9 ms·
The "Bullshit Jobs" phenomenon was identified decades ago by Buckminster Fuller: "We must do away with the absolutely specious notion that everybody has to ear
by ryandrake 3y ago
The "Bullshit Jobs" phenomenon was identified decades ago by Buckminster Fuller:
"We must do away with the absolutely specious notion that everybody has to earn a living. It is a fact today that one in ten thousand of us can make a technological breakthrough capable of supporting all the rest. The youth of today are absolutely right in recognizing this nonsense of earning a living. We keep inventing jobs because of this false idea that everybody has to be employed at some kind of drudgery because, according to Malthusian-Darwinian theory, he must justify his right to exist. So we have inspectors of inspectors and people making instruments for inspectors to inspect inspectors. The true business of people should be to go back to school and think about whatever it was they were thinking about before somebody came along and told them they had to earn a living."
As more and more work becomes automated or done by robots, we have less and less to actually do, but with a growing population. So we make up all this work and have 1/2 the population digging holes so the other 1/2 can fill them in. I fully expect that by the time my [eventual] grandchildren enter the workforce, more than 50% (maybe more than 75%) of jobs will be make-work that just serves to employ people so that society doesn't fall apart.
- silisili 3y agoIf such a scenario were recognized, and we end up with something like UBI, how does one 'get ahead?' It seems some people are always wanting and willing to get ahead, either through multiple jobs, long hours, or study. Is that dream now crushed into just do nothing and exist like everyone else? The robot owners aren't going to just hand out money, so would have to be taxed at some insane rate, I think. Being able to survive without 'working' sounds like a dream, but I get hung up on the technicalities of it all.
- pixl97 3y agoWhuffie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_and_Out_in_the_Magic_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_and_Out_in_the_Magic_King...
- javajosh 3y agoAnd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riders_of_the_Purple_Wage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riders_of_the_Purple_Wage
- UncleOxidant 3y agoSure, some people want to get ahead just for the feeling that they're doing better than most people, but a lot of people try to get ahead out of fear of not having enough. In a system where everyone has enough wouldn't that fear be at least greatly diminished?
- zaphar 3y agoI think there is a pretty strong case that "having enough" is very much a moving target and now matter how much many people have it's not "enough". I see a lot of evidence that it's impossible to have a system where everyone has enough and I haven't seen a lot of evidence that it is possible to build such a system.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoWhy does getting ahead have to mean money? In a Star Trek utopia where money is meaningless, everybody can become one of the best in the world in some small niche.
- Ekaros 3y agoStar Trek utopia always smelled unworkable... It really leaves way too many open questions of how does that economy really work. Most media is about the absolute elite of that society. Or their relatives. It never truly answered where the non replicable resources come from.
- pengaru 3y agoIt's not like UBI prohibits working hard. All it does is give everyone access to enough resources for basic survival, not Ferraris, which will still exist and continue to motivate some to be Vikings.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoI think the idea of what it means to "get ahead" would change. For example, with UBI I'd still work part time at a coffeeshop to save up money to turn my long-time hobby into a small business. That's a way to "get ahead" in a way that personally fulfills me. I don't need to become the next 30 under 30, or show up on some list for my success. Just the personal satisfaction of being able to say "I did this, and I'm proud of it. I hope you can enjoy it too". Of course, those who do want to show up on that 30 under 30 list can make different choices to get ahead in the way they interpret that meaning. UBI brings more options for people to dedicate to new ideas, new inventions, new ways of thinking. It doesn't restrict the choices of any citizen, it opens up more choices. Getting ahead still exists, and those who want it can go for it, that option wouldn't be taken away from them.
- johnnyworker 3y ago> how does one 'get ahead?' By learning things? By knowing and liking many things? By knowing and liking many people? By being very good at a unique permutation of skills, and using them to improve your life and that of your friends, having great adventures and whatnot? > The robot owners aren't going to just hand out money, so would have to be taxed at some insane rate, I think. Which would not be a problem, since all other super rich people would be taxed at the same "insane" rate, leaving the "getting ahead" relative to your peers completely untouched -- if that was really the issue, if people really couldn't think of ways to stand out amongst others other than the amount of money they "make" (it's just shifted around after all). The problem is exploitation I'd say, and even that is not an end in and of itself, it's just a necessary nuisance that is optimized away wherever possible, leaving pure ownership of pure [0] means of production in very, very few hands. The rest gets nothing, and since humans cannot persist on that, cease to exist shortly after. Compared the trajectory we're on -- the scenario we're in -- the technicalities of how to make the world somewhat human and livable instead of just an insane runaway train seem rather minor to me. [0] As in, basically no workers, no more than you can personally oversee or even be yourself. I know that will never be "fully achieved" but I think that's splitting hairs. It's the trend, we keep accelerating and making previously thought impossible tools of dystopia real, who cares if there will ever be just one dude in a toga living forever commanding a blob of energy that can do and create anything, except make him sane.
- gswdh 3y ago[dead]
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> Being able to survive without 'working' sounds like a dream, but I get hung up on the technicalities of it all. One technicality that blocks me is something I encountered not that long ago... How do you compensate those that will come dig in human manure, sometimes for hours, to fix a house's clogged pipe? I had to do that: toilets wouldn't flush anymore, shits floating and all. I didn't know where the pipes were exactly and one them, the last one before the sewers, was clogged. So basically 40 meters of shit blocked inside the pipe, which then started overflowing on the property, for weeks (or months), unnoticed. The plumber couldn't come immediately (it was a sunday late in the afternoon) but would be there next morning. So for five hours I dig into human manure to find the damn pipe (which I more or less knew where it was located). It saved the plumber five hours of digging into, literally, shit and piss (saved me five hours of billing and five hours of waiting for things to be fixed too). In that "without working" society, who digs into human manure? Who comes to pick up the trash? Who comes to fix a broken AC? Who wants to spend 12 years studying medicine to save the lives of those who aren't working? That's what I don't get.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"Who wants to spend 12 years studying medicine to save the lives of those who aren't working?" I think the argument is that there is inherent value in helping fellow man/woman, self actualization, etc - and that is the reward in itself. I do not agree with this.
- ryandrake 3y agoI think the UBI argument is that the cost of those shit-digging jobs will have to significantly rise to the actual price of finding someone willing to do them. If I have to do work or starve, maybe I'm willing to dig shit for $15/hr. If nobody has to do work to survive, suddenly you have to shell out $300/hr to motivate someone to do it.
- one_level_deep 3y ago[dead]
- javajosh 3y ago>more than 50% (maybe more than 75%) of jobs will be make-work that just serves to employ people so that society doesn't fall apart. Yes, and then firms like OpenAI come in and automate those BS jobs, and take away all the societal upside of their existence. OpenAI will thrive, at first, by undoing the intricate scaffolding of lies that buttresses BS jobs. The country will either embrace socialism at that point, or perhaps there will be a Butlerian (buttressarian?) jihad of some kind in foolish attempt to put two genies back in the bottle. And who knows what will work to keep us alive and relatively thriving in the future? It seems clear to me that belief in a fantasy panopticon, if not taken to an extreme, was a useful part of society. It is strictly better than a real panopticon or no panopticon - and who could have guessed that from first principles? Perhaps it really is better to have BS jobs than overt socialism. Maybe people really do feel better believing their work makes a difference rather than just existing and knowing they do nothing. Idealists want to believe that people will thrive with the truth, but I think that's demonstrably false.
- lispisok 3y agoThe thing about BS jobs is you could eliminate the position entirely and nothing would happen. The point of the BS job is to be filled with bodies so there is no reason to automate it.
- spacephysics 3y agoPopulation rate is declining, and in the next couple of decades many first world countries are expected to have a population collapse. I understand what he’s saying the problem is, I think it’s just part of how complex processes such as companies and governments expand. However, part of me leans in the efficient market side of, yes there are inefficiencies but once capital is justly expensive, then the wheat is separated from the chaff. If a company could do something more cheaply with equal quality, they will probably try that. Though the larger a company gets, the easier it is to “hide” these busy-work jobs. Further, we don’t know the outcome of UBI. We saw a glimpse of it during covid. A very rough trial, but many people were getting more money via unemployment than by a minimum wage job. Most these individuals sat around hedonically watching TV, smoking weed, or drinking. Surely part of the pandemic in general, but I think there’s a human-nature aspect of path-of-least-resistance. I’m not convinced our society has the proper values to take UBI healthily, I think it will exacerbate the existing meaning crisis we’ve been in since religion has started to decline. We have young kids going to nihilism and mainstream outlets justifying this as a good thing. I think the last thing we need is to give people more time to ruminate on these ideas with a slosh fund. In a perfect world we could have UBI, have a subset of the population be the productive earners that can make more money over the UBI, and those on UBI would use the time and money for creative enhancement of themselves and society. But I think that’s too optimistic an outlook. We have foundational problems with many aspects of western civilization that need to be addressed before we add fuel to the fire.
- bovermyer 3y agoIf I didn't have to work, I would spend a lot of time building things (whether code things or physical things). I know people who, if they didn't have to work, would just sit around binging TV all day. I also know people who, if they didn't have to work, would probably somehow discover faster-than-light travel or solve world hunger or something. It might not be culture. It might be personality that determines what we do in "idleness." More likely, it's a mix of both.
- dbalatero 3y agoI think I'd do both, depending on the week.
- chongli 3y agoI don't think it's going to be in any way easy to convince people that it's okay not to be useful. No matter how times we care to repeat it, people will still feel dejected and hollow. "What is the meaning of my life?" is a difficult enough question to answer when you're a philosopher who has studied the problem academically and you're surrounded by other people going about their productive lives and overcoming various challenges in order to survive. Now we're supposed to have millions of people face the question and at the same time tell them "no, there's nothing useful for you to do, robots can already do it faster, cheaper, and more efficiently than you will ever manage." So, what? Do we tell everyone "just go smoke weed and play video games"? Or "go kayaking and hiking and rockclimbing and find yourself in nature"? The latter will not scale. Many natural places are already overcrowded and we don't even have a post-work economic system in place.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoFind yourself in nature won't scale, and smoke weed and play videogames is hollow. I love videogames, but the few times of my life where I genuinely did just play games all day for weeks or months, I felt awful. I just couldn't bring myself to do anything else.
- ericmcer 3y agoThe exception to that is highly social games. I did genuinely feel a sense of accomplishment when me and 4 friends would crush another team in league of legends. Or the old World of Warcraft raids involved coordinating 40 people and felt meaningful to execute. Maybe there is a future where video games optimize around giving life meaning once there is little work to be done. Designing a game where the goal was to create strong friendships between players would be a pretty interesting task.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bonniemuffin 3y agoInstead of telling people to play video games or go kayaking, I hope we can ask them to go play checkers with the elderly, read to children, hold hands with dying people in hospice, and mentor the formerly-incarcerated. These are "jobs" that I would argue robots cannot meaningfully fill, but which society would benefit from a lot more of.
- luxuryballs 3y agoIf you don’t maintain your own means of making a living then your mode of living will end up owning you. This seems to happen every single time. I don’t think there’s ever been a single person who is a permanent dependent that didn’t ultimately end up as a subject or slave to the provider.
- ecf 3y agoSo what does that leave us. Service industries? Good luck getting those youths to work in a kitchen.
- organsnyder 3y agoGiven the typical compensation and working conditions, hard to blame them.
- Ekaros 3y agoFood and bars is one sector I could honestly see to be run as hobbies. Maybe bad customers would be shown door or the opening times would be erratic, but there is plenty of people who could run one as part of self-fulfilment. This scaling to feeding everyone everyday might be harder.
- m_0x 3y ago> we have less and less to actually do, but with a growing population. People will point out that the solution would be the opposite: a decreasing population. But that is not cost-free and basically is swapping a set of problems for another set of problems. Even then "swapping" is a promise at-best. We could end with two sets of problems instead of one.
- trylfthsk 3y ago> So we have inspectors of inspectors and people making instruments for inspectors to inspect inspectors. With all due respect to mister Fuller, this sounds like bullshit from someone that hasn't worked in manufacturing. Quality manufacturing processes are hard, and this complexity only increases with the sophistication of what's being produced. Usually, the measurement systems in place are a tradeoff between cost, efficacy, and regulatory requirements - and I guarantee if an inspection can be removed, some engineer is begging to do it.
- Buttons840 3y ago> It is a fact today that one in ten thousand of us can make a technological breakthrough capable of supporting all the rest. More than that are capable of great work and breakthroughs, but they're too busy doing bullshit work.
- alanbernstein 3y ago> So we have inspectors of inspectors and people making instruments for inspectors to inspect inspectors. This is an amazing precursor of the current software equivalent: https://xkcd.com/1629/ https://xkcd.com/1629/
- nprateem 3y agoYou really think companies employ people for fun? There may be perverse incentives and inefficiencies but this is rubbish.
- grumple 3y agoThis is total nonsense. It takes a huge amount of actual human effort to do all the most important jobs in society: grow food, transport food, make clothing, transport it, build housing, repair housing, build things for growing food and transporting clothing, healthcare, building hospitals... we are not remotely close to replacing the need for vast amounts of human labor for our most basic needs. We have huge trade shortages. We have bridges collapsing. Fuller's assertions are total fucking nonsense, only someone extremely insulated from the real world could believe what you just quoted. The number of bullshit jobs is always small; first level managers manage a team of people. You have mid level managers managing several managers, etc, but the frontline workers always vastly outnumber management, even in bloated organizations. And yeah, people should justify their existence by contributing to society. Dismissing that idea off-hand is absurd.
- kwhitefoot 3y ago> people should justify their existence by contributing to society. So what are your intentions regarding those who won't or can't satisfy your criteria for contributing?
- grumple 3y agoWhy is your response to "everyone should contribute to society" basically an accusation? Obviously I mean everyone who is capable of doing so. Those who are capable but unwilling? I wish them luck, but they are owed nothing by the rest of us.
- imtringued 3y agoThe thing is, if you have growing productivity but a stagnant population, either everyone works less hours or some people work and others don't work at all. So economists say we should grow the economy so everyone has enough busy work. Whether that growth is actually necessary or not doesn't matter.
- sublinear 3y agoI think the idea is to use humans and robots to make progress, not be complacent with existing jobs. There's always more work to be done. There will always be details discovered that are not automated yet. There will always be new topics unexplored that robots have not been built for yet. A general purpose robot is by definition a "jack of all trades" compromise that cannot do what specialized humans do first. This need for humans to explore is where all the progress and all the money is, and how you fight off both the bullshit jobs and AI taking our jobs.
- marcusverus 3y agoFrankly there is no surer sign that the opponents of "the system" are running out of material than this god-awful "bullshit jobs" argument. We are not going to restructure our economy and raise other people's taxes to spare anyone the first-world problem of having a lame job.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoThe problem we have is that the people who still have to work in order to keep the robots on etc won't want to pay for the scum people to have 15 children
- dudeinhawaii 3y agoWhenever I consider the UBI and "bullshit jobs" arguments, I end up thinking about jobs that we might need but don't inherently create economic value. In a society where we reward jobs that "create value" and have everyone else on UBI, who manages the country, who fights the wars, who modernizes the military? Perhaps these roles are also relics of the past which should fade away. Is being a lawyer a job that creates value or one that exists solely due to the necessities of a flawed system? As tech enthusiasts, we often envision a Star Trek future where all value originates from science and technology, and everyone else has to justify their existence. To some extent, I understand this view, but it will never fully materialize. Any practical system will be shaped by its current participants: politicians, governments, etc. So, by definition, "bullshit jobs" will be recognized as respectable in any system designed by humanity. In fact, they will be enshrined as the elite class, and then the entire utopia morphs into a mirror of our existing society. Those at the top remain entrenched indefinitely, while those at the bottom are viewed as providing no value—except now, this perception might be closer to the truth.
- aatd86 3y agoEveryone will be athlete, entertainers, artists, caregivers, blue-collars while robots are not very high-dexterity, doctors and nurse, scientists, deep space explorers... And what not. The end of white-collars.
- refurb 3y agoWe must do away with the absolutely specious notion that everybody has to earn a living. It is a fact today that one in ten thousand of us can make a technological breakthrough capable of supporting all the rest This comment misses the alternative - continue working and produce even more. No, not more production for things like cars or other consumer items - more production to pay for things like social benefits, better healthcare, etc.