4 ms·
> You have no natural right to a profit at other's expense Another thing is that the stock market doesn't work here. It promotes shortsighted trading without a
by amelius 3y ago
> You have no natural right to a profit at other's expense
Another thing is that the stock market doesn't work here. It promotes shortsighted trading without an eye for long term side effects. In principle shareholders should be accountable too. If you owned stocks of a company that caused damage during the period when that damage occurred, you should be accountable and at least you should not be able to profit from it. The stock market should be retrofitted with an accountability system. This is the only way shareholders will start caring about our future.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoProjecting your wants onto power aside, why would this ever happen? What would drive our government to do that? If there's no incentive, it's empty desire or based on some fantasy that government would suddenly operate in terms of what's best for society rather than a serious consideration of how power works. Why look to government to do that? Are examples of government pollution controls effective, or examples of greenwashing? For instance a lot of the Quebec forests that burned already contributed to those CO2 offsets by having someone say they wouldn't burn them, and yet...
- amelius 3y agoGovernments are implementing accounting mechanisms for CO2 emissions too, e.g. CO2 certificates, CO2 tax. So why not think of other accounting systems that can help make people accountable for their actions? Plus, I like to think that IT can save the world :)
- wahnfrieden 3y agoThe problems caused by power and hierarchy aren't solved by dreaming up rules for them to follow
- gruez 3y ago>Another thing is that the stock market doesn't work here. It promotes shortsighted trading without an eye for long term side effects. You assert this without elaboration. What makes you think that? Maybe the average wall st trading firm doesn't care, but institutional investors (eg. pension funds, university endowments, family offices, sovereign wealth funds) would very much care if their holdings go up in smoke a few decades from now.
- amelius 3y agoI feel like it's kinda obvious that the burden of proof is not on me here, so I'm not going to explain it further, sorry.
- memefrog 3y agoIt is very obvious to me that it is on you.
- toss1 3y ago>>would very much care if their holdings go up in smoke a few decades from now. Nope Any fund has nearly constant review of their holdings (and certainly scheduled periodic reviews), which would highlight issues with any of their holdings. Moreover, there are many hedging strategies. It isn't like companies with these kinds of externalized risks go poof in a minute. The problems, especially legal liability, become evident over the course of years, and the funds can an do adjust to not take the losses. Anything less would be a breach of their fiduciary duty to their shareholders/investors.
- lokar 3y agoThe issue is not the public stock corporation, it is the entire class of limited liability entities. It allows a one sided bet. Things go well, I’m rich. They go very very badly all I can loose is my investment.
- nokcha 3y agoMost individual shareholders (especially those who just buy index funds) have neither knowledge of corporate wrongdoings nor, in practice, power to prevent them. A better model would be holding accountable the particular individuals with power and responsibility, such as in the Volkswagen emissions case where Germany criminally prosecuted executives involved in the fraud.
- loa_in_ 3y agoWhy kick the can. Index funds are operated by someone, right?
- mrguyorama 3y agoI don't care. If you want to get %5 yearly gains from stocks, then fucking educate yourself on your investments. If that's too much effort for the average person, maybe we shouldn't design our economy around requiring the average person to basically gamble with their income to hopefully have a nest egg for retirement.