3 ms·
There are of course rails for transporting goods.
by JKCalhoun 3y ago
There are of course rails for transporting goods.
- sokoloff 3y agoMany people prefer to buy groceries at the grocery store rather than pick them up at the rail depot. As GP observes, moving freight by rail doesn’t eliminate roads.
- crote 3y agoHow about designing neighborhoods in such a way that there is a grocery store within a 15-minute walk from your house? And place a school next to it, so you can grab some groceries when you drop off your kid. That'd already massively reduce the amount of driving required, as you suddenly no longer need to drive a few miles for your groceries. And because you don't arrive by car the grocery store doesn't need a huge parking lot either.
- sokoloff 3y agoThis subthread is about “how would the grocery store fill its shelves without roads?” more than it is “how could we avoid the final driving by grocery customers?”
- crote 3y agoThe roads are mostly filled with cars, though. If we only needed roads for trucks to stock stores, we could get rid of 90% of them. Nobody is proposing getting rid of all roads, they clearly have value. People are just proposing making it possible to live without requiring a car for something as basic as grocery shopping. As long as cities are built from a car-centric perspective first, they will require a car to live in.
- pfdietz 3y agoAlso, if traffic is lower, lower quality roads could be built.
- kspacewalk2 3y agoFewer lanes, asphalt replaced far less often, (almost) no parking lots.
- acdha 3y agoOr simply smaller. If you drive around most urban areas in the US at any time but rush hour, it’s striking how the roads are barely utilized – if it was just transit and last mile delivery, you’d almost never need more than one lane. Most of those billion dollar projects are trying to handle car commuting spikes.
- pmontra 3y agoIf cars are lighter they consume roads less. Road consumption is by the fourth power of the load on axles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_power_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_power_law
- underdeserver 3y agoThis is interesting! If I understand it correctly, it means that damage to roads is completely dominated by trucks, as long as you have more than 10,000 cars per truck. Near my home I would estimate it at around 100 cars for every truck. This means that cars are completely negligible, and that supporting road construction and repair by taxes (ideally, direct taxes on the truck users, which is then rolled on to consumers through higher prices) is correct.
- pfdietz 3y agoCars add cost by requiring the roads to be very smooth. A large truck might be fine with an unpaved road. Places like mines or forests with large traffic of heavy vehicles don't typically pave their roads, I think.
- pmontra 3y agoOnly between stations. You have to bring goods there and from there to homes. Some factories have their own rails, some farms too. Often they don't. Some people can walk to shops (I did when I lived in a city) or use rails, others can't. I can't anymore, I have to use a car. I bought one again after many years without it.