3 ms·
The biggest polluter isn't the US. It's been outsourced to China because they make what the west demands. A lot if it can be addressed by having western count
by defrost 3y ago
The biggest polluter isn't the US.
It's been outsourced to China because they make what the west demands.
A lot if it can be addressed by having western countries order more costly physical goods that last longer and are more repairable.
Per Capita the US remains a leading consumer nation and one that sets an example, that example being to outsource problems and waste.
- matrix_overload 3y ago>A lot if it can be addressed by having western countries order more costly physical goods that last longer and are more repairable. I would love, LOVE to see that. Together with more local production, repair industry with middle-class jobs, and overall education of people on how to take good care of what they own. Except, how many green activists have you seen actually suggesting it? The solutions proposed so far: * Have fewer kids * Eat less meat * Suffer with no A/C * Rent an apartment instead of owning a house * Don't drive outside, sit at home * Don't use plastic bags and straws All of these lower life quality of regular people, are not even in the top 10 of biggest polluters, and often angled towards more wealth transfer to the corporations (like less kids => lower salary expectations). I think, it's a reasonable, rational and well-informed choice to not agree with, and not support these policies.
- wyre 3y agoAdd biking or taking public transit instead of driving and not flying in planes as well. Having fewer kids, eating less meat, using human powered or public transport instead of cars or planes are the biggest things individuals can do to lower their personal emissions. Also everything you listed are things nearly everyone can do. Creating local production and improving our repair industry are pipe dreams that go against the current capitalist mindset. It’s a tired argument that these things lower our quality of life: we are all going to die to global warming because we wont stop abusing fossil fuels to selfishly maintain our quality of life.
- matrix_overload 3y agoThat's just not fair. "Sorry, honey, I need more drinking money, so the biggest thing you can do to optimize the family budget, is wear second-hand clothes and eat at soup kitchen". Screw that, I'm not sacrificing my lifestyle for their profits. >It’s a tired argument that these things lower our quality of life: we are all going to die to global warming because we wont stop abusing fossil fuels to selfishly maintain our quality of life. Nope, you are being used. If the rich seriously thought that we are all going to die in our lifetimes, they would not be having kids and buying waterfront properties. Nope, they don't think so. They created the whole sense of panic and urgency, so you would not be asking them why you can't afford kids, house and a healthy assortment of gourmet meats, but would instead go after people like me who do not buy into the BS. You need to be skeptical, look what people actually do (rather than say), and who owns the people that say things that influence you.
- wyre 3y agoNothing is fair. Stop being selfish. The absurdly wealthy showcase sociopathic tendencies and will choose things in their self interest at the expense of the rest of us. Doing something because the opulent does will only create a tragedy of the commons that will only accelerate the death knell of global warming and climate catastrophe. I have no control over the actions of oligarchs (besides voting) but I have control over mine.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> It’s a tired argument that these things lower our quality of life: The problem is that even if we solve global warming, we are still going to die, probably at the same time. Being concerned about the effects of climate change means having empathy for your children and grandchildren who will suffer much more from it.
- noduerme 3y agoThe US still hasn't come to grips with the fact that half of the countries in Latin America are practically failed states as a result of our country's drug addiction. Good luck getting Americans to blame themselves for the environmental damage caused by their consumer-goods dealers. Out of sight, out of mind. As usual, the only solution in grasp is really demand-side. What is really frustrating is the fact that tariffs on foreign goods (produced under inhumane conditions and without environmental regulations) are still widely rejected by the new (non-labor, middle class, supposedly ecologically conscious) Left, while the revanchist Right and the old Union Left are both okay with them. Why can't our trade policy both benefit American labor and serve an environmental purpose?
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoIt isn’t just our drug addiction problem (which is increasingly being sourced from China these days), but we also provide them with lots of guns.
- noduerme 3y agodrugs & guns are both fine, if people are able to control themselves. In a society where self control and common purpose are valued, the ability to tolerate all views is a strength. Trouble is that the underlying set of ethics has been obliterated, so you're left with rights that don't pertain to the people who have inherited them.
- klabb3 3y agoYeah but even that doesn’t explain the extent of US uniquely high emissions. The US has close to 2x per-capita CO2 emissions than China even without adjusting for export. The only ones beating North America are small petro-states like Saudi and Bahrain.
- defrost 3y agoI'm well aware "my comment" falls short of the full story. It's best read as a minor edit of a portion of the comment above mine.
- dirtyid 3y agoTBH bigger issue is bulk of new emissions is going to come from ~7B (85% of global pop) poor people from global south who all want to develop and own their own refrigerators, air conditioners etc. Value engineering cheap consumer goods so they can have it ASAP is more important. Frankly budget models without basic features in countries with low labour costs actually get fixed/repaired because it's economically viable. But really physical goods pretty small slice of pie considering construction/building operations, transportation and heavy industries.
- myshpa 3y agohttps://i.imgur.com/LaEFQmV.png https://i.imgur.com/LaEFQmV.png