6 ms·
Even people who bought Meta’s Ray-Ban smart glasses don’t want to use them
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y agoYou know, I do want to pay $300 dollars and carry an additional screen around everywhere I go just so Facebook can show me more ads.
- vidarh 3y agoIt doesn't have a screen, so there's that. It (optionally - for now?) uploads the pictures and video to Facebook though, so don't worry, there's another downside.
- causi 3y agodescribed the camera performance as OK at best, if not subpar, with low-light performance being a common complaint. It greatly amuses me that this usage scenario requires the user to wear sunglasses in the dark.
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> The music video, directed by Rob Quartly, shot at the Don Jail in Toronto, reflects the vision of a "fashion" police state, with scenes of Hart in a prison cell, without sunglasses, being strong-armed by police officers and paraded past various citizens wearing their regulation shades.
- slim 3y agoit's a very common use case in clubs
- dalbasal 3y agoWearables, ultimately, are an expiremental product. Neither the users not the developers really know what the application is. So... I think we should go easy on the dunking. These things must be tried to succeed. Failures like Google glass get so much criticism no one wants to try. That said, these give us to types of (maybe instructive) failure. Glass looked too much like a headcam to be used casually. These put looks first, but aren't responsive enough. The application both products targeted is there proverbial deep end. The bar is very high for a device mounted on your face as part of daily life. Performance has to be flawless. The frustration caused by a small lag, voice recognition or whatnot is extremely magnified relative to a phone or pc. Same for aesthetics, comfort, etc. All that without a very clear picture of how people will use the device. I do think there's room to succeed in this space, but I think the innovations need to come in steps. Going for the mass-production, mass-appeal, everyday usage device before you have a successful predecessor... You need to hit multiple bulls eyes. A sports, adventure or camera centric product has much better odds. Those activities already allow "gear." The problem is that it's a race to the ultimate product, and making an intermediate may be just free market research for apple/meta/etc.
- cykotic 3y agoWhat you wrote is well written and thought out. I do agree with the sentiment that it’s worthwhile to try to make such products. I wonder though if a large part of the backlash has more to do with the who is behind the product than from a failed attempt. People don’t trust Google or Facebook. There are people like me who want them to fail when coming up with new products because ultimately those products, if they succeed, are going to be ad filled experiences.
- darkclouds 3y ago> if they succeed, are going to be ad filled experiences. So will self driving taxis be an experience where the passenger is bombarded with adverts projected onto all the glass so you cant see where you going? I'm surprised this has not already appeared in the US!
- cykotic 3y agoSeven years ago I got a taxi in Las Vegas to go from the airport to my hotel. The whole ride had ads blaring from the radio and the backseat area was filled with display ads. I’ve never taken a taxi since then. What you describe will be a thing in the U.S. if self driving becomes a thing. We already can’t get gas without being bombarded with ads. To me this fact is the main reason I hope to get an electric car someday.
- JohnFen 3y ago> We already can’t get gas without being bombarded with ads. Thank goodness this hasn't become common in my part of the country yet. The only gas stations that do this are the ones near the major hotels that out-of-towners stay at (where the gas is also more expensive), so they're easily avoided.
- JohnFen 3y ago> I'm surprised this has not already appeared in the US! It has, but on touchscreen displays instead of the windows. It's exceedingly terrible.
- danuker 3y agoThis is more of a story of how many people can be conned into buying garbage hardware with software under someone else's control, and not get refunded.
- haunter 3y agoI liked Casey Neistat's review. The idea is not bad but the picture quality is horrible (and it's very apt comparison that is nowhere near good as even an iPhone 5 from 2012). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PF3iysOyelg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PF3iysOyelg Honestly I'd buy one of these. We already have GoPros on helmets so a camera in a sunglass would be pretty nice. Well as long as it makes good pictures at least.
- rchaud 3y agoThey have demo pictures and video on the official product announcement page, and even there the quality is shockingly bad. GoPro era was 10 years ago, it's crazy that FB would release something with such poor quality for $300. https://tech.facebook.com/reality-labs/2021/9/ray-ban-and-facebook-introduce-ray-ban-stories-first-generation-smart-glasses/ https://tech.facebook.com/reality-labs/2021/9/ray-ban-and-fa...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoI'm intrigued by this kind of tech as I think it could be repurposed as a fancy pair of cycling glasses. Rather than looking down at a cycle computer, have the relevant data fields shown in a HUD and also a killer application would be to have an overlay of a rear view camera so you can see when there's gaps for turning etc. (you'd still have to look behind before performing the manoeuvre though).
- vidarh 3y agoThese do not have a HUD. You can use them for voice commands, or to take pictures of whatever you happen to look at. That makes them very limited even just as cameras - a fairly large proportion of the pictures I take involve moving the camera (my phone) into angles I wouldn't get my head into with comfort. If cheap enough they could be fun as "I want a picture too fast to get my phone out and happen to have my sunglasses on" cameras, but that's not exactly something you'd expect to get you huge use. If they were cheap enough and they didn't upload everything to Facebook (which they apparently do; EDIT: someone is saying elsewhere this is optional, which makes it marginally better if I trusted Facebook not to change that down the road), it might be something you'd think is a fun "nice to have" you might not use very often, but hardly something many people will go out of their way to buy at a large added cost.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoOkay, that makes them fairly useless then. If I wanted to take lots of photos of stuff that I look at, I'd be better off with some kind of GoPro video camera just stuck on a hat.
- vidarh 3y agoMy thought too, not least because being obtrusive avoids all the pesky social issues of appearing to be trying to obscure that you're possibly filming. When it then also costs 3x a regular pair of Raybans (UK prices at least) and if you're happy to look like you're going around spying on people you can buy a pair of cheap spy glasses on Amazon for 1/10th the price, I don't understand what market segment they think they're going for. As just a camera, if they were detachable and visible enough that you're not looking like you're trying to get away with something, I'd be far more interested. If they're going to be permanently mounted, they need to be invisible.
- mrweasel 3y ago> We’ll... need to better understand why users stop using their glasses, how to ensure we are encouraging new feature adoption, and ultimately how to keep our users engaged and retained Well... maybe they aren't particularly useful to the average person? I get the feeling that Meta might be ignoring the possibility that this isn't actually a sensible product. You still need to carry your smartphone, the camera isn't as good as strapping a GoPro to you head, many won't be into the idea of varying sunglasses non-stop. It's a cool demo, but what's the use case exactly? I can see them being useful in a professional setting, like a plumper or a mechanic who needs to be able to show an issue to a customer. I just wouldn't make them into sun glasses, nor would they need the Ray-Ban branding. The reality of products like this may be that they are primarily useful in work environments, but that's not a sexy market to be in for Meta. Maybe they should have teamed up with Black & Decker or Bosch.
- mannykannot 3y ago"But according to a February corporate document WSJ says it saw, under 10 percent of Ray-Ban Stories ever purchased are in active use." This being Meta, there's all the data you can possibly imagine to back up this claim.
- shiftpgdn 3y agoI am convinced all the naysayers here haven’t even given them a shot. I got a pair a year ago and use them all the time, it’s like a dash cam for my head. I’ve taken a ton of video and photos with mine and absolutely love them for phone calls and music. I do wish they were water proof and had more battery life, but. Otherwise they’re great.
- paulsutter 3y agoWhile its true that the both the article and title are obvious clickbait and make no effort to present a balanced view. It's also true that today AR/VR is a tiny niche market of little consequence. That may change when we have much lighter glasses that enable an AI assistant, but today its expensive R&D not a viable consumer product
- houseatrielah 3y agoIts great for people with young kids. You can be present and get a spontaneous shot.
- naillo 3y ago> it’s like a dash cam for my head Basically the reason I wouldn't want to be friends and hang out with anyone wearing them.
- sumtechguy 3y agoThere is a market for these things. But that market the big companies making them does not seem to understand. They keep doing these big splashy expensive things that most people do not want but some do. So instead of small launches with iteration into good things they come out swinging. Overspend like crazy then the thing looks like a total disaster. All of these companies want hockey stick curves on sales and are totally unsatisfied with small trial runs.
- shiftpgdn 3y agoIt doesn't roll continuously, but I can press a button and it starts recording. Something I would have missed, especially with little kids, I can now capture.
- the_only_law 3y agoHonestly, this happened to me with smartwatches. I’ve had at least two over the years. One Samsung and one Apple. I’m pretty sure they’re both sitting around somewhere having not been used for years. I just really hate having to constantly charge things. My phone is enough. It’s half the reason I was disappointed with everyone dropping the headphone jack.
- wombat-man 3y agoIf you just want sleep and activity tracking, I am pretty happy with garmin so far. I charge it about once a week or less. I don't use it for notifications or any other smart stuff. Just weather, sleep, and activity tracking.
- lawn 3y agoI've got this simple smart band from Garmin that I don't have to charge for over a week, and they have other models that hold even longer. Even if the only thing it would do is vibrate when I'm getting a call, that would be worth it. I also hate charging things all the time, I'm sure you'd like it more.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI mean some years ago Apple (or someone in the industry, don't quote me this is now just rumours and hearsay) that they intentionally optimized for about a day of battery life; the technology is there to make a smartphone last for a week, but that means cutting down on performance and whatnot. I'm pretty confident that iOS 1.0 or 2.0 or whichever would last for a week on a modern-day iphone, even without all the optimizations they've done since then. Battery capacity tripled or quadrupled, and there's been multiple generations of chip design since then.
- jermaustin1 3y agoI am the same way. My watch is firstly a watch, secondly needs to do minimal things (HR, step counter, sleep analysis, notifications). For that the Withings Steel HR [1] was perfect. I bought it at the start of the pandemic after seeing it on my local news, and wore it every day/night for 5-6 months before needing to take it off to charge, and when I did that, I realized I lost the charger. It was an amazing watch though. Simple and elegant. 1: https://www.withings.com/us/en/steel-hr https://www.withings.com/us/en/steel-hr
- pavlov 3y agoI was kind of surprised that Meta went ahead with shipping these after the clear failure of Snap Spectacles, a very similar product technically although with a more outré youth-oriented design.
- josefresco 3y agoYou're telling me these didn't sell and people that did buy them won't wear them? https://media.ray-ban.com/cms/resource/image/181530/landscape_ratio144x65/2592/1170/429650a030ed44416a4833bebdbac2c4/2B8609F59037BC5FD6B0F29017F9B2D2/rb-stories-hero-meteor-sun-talent.jpg https://media.ray-ban.com/cms/resource/image/181530/landscap... Shocking. They look like novelty glasses you'd order from the back of a kids magazine.
- dsgnr 3y agoI interviewd at facebook when these launched and one of my interviewers wore them throughout the call and i just couldn’t take the goofy dude seriously lol. what a dumb interview.
- wombat-man 3y agoYeah I was excited to try the spectacles from Snap. they're ok, they worked but when do I use this exactly? It is just sort of awkward in my experience.
- nologic01 3y agoThe failure of various smart glasses (and the AR/VR vision more generally) seems to punch a hole in the argument that in industrial capitalism consumer wants are manufactured. Companies can push very hard with marketing but there needs to be a minimum "click" with at least some consumer demographic for the magic to happen. The article mentions privacy concerns, hardware / quality issues etc. but this does not feel like a coherent explanation. The masses have been conditioned not to worry about their loss of privacy and first adopters tend to be accommodating of usability and quality issues. Somehow all this "tech stuff on our head" has hit a cultural and/or user experience barrier that is non-trivial to overcome. Yet it is hard to pin down the real reasons: Billions are now entirely happy with "tech stuff in our hands", tech that is privacy violating, has been of varying quality, creates potentially dangerous distractions etc. Impenetrable the soul of Homo Consumptiens
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lostmsu 3y agoHas anyone tried to unlock them to put your own software there?
- wnc3141 3y agoWriter Scott Galloway (former brand strategist) notes that essentially noone will ever wear something that doesn't add to their self image or presentability to others. Trillions in commerce has happened on this premise.
- Nasrudith 3y agoSmartglasses seem to forget just how many people already have that equipment slot taken up by their actual glasses. A lesser concern for the market, as they aren't even close to adoption to saturate the non-glasses wearers but still something which personally kills my interest before it starts.
- spott 3y agoI think AI is going to create the killer app for something like this… though if people will be ok with that is another question. I’m imagining something that attempts to record your life so it can help with it. “Remember you told your wife yesterday you would take out the garbage today” Driving home from a meeting with Joe: “Glasses, can you get me more information about the thing Joe mentioned?” “Sure, he asked about the viability of selling our widget in Asia, my brief search tells me that there are three obvious competitors to your product there, and they are X, Y, and Z. The market appears to be growing at 10% year over year. Blah, blah” “Thanks. Can you tell me more about X?”… When you get home: “Glasses, summarize our last conversation and put it in my inbox.” Get topical reminders: you are at the grocery store, and your glasses reminds you of your grocery list without prompting (when no one is trying to talk to you, so you can pay attention, and when you need to know about the item: so onions and celery in the grocery section, pork butt when near the meat, etc). You are at the grocery store, and you can’t remember if you have any saffron at home, and you didn’t throw it on the list. Your glasses can tell you because it remembers. Etc. We are almost there. The tech isn’t at the level it needs to be in accuracy and we haven’t built the “meta” ai, that can recognize that knowing what food I have at home is valuable, so it should pay attention to that, etc. I just hope there is a self hosted version built by someone when we get there.
- ambrose2 3y agoThere’s a Black Mirror episode about this, I’m not terribly looking forward to it.