3 ms·
This kind of ignores the fact that there are real differences between languages. Anyone who has programmed in a few languages knows that. For instance, consider
by IshKebab 3y ago
This kind of ignores the fact that there are real differences between languages. Anyone who has programmed in a few languages knows that. For instance, consider the pain of setting up projects in Python or C++ to that of Go or Rust.
Clearly intrinsic quality is a factor, and likelihood of being a greenfield project is a factor too.
- brabel 3y agoYou're just stating the "obvious hypothesis" which the author is challenging, and showing evidence against.
- strken 3y agoEvidence for the existence of factor B doesn't disprove the existence of factor A.
- brabel 3y agoWhile that's true, you would need to show evidence that factor A is more important than B in order to show that A is not a deciding factor. Factor B being "the loved languages are better languages"... I would say there's ample evidence that better languages are far from being more popular, and hence loved... Lisp is probably the poster child of _better languages_ according to many people, including me, but there are many others: Smalltalk, OCaml, Haskell, Erlang. Not to mention that showing conclusively that a language is "better" than another is incredibly hard, probably impossible as it just depends on too many factors, many of which are subjective. So your factor B is basically unmeasurable, which makes factor A a much more useful metric (easy to measure and arguably reliable until shown otherwise).
- IshKebab 3y ago> Lisp is probably the poster child of _better languages_ according to many people, including me, but there are many others: Smalltalk, OCaml, Haskell, Erlang. I think you just have an unpopular view of "better". Lisp is weird to read and write. OCaml is ok but its infrastructure is arguably worse than Python's. I've been forced to use it recently and Opam is the most annoying tool I've used for quite a while. Haskell is simply too difficult for most people. I think it's pretty clear that algebraic effects are going to be much better than monads where you absolutely need purity, and I think most people don't care about purity most of the time. I have never used Smalltalk. Anyway, his "evidence" is equally consistent with A and B so it doesn't really show anything. > Not to mention that showing conclusively that a language is "better" than another is incredibly hard, probably impossible as it just depends on too many factors, many of which are subjective. Of course. But that obviously doesn't mean that all languages are equally good.
- IshKebab 3y agoHe provided zero evidence against it. He showed that more loved languages are likely to be newer. That is consistent with them being loved more because they're more likely to be used on greenfield projects. But it's equally consistent with newer languages being better languages. I think it would be difficult to argue that newer languages are not usually better than old ones. They wouldn't be adopted if they weren't!
- pjmlp 3y ago1 - Start Visual Studio, XCode, Clion, QtCreator,... 2 - File => New Project 3 - Build
- IshKebab 3y agoNow add some third party dependencies. Have fun! vcpkg makes it tolerable, but it's very very recent.
- pjmlp 3y agoDepending on the OS. - Instal as dev package and use pkg-config - Use NuGET, vcpkg or conan - Download a binary build, add location to include and lib search paths. Hardly any herculean effort.
- IshKebab 3y agoYeah well it's a massive faff even when it goes perfectly, which it very often doesn't. For example just this week I was building a project that uses pkg-config to find GMP. I use RHEL 8. It has GMP but guess what? It doesn't install a pkg-config file. Compare that to `cargo add foo` or `flutter add foo` or `npm install --save foo`. Feel free to pretend it's fine. The rest of the world is going to move on to more pleasant languages.