8 ms·
Horrifying numbers of Americans will not make it to old age
- rcarr 3y agoAs someone from the UK, this line stood out: Managers at Buc-ee’s, a Texas-based chain of stores, can make more than experienced doctors earn in Britain.
- throwawaysleep 3y agoA Buc-ees probably has 400 or so employees? The typical CEO of a 400 person company would outearn a doctor even here.
- rcarr 3y agoIf you personally needed a life saving operation, would you want your doctor to be paid more or less than a convenience store manager?
- bagacrap 3y agoOn the other side of the globe? I guess that wouldn't cross my mind. I do like the idea that there are well paid jobs that don't require many years of schooling. Seems good for social mobility.
- rcarr 3y ago> On the other side of the globe? I guess that wouldn't cross my mind. Everything is interconnected. If your country is the only one on the planet that is doing well, it will not be long until resentments start brewing. If inequality stretches too far, eventually it results in instability. You can see this now with the amount of people immigrating to richer countries, both legally and illegally, and the resulting instability it causes, both in the countries that people immigrate to and those that they have left. Taken to the extreme, it eventually leads to wars between countries over resources. The United States might have the biggest military in the world, but it can't win a war against the rest of the world combined. This is why Joe Biden came out and said that it wasn't the United States economy that worried him, but the economical weakness in the rest of the world. If people think that the United States prints money only to look after the interests of the United States, it will lose its status as the reserve currency of the world. This is already starting to happen, with China making strong inroads in Africa and Latin America with disgruntled countries that have been left behind. If America loses influence in these countries, it's power diminishes and it will only be a matter of time until it is your doctors who are being paid less than convenience store managers in foreign countries. You might not be alive to see it, but your grandchildren might be. It was only 90 years ago that it was the UK and not the United States that was the dominant world power. Ray Dalio is quite insightful on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xguam0TKMw8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xguam0TKMw8 > I do like the idea that there are well paid jobs that don't require many years of schooling. Seems good for social mobility. Only if those jobs require a similar amount of years of experience to attain. Otherwise people stop pursuing the jobs that require many years of education in favour of earning more money in those that don't and your systems start to collapse as everyone chases the easy money.[1] As Dalio explains in the video above, it is investment in education which is the first step for those countries that begin to ascend and grow. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/may/08/nhs-staff-quitting-to-work-in-supermarkets-because-of-poor-pay https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/may/08/nhs-staff-qu...
- bagacrap 3y agoSo the UK was a dominant power 90 years ago and now it's a minor player, meanwhile the US is dominating... but yeah, it's the US that's got capitalism wrong. Okay. Perhaps it's your socialized medicine that is causing doctors to be commoditized and undervalued.
- rcarr 3y agoHow did the UK lose its status as dominant power? By being involved in two costly wars within the space of 30 years that, even though it won, left it essentially bankrupt. The US has already been involved in Afghanistan and Iraq, it has an incredible amount of debt, it has domestic problems and it’s now spending an increasingly large sum of money on the Ukraine Russia war. If China decides to kick off in Taiwan and the US gets involved in that one too then, even if the US ended up winning, it could very well be in so much debt that, like the UK, it is superseded by an emerging power. In this scenario, China would be depleted from the loss and it would likely be India that took the mantle as the emergent superpower.
- HybridCurve 3y agoApples to oranges comparison. We know the healthcare system in Britain has been suffering from neglect for some time and AFAIK doctors often either work for the NHS or are independently contracted by them. Also, while Buc-ees technically a convenience store, it also a gas station (they held the record as the world largest with 120 gas pumps)with a large deli, tons of groceries, and the cleanest bathrooms you will ever find off the highway. They do a lot of business and have a large team of of very busy workers. Their income is well earned. That said, healthcare workers are very underpaid in Britain and have been for some time, but it's not fair to compare the incomes while trying to diminutize Buc-ees by simply labelling it as "convenience store".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sneed_chucker 3y agoDefinitely not. A Buc-ees is essentially an overgrown gas station and convenience store, but it's smaller than an American super market. I'd be surprised if a single Buc-ees location had 100 employees, let alone 400.
- paxys 3y agoThe median wage for doctors in the UK is around £50K/yr, so this is not at all surprising.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoWhy would anyone do such a stressful job for that money? Especially now that education is so costly. I made more than that as an electronics engineer, and later as a software developer, and I was able to go home every single day of my career knowing for certain that nothing I did or didn't do had killed anyone.
- nemo 3y agoJust for a little more context on why this is, Buc-ee’s is a gigantic operation. They're major truck stops with super-massive gas stations, tons of parking, and very large stores with a wide variety of stock including a lot of food. At any given point during the day they could easily have a hundred customers on premises gassing up or at a store. Managing that operation is not like managing a typical roadside gas station/store.
- badcppdev 3y agohttps://archive.is/31aZA https://archive.is/31aZA
- Tiktaalik 3y agoThe increased deaths related to obesity and car crashes have a common cause: severe car dependency in the USA. As other countries (ie. france cited in the article) move further away from car dependency they are accordingly seeing improvements.
- rcarr 3y agoVisiting Venice was magical for me for many reasons. One of those was the complete lack of cars. It was truly blissful.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoHow did you get there?
- rcarr 3y agoTeleported
- generalenvelope 3y agoI think the social ramifications of car dependence are overlooked. US loves its freedom but in many ways cars make people much less free by taking away their free time, money, social interaction, physical activity, etc. It's incredible how expensive car infrastructure is, which increases taxes to an often unsustainable level (and poorer people not living in the sprawl of single family homes end up subsidizing). Paving everything looks disgusting and is bad for the environment and economy. Not to mention minimum parking laws' contribution to the housing crisis, or the trauma caused by ~40,000 deaths per year due to cars (not to mention all the other injuries). It's not hard to see why this sort of lifestyle could damage your health. I hope we can get more deep dives on this topic as you mentioned because there are millions of people that would use viable alternatives. These would carry over to QOL improvements for everyone else too.
- local_issues 3y agoAs the resident HN conservative, I wish the GOP would embrace bikes as a symbol of freedom. Cars are NOT tools of freedom - you are at the whim of gigacorporations and authoritarian governments like Iran. With a bike, you move through the world, on extremely low cost infrastructure, while becoming a Fit Western Man and through Self Reliance. You don't need subsidies, you just need a bit of Strength and Forethought and all those other conservative goals.
- hinkley 3y agoWe are relearning a lesson from 100 years ago which is that the act of putting your name on a product enters you into a social contract where adulterated products lead to an unprofitable loss of status. It’s a form of mutually assured destruction. If we finished decriminalizing the “alcohol tier” drugs and allowed for national brands, instead of a mosaic of companies who cannot legally transport product across state lines, then we would have a real alternative for people who think their highest priority is to check out of life for a while. For the people who want to check out as long as possible/forever, they already need loads of therapy. And legalizing or criminalizing activities they like to repeat doesn’t change that. You take your average severely depressed person, who may describe themselves as too much of a coward to end it all. Now threaten them with ruining the rest of their life? I have news for you, most of them already believe their life is ruined. Putting yourself in harm’s way to feel something is a terrible existence, and I think the people who describe it as slow suicide are not wrong. I also worry sometimes about adrenaline junkies. You can’t outlaw self destruction. What threat can you possibly make that will have any import? You can outlaw reckless endangerment.
- legitster 3y ago> For an explanation, a look at America’s geography is revealing [...] the national trend of stagnant life expectancy reveals huge regional variation (see map). In a place like Hazard, in eastern Kentucky, life expectancy is lower now than it was in 1980. In a place like Manhattan, or some wealthier counties of Colorado, it has increased by not much less than anywhere in Europe. If you actually look at the map, it's pretty clear that geography is the biggest factor. The rural lifestyle is killing people - poverty, the amount of time spent in a car, the boredom.
- alephnerd 3y agoThe meth and opioid crisis hit rural regions much more significantly than urban areas. It's also interesting that they point out 1980 vs 2023. Pre-Globalization, those rural areas used to have factories that by the 90s began leaving for Canada+Mexico and by the 2000s for China. Vast swathes of America's rural hinterland effectively deindustrialized, leaving rural residents economically disenfranchised
- allturtles 3y agoSame with mines, which is what the Hazard, Kentucky economy was built around. This is not just an economic crisis but also a crisis of meaning. The mines and factories provided stable, decently paying jobs. People could feel they had a place in the world and see a future for their children. Now what? I fear that the college-graduate white-collar work that has provided meaning, stability, and economic sustenance for most of us on this site is headed for a similar pass with AI.
- alephnerd 3y ago> This is not just an economic crisis but also a crisis of meaning. The mines and factories provided stable, decently paying jobs. People could feel they had a place in the world and see a future for their children. Now what? Exactly! When people don't see a future they either despair (ie. Hit the bottle or meth) or rage (ie. Political polarization and extremism). > I fear that the college-graduate white-collar work that has provided meaning, stability, and economic sustenance for most of us on this site is headed for a similar pass with AI Already started happening in certain segments of tech. If you work in Cybersecurity, Infrastructure, or Cloud the talent base across the board doesn't exist in the US anymore - it's mostly in Israel and India now. Similar shifts are going to happen over the next few years now that 1. Plenty of US trained and educated H1Bs are forced to return to India and China 2. Remote work is normalized 3. Colleges don't teach much aside from leetcode and some fullstack development now. Accounting, back office, marketing, communications, and administrative roles have already been outsourced or automated
- b59831 3y ago[dead]
- Tiktaalik 3y ago> Nearly 4,000 people died in fires, the highest number in close to 20 years, making for a death rate of nearly twice that of western Europe. This seems particularly damning considering that in the name of fire safety, the USA (and Canada) goes to the effort to build two stairways in apartment buildings, which makes them harder to build, and compromises the design in making them subjectively worse to live in. Europe does not do this extra safety step, which benefits their housing, and yet they have fewer fire deaths.
- legitster 3y agoA lot of these fire deaths are not happening in modern up-to-code houses. They are happening in older "grandfathered" buildings or trailer homes.
- snowpid 3y agoI can assure you that most fires in European buildings don't happen in " modern up-to-code houses ".
- nemo44x 3y agoThere's a difference though. Old homes in the USA are often made from timber and don't have fire retardants like insulation, drywall (instead they have plaster and lath which is more flammable than drywall), etc. Plus the wood is very old (but very high quality!) which means it's very dry which means it goes up quickly. And with no insulation it spreads really quickly. Plus a lot of older homes haven't been brought up to date with new hardwired fire alarms, modern electric, etc.
- hotpotamus 3y agoAnother quirk of American home building history is "balloon framing" that used long, continuous studs for the exterior walls that could rapidly channel fires between walls. The modern method is called "stick framing" where floors are essentially stacked up which creates fire breaks. So not all wood construction methods are equal where fire safety is concerned. Modern homes will certainly burn, but you should have a reasonable amount of time to escape at least.
- thinkingkong 3y agoIt might be too much of an extrapolation but theres quite an odd cultural phenomenon around death in north america. It almost feels as though people think you deserve to die if you’re poor, get sick, dont currently have benefits, etc. There’s a massive for profit institution obsessed with extracting maximim value from you before you die. If you do, it was your responsibility anyway. We dont really care about people living, or their quality of life. We care about the metrics sureounding those things, and gaming them to the maximum extent permitted by law.
- grecy 3y ago> around death in north america I would just like to clarify - Canada is in North America and it is nothing like you describe above. Actually it's quite the opposite, our healthcare means we're literally all-in to help each other. You're talking about the United States, not "North America"
- nemo44x 3y agoCanada actively promotes suicide.
- grecy 3y agoI've been living here 15 years, and my partner works in healthcare. I've never once heard of suicide being "promoted". If you mean that assisted suicide is legal in Canada under very strict circumstances for terminally ill people, then yes, that is correct. It's legal in multiple developed countries around the world. Personally, after watching my Mum be eaten alive by Cancer that spread from her lungs to her bones to all her organs, I think it's merciful and much needed.
- nemo44x 3y agoThey aren’t strict at all and pretty much anyone that wants it can get it. https://apnews.com/article/covid-science-health-toronto-7c631558a457188d2bd2b5cfd360a867 https://apnews.com/article/covid-science-health-toronto-7c63... > Disability experts say the story is not unique in Canada, which arguably has the world’s most permissive euthanasia rules — allowing people with serious disabilities to choose to be killed in the absence of any other medical issue Absolutely disgusting and barbaric.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoVictims of outsourcing and the winner take all economy championed by wall st.
- racked 3y agoHow is it horrifying? The world could do with less of us parasites. Every time I read articles like these, taking about obesity death rates and such, I think: so? We overconsume. There are limits.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwaway5959 3y agoWow, never seen someone call obese people parasites before.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoThe parasites word referred to us, including the writer.
- racked 3y agoJump to conclusions much?
- nemo 3y agoThis is pretty much a Social Darwinist PoV. Blaming systemic issues on individuals supports toxic systems. Sure, people can make better choices, but the choices they're offered don't appear in a vacuum.
- grecy 3y agoMy partner and I are expecting our first baby, and we were looking at stats. Mothers-to-be in the US are much more likely to die in childbirth than in any other developed country. [1] When it comes to healthcare outcomes, the US is comparable to Latvia and Chile, not developed nations. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1240400/maternal-mortality-rates-worldwide-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1240400/maternal-mortali...
- chmod775 3y agoI'd expect the outcomes in hospitals to be about the same. It's just that Americans avoid those for obvious reasons. I highly recommend that you or your partner give birth surrounded by professionals, as well as getting check-ups done before - even if those professionals are expensive.
- 1270018080 3y agoAnd homeless people should just buy a house
- thenerdhead 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iatrogenesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iatrogenesis
- x3iv130f 3y agoThe average in the US are heavily affected by obese African American women with diabetes lacking a highschool education. It's a societal issue more than a healthcare issue.
- 1270018080 3y agoThe mortality rate is still 10x higher for white women in the US than the average in western europe.
- nemo44x 3y agoThere's lies, damned lies, and statistics. You need to interpret these stats. America is a very broad place with a lot of different types of people. We have millions of people that refuse to accept medicine due to religious reasons. Similar to beliefs around birthing children. There are more weirdo's here than anywhere else. This works in America's favor in many ways but is negative in many ways too. If you're a normal person you don't have to worry. Subtract the weirdo's from the datasets and outcomes are fantastic. The same thing with all these other health and life expectancy numbers. If you're normal, avoid obesity, don't smoke or do drugs and avoid a variety of high risk behaviors, and visit your doctor then you're likely to live a long life.
- at_a_remove 3y agoNo offense to anyone who is all "yay, life!" but as people learn more, as the blinders fall off, as we are encouraged to question tradition and establishment, what we see at the end of the line doesn't look great. Miserable health if you make it to retirement, disposable marriages, your social institutions crumble. Forget the church and the Elks lodge, we can't even keep bowling leagues and book clubs together. Life starts seeming absurd and has for a long time. Think of that bit in Con Air, where the too-aware serial killer says ""What if I told you insane was working fifty hours a week in some office for fifty years, at the end of which they tell you to piss off? Ending up in some retirement village, hoping to die before suffering the indignity of trying to make it to the toilet on time." Everything has been first chisled, then jackhammered, and finally bulldozed away. No rocks to fall on us and hide us from the grim end of Terror Management Theory, no sense in planting a tree which we might never sit in the shade of if it will be scorched to a stick in some kind of global warming furnace. We ought not to be surprised, then, if so many elect to reach for non-thought, for entertainment and distraction, because staring into the abyss can get old. We used to have protections, elaborate and impermeable to questioning, which protected us from seeing how unappealing the inevitable decline and end can really be.
- thenerdhead 3y agoIt is possible to find meaning in the absurd. That is what Camus and other nihilists propose. We have sadly lost our values as people. We don’t value community in the same way as it was before the internet for example. We should not give into despair, although many already have.
- at_a_remove 3y agoNot exactly. It was proposed that we assign meaning. It is not there to be found. Unless you are a virtuoso of self-deception, you will be aware that you have arbitrarily assigned meaning. It is no less hollow than an atheist with a communion wafer. That is the crux of my point: all of the constructs we had, including whimsy and distraction, become reduced to so much translucent -- at best -- mist once we're aware.