5 ms·
But they used two bombs. Wouldn't one have been enough to end the war?
by croes 3y ago
But they used two bombs. Wouldn't one have been enough to end the war?
- cduzz 3y agoDid the first one end the war? Did the second one end the war? Did the first and second ones prevent the next war? I'm not sure of the answer to these questions; they're obviously important and difficult to answer. The timing certainly hints to "no, yes, maybe" but we're not going to get a do-over.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe last one seems to be 'for now', but it may not hold.
- pasc1878 3y agoBut we have had nearly 80 years of peace between major powers and that has not happened since there were major powers. Ok you get many indirect wars e.g. Ukraine, Vietnam, Korea much in Africa but not ones that could escalate to World War levels.
- jacquesm 3y agoIf it doesn't hold we won't be able to continue the conversation so I hope that we can extend that 80 years. Proxy wars are still wars though, and proxy wars always have the possibility of escalation built in to them.
- pasc1878 3y agoHistorically cold war proxy wars were unlikely to escalate as even when a major power had troops on the ground it was on behalf of another country and also we seem to have had sensible leaders. Ukraine does differ as a major power is involved in its own name.
- jacquesm 3y agoAnd Russia seems to not have a sensible leader.
- radiator 3y agoUkraine definitely does not have a sensible leader. In 2021 he declared both that "he does not like the Minsk agreements" and that "Ukraine needs to obtain nuclear weapons". After the start of the war, he insists that Ukraine be allowed to join NATO, which would automatically mean World War. Alright, from his point of view, perhaps this is sensible: Ukraine stands to lose otherwise, so for him the World War might be preferable.
- jacquesm 3y agoYou're hilarious.
- Vecr 3y agoUkraine's probably not going to join NATO. Obviously they really want to but it's hard to imagine a future where both Russia and Ukraine don't retaliate against even non-government and uncommanded (i.e. soldiers fire without authorization) attacks that go back and forth across the border.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoThey used two because they had two different designs, and they wanted to test them both on real targets. They purposely chose purely civilian targets, in order to inflict maximal civilian casualties. If this is not morally wrong, then nothing is.
- XorNot 3y agoHiroshima and Nagasaki were both industrial centres involved in the production of war material. By the technology of the time (precision weapons were half a century away), they were absolutely valid targets.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoFirst, by this argument, literally every urban center is a military target. Put another way, it's an argument for total war, in which nothing is off limits, and every "enemy" civilian is fair game. Is that the world you want to live in? Second, the US did not target any specific industrial areas of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In each case, it targeted the center of town, with the goal of inflicting maximum destruction on the city as a whole.
- XorNot 3y ago> First, by this argument, literally every urban center is a military target. Put another way, it's an argument for total war, in which nothing is off limits, and every "enemy" civilian is fair game. Is that the world you want to live in? Industrial bases, military bases, centers of government: these are all legitimate targets in a time of war and all are built in and around cities. The difference today is we have precision weapons so they can be reasonably targeted accurately, and the side-benefit is that night-vision capability favors night-time strikes which minimizes the number of civilians around. But don't delude yourself into thinking that there's any such thing as a "clean war". It's a war.
- gizajob 3y agoIn your morals perhaps. If you were to run a utilitarian calculus, bombing such a target could deliver the most morally optimal solution. If the war had not have ended, the Japanese could have continued to potentially kill millions. The bomb was a clear and final “you cannot win if you continue to wage war” that they came to accept. The Americans could have as easily dropped it on Tokyo.
- jnwatson 3y agoThe idea was to show that the US had an endless supply. Of course we only built two, but the Japanese didn’t know that.
- iforgotpassword 3y agoThree
- cduzz 3y agoDidn't they have the goods for roughly four? Trinity, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and the demon core.
- iforgotpassword 3y agoYep, I only counted the ones intended for Japan. The demon core was finished a few days before Japan's surrender, but never shipped to Tinian base for assembly. Iirc they would've been able of making three bombs per month.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt was just a matter of time, right? The US had the ocean by that point, so presumably we could have just bottled them up on their island and then take our time making more bombs. Grim stuff. As horrible as the war was already, glad it didn’t come to that.
- ROTMetro 3y agoAs someone whose grandfather was fighting in the Pacific, looking back sure seems easy to judge but there are no guarantees and in the horror that was WWII you don't really take risks 'because'. You ensure victory. My grandfather was forced to call in flamethrowers on other human beings that would not come out of tunnels. He never forgave himself for that. Was he a monster? Should he have told his supperiors to stall out their plans, maybe wait the guys out instead? He was part of the occupation and saw the damage the bombs did first hand, helped cleanup the damage, but he never doubted the need to end the war or the way it was done. But glad you looking back figured out a better way by volunteering to let my grandfather 'bottle them up'.
- enkid 3y agoThis is a question with no answer, but even with two parts of Japan's military tried to stave a couple to ensure the war would continue. Either way, even if dropping the second bomb only decreased the likelihood that an invasion of Japan was necessary or only shortened the war in China by a few months, it was worth it in human lives saved.
- jacquesm 3y agoI don't know about that. It brought nuclear weapons into the world in a way that I'm not sure we could have done without. The answer that the question of whether or not that was ultimately beneficial will quite possibly not stop with the end of World War II, but may well carry over into the beginnings of World War III.
- gumby 3y agoIt's not even clear in retrospect; the minutes of the Imperial war cabinet show they were confused as to what was going on after the first bomb. Note that there was a third bomb scheduled and in preparation and it was decommissioned and returned to Los Alamos. Also note that the conventional bombing of Tokyo just a few months prior caused greater destruction and loss of life. Evaluations have to be made in context, which is very hard. There was a lot of anger and pain on both sides, which lead to irrational "momentum" in prosecution of war. Also there is the logic of industrial warfare: look at Europe: many smaller German cities were bombed for the first time just in the the last month of that war, because a huge machine had been switched on that just kept emitting planeloads of bombs which had to be dropped somewhere. There is a thoughtful discussion of this topic by Tooze from just a few days ago: https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-230-burning-hamburg-1943 https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-230-burning-hambu...
- jacquesm 3y agoDresden... The Germans did terrible things, but the allies definitely did not have the moral high ground on all fronts. This is for me the horror of war: that because of one side losing its humanity the other side will too.
- nvy 3y agoDresden was as legitimate a target as any other city. Its factories made, among other things, precision optics for bomb sights. Dresden being a purely civilian target is a myth.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, and precisely the large industrial areas of Dresden were not targeted but the inner city with lots of civilians was. Note that I have no love for Nazi Germany, my family suffered tremendously at their hands and the results of that are still felt today. At the same time: I am categorically against indiscriminate firebombing of cities leading to 20K+ civilian deaths and if you feel that those civilians were a legitimate target because they happened to be in the city then you and I are probably not going to have a very productive discussion.
- BurningFrog 3y agoEmpirically no, since Japan didn't surrender after the first.
- cykotic 3y agoFrom the wikipedia article on the surrender broadcast: As many as 1,000 officers and army soldiers raided the Imperial Palace on the evening of 14 August 1945 to destroy the recording. The rebels were confused by the layout of the palace and were unable to find the recordings, which had been hidden in a pile of documents. The two phonographs were labelled original and copy and successfully smuggled out of the palace, the original in a lacquer box and the copy in a lunch bag. Major Kenji Hatanaka attempted to halt the broadcast at the NHK station but was ordered to desist by the Eastern District Army.[2][3] Even after two were dropped members of the armed forces still wanted the war to continue.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoEven after two bombs were dropped, and the Russian declaration of war and invasion of Manchuria, and the decision of the Emperor!
- matthewdgreen 3y agoAfter the coup failed, Hatanaka shot himself. Many others did the same, and some were hung following war crimes tribunals. These people knew exactly what Japan had done under their leadership, and presumably assumed that surrender meant death.
- hef19898 3y agoElememts of the armed forces. As elements of the German armed forces were willing to kill Hitler, but not all of them.
- cykotic 3y agoOne bomb may not have been enough evidenced by the fact that even junior level officers attempted to thwart the surrender. One bomb might have been enough. The decision to drop the second one was not entirely unjustified since the Japanese government was, apparently, in no hurry to end the war after the 1st one was dropped.
- dboreham 3y agoPossibly but the idea was to demonstrate that the allies had more than one bomb. It might have been possible to just make enough fissile material for one weapon, then take another 2-3 years to make a second one. In that case if you're Japan you don't need to surrender.
- euroderf 3y agoA book I read way back in the 70s quotes Groves as saying that one bomb could be seen as a one-off but two bombs would make the Japanese think there's more to come.
- jcranmer 3y agoThe question of the role of the atomic bombs in compelling Japanese surrender is one that is still debated among historians to this day, and will continue to be debated for as long as I live. The indisputable fact is that Japan had thoroughly lost the war at that point--it was either losing or had already completely lost in every theater. I tend to think that the atomic bombs played a big role in the decision to surrender in that it showed that the Americans were capable of devastating entire cities with a single bomber: air defenses are unlikely to score any hits against a single bomber unlike a large fleet of bombers carpet bombing cities into oblivion, robbing Japan even of the chance to die in a blaze of glory. But this also raises a tricky moral question. The decision to end a war is not made by the victor but by the loser. What should you do if the loser refuses to admit the loss?
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoBy the time the atom bombs were used the 60 or so major cities in Japan had been destroyed by the firebombing. Whether it was done with one bomber or dozens didn't really matter. Japan didn't have the capacity to stop either at that point. On the Japanese side there were multiple factions. Everyone in leadership understood the war was lost, but a large fraction still had hope of making things costly enough for the US to negotiate a conditional surrender that preserved the Emperor.
- InTheArena 3y agoThe only slight correction I would add here is that the Japanese were not playing to win the war at this point. They were simply playing to not lose. Their calculus was that they could inflict enough casualties on invading forces that any surrender would take into account them, continuing the whole China, Korea, and all of the other Pacific islands that they had seized. casualties were not a bug, they were a feature. This is what all of the constant debates on hacker news failed to take into regard. If you look at the correspondence and the commentary of the people making decisions, it is quite clear that prior to the atomic bombing, the only side that was trying to minimize casualties was in fact, the United States. In fact, even on the allied side, neither Russia nor the United Kingdom, were particularly concerned with minimizing casualties. Since Stalin felt that he would gladly trade Soviet lives in favor of land that he could hold after the war, and the United Kingdom government was determined to make an example to justify their occupation of Asia . It’s also worth noting that Nimitz and King, were proposing a path that would’ve led to an order of magnitude more death than either an invasion or the atomic bombs. A fleet blockade of Japan would’ve starved everyone in Japan.