6 ms·
Disables WebEnvironmentIntegrity feature and origin trials
- PaulHoule 3y agoWe gotta start telling our politicians and regulators to say now to WebEnvironmentIntegrity.
- TobyTheDog123 3y agoI would be surprised if politicians and regulators even know what a web browser is, so this might be a tough sell to them.
- k_roy 3y agocan they use it to exploit us and collect more money? That's the real decider
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoGiven that 5.07 billion people use the web https://www.demandsage.com/internet-user-statistics/ https://www.demandsage.com/internet-user-statistics/ it would be surprising if the politicians and regulators of the countries that HN users reside in are not at least some of them among those users. As there are many regulations and court cases in the EU and the US (and I presume in other places as well) aimed at some of the richest companies in the world that have to do with browsers behavior it seems that they would have to know what a browser is.
- judge2020 3y agoUsing the web isn't the same as knowing what the difference between a web browser and a computer OS is. Most people don't buy personal computers anymore, politicians are likely only using office PCs and their phone.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoI use a train to get to work every day, but I don't really know anything about how the technology works (beyond a superficial level, the same degree of trivial superficiality whereby I know that Khartoum is the capital city of Sudan) Even if I didn't know the word 'train' I think most reasonable users of English would still agree that I know what a train is. People who use a browser to go on the web, even if they don't know the name for the category of application they are using is "browser" and all the technical functioning of the browser and how the internet works, can be said in normal English usage to know what a browser is - it is one of a class of applications that they use to go on the web. They click on an icon, a window opens up they go on the internet. The "browser"
- komali2 3y ago> it seems that they would have to know You'd think they would have to know what a browser is. Certainly some people within the courts and legislative bodies do. But, I challenge the "have to," because I want to give credence to my anecdotal theory that a ton of people have no idea, especially older people, and most politicians are super old. Why do they "have to?" Couldn't a lot of boneheaded decisions we've seen over the years be because they don't understand? They could maliciously be applying law per their lobbyist needs, which is probably a thing that happens, but they also could just be ignorant. Remember "series of tubes?" What about David Cameron's push in 2014 to "protect kids from porn" that was really just a PRC style great firewall? Pretend it wasn't a malicious attempt at massive state surveillance - how does it stop kids from getting porn from Twitter, Youtube? Anybody with a glancing familiarity with the internet would know why stopping porn is essentially impossible without blocking literally EVERYTHING and creating a country intranet, combined with a massive, pervasive state surveillance operation with police that have broad powers. Impossible in a liberal democracy (the effective porn blocking, not the attempts to have pervasive state surveillance - the issues come when it's time to start arresting). Some quotes from when Zuckerberg was in front of congress: "If I’m emailing within WhatsApp … does that inform your advertisers?" Senator Brian Schatz "What was Facemash?" Senator Billy Long "How do you sustain a business model in which users don’t pay for your service?" Orrin Hatch (the "senator... we run ads" quote) Why are so many politicians opposed to encryption? Because they're fascists that want better state surveillance? Maybe, but I think more likely is they hear that it makes it harder for the FBI to track down two murderers in San Bernadino and they think "Encryption? Affecting law enforcement? Do we need it? Just make it illegal." Tangent: This makes me wonder about a broader topic I've been questioning: I think we assign too much competence and reasoning to eachother and to our leaders. Random examples: Musk put a big flashing X on the roof of the twitter offices, it's obviously against code, it's obviously horrible, but there are people arguing "Genius marketing move! No press is bad press!" Really? Or, when Bezos climbed into a rocket. "He wouldn't get into it if he wasn't sure it was mostly safe. You don't get to be a billionaire without knowing what you're doing." A couple years later and a submarine that the most layperson of laypeople would point out is a deathtrap proves that idea wrong. This on top of the fact that sometimes it seems like entire financial markets depend on people making "rational" decisions. A housing crash because "the banks would never maintain these portfolios as AA if they weren't rock-solid!" A dot-com crash because "www is the future, it'll make money somehow!" It keeps happening. We keep giving ourselves way too much credit. I think climate change is going to be the greatest example of this, should we survive it. "We'll let it go far, but not past a certain point. Someone will stop this before it's actually irreversible. Or if necessary, at some point, the people will rise up and destroy oil pipelines." No, I don't think so, I think we'll keep thinking we're too smart to let something like that happen.
- whoopdedo 3y agoGoogle spends around $10million each year to make sure politicians know what a web browser is.
- abeyer 3y ago...and carefully look the other direction while crafting legislation
- jonas21 3y agoDo you believe they would be opposed to it?
- cmdli 3y agoI believe so. Big Tech has gained a lot of enemies in governments around the world, and it doesn’t require a lot of technical knowledge to understand that WEI is a way for Google to gain more control. Whether WEI is good or not, politicians on both sides in the US would be more than willing to oppose Google.
- neltnerb 3y agoI don't have any desire to carry water for this horrible concept but "Google is too important" is awfully abstract to run a campaign on. We're at the level where "does it break end-to-end encryption without anyone else being technically capable of reading it" is a serious debate. Why does this technical proposal actually threaten them or their constituents in a concrete way? More importantly, does it threaten a politician's ability to fundraise or broadcast the message they like? I think the idea is horrific on many ethical and technical grounds, but how can Google directly use it to ruin a [political] career? That feels like more what they will empathize with.
- lamontcg 3y ago> politicians on both sides in the US would be more than willing to oppose Google. You're living in a fantasy land where the US government actually regulates industry in any sort of pro-consumer non-regulatory-capture way. If this happens it'll be the EU that does it.
- asynchronous 3y agoIf I must vote with my participation then I choose to vote by using Brave as my browser. They’ll making choices I agree with more than any other browser currently.
- Dah00n 3y agoPissing in pants for warmth IMO. It is still Chromium. Feels like not voting in protest when a candidate you don't like looks to be winning big. The only difference it will make is how you feel, no real world implications.
- silisili 3y agoEh... it's still Chromium for as long as it needs to be. Just like Chrome was webkit as long as it needed to. I have zero doubt that when things get rough, they'll either hard fork it or work with a different engine.
- PUSH_AX 3y agoIf this was easy it would have happened a long time ago.
- narenkeshav 3y agoI use Brave. There has been reasons & will be in the future as well.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoDo any Brave users compile from source.
- habitue 3y agoThough, of course, as with DRM, if it becomes standard for let's say, all payment sites to require it enabled, your choice becomes "stop using the internet" or switch browsers
- nottheengineer 3y agoThere's a third option: Just stop paying for stuff that uses this.
- klardotsh 3y agoWhich works until (1) your job depends on it, or (2) your bank/credit union depends on it. I have to use Chromium for Slack Huddles for example, since evidently Slack Huddles "don't support" Firefox on Linux (it's WebRTC, wtf?). I don't really get an opt out of using Chromium for those couple occasions a week, because work. Now imagine that, but with GoogleDRM.
- wetpaws 3y ago[dead]
- judge2020 3y ago1 makes sense, no? assuming your job has certain security policies in place to ensure compliance with laws and regulations, requiring some level of attestation + MDM to ensure this compliance.
- klardotsh 3y agoWell, I was thinking more of the "your work requires you to use some SaaS shit that transitively requires this attestation, whether it's legally required or not" angle. Like if, I don't know, let's say your time tracking software or something started depending on WEI.
- willow8349 3y ago[dead]
- p-e-w 3y agoMoral posturing sure is fun, but we'll see what happens once Chrome becomes the only browser that you can use to log in to your bank. Mozilla made lots of noise about EME, but eventually fell in line – and that was at a time when Firefox had a market share it can only dream about today. The so-called "independent" browser makers will scream and shout with indignation, then try some legal and political action (which will fail), then try to find a compromise (which they won't get), then finally implement whatever Chrome implements, while explaining to their users that this was really always about choice and adding this feature gives the user that choice. And then they will move on to their next battle, which they will lose just like they lost all the other battles they fought over the past 10 years or so.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt would be annoying to buy a separate device just to access my bank. Not annoying enough to change banks of course, but it could be the straw that broke the camel’s back if I was already inclined to switch.
- quickthrower2 3y agoCryptocurrency gets a lot of hate, but it doesn’t mandate your user agent.
- Semaphor 3y ago> It would be annoying to buy a separate device just to access my bank. Not annoying enough to change banks of course Why "of course"? That would very much be annoying enough for me to switch. I switched banks because they decided to randomly start requiring SafetyNet to pass.
- slabity 3y agoOut of curiosity, is there anything stopping websites from detecting if a browser has WEI and then simply not serving the website? It would be amusing to see browsers get pressured to not implement certain features for them to access the web, rather than the other way around. And it would be ironic for it to be a DRM feature. Is there any reason at all that websites can't do this?
- trashburger 3y ago> Out of curiosity, is there anything stopping websites from detecting if a browser has WEI and then simply not serving the website? Of course, just check for the existence of the attestation API described by the spec. > Is there any reason at all that websites can't do this? Because it would be an extremely dumb move regarding reach. Banning WEI-enabled user agents means you're banning over 80% of your traffic. This might be okay for a small blog or if the website owner is big into activism, but if you have a commercial interest you absolutely can't do this. Plus, blocking WEI-enabled user agents only hurts the user in the end; Google won't walk back on such an aggressively-pushed feature simply because some site refuses to serve Chrome users.
- friendzis 3y ago> Because it would be an extremely dumb move regarding reach. Unless you are a de facto monopoly. Google can mandate WEI because they are a monopoly, other monopolies can do the opposite. Sadly, it is hard to imagine a monopolic website that both is used day to day and does not meaningfully benefit from WEI. Banks, utilities, etc. are used too rarely to matter.
- Eli389494 3y ago[dead]
- jojobas 3y agoMozilla already rejected this. If this is the fork point between corporate and old internets I'm willing to stay in the old one.
- dv_dt 3y agoWEI gives me flashbacks to Microsoft Internet Explorer and activex objects debacles.
- userbinator 3y agoWEI is worse, much worse.
- anigbrowl 3y agoMeanwhile Vivaldi Browser is putting its hope in regulation: https://vivaldi.com/blog/googles-new-dangerous-web-environment-integrity-spec/ https://vivaldi.com/blog/googles-new-dangerous-web-environme...
- soundnote 3y agoI think it's the smart plan on this one, because a lot of more or less essential services like Bing, Google, banks and streaming services are likely to adopt it. And together those can easily force something through, especially since it doesn't per se bother legitimate users.
- NovaDudely 3y agoIf a website uses this, I won't use that website. Simple as that. Being near "full Stallman" I use one of the few FSF approved Linux Distros (Trisquel), there is no way this will ever be implemented in that system.