliver the boxes to my room for free (which I'd paid for, since I'd put my room number on the address form when shipping), and the office is actually about a half mile away down very long marble-tiled hallways. The hotel wouldn't let me use one of their hand carts/trolleys (they had to be handled by their bell people), and they wouldn't go with me even for a substantial tip, because they had an agreement with FedEx. FedEx charged me $150 to deliver the boxes to my room -- more than it'd cost to ship halfway across the country. This was about ten years ago, so things might be different now.
- mcpackieh 3y ago> Fedex wouldn't deliver the boxes to my room for free (which I'd paid for, since I'd put my room number on the address form when shipping) Ship a package to a specific apartment number and there's a 50/50 chance Fedex, UPS or any of the others will deliver it to the front desk / mailroom instead of to the door of that apartment.
- jprete 3y agoFor what it’s worth, delivering to the mailroom is typical for NYC doorman residential buildings and probably elsewhere in large buildings. But those buildings also usually have a trolley and will loan it to you for free.
- mcpackieh 3y agoYeah, I'm surprised the hotel wouldn't let you use the trolley yourself, every hotel I've ever been in has those trolleys available for any guest to use themselves. Maybe they had unionized bell hops and this policy was to protect their work? Really bizarre that they wouldn't do the work themselves for a heavy tip though.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoIf FedEx cannot guarantee they can do it then it shouldn't be advertised. Instead they should warn customers at the time of purchase when they won't be able to, or where there is additional cost. Everything else is false advertising.
- dec0dedab0de 3y agoSo you expect them to keep track of the rules for every building in the world and dynamically adjust at the time of shipment? Sure, they could do this for buildings they have shipped to within x amount of days, and therefore know the policy. However, that would then leak information to those buildings out to potential thieves.
- toast0 3y ago> Every other service has a legal obligation to deliver the goods, or at least try to get my bag to the destination, rather than pawn it off on a fly-by-night local delivery van service. Isn't subcontracting to a locally delivery service trying to get your bag to its destination? Should we expect airlines to also run a last mile delivery service?
- sandworm101 3y ago>> Should we expect airlines to also run a last mile delivery service? Yes. They should be responsible for bags until delivery. If their subcontractor loses my bag I don't want to hear that the airline isn't responsible. The airline should know where my bag is and when it is expected to be delivered. I don't much care who actually drives the van, but they should be under the control and direction of the airline. Give it to USPS for all I care. At least USPS tracks packages.
- amalcon 3y agoThe first rule of flying with medication is that it goes in the carry-on, over everything else. If you can't fit so much as a book alongside your meds? Tough, meds have priority. In the US at least, the airline simply isn't allowed to make you check your medication, and the TSA is not allowed to confiscate prescription medication in its original container. OTC stuff, beyond what you need on the actual flight, should just be purchased at the destination. FedEx in that context is probably because it has less trouble getting through customs, rather than for airline employees.
- wredue 3y agoThey don’t “confiscate” meds. They steal them. I’ve never flew and got my bag back with the lock still on it (it was taken off and rummaged through). My wife has had underwear stolen. My kids gym shoes were stolen. It’s like airlines require a criminal history for bag service. Always take important or expensive stuff in carry on.
- mcpackieh 3y ago> It’s like airlines require a criminal history for bag service. Well hey, they did their time and paid their debt to society right? Should they continue being unemployable for life, forced to return to a life of crime? Give those guys a second chance to earn an honest living and show the world they aren't defined by their past. (Is it actually true that airlines hire people with criminal histories to handle luggage? I think they actually require clean background checks for those jobs, for obvious reasons, but such background checks are often the subject of the sort of criticism I just presented.)
- Eisenstein 3y agoWhat's more likely, stuff gets lost or kids forget to pack it, or this guy has gotten perv bag handlers that can sniff out women's underwear and children's gym shoes and stole them, risking their job in the process? If they weren't able to sniff them out, then they rummage through bags randomly as they are running down conveyor belts to find clothing items and shoes to steal.
- ghaff 3y ago>If I could, I would send my bags by almost any other means than "checking" the bag with the airline On the other hand, I shipped luggage internationally once because I was doing outdoor stuff after a somewhat complicated business trip. It ended up stuck in customs and I'd have had to go there during the week to retrieve it, which because of the nature of the trip I was unable to do. I try very hard not to check luggage but if you're doing certain types of activities, that's pretty much impossible to do. In this case, I had an inkling in advance there might be a problem so I was careful to get as much critical stuff as possible either on me or in carry-on, I bought a bunch of stuff at a good outdoor store at the city I arrived in, and was able to borrow a few things. ADDED: I'd just add that the airlines have a well-developed system that's usually pretty reliable about getting your bag to a carousel where you can pick it up. I'm less confident about FedEx or whoever getting it to you at a random hotel.
- codetrotter 3y ago> If I could, I would send my bags by almost any other means than "checking" the bag with the airline. I recently took my monitor with me to Spain, it’s a big 34 inch curved screen that I’ve had for about three years (I bought the monitor in my country in the beginning of 2020). When I left Spain I sent the monitor home to my country. I used my girlfriends name as sender and her parents address in Spain as return address, in case anything happened causing it to be sent in return. By accident they ended up marking the value of the package as €4000. I had told them it was worth about €400 which is probably more than I would even be able to actually sell the monitor for. Anyway. The package arrives to my mother in my country. And she goes to get it. The postal office told her to pay almost €1000 in toll fees. I had originally paid about €700 for the monitor when it was new. And due to a mistake with the label they want more in toll fees for my three year old monitor than it had even cost when it was new. I contacted the postal services customer support and explained the situation. They told me to submit proof of the value of the monitor and such, and that they will help me. Fortunately I originally bought it online and still have my login details for the store I bought it from, and from there I was able to grab screenshots of the original order. This was on Friday. Hopefully they will be able to resolve it, so that my mother can get my monitor for me without crazy toll fees. This experience has left me uncertain if I ever want to send anything valuable home by mail again. We will see how it plays out.
- rolph 3y agowhat would be the value of a monitor that is not working, regardless of the fact that its missing one or two easily replacable, but critical parts, that happen to be in easy reach?
- codetrotter 3y agoYou could probably claim it was only worth like €50 or something in that case. I think I see what you are suggesting :p but I think it is better to not sabotage your own monitor before shipping it somewhere.
- rolph 3y ago>>I would rather spend an extra four hours sleeping in the back of a C-130<< i miss those days sometimes
- sandworm101 3y agoThere is no more comfortable flight than a bench made out of webbing, a lunch in a cardboard box, a pair of ear defenders, and absolutely zero in-flight announcements. Only words I heard the entire flight were: "Sir, wake up. We are on the ground now."
- version_five 3y agoLots of "customer support" is literally just lying people to get them off the phone and hope they give up. It's pretty clear that's what this is. They have no incentive to help, so they dont.
- Simulacra 3y agoannnd "customer support" is usually someone working in a boiler room warehouse somewhere and paid low wages, so an even bigger incentive to not help.
- bluedino 3y agoIt's not lying, it's ignorance or not having the time/resources/ability to find the correct or more helpful answer.
- ydlr 3y agoThe individual service rep may not be lying, but the company is. They intentionally put someone in front of the customer without the correct information and without the ability to find it so that they will have no option but to follow a script without any regard to whether the words they are saying are true.
- ghaff 3y agoThe company is "lying" in the sense that their computer system has the wrong information caused by a human error. And you can certainly argue that this should have been special cased sooner rather than later. (On the other hand, like it or not, I assume that a lost piece of luggage is also written off as unfindable well before mountains are moved to try to find this item which is apparently out of the computer system's knowing. I've certainly experienced something similar with deliveries from time to time.)
- whstl 3y agoThere are definitely lies in some of the interactions in the article itself. First saying that it is in the wrong place, then saying that "the baggage team will take care of it". Not to mention mistakes made and not admitted. Not to mention they told CNN the woman would get her money back for the travel, but not contacting her. If you're talking about support in general, they don't say "I don't have the time/resources/ability to handle that". They instead flat out lie to you (how many times I got the "your cancellation was requested" only to be charged again), shift blame often back to customers, ask customers to re-do procedures because of their own mistakes, transfer to phones that often disconnect, or even refuse to perform support by some channels ("please fax this form for cancelling you account"). Not to mention transferring the call and then disconnecting you, very common with cable/telecom. Often the individual person is not to blame, as they're following orders, but they're also not saying the real reason for the problems, so you can definitely say they're paid to lie. All of this has a reason. It's rarely lack of time, though. Cancelling some subscription sometimes takes several unnecessary minutes, sometimes hours when you put together days. This time could have been used to do actual support.
- hinkley 3y agoMy ex incorporated for reasons I no longer recall, but is important at the climax of this story. I helped her pick out a monitor, which was to be delivered by UPS. UPS receives it, moves it, and then nothing for days. For a week. She calls. They can’t find it. Thee weeks go by and we have escalated through recriminations. She wants a refund, but they don’t do refunds for lost goods (seriously? Wtf), unless, the employee mentions offhand, this is for a business account. Aha. This monitor was bought for her business, which she intended to write off as an expense. So can I have my money now? And then a miracle happens, suddenly they can find her monitor. A month after she ordered it her monitor shows up. The box is dirty as hell, but she finally got it. Also fuck UPS. Several of my friends have thought I was joking about the UPS curse, and then they knew me longer and found out I am cursed (I joke that I must have dissed some manager and didn’t know it). The day Amazon stopped letting you pick your shipping service was a dark day.
- ben_w 3y ago> Amazon stopped letting you pick your shipping service I never knew this was an option. Given my problems with Yodel (in the UK before I emigrated) and DHL (in Berlin, after), I basically don’t even bother trying to get stuff on Amazon any more — it’s not only faster to go to a nearby store, but given the seemingly random choice of 4 delivery depos, it can also be more convenient because two of those four are further away than whichever shops are selling the things I’d tried to buy.
- hinkley 3y agoIt was often just two choices, and if it was a regional thing I wouldn’t be surprised. And it might have been tied to urgency. When I cared more about getting the thing that when exactly I’d get it, USPS was usually an option, and they know how to do their fucking jobs. I don’t know who ran the northwest division of UPS in the 00’s but they and all of their lieutenants should be shipped to Siberia.
- Operyl 3y agoThe other way to get them to actually do anything quickly is if it’s an Apple shipment. They value that contract so much that they will bend over backwards for both you and Apple to get it resolved, like same day 1 hour the driver will unfuck whatever mistake he did. One year I worked UPS during peak season for extra cash, and the number of times I went searching for a missing Apple product during preload shift was astonishing.
- julienchastang 3y agoKey detail: > In fact, they were right – sort of. The claim number was indeed the same as the tag that had been attached to her bag – but the check-in agent had attached the wrong tag. This one was for another passenger, who was traveling from Baltimore to Chicago only. That meant the bag had been taken off the plane at O’Hare and sent straight to the reclaim belt, instead of being loaded onto the Denver flight. That reminds me of a story when my father and I were traveling in Hawaii many years ago (~1985) where we were given the wrong boarding pass from a different traveler and apparently only one so one of us could not board the plane. We went back to the ticket desk to protest, but the agent would not help us. We then marched back to the plane and the guy checking boarding passes said, "OK, I'll let you folks through".
- bombcar 3y agoI overheard the passengers next to me at the desk - as they walked away the guy said “wait this is the wrong ticket” - turned out there were TWO people on the flight with almost identical names - I think middle initial was different.
- TheJoeMan 3y agoI don’t want to sound like a victim blamer, but not reading that the bag is “checked through” to the final destination seems to be part of the problem
- selestify 3y agoIn my experience, they only inform you if you need to pick up your luggage in between. Otherwise, you can assume you pick up at the final destination. You can ask for additional confirmation if you want, but the onus to double check shouldn’t be on the customer.
- throwaway2990 3y agoI’m 100% buying some AirTags before I travel next time. And double checking the tag they put on my luggage!
- xivzgrev 3y agoOf course they only refund her when CNN contacts them. Just like that guy who wrote the song about United breaking his guitar, they didn’t do shit until it went viral
- charles_f 3y agoWhich make you think, how many people are in the same situation, don't get viral, and get screwed in the end. How likely would it be that you would win a trial in a small claims court?
- cmur 3y agoHello! I’m one of those unresolved United cases. When I played trumpet primarily, I had had a horn get destroyed from mishandling on the way to an audition. I didn’t get any compensation at all.
- cj 3y agoHighly recommend AirTags in checked luggage. I flew United from USVI to NYC last Christmas, bag checked at the gate because I overpacked (wouldn’t fit in the overhead bin). On arrival at NYC, the bag didn’t appear at baggage claim. So, opened up the Find My app, and the AirTag was reporting my bag at an airport in Puerto Rico (bag was put on the wrong flight). I showed this to the baggage desk at EWR, and they assured me it would arrive the next morning via fedex. It didn’t arrive the next morning, but it did eventually arrive 5 days later. The AirTag wasn’t helpful in retrieving the luggage, but it was very helpful at providing peace of mind re: where my luggage actually was without relying on United’s own tracking system which was useless.
- greedo 3y agoI usually despise airline service, but on my recent vacation, one of our checked bags got left behind at a connecting airport. I was ready to have a ruined vacation, but the baggage clerk was extremely nice and professional. She found our bag, got our address and had it delivered the next morning before I was done with breakfast. We got some extra miles added to our account too. Now it would have been better if they hadn't misplaced our bag, but shit happens, and how you deal with it is a sign of how competent your systems are.
- tim333 3y agoYeah just as a counter-example to the horror stories I only really had a misdirected bag once in ~40 years of flying and Swiss who misdirected gave me a good bit of money for new gear and delivered the bag to my hotel the next day. Maybe it's different in Europe? I daresay I normally travel hand baggage only.
- kleinsch 3y agoWhenever possible, verify your name and destination are correct on the tag and watch the agent attach it to your bag. Tons of bag messes come from tags getting put on the wrong bag.
- grishka 3y ago> Tons of bag messes come from tags getting put on the wrong bag. How could that possibly happen? Usually the check-in agent would print your boarding pass, then the bag tag, and then they'd peel part of the tag and stick it to your boarding pass. The rest of the tag goes on the bag itself, on the sides and around the handle. At least looking at how they do it, this exact kind of mess-up feels nearly impossible. But idk, maybe US airports do these things differently.
- jonhohle 3y agoMany years ago I traveled for work and would fly on Mondays and either Thursdays or Fridays. On some weekends I would go back “home”, and others I would go elsewhere. I often had several weeks of flights booked to various places, but typically going back to my work site. I prefer to check a bag if it’s larger than a backpack and was making nearly a hundred trips a year without issue. And then one day my bag didn’t show up. The airline finally did find it, but they had sent it to a destination I happened to be visiting the next week. When they offered to ship it back I asked them to keep it where it was and they were incredulous. I was more concerned about not having it for the next leg of my trip and didn’t want something to happen to it in the mean time. When I arrived, it was waiting for me unscathed. This was long before it was cheap enough to track anything of moderate value, so it was a relief that the bag was found at all.
- anshumankmr 3y agoAre there any good alternatives to Air tags? I have an iPad but I am looking for something cheaper and that is avaialable in India. The stuff on Amazon I find has bad reviews.
- School-Cotton 3y agoTile is the main reputable competitor I know of. It’s around 2000-4000 rupees on Amazon.in, depending on the model. Edit: btw, I don’t have any experience with tile myself, just saying they’re widely known.
- Aachen 3y agoI mean, it requires a global surveillance network tuned to the frequency of your tag. No need to read reviews for individual tag products if you can just check the market share of trackers in your target region
- Zak 3y agoI once filed a claim with United for an item stolen out of my bag. They had an email address for receiving documents, but a policy to refuse to provide status updates by email. Status updates required a phone call. It seemed to be the same people answering both. I'm having trouble imagining a reason for such a policy. If it was structured to make filing the claim harder in the first place, it would be evil, but at least rational. Incompetence seems more likely.
- classichasclass 3y agoI can't believe I'm rising to United's defense, but they generally do have good bag tracking in the United app. We've had two instances of misrouted luggage on a domestic flight; we found it in the app, they had already detected it as an error, and they hand-delivered it the next day, the first time to the hotel (missing poster for a presentation), the second time to our house (regular luggage). Worth noting for full disclosure that we're Star Alliance Gold. On the other hand, all that assumes they tagged the bag correctly, which the gate agent didn't do here, so that goes out the window.
- broken_clock 3y agoI have been traveling a lot and have had good luck with the following tips: 1. Carry on size pack like an Osprey Farpoint 40L and packing cubes. It's incredible how much clothing you can actually fit on. Hard to lose a carry-on. Obviously doesn't work for this story but should work for most travelers. 2. Less sure about this, but putting stuff in cardboard boxes. Seriously. You go through the oversized baggage route where it's hand-carried on and off the plane.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoCardboard boxes (for anything other than a bicycle or other sporting equipment) are widely seen by airlines as an unsuitable form of packing. You may be able to check a cardboard box in only by signing a liability waiver. I fly with my bicycle at least four times a year, and about half the time my cardboard box has been gashed open by the time I collect it at the destination. Everything inside the bike box has to be tied together so that nothing falls out. I definitely wouldn’t trust a cardboard box for ordinary luggage.
- kylecazar 3y agoI admire the persistence. I recently had to recover a bag that arrived at the destination without the passenger (a family member had a medical emergency in the airport at the gate). The normal customer service channels told me they couldn't help without the tag number of the checked bag, which we didn't have. I called the destination airport, which was very small, directly. It was late at night local time. They transferred me to security, where someone on duty heard the explanation and after some very basic proof the airport fedexed it back to me. It was very satisfying. I'm sure some protocols weren't followed to get the bag back, but we were very grateful.
- sneak 3y ago> The claim number was indeed the same as the tag that had been attached to her bag – but the check-in agent had attached the wrong tag. This one was for another passenger, who was traveling from Baltimore to Chicago only. That meant the bag had been taken off the plane at O’Hare and sent straight to the reclaim belt, instead of being loaded onto the Denver flight. This is the reason I always supervise the check in agent very carefully when checking luggage, and always insist on both photographing the tag actually placed on my bag, and also affixing those little extra code tags to two opposing ends of my bag and making sure they are firmly attached.
- xwdv 3y agoThis has become so frequent that I wonder if there’s an opportunity in creating an independent bag retrieval service if you know where your bag is and just need someone to go get it and ship it to you. Some kind of gig based thing.
- mojomark 3y agoOnce upon a time, taking a flight was a luxurious adventure - then came deregulation and the race to the bottom ensued (1). 1.) https://airandspace.si.edu/stories/editorial/airline-deregulation-when-everything-changed https://airandspace.si.edu/stories/editorial/airline-deregul... Regulations can be bad, but they can also be good. Maybe the pendulum can start swinging back the other way to find the right balance between accessibility to all who need it and flying cesspools.
- gruez 3y ago>Regulations can be bad, but they can also be good. Maybe the pendulum can start swinging back the other way to find the right balance between accessibility to all who need it and flying cesspools. What relevant regulations would have helped in this case? Airlines are already liable for expenses that you incur as a result of lost/delayed baggage. Do we need to the DOT to mandate that gate agents double-check baggage tags before they're attached? [1] https://www.transportation.gov/lost-delayed-or-damaged-baggage https://www.transportation.gov/lost-delayed-or-damaged-bagga...
- mojomark 3y agoIt's a secondary effect. De-regulation of flight costs and routes cause airlines to cut as much "percieved unnecessary" expenses to maximize profit to the point of where they are now - bare bones staffing, ancient IT infrastructure, paying for luggage or even in-flight bathroom use! (1)), negligiable accountability for dropped flights, etc.. These cuts lead to the inability to handle simple and quick tracking of misplaced luggage. 1.) https://aviationsourcenews.com/news/charging-passengers-to-use-the-toilet-pay-to-stand-airfares-10-years-on-since-ryanairs-oleary-caused-controversy/ https://aviationsourcenews.com/news/charging-passengers-to-u...
- CamperBob2 3y agoUnless you want to pay many thousands of additional dollars for airfare, you probably appreciate deregulation more than you think you do. That said, keeping better track of luggage is a specific issue that arguably should be regulated.
- jayski 3y agoAm I the only one that finds it odd bus travel offers a 10x better customer service and overall experience? If you go anywhere by bus, it leaves on time, they don't lose your stuff, if there's an issue there's someone to talk to. shouldn't flying be a bit of a step up? This is going to sound crazy, but I think air travel has become too cheap. The price wars between airlines has made the margins so thin they have to cut every single corner and pay terrible wages to employees that have no interest in helping you. Maybe it should be a little more expensive and better quality. Its gotten so bad I think I'd rather take two normal flights per year instead of 3 cheap but traumatic ones.
- crazygringo 3y agoYes, it might be just you. Buses are frequently hours late and break down mid-journey. And not only is customer service on the phone often non-existent (what do you expect for your $23 ticket?), but the bus station itself doesn't even have any employees to talk to -- the only actual person involved is the driver, whenever they show up. Obviously it depends on the company/country, but this is the case for budget long-distance buses in the US. Obviously if you're booking an expensive luxury overnight sleeper in a city that has those, it's different.
- Laaas 3y agoFlixBus in Europe has been great IME
- nvy 3y agoI can fly from Vancouver to Toronto in about 5 hours. The same trip via bus would take about four days via the USA, or a week if you take the longer route through Canada. All day, every day, sitting on a fucking bus watching the telephone poles go by, hoping you never get a flat tire or a fender bender. That is not a "10x overall better experience".
- Aachen 3y agoI took an overnight bus through Finland as a student. Never again. Less leg space than the cheapest airline, no awesome view like you get from flying, no toilet as I recall (so no reason to get up and stretch legs either), and didn't sleep for a moment. Six hours of boredom while being dead tired and needing to stay seated upright. After arriving, the day consisted of bone-chilling cold strolling through a city while dead on my feet. Flying is approximately 850km/h as the crow flies compared to the 100 that a bus does across defined roads. If the bus ride is more than three hours and there are no other options like a train, all else being equal, probably I'd opt for wasting more time with airport stuff (getting there and back, waiting an hour on the airport and 30 minutes in the boarding line because they require you to be unnecessarily early) and cause more greenhouse emissions to avoid the disaster that is overnight busses
- JSavageOne 3y agoAre there any non-Apple equivalent of AirTags? Definitely admire this girl's persistence. And shame on United for handling this so poorly.
- neilalexander 3y agoChipolo's ONE Spot if you want it to work with the Apple Find My network or ONE Point if you want it to work with Android Find My Device.
- whimsicalism 3y agoThe ONE Spot is iPhone only fyi to those who are curious if there is a way to get acess to Apple's mesh on Android
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThere are plenty of alternatives. But without Apple’s moat of high iPhone adoption, they aren’t very useful.
- spread_love 3y agoTile works with all phones, Android and iOS
- Aachen 3y agoJust installed the Tile app: doesn't run on Android. I have Play Services installed (stock Samsung firmware) but it complains that something is wrong with the Play Services and the only option is to close the app. Based on the layout, the pop-up is from Google Play themselves and the app (prompting me to log in) would work fine if I could just click that pop-up away like one could on the web. So it doesn't run on any Android, it runs on Google Play Services (not all androids have this), and for some reason not on my device despite having the google backdoor services installed exactly to avoid this sort of shit
- bob-09 3y agoDoes Tile work with iPad Air? It’s not listed on their support page. https://support.thetileapp.com/hc/en-us/articles/200424778-Tile-Device-Compatibility https://support.thetileapp.com/hc/en-us/articles/200424778-T...
- sneak 3y agoAirTags only work with an iCloud account and Apple ID. To get such you need to provide a telephone number, which is linked to your real-world identity, allowing Apple and the US federal police to track your ID-linked tag whereabouts in real-time without a warrant.
- datapolitical 3y agoAirTag data is encrypted with a key that resides only on your devices. It cannot be decrypted by Apple.
- sneak 3y agoThat's what they say about iMessage, too, but then the devices back up the endpoint keys to Apple in the iCloud Backup (non-e2ee and readable by Apple/FBI). The AirTag keys are supposedly stored in iCloud Keychain (which unlike nudes sent via iMessage, is actually excluded from the non-e2ee iCloud Backup) but it's been a long time since I have read the security architecture document for how the offline Find My system works. The issue with "the data is encrypted" is that a) the receiving device isn't yours (it's some random person's iPhone) and if it's totally opaque to Apple, how do they know to provide that encrypted data provided by some random airport iPhone to your specific account so that you can decrypt it? It seems sort of handwavey to me. I remain unconvinced that Apple is that diligent about maintaining lack of location tracking for iCloud to AirTag mappings given that 99.99%-ish of iCloud users are already providing location to Apple a hundred other times a day (maps, ads, app store, music, books, TV+, etc).
- benabbottnz 3y ago> “you need to provide a telephone number, which is linked to your real-world identity” What country do you live in? I can go to my local supermarket and buy dozens of pre-paid SIM cards with pocket change. If you’re somehow associating your literal identity to a phone number, it sounds like you must be in a pretty heavy surveillance state. Additionally, if you’re worried about being tracked, I hope you don’t carry a phone whatsoever.
- grecy 3y agoI'm always shocked bags can get "lost" at all. They get those huge universal bar codes in multiple places, and then whisk away on the conveyor. I understand there would be mix ups, bags fall off, bags get jammed, bags get pulled off flights so airlines can put more expensive cargo on there. That's all fine, because none of those bags are "lost", they're just delayed or in the wrong place. Surely whenever a bag is in an odd place someone can just scan it, and send it back on it's way. Other than bags actually getting stolen (is that really a HUGE problem?), I can't understand how any bags wouldn't eventually get to the correct destination.
- crazygringo 3y ago1) Tags can get ripped off (nothing to left scan) 2) Bags can be mistagged in the first place (like in this article) 3) Bags can be misplaced/lost in a location nobody will ever scan again (e.g. sent to the wrong airport, unclaimed bags are all put in a room to be claimed but they never bother to re-scan because they assume they're already at the correct destination) 4) Bags can be misdelivered (e.g. they deliver your late bag to a totally wrong hotel) And so forth. Also I don't know what bar code "in multiple places" you're talking about, I've only ever seen a single looped sticker around the handle. Are there airports that do something extra? Where?
- wasmitnetzen 3y agoRe multiple places: I've only flown in Europe in recent years, but all the looped stickers had like 3 smaller stickers on them which you could put directly on the luggage. I think it's the small ones you can see here, near to the right hand of the person: [1]. When checking in at a desk, they don't always bother to put them on the luggage, but when I'm at a machine, I always make sure to use them. [1]: https://www.airport-technology.com/products/self-adhesive-tags-bags/ https://www.airport-technology.com/products/self-adhesive-ta...]
- crazygringo 3y agoHa, I've always wondered what those were intended for. Because you're right, whenever I've checked in at a desk, I've never once had them bother to actually stick them on my luggage. Thanks.
- spiritplumber 3y agoHappened to me with a game I had preordered (Wing Commander 3, showing my age here). Thinking back, I figure it's a case of "One of the workers there wants to take it home himself instead", as it was supposed to arrive the last day of shops being open before Christmas. I was told "it's not here". I went into the back to look for it myself, found it, then I was told "OK, but now I can't sell it to you, because you went into the back without permission". I said OK, I already paid for it last week, here's the fiscal receipt, and walked off. These things happen. The problems occur when a system is incapable of self-correcting.
- rolph 3y agothat happened with a major post office near me, except it was about two dozen people, that wanted thier mail and packages.
- mettamage 3y agoThis is why I insist on only taking hand luggage and never letting it be tagged on the flight for checked in luggage - which airlines sometimes do because they claim there's not enough space in the overhead cabins. I've always ripped the tags off and always found there to be enough space (while being one of the last to board).
- kennethrc 3y agoFWIW,I've had at least a thousand flights over the last 15 years with at least a bag (and many times two) checked and have had one delayed until the next flight about 5 times, but none ever lost.
- nicpottier 3y agoWhere are you flying? I've never lost a bag outright but I've had bags delayed by days or weeks on maybe 5% of flights. I tend to go to places off the beaten path though. If at all possible I use carry on only.
- kennethrc 3y ago> Where are you flying? 99% of that has been within the US, and about 2/3rds of that up and down the Western US. > If at all possible I use carry on only. I can work nearly anywhere thanks to WFH, but that also means I have a lot of hardware to drag along many times, too.
- robg 3y agoPro-tip: You can reach the baggage offices by calling the airport and asking them to connect you.
- thadk 3y agoMaybe if they made the printed claim and bag stickers random, matching colors, this mixup would be less likely to occur.
- AlbertCory 3y agoHas anyone pointed out that, if customers can put a tracking device on their bag, so could the airline? In fact, it could be a part of the bag. The airline just reads it when you check in.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe airline slaps a barcode sticker on the bag, what's the difference?
- gpm 3y agoBarcode stickers only work when they are scanned. The difference here is that bluetooth tags are automatically and continuously scanned by things in their environment. Though if the issue is "they put the wrong tag on it" (which sounds like the issue here) that's not going to solve anything.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI would presume that if a bag passes a scanner, and the tag is folded over itself or not visible for some reason, and no barcode is detected, it would get shunted to somewhere for manual scanning. Maybe that's assuming too much. I guess the tag could get torn off entirely, but they seem pretty tough. I've never been able to just tear one off, they have to be cut off with scisors.
- HALtheWise 3y agoThe airline basically does put a tracking device on the bag, in the form of a tag with a barcode and (in some cases) RFID. Having the barcode built into the bag itself wouldn't change anything, there's still things that can go wrong where it gets disabled or, as happened in this case, the airline employee attaches a bag to the wrong customer. Having the standard system use an Airtag-like tracking device that requires batteries seems like it would be strictly more likely to fail than what they do today.
- AlbertCory 3y ago
- sigwinch28 3y ago> but the check-in agent had attached the wrong tag. This one was for another passenger, who was traveling from Baltimore to Chicago only. So what? It’s not the customer’s fault that someone acting on behalf of the company made a mistake. That’s the company’s problem.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> “I understand outsourcing, but there are real inefficiencies here.” says Shuster, baffled that nobody realized that the passenger was actually saving them time and effort.
- callumprentice 3y agoLike many other posters here, whenever we travel, I put AirTags in all our checked bags as well as hand carry (in case we lose them or they get stolen). I also made my own sturdy luggage tags with a laminator that has our contact info on it. For each flight, I print a sticky label with the dates, airlines and flight numbers and attach it to the tag. Then, if the airline label ever gets ripped off, there is at least, some way to identify it. So far so good even after 100 or so trips. My family chuckles about it when we’re packing but I think deep down, they understand it might one day save a trip. We also have these reusable stretchy nylon covers for the checked baggage. As well as protecting the cases and making them easier to identify (neon colors), I’d like to think that makes opening them less attractive to airline baggage thieves than all the other ones but who knows.
- charles_f 3y ago> but the check-in agent had attached the wrong tag How is that even possible? They either print the tag in front of you, or have you print it on the self check-in stands, then your baggage goes. Do they keep a stack of tags to lose the baggage on purpose?
- notRobot 3y agoIt's possible they printed the wrong tag and no one noticed in the moment, no?
- LorenDB 3y agoWhat else do you expect from the airline that breaks guitars[0]? [0]: https://youtube.com/watch?v=5YGc4zOqozo https://youtube.com/watch?v=5YGc4zOqozo
- IronWolve 3y agoUnited gave the good ole, apology non apology like corporations do when they fuck up. ‘we know this has been frustrating and making you anxious.’
- tonfreed 3y agoIt's interesting that the check-in agent was the one that attached the tag. I recently flew Melbourne to Frankfurt, and there was no interaction with staff at all during check-in and going through security, it was all DIY tagging and putting it on the conveyor. Similar story coming back via Heathrow airport. Wonder if it's just Australia and Europe automating it and whether it actually helps lower lost bag numbers.
- smsm42 3y agoI read the company name is United and I am thinking "but of course it's United, who else".