12 ms·
FCC fines robocaller a record $300M after blocking billions of their scam calls
- wombat-man 3y agoWould love to see some jail time too. What a nuisance.
- jasonmp85 3y ago[dead]
- footlose_3815 3y agoAt the scale they are wasting people's time, they should be jailed for life. Plenty of lifetime's worth of wasted time. We should also retire auth-less POTS.
- Google234 3y ago1 second of jail for every second of American time wasted
- coding123 3y agoThat doesn't even account for the scams, life savings lost, ruined relationships.
- myself248 3y agoSurgeries failed because the doctor didn't get enough sleep because they forgot to put their phone on silent... (I refuse to blame the victim here.) While it would be hard to definitively trace any specific death, statistically these spammers are also mass murderers.
- coding123 3y agoThis is the way to do this. If more of these scam calls & texts are found to be coming through certain pipes, fine those parties, jail those parties so that there is an incentive to stop it. I don't know why its taking them this long to figure this out.
- jiveturkey 3y agocouldn’t disagree more. this is pointless and useless. jail time is required, not an uncollectable fine from the perps. a more palatable solution would be fining telcos (because it’s collectible and damaging) for allowing it. we’ll then see good blocking measures in place.
- lightbendover 3y agoNot even sure why telecoms are allowed to allow spoofing. Should be absolutely illegal both in their own network and they should be disallowed from peering with networks where it is allowed. Actually, I do know: it's profitable to them and they lobby a lot.
- shadowgovt 3y agoTelcos actually don't have that much leeway in whether they can allow this stuff on the network. That's part and parcel of the whole "common carrier" thing that some people wish would be required of internet service providers; as a common carrier, they can't block legitimate, legal use of the service until some authority tells them it's not legitimate or legal, and that's a (due) process. So not to go to bat for Ma Bell and her li'l babies here, but fining the telcos for following the law would be counter-productive and unfair.
- jiveturkey 3y agoi understand that but that rule is actually imposed by the same agency (FCC) imposing the fine. AIUI. so that is changeable. correct though, under the current rules this is not possible
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoRoy M. Cox and Aaron Michael Jones. They don't even have wikipedia entries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 3y agoThis kind of thing is why a lot of people dropped their land line. Sure it was made largely redundant with mobile, but it also became primarily a nuisance. Facebook and others keep that in mind as you relentlessly monetize without offering value to people.
- vkou 3y agoI get mobile robocalls, too.
- jiveturkey 3y agosure, now. but at the time it was one of the drivers for cutting the land line
- EamonnMR 3y agoMost of them get a "scam likely" flag these days though.
- CWuestefeld 3y agoAlthough even today I still have a "house phone", I haven't used a POTS land line in 15 years or more - I switched to VoIP long ago because of related nuisances. The straw that broke the camel's back was that somebody had their fax machine to send something to a (wrong) number every night at 2am. The phone company said they had no way to just block that number for us, but that for abusive calls we could talk to the police. The police said they couldn't do anything because although it was an extreme nuisance, it didn't fit the legal definition of abusive. Since we were going to have to change our number because of this anyway, we decided to just move to a platform with which we really could manage blacklists and such. A prior experience had a debt collection agency calling us a couple of times a week, asking for some guy we never heard of. Each time we'd tell them that this was a wrong number, but they'd just call back a couple days later anyway. I tried using logic: the person they were looking for apparently had a Florida address, while the number they were calling at was a NJ number (back when you could pretty definitively link phone numbers to geography). The guy calling us agreed that it didn't make sense, but that didn't matter. I finally told them that the guy was deceased, and oddly, they seemed to buy that. Anyway, my experience suggests that the demise of land lines has been not just because of the nuisance itself, but also because the technology and regulatory situation didn't allow people any effective way to deal with it. Makes me wonder what that will eventually mean to email, SMS, etc., if anything. EDIT: my current solution for spam calls on our VoIP line is three-pronged. 1) Known abusers are blacklisted, never to be heard from again. I don't really use this, though, because they're probably just spoofing the number anyway. 2) Everybody on my contact list can freely ring our phone, no problem. 2) Otherwise, the call is intercepted by a voice response system. It just tells them that if they want to talk to us, to push "2". Bots never do that, so we're very nearly 100% free of spam calls.
- supertrope 3y agoPreviously the FCC has collected $0. The most they ever collected was a few thousand. They have to ask another agency to enforce these and by then Shady Telecom LLC has been shutdown by the owners without any forwarding address.
- devindotcom 3y agothey've collected considerably more than that, but you're right that it's not likely to be anywhere near $300M. but it's up to justice to collect, something the fcc wants to change (as Rosenworcel says ITA).
- psychlops 3y agoNothing like giving an independent agency the ability to investigate, fine and enforce payment collection when they want. What could go wrong?
- supertrope 3y agoThere’s still a court case. This is just so they can file it themselves.
- babyshake 3y agoI don't even try to stop the scams anymore for the most part. I just assume that anything incoming is a scam until I am able to verify it. It is kind of crazy making, but maybe not as crazy making as trying to stop the flood.
- larperdoodle 3y agoMy phone hasn't rung with a scam call since I enabled Google assistant call screening. Unknown callers have to explain why they're calling
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhat's in it for Google?
- esalman 3y agoThey can sell more Pixel phones.
- jjoonathan 3y agoYeah. I ragequit Android when they went back on photo storage promises but wowza I did not think that Apple would be so bad at handling spam. Unless they get their act together I am ragequitting the Apple ecosystem back to Android for my next phone.
- ajhurliman 3y agoIsn’t that more of a carrier thing?
- jjoonathan 3y agoThe phone changed but the carrier and phone number didn't. Pixel's robocall screening was evidently like that meme with the soldier blocking the arrows.
- plagiarist 3y agoIt's insane that this is not a solved problem. Here's a thought: if I could collect $100 from my carrier for each spam call they put through, this problem would be solved overnight.
- ipython 3y agoYou can collect $$ for spam calls already in the United States, with laws on the books today- see the [TCPA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_Consumer_Protection_Act_of_1991 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_Consumer_Protection_...). Problem is that you have to track down the individual/company that's doing it. That's become dramatically more difficult over the past 15 years.
- viraptor 3y agoTime for my usual comment. No, it's not difficult. Every Telco knows where the call comes from and where it's routed to. Sure, the end-user doesn't necessarily know the origin, but there's regulation that would trivially solve this. "For each spam report, you're responsible unless you point out where you got the call from" if enforced would sort out the problem almost immediately. Telco can't say how the call happened? Fine them. Telco can't sort out their spammy customer? Fine them. "Oh, but international calls!" - they can drop the spammy international peer - the US is large enough that nobody serious would risk getting disconnected.
- ipython 3y agoWell, it’s not quite that simple- especially for an end user. I don’t have the ability to trace it- and even if I did most of the scam calls I get these days are from overseas voip providers. So I have to invest a lot of time to get to a U.S. based business that benefits from the calls. Even then, the tcpa may not allow you to collect (some state laws do) It is difficult enough that there is a full on coalition dedicated to this (the trace back working group that’s mentioned by the fcc in this order)
- 3y ago
- mikeyouse 3y agoNote, Roy Cox was previously sanctioned and fined for the exact same behavior - his $1M settlement was suspended due to "inability to pay". https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2013/02/robocaller-banned-telemarketing-settlement-ftc https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2013/02/...
- edgyquant 3y agoSo take every cent from him and jail him if he makes no cents. Inability to pay is bs
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoWe don’t really do debtor’s prison anymore…
- edgyquant 3y agoWe most certainly have penalties that include jail time for not paying fines. You’re right that isn’t a debtors prison so I’m not sure why you’ve brought them into the conversation.
- dymk 3y agoThat's fine, but we do prisons for criminals, and the guy is a fraudster
- qingcharles 3y agoTell that to the thousands of people locked up for inability to pay their child support. They don't imprison you for the debt, they imprison you because the court gave you a direct order and you could not fulfill that order, thus you committed contempt.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoMy understanding is that you don’t go to prison for inability to pay, but for having the money and not forking it over.
- sgustard 3y ago"Two of the central players ... were under lifetime bans against making telemarketing calls" Wait, why isn't every human under such a ban?
- jhallenworld 3y agoTo allow political ads I would guess.
- pnpnp 3y agoIf I had to guess, capitalism?
- csa 3y ago> Wait, why isn't every human under such a ban? Because it would kill cold sales calls, which I think have a ton more value than you probably think they do (when ethically done). For reference for a business I previously owned: - Per 100 cold calls based on leads we qualified… - We actually spoke to about 30 people… - Of which about 10 were actually interested… - Of which about 3 became customers. - Customers paid on a monthly basis for an average of well over two years for our service. For loosely qualified cold calls, this was a pretty big success, imho. Yes, we mildly bothered 70 people (unanswered call), and we bothered 20 more with an unwanted sales pitch (usually less than one minute), but we had good conversations with 10 of them. Whether they became a customer or not, I think that we at least helped them understand clearly what their options were in our product market.
- unsignedint 3y agoImplementing a challenge system could be a potential solution. In this system, each outgoing call would require the caller to pay a dime as a deposit. If the recipient marks the call as legitimate after the conversation, either through the app or website, the caller would receive the dime back. To ensure customer convenience, inbound business numbers could have the option to opt out of the challenge deposit requirement, allowing customers to call in without any deposit. While requiring all outgoing calls to be charged might be more effective, it might not be a popular direction, especially in the United States. Thus, the challenge system with a deposit and the optional opt-out for inbound business numbers appears to be a more balanced and acceptable approach, considering both the need for legitimacy verification and user satisfaction.
- j-bos 3y agoThis would be a cool idea for an email filter.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoThere was a proposal for this in the 90s called Hashcash. Senders would have to brute force some random data to append onto email headers until they found some such that the first n bits of the hashed header were 0s. Sending emails would be computationally expensive, but not to a point that it would impact non-bulk users. The proof-of-work email use case never took really took off, but if you're acquainted with cryptocurrencies some parts of the implementation might sound familiar :)
- c0nsumer 3y agoLike STIR/SHAKEN to provide affirmation that the calling number is legit? https://ribboncommunications.com/company/media-center/blog/overview-stirshaken-what-it-and-why-it-important https://ribboncommunications.com/company/media-center/blog/o...
- unsignedint 3y agoSTIR/SHAKEN is a mechanism that validates the origination of calls but doesn't verify the legitimacy of the call, which can only be determined by the recipient. While it is a good starting point to protect against spoofing, what we truly need is an end-to-end deterrent to prevent these annoying calls altogether. I believe that imposing a potential financial burden on the caller could be the only effective solution to counter these calls.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 3y agoIt's a start. Next time fine the carrier.
- TechBro8615 3y agoI haven't answered the phone in years. All calls from unknown numbers go straight to silent, and anyone in my contacts knows not to call me anyway. What kind of real person uses the phone nowadays? It's literally scams, customer support, billing departments, credit collection agencies, and generally people you don't talk to as long as you can avoid it. Normal people use FaceTime, WhatsApp, Messenger, Zoom, etc. There's basically zero upside to phone calls, and frankly nor is there much for SMS either. I would suggest that phone companies completely deprecate their telecom networks and go all-in on internet, but then the spam would migrate to the apps (it's already begun with whatsapp), so I don't want to give them any ideas.
- beebeepka 3y agoThis reads like sarcasm to me. I barely use my phone, yet calls is 99% of what I do. I get less than 5 unsolicited calls per year. Don't use any of the things your imaginary "normal people" use. What a weird thought process. I guess the world does revolve around you
- TechBro8615 3y agoWhat do you mean calls is 99% of what you do? For work? Doesn't that just prove my point? You're not using the phone system for personal calls. You must work somewhere doing outbound calls for some reason or receiving them for another. And yes, I would include sales in this classification.
- ryandrake 3y agoI'm with you. My Phone app is probably the least-used app on my phone, because pretty much all inbound calls are unwanted. I occasionally need to make an outbound call so my Phone app usage is not quite zero.
- vel0city 3y agoI have a lot of somewhat tech illiterate family which I communicate with regulaly who pretty much only care to SMS and regular phone calls. Before Signal dropped SMS support I had managed to get a number of them on Signal, but dropping SMS really confused most of them so they dropped it. I also participate in a lot of local groups where the least common denominator is usually phone/SMS for quick comms. I refuse to use Meta products outside a privacy container on my computer so no Facebook Messenger/WhatsApp on my phone.
- TylerE 3y agoFine for stuff like this should be: You get audited, and pay 150% of what you earned from the illegal activity. Not "cost of doing business". Can't pay it? C-Suite goes to prison.
- m463 3y agoFrom what I understand, these huge fines are never collected.
- shadowgovt 3y agoA hack someone introduced me to that I cannot recommend enough if you still, for some God-unfortunate reason, have a landline: Record the audio for the "We're sorry, this number has been disconnected" message from Verizon or whoever. Keep it on your phone. If you get a lot of telemarketers, queue it up before you answer an unknown number. Hit 'em with it if it sounds like a robocall. Robocalls still cost time even if they're functionally free money-wise, so a lot of systems will key on that message and will yank your number off their call list.
- green-salt 3y agoA friend of mine recorded that to the beginning of their voicemail greeting, and apparently its worked.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoI've noticed an influx of robocalls that get through my pixel 4 spam call filter. Recently when I get these, unless I'm in a hurry, I play nice with the robot and they connect me to a real person. Either I'll waste their time by acting sincere but stupid, or I'll tell them a sob story, eg, sorry, I don't need your home insurance because I got fired from my job, so my wife divorced me, and now I'm homeless and living out of my car. What I'm really hoping for is a real-time AI app that can (a) understand what they are saying and generate plausible time wasting responses.
- datashaman 3y ago> What I'm really hoping for is a real-time AI app that can (a) understand what they are saying and generate plausible time wasting responses. ...until one day the AI is convinced it's a good deal and buys you a comprehensive insurance package. :)
- midjji 3y agoFCC the regulator agency charged with regulating telecom companies once again fails to regulate telecom companies. Despite a trivial and permanent remedy beeing available, e.g. fine the telecom companies in significant excess of what they made from providing the robocalling companies with the services required to make the robocalls, they instead place a ineffectual and unenforceable fine on a couple of soon to be chapter 11 LLC. Yay for telecom lobbying....
- al_be_back 3y agothe telco industry failed terribly to innovate around the phone-line and the mobile-line. phone line: hoisted for internet services, then customers dumped it mobile line: being hoisted for internet services, customers will soon dump them too biggest issue: privacy & security - it's a spammers, scammers paradise. fines won't fix the underlying issues (telco)
- alexmarcy 3y agoThis is going to have zero impact on the 900 spam calls I get every single day from towns in my home state with less than 50 residents.
- FPGAhacker 3y agoWho gets the money from fines like these?
- youniverse 3y agoOne thing going around for high end retail businesses (real estate, dental, etc. is this scam marketing robocall that starts with: 'Your google business listing is about to expire, if you are the business owner please press 1.' Then it will connect you to someone from the US who will ask if you are the owner and if you say no they just hang up on you! If you are the owner they pitch you on some nonsense google business enhanced listing for a $300-$500 one time payment.