8 ms·
I used a Xerox 1108 Lisp Machine from about 1982 through 1989 - a great developer experience, and not a bad platform to sell software products on. That said, I
by mark_l_watson 15y ago
I used a Xerox 1108 Lisp Machine from about 1982 through 1989 - a great developer experience, and not a bad platform to sell software products on.
That said, I encourage people who want to hack/learn Lisp to stick with one of the modern setups like: Common Lisp (with Emacs or a complete free IDE setup like ClozureCL), Clojure (with Emacs or other IDE), Racket, or, ...., etc.
I would much rather see people spend time learning a Lisp language rather than fiddling with very old environments.
- jf 15y agoWhile I agree with you in principle on not "fiddling with very old environments", I had to try out Genera after hearing from two separate people that Lisp Machines were the best computers they ever used. One guy was a VP at Yahoo. The other guy is a core contributor to the Java VM. Both of these guys are hardcore Emacs users, running Mac OS X, and have in-depth knowledge of POSIX. It was hard for me to write them off as people who just didn't understand how modern computers work. Fiddling with Genera has been a very worthwhile endeavor because of how much I've learned from it. What have I learned? Well, so far I've learned that Genera is basically a case study showing that Richard Stallman's fears were actually well founded. I also learned a tremendous amount about an important but obscure part of the history of computing, a history that I think is actually a vision of what our future is. So, yes, by all means, hack on and learn on one of the modern setups that Mark suggests above. Once you've done that, look me up and I'd be more than happy to give you a tour of Genera on my MacIvory.
- masklinn 15y ago> What have I learned? Well, so far I've learned that Genera is basically a case study showing what Richard Stallman's fears were actually well founded. Could you expand on that?
- jf 15y agoSure! This is actually a good reminder that I should write something more in-depth on this topic, since most of what I think I know is based in large parts on oral-history with some conjecture. Lisp Machines started at MIT, some of that code is actually available online now (http://www.heeltoe.com/retro/mit/mit_cadr_lmss.html http://www.heeltoe.com/retro/mit/mit_cadr_lmss.html). That software became the basis of two companies: Symbolics and then later, Lisp Machines Inc (LMI). This Wikipedia entry does a good job at explaining the impact this part of history had on RMS: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisp_Machines#Folklore_about_LMI http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisp_Machines#Folklore_about_LM... So, here is where the history of Genera is non-existent or murky. Yes, you can download a torrent of Genera. But how do you obtain a legal license Genera? Who actually owns the IP to Genera? In learning the answers to those questions, I was left with even more respect for RMS and an amusing, if not ironic, anecdote showing how his vision for the future turned out to be correct. > How do you obtain a legal license Genera? You purchase a copy of Open Genera for the DEC Alpha for $5000 from David Schmidt. > Who actually owns the IP to Genera? John Mallery (http://www.csail.mit.edu/user/926 http://www.csail.mit.edu/user/926). He's the most recent owner. Before he got the IP, it was owned by a series of law firms and ex-Symbolics employees. Why do I find this this amusing? Well, the software that RMS worked so hard to protect and that ultimately helped "inspire" him to start GNU has been relegated to the footnotes of history. Meanwhile, GNU software is used on millions of machines.
- rdl 15y agoI wonder how much of a community bounty it would take for John Mallery to open source it.
- jf 15y agoI tried to contact him to ask that exact question. He didn't answer my email. I've thought of just calling him. But I'm intimidated of him to be honest. He wrote the webserver that ran whitehouse.gov during the Clinton administration, I can barely program in Lisp.
- rdl 15y agoMaybe getting an AI lab person to do it (early Akamaite or maybe a MIT faculty member?) would be helpful.
- tomjen3 15y agoWhat is the worst thing that can happen? I know they are called Lisp ninjas, but they are 40-50-60 year old guys with neck beards...
- rdl 15y agoI think "ignoring it due to being overworked or misaddressed" is the most likely -- and if it's either, try fedex/ups mailing a physical item (like a book or other gift, or food, or whatever -- something which doesn't fit in an envelope, and which is obviously nice enough that 1) dude feels guilt if he doesn't respond and 2) intermediaries will try to pass it along. I've used this trick quite successfully ($20-50 items from appropriate gift vendors -- Cabelas for outdoor type people, gourmet food vendors for other people). It's like the next-level of conference schwag.
- jf 15y agoYou're probably right. I'll bet I'm over thinking this. I like the idea of sending him something nice. I'll do that.
- maaku 15y ago> I also learned a tremendous amount about an important but obscure part of the history of computing, a history that I think is actually a vision of what our future is. Could you expand on that as well?
- jf 15y agoReading the rant from John Rose in the preface to THE UNIX-HATERS Handbook [1] was pretty eye-opening to me. The world that John is complaining about is the world that I've spent many years living in, quite happily too! How is it that we lost the ability to fix the code to a program that crashed, then continue running the program from where it left off? Why aren't all of our tools self-documenting? Etc, etc. I've spent quite a bit of time wondering why we've "lost" so much. I think that part of the problem is that technology was developed a rate faster than what most people could keep up with. I remember that early Macs had a game to teach people how to use the mouse! Also, before the internet, it was hard for to transmit software and information about it. So, the way I view the world of technology now is that we haven't "lost" anything, we're just catching up with the past. And doing a better job of it too! In many ways, I think that the capabilities of "HTML5" (HTML/CSS/JavaScript) are converging on the capabilities of the X Window system. The main difference that I can see is that "HTML5" requires about 2-4 inches of book to understand while the X Windows System required a couple of feet of book to understand. I'm not sure if my view of us just needing to catch up with the past is correct, but it's been pretty useful to me. Now, instead of bemoaning things that are lost, I look forward to seeing those things again, in a form that is easier to understand. More "pure" if you will. I'm looking forward to the day when I can edit any part of my OS or applications, live, while they are running. I'm looking forward to being able to fix a program that has crashed and then have it continue running. I enjoy using interactive debuggers and I'm looking forward to seeing them in more languages. I love using REPLs to learn new languages and for doing quick prototyping. That's why I'm watching JavaScript with interest. Many people are doing things with JavaScript that we were doing with Lisp Machines before. Some people are able to edit their server-side JavaScript live. Many of us know that our web browser has a built-in JavaScript REPL, some of us use that to fix webpages that other people wrote. In short. After spending a lot of time reading, talking about, and using Lisp Machines, I feel like I have a deeper understanding of what William Gibson meant when he said "The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed." Footnote: 1: http://www.cs.washington.edu/homes/weise/preface.html http://www.cs.washington.edu/homes/weise/preface.html
- javascriptlol 15y ago>It was hard for me to write them off as people who just didn't understand how modern computers work. I'm glad you didn't fall for that trap. Software engineers constantly make excuses for doing things in idiotic ways. Almost nothing I use really works anymore. It just "kind of" works most of the time. Look at your average web applicaton and the ridiculous resources it takes to get the thing up on the screen and interacting with the user. We've become addicted to high powered machines and finding more complex and inefficient ways of doing the same things.
- jf 15y ago> I'm glad you didn't fall for that trap. Well, maybe I'm not in that trap now, but I was for a long time. > Almost nothing I use really works anymore. I'm hoping that I can hide from that inside the Emacs monastery. That didn't seem to work for jwz though, so I'm not sure if there's a way to avoid having to update my silly software several times a decade.
- gaius 15y agoAbsolutely agree. I was playing with a BBC Micro last night, 2Mhz processor and 52k RAM (shadow RAM card fitted, and 16k sideways RAM - this is a beast of a machine!). Then I did some stuff on my 2x2.4Ghz, 4G RAM Mac, and I almost punched the damn thing in frustration, 2000x "faster" and it can't even keep up with my typing! We need to take it back to the old skool.
- socially-distnt 15y agoJFC! I've been going through this at work today - the developers of a third-paty app designed the app for low utilization companies - our company is a bad fit for this software. We're in the top 500, and our usage patterns expose every scalability flaw in this software...
- jpdoctor 15y ago> rather than fiddling with very old environments. I worked on Symbolics machines (rms, please forgive me). I even fixed a bunch of the wire-wrapped original LMs from before Symbolics. I remember it being earth-shattering at the time (self-documenting? whoa) but I confess I'm curious how much was just the transition from TOPS-20 etc to a completely new single-user environment. All stuff from the dark ages really. I'd probably fire it up out of nostalgia if nothing else. BTW: Dan Weinreb's post ("Why did symbolics fail?" linked in the OP) has migrated to here: http://danweinreb.org/blog/why-did-symbolics-fail http://danweinreb.org/blog/why-did-symbolics-fail
- jf 15y agoI'm 29. The first used Genera a few years ago. The "Help" button the Symbolics machines blew me away. I've used software with great built-in help. It's impressive to see it system-wide. Another thing that I still find really impressive is how (aside from the bootloader) all of Genera is written in Lisp and can be edited, live, while the system is running. A lot of the things that I see people doing with JavaScript feel very familiar. It's exciting to see how the things that people are doing with JavaScript are approaching the capabilities of Genera, but in a way that will be much more accessible to the "kids these days".
- javascriptlol 15y agoI don't see the connection between Lisp machines and JavaScript. JavaScript (in the browser at least) is a heavy-weight C++ system utilising huge amounts of library and operating system code with some weak scripting capabilities a the bottom. What relation does that have to Lisp machines or Smalltalk type environments where everything is built in a simple an transparent manner?
- jf 15y agoYou're right, it's a weak connection right now. I could be wrong, but I'm seeing JavaScript getting pushed "down" the stack. People are doing things like implementing the DOM in pure JavaScript. I'm also very interested in seeing what people are doing with Emscripten, ClojureScript, swank-js, and the like. Yes, we don't have a Lisp or Smalltalk like environment for JavaScript. Not yet. Given how widely supported JavaScript is though, I could see us getting there organically? Not sure.
- ChuckMcM 15y ago"I would much rather see people spend time learning a Lisp language rather than fiddling with very old environments." As a general rule learning is better than repeating, however there is value in those old environments. Primarily for a long time software was getting more complex than hardware could support and so there are a lot of adaptations that were made in 'old environments' to support better performance on under-performant hardware. As we enter the 'post PC' era and get a wider spread of machine capabilities in the market place, it is always useful to have a few 'tricks' in your pocket for getting better performance out of your system. Knowing that you got those tricks from systems that are now > 20 years old provides a pretty good patent defense if you get trolled. Especially if you can show that you, being reasonably skilled in the art, learned to do what you did using exemplars that are greater than 20 yrs old. That is a strong case for prior art.
- EdwardCoffin 15y agoI consider my time with Genera to be more akin to archeology and code reading. I look through it for ideas and for examples. How did a group of really smart programmers build an environment that they really liked using? What ideas and techniques did they use? Those are the questions I am looking for answers to. When I actually do any Lisp programming for its own sake I use RMCL or something like that.