7 ms·
It is bizarre, beyond bizarre, that these people keep focusing in on Trump's flamboyant habit of lying. His opponents lied. Everyone in politics lies. Why there
by roenxi 3y ago
It is bizarre, beyond bizarre, that these people keep focusing in on Trump's flamboyant habit of lying. His opponents lied. Everyone in politics lies. Why there is this expectation that people will stop supporting Trump because he lies is beyond a mystery. Are Huppert and Levine proposing that they vote for honest politicians? Where are they supposed to find them?
Your options are to vote for politicians who never say anything of substance, or vote for people who are habitual liars. I'm glad we're realistic about Trump telling lies, but please can we also focus on the lies like the claims there was no spying apparatus, that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction or that the US economy was strong going in to all the major recessions? The difference between Trump and that is that Trump's lies didn't end up having much in the way of consequences.
- actionfromafar 3y agoWell, at least Nixon had some consequences. I feel like, in the past the liars at least tried to delay the exposure of the lie. And “plausible deniability” came from that environment. Trump implemented a new tactic of “carpet bombing” of lies. I don’t know which is worse for society, really, but it’s different. Maybe one paved the ground for the other.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoTrump is worse. It's one thing to lie, and try desperately to cover up the lie and not get caught. It's much worse to lie so blatantly and frequently that people give up even trying to expose and refute all your lies. It's worse because it's more corrosive to the moral fiber (and even sanity) of the population. It is not healthy to continually bathe in lies. You can lose track of reality.
- fabian2k 3y agoThere is still a very large and fundamental difference between the kind of election promise breaking you expect from most politicians and what Trump did. He was constantly lying about everything and denying reality. That is not how all politicians behave.
- roenxi 3y agoThe US government has a history - a long, storied and very visible history - of moving armies around killing people for stupid reasons. Partly because of special interest lobbying by the military industrial complex, partly because they are oblivious to the destruction and it is convenient to them politically. Afghanistan alone was multiple trillions of dollars. The cost in lives was higher than that. That type of reality denying - which goes beyond any one politician and highlights the rot of the entire apparatus is much more concerning than Trump. That is how the majority of politicians behave. And, hot take, Trump probably would have pushed against starting those wars if that recording they're trying to convict him with [0] is any evidence. There is a pretty good chance that is why the entrenched players are so keen to get rid of him in fact. The powers in Washington clearly have no problem with liars because a lot of them keep happily plugging away. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPyua_6ht9Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPyua_6ht9Y
- lockhouse 3y agoI fail to see how that is different from our current President. I'm surprised when Biden actually says something truthful. He's still telling people that his son Beau died in a combat tour in Iraq, when he died from cancer in a hospital in the US.
- fabian2k 3y agoJoe Biden has said that the cancer was probably caused by the burn pits during the war. Which is plausible, though of course hard to substantiate. So attributing the death to the war is rather confusing and potentially misleading. But if this is the first thing you think about when claiming Biden is as bad as Trump in lying, I think it is obvious that this is nowhere near the same level.
- lockhouse 3y agoBiden has literally said Beau died in Iraq. Biden also said 150 million Americans were killed by guns. For context that’s almost half the US population. I can find egregious Joe Biden quotes and lies all day. He’s at least as much of a liar as Trump.
- true_religion 3y agoTo be honest, it’s not about Trump. It’s about the lying. For too long we have accepted that everyone lies in politics but when someone comes and carpet bombs the nation with lies and seems pleased with himself rather than ashamed, it’s time to put an end to the practice. Politicians must be held accountable to some standard or else we cannot still pretend to have a democracy.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoIt seems like a very fragile system if it relies on the day to day goodness of individuals and lacks mitigation against liars but gives them the power of authority anyhow. Like that setup wouldn’t pass the rigor of a devops 5 whys analysis - you wouldn’t say oh this one employee is just bad put a better one in their place, instead of actual systemic change. Instead you’d make sure individuals don’t have the power to mess up.
- cainxinth 3y ago> It is bizarre, beyond bizarre, that these people keep focusing in on Trump's flamboyant habit of lying. His opponents lied. Everyone in politics lies. “All baseball players hit baseballs. Why are we focused on Babe Ruth just because he hit more than most?”
- roenxi 3y agoThat is certainly a more reasonable analogy. What Trump does is outplay his opponents by using more interesting lies. They do a sort of ha-ha-I-technically-said trick where they lie but want to pretend they didn't. John Kerry is denying flying in a private jet because his wife was the one who owned it, not him and besides they sold it at some point [0]. Trump would just claim there is no jet, that he only travels by bicycle, that everyone knows he has the best jets and that the questioners were low energy. Then the fact checkers say Kerry was telling the truth. Cue the eye rolls from Trump voters - at least Trump is not trying to insult everyone's intelligence. He just up and lies in straightforward and entertaining fashion. Assuming the sentences parse enough to work out what he technically said. But at least there isn't some stupid game where we all have to pretend he was being honest. [0] https://fortune.com/2023/07/13/john-kerry-stupid-lie-private-jets-climate-change-house-republicans/ https://fortune.com/2023/07/13/john-kerry-stupid-lie-private...
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoAn entertaining liar. That... explains some things. But I think it's more than just being interesting/entertaining. I think Trump also tells lies that a large number of people want to believe. But this may be changing. Trump's lies aren't nearly as entertaining anymore. "I won in 2020" is like, "Really? You're still on that? Get some new material." "All these court cases are just incompetent people, jealousy, conspiracy, and election interference!" Yeah, right. You're saying the same thing over and over (as the court cases keep coming). It's been getting repetitive. There's nothing new there any more.
- lockhouse 3y agoExcept Trump didn’t lie more than most? There’s an old joke about it even: “How do you know when a politician is lying? When their lips are moving.” There are so many legitimate things to attack Trump on but it’s ridiculous to claim that he lies more than other politicians.
- gooseus 3y agoRead the latest indictment[1] and then find me another politician who has lied at anything approaching the scale and seriousness of Trump and his co-conspirators. At this point, in light of all of this evidence comprehensively laid out in relatively plain English, supporting or minimize what Trump has done (and attempted to do) is an admission of extreme ignorance, or malice. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/documents/8a7503af-fde7-4061-818c-7d7e0ee06036.pdf https://www.washingtonpost.com/documents/8a7503af-fde7-4061-...
- roenxi 3y agoWell, as mentioned, G. W. Bush was cheerleading an unwarranted invasion in Iraq and Obama oversaw a sweeping an likely unconstitutional omnisurveillence system. Both of those things are worse than asking people to do things that the Biden DoJ doesn't like. If someone could trade a 2nd Trump term for not sending the troops to Iraq that'd be a great deal for America. And depending on your authoritarian-libertarian leanings it'd be a good trade to get rid of the surveillance state too. At this point the Democratic establishment has a history of frivolous use of law to attack Trump. That indictment basically admits in point 3 that it is on shaky ground. The Democrats had their chance to hit Trump with the Russiagate investigation and came up with nothing. Then they started impeaching him to try and stop Biden's Ukraine dealings from coming to light. In light of that it seems unlikely that these lawsuits will prove serious allegations, even if they manage to get a lucky judge/jury combo and score a conviction. It is naked politics.
- gooseus 3y agoWhile GWB overthrowing an authoritarian government in Iraq on a lie is really bad, it does not rise to the level of overthrowing a liberal democracy in America on a lie. Yes, both were lies, but Bush barely had to lie at all to get the Congress to go along with it and one could make the case that he believed the lie himself. Not so with Trump, as the indictment makes clear. If you read the Mueller Report it's also clear the the "Russiagate" wasn't a hoax and this argument that the "Democrats had their chance to hit Trump" as if the fact that the impeachments clearly failed on a partisan basis and Barr misrepresented the findings in the Mueller Report, which were damning and would have been worth an indictment if not for the fact of Trump being the sitting President at the time. If you hate the American system and think the current liberal democracy deserves to be destroyed (for whatever reason) then you can just say so without pretending that Trump isn't a uniquely malignant liar beyond precedent.
- tzs 3y agoThe difference with Trump was summed up well in 2016 by conservative columnist and Cato Institute Fellow P.J. O'Rourke when he was a guest panelist on an episode of NPR's "Wait Wait...Don't Tell Me". Shocking everyone on the show, in the live audience, and listening on radio he announced he was endorsing Clinton, saying: > I have a little announcement to make ... I'm voting for Hillary. I am endorsing Hillary. I am endorsing Hillary, and all her lies and all her empty promises. It's the second-worst thing that can happen to this country, but she's way behind in second place. She's wrong about absolutely everything, but she's wrong within normal parameters.
- tootie 3y agoWhen you talk about inexplicable voter behavior, Trump is at the top of my list by a mile. I'd say Bush was worse in terms of outcomes, but you could at least understand how mania over terrorism lead to a lot of bad decisions. I actually think most of the Bush admin believed they were doing the right things and not lying at all. Trump is a whole different beast. He lies like he breaths. Makes up facts that aren't even relevant. Says things in direct opposition to observable reality. Denies saying things he said on camera a week earlier. His hand-modified hurricane map was both trite and shocking at the same time. I personally do not understand his appeal to anyone at all and would love for a political scientist to tell me something new.