3 ms·
Modern architecture is individualism run amok. Buildings are more testaments to architects’ egos than organic improvements to the surrounding environment, or so
by rayiner 3y ago
Modern architecture is individualism run amok. Buildings are more testaments to architects’ egos than organic improvements to the surrounding environment, or sources of aesthetic pleasure to passers by.
- Perceval 3y agoMost of the pioneering modernist architects were socialists—not a lot of ideological overlap with individualism run amok.
- constantcrying 3y agoThey were western socialists. Have you seen stalinist architecture, it is almost neo-classical compared to modernist architecture...
- eej71 3y agoWhile spoken by a fictional character, I believe this is a good way to view what architecture should be. "A building has integrity, just as a man and just as seldom! It must be true to its own idea, have its own form, and serve its own purpose!" Would that produce an architectural style run amok? I don't think so. But I believe the view point described there would be described as individualism.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Modern architecture is individualism run amok. I don't see much individualism in modern architecture, though. All these modern buildings tend to look the same. Ugly and depressing.
- thih9 3y agoThere’s also practicality. E.g. in the first set of pictures, the rejected “modern” one featured balconies, and perhaps a garden level in the middle (based on the amount of plants). Responding to modern needs with modern solutions might be easier without having to match the traditional style.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat art can't you say that about?
- xyzzyz 3y agoIt’s very easy to avoid seeing or paying for modern “art”, not so easy with modern buildings.
- Knee_Pain 3y agoWhich buildings of any era have you been able to unsee? Can you teach us this technique?
- xyzzyz 3y agoNone, that’s what I meant by “not so easy” (just in case you missed the mild sarcasm, and took my comment to literally mean that it’s not easy but still doable to not see ugly buildings).
- tptacek 3y agoIronically, one of the major themes of modern(ist) architecture is eliminating ornamentation and focusing solely on the hierarchy of spaces buildings create and what their uses are. "Form follows function" comes from modern architecture. (Not all of it is successful! And like, it's hard to say Calatrava is about that. But we hear more about the failures than the successes in modern architecture, and conversely less about the failures of classical architecture, b/c survivorship bias.)
- kasey_junk 3y agoIt’s literally the opposite of that. It was embracing fabrication over craft creation. It was prioritizing local placement and the uses of the structure over the sentiments of the architect. It’s possible that _you_ don’t like the resulting aesthetic but that’s not some broader statement about modern architecture, it’s literally your personal preference.
- yowzadave 3y agoMaybe the problem is that the egos are too small--if they REALLY had an ego, they'd build a massive monument to their own memory, like the Great Pyramid or the Taj Mahal, and it'd become forever celebrated as a monumental human achievement.