15 ms·
“seven years late and $17 billion over budget. At its full output of 1,100 megawatts of electricity” Ignoring interest for those 7 years and all other costs ju
by Retric 3y ago
“seven years late and $17 billion over budget. At its full output of 1,100 megawatts of electricity”
Ignoring interest for those 7 years and all other costs just the overage is insane. 17 billion / ( 1,100,000 kW * 90% capacity factor * 24 hour * 365 days * 50 years) = 4 cents per kWh. Add interest etc and someone lost an incredible amount of money on this project.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> someone lost an incredible amount of money on this project. All roads lead to Ratepayers (electrical customers). > Georgia Power’s residential customers are projected to pay more than $926 apiece as part of an ongoing finance charge and elected public service commissioners have approved a rate increase. Residential customers will pay $4 more per month as soon as the third unit begins generating power. That could hit bills in August, two months after residential customers saw a $16-a-month increase to pay for higher fuel costs. > The high construction costs have wiped out any future benefit from low nuclear fuel costs in the future, experts have repeatedly testified before commissioners. > “The cost increases and schedule delays have completely eliminated any benefit on a life-cycle cost basis,” Tom Newsome, director of utility finance for the commission, testified Thursday in a Georgia Public Service Commission hearing examining spending. > The utility will face a fight from longtime opponents of the plant, many of whom note that power generated from solar and wind would be cheaper. They say letting Georgia Power make ratepayers pay for mistakes will unfairly bolster the utility’s profits. > “While capital-intensive and expensive projects may benefit Georgia Power’s shareholders who have enjoyed record profits throughout Vogtle’s beleaguered construction, they are not the least-cost option for Georgians who are feeling the sting of repeated bill increases,” Southern Environmental Law Center staff attorney Bob Sherrier said in a statement. This will likely be the last commercial nuclear generator ever reaching criticality for the first time on US soil. Consider the current interest rate environment and the appetite for backstopping a multi decade construction project. https://www.lazard.com/media/2ozoovyg/lazards-lcoeplus-april-2023.pdf https://www.lazard.com/media/2ozoovyg/lazards-lcoeplus-april... [pdf, start at page 4]
- runako 3y agoIt's nice to have a captive customer base. Georgia Power serves more than a million additional people now than it did when this thing broke ground. And somehow all the pre-existing customers, plus the million+ new residents, all have to pay $4 extra for the power generated here. This, in addition to the fees they pay for electricity. Vogtle isn't going to be a good sales pitch for expanding nuclear. It's no wonder Georgia Power doesn't provide a calculator to let people know how Vogtle coming online affects the per-unit cost to consumers.
- laiewjrliawej 3y agoAnd that's why I left the nuclear industry. Nuclear power is the safest form of power production we've ever produced (more people are killed per MWh installing and repairing wind turbines than in the nuclear industry) but it has never been anywhere near cost effective and no nuclear project has ever been completed anywhere near on-schedule. Every time I hear someone talk about how the world needs tons of new nuclear plants and solar and wind can't possibly meet the demand quickly enough, that person seems to imagine that none of the next wave of nuclear plants magically will not have any of the problems that every previous nuclear plant had. Meanwhile solar and wind are beating estimates year after year. I still love nuclear physics (and I am excited about several up-and-coming fusion projects) but I just don't believe in the nuclear (fission) power industry anymore.
- mywittyname 3y agoThe sad part is, this is a solvable problem. If the nation really wanted to build a large number of safe, effective nuclear power plant, we could, and probably in a time frame of months, not years. But entrenched interest from natural gas and coal producers combined with anti-nuclear sentiment practically guarantee that will never happen. Nuclear power is held to too high of a standard to really be a viable source of power, especially in a democracy.
- breckenedge 3y ago> Nuclear power is held to too high of a standard to really be a viable source of power, especially in a democracy Don’t tell that to France.
- Manuel_D 3y agoThose are non-intermittent kilowatt hours, though (and the maintenance that does need to happen is known in advance). One energy demand at peak production is saturated, intermittent sources become a lot more expensive since storage needs to be provisioned. Some markets are fast approaching this scenario: https://reneweconomy.com.au/california-duck-curve-now-a-canyon-as-grid-load-vanishes-in-the-midday-sun/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/california-duck-curve-now-a-cany...
- Scoundreller 3y agoWouldn’t solar, as an intermittent source, be well correlated with demand in Georgia? Sun’s out = heavy AC load? Doing any grid 100% solar needs a lot of storage, but there’s gotta be a perfect point that mostly shaves peaks really nicely. (Yeah yeah, it can be cloudy and hot+humid, but still)
- Manuel_D 3y agoDemand typically peaks in the evening, around 9pm. This is right as the sun sets, where solar is tapering off. It's not "shaving peaks" about half your electricity consumption (including peak consumption) is going to happen during periods of non-production.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoAnd yet their on-peak times in the summer ends at 7pm: > Shift some of your summer energy usage away from the on-peak time periods (2-7 p.m., Monday–Friday, June–September, excluding holidays).
- Manuel_D 3y agoDemand shifting is just a long winded way of saying, "we can't generate enough electricity, you just need to stop using power at certain times of day." And it's easier said than done. Residential demand shifting, and some forms of industry (e.g. arc furnaces) can shift demand. But others cannot: the pumps powering your sewage system needs to work all day around. Same with data centers, and plenty of other industries.
- merpnderp 3y agoThe good news is that after it is paid for, it will cost about $20-$25/MWh. The bad news is that at least for the few decades it will cost $75, which is about the same as solar+battery LCOE today.
- Retric 3y agoThose numbers are wildly optimistic, these overruns mean the plant is going to be repaying construction costs over it’s full lifespan. I don’t know where you messed up but if you’re running the numbers include the full cost not just the overrun, interest rates, increasing operating costs during loan repayment, capacity factor, and decommissioning costs. Opening costs late in life is a real killer as older power plants mean ever more equipment needs to be replaced which then lowers capacity factors etc. Also, LCOE battery backed solar is also under 60$/MWh https://atb.nrel.gov/electricity/2022/utility-scale_pv-plus-battery https://atb.nrel.gov/electricity/2022/utility-scale_pv-plus-... Numbers may be slightly higher in Georgia, but still well below your estimate.
- krasin 3y ago> 4 cents per kWh. For comparison: I live in SF Bay Area and pay 42 cents per kWh.
- vel0city 3y agoFor comparison: I pay 6.269¢ per kWh for energy costs.
- charrondev 3y agoFor comparison I pay 6 cents per kWh in Quebec (and that’s Canadian money).
- SilasX 3y agoJust to make sure no one misunderstands (not saying you did, just that this is easy to misread): The 4 cent/kWh figure is the additional cost it would have to charge, over the life of the plant, to make up for the budget overage, and would go on top of whatever ratepayers would have to pay for its "regular" energy output. Further pedantry: you'd have to factor in time value, so that kind of understates it, as the entity that built it would have had to borrow that much more to finish, and pay back with interest.
- krasin 3y agoThanks. I can now see how my comment could be misunderstood. My point is that while 4 cents per kWh for 50 years is a very big number in terms of cost overruns and the taxpayers in Georgia will have to eat it, I as a California resident, somehow pay through the nose despite abundant and cheap solar energy, especially during the daytime.
- llsf 3y agoNuclear power plants now run more than 50 years. We are pushing some to 80 years already. https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/whats-lifespan-nuclear-reactor-much-longer-you-might-think https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/whats-lifespan-nuclear-re...
- FrustratedMonky 3y ago>“seven years late and $17 billion over budget. At its full output of 1,100 megawatts of electricity” It's all projects. This just happens to be a big one. Everyone likes to point to over-runs, over-budget, late projects. Nobody goes back and asks "who did the original estimate that we eventually went over?". Many projects start with /s 'everyone knowing it will go over budget, but if we give a real estimate it wont get off the ground'/s. Then later someone has to get blamed. If everyone is (quietly)honest they kind of spread around the blame and the success. If it is a contentious project, everyone is playing tag at the end.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoEvery other kind of power project is built using fixed price bids. If a company bids $3B for a natural gas plant or solar plant and the project costs more than $3B to build the company is on the hook, not the ratepayer.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI didn't dig into details on specific of this project. But any large fixed price project I've been on, it all hinged on verbose specifications. And then any change resulted in change orders. And it becomes a pissing match of who will pay. It is rarely cut and dry.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThey are power contracts, not construction contracts. The power company isn't buying a power plant, they're buying power. That's what makes the contract so much simpler.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI'll have to pass. I don't know the power industry that well. My rule of thumb thought, is that nobody looses 17 billion. That gets passed to the consumer somewhere somehow. In someway obviously or not obviously.
- aputsiak 3y agoOn the news page, there is a link til an article on India purchasing 1,200 MW facility from China for 3,5 billions. Edit: https://apnews.com/article/pakistan-china-nuclear-power-plant-chashma-7f49994919b4398fde3d207dd53075b5 https://apnews.com/article/pakistan-china-nuclear-power-plan...
- yodelshady 3y agoIf you ever doubt that the US has a simply fucking insane advantage in primary resource extraction and consumption, consider your comment. You think $40 per MWh is expensive. Wholesale rates in Europe hit SIX HUNDRED AND SEVENTY FIVE EUROS PER MWh last year because of gas supply issues and unfavorable weather. Spot prices have gone higher still, over one order of magnitude higher actually, those were futures contracts for a useful period of time. Because THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE WILL PAY WHEN THERE IS NO ALTERNATIVE. Consumer rates of 30 cents per kWh are perfectly normal. 100 not unheard of. Oh, fun fact; the largest producer of nuclear power in Europe is suing its government because it was forbidden from selling at that market rate. It had to sell at 40 cents per kWh. Not to consumers of course, to the fucking glorious private sector, aka resellers, who did sell it to consumers at market rate. The ones who hadn't gone bankrupt and fucked off earlier when market conditions were against them, that is. Although they did spend a lot arguing, successfully, they didn't need to pay producers then, either. Because the glorious efficient private sector can't have competition. Yes, I'm bitter. Going to an industry conference and seeing no one able to run plants properly because of unreliable power, whilst neighouring Germany sets a new coal-burning record, in unnatural heat, does that.
- Retric 3y agoTexas spot prices recently peaked at 9,000$/MWh briefly that’s in no way what I am talking about. 4c/KWh is the minimum additional cost across 50 years ignoring interest not the total cost of this power. In other words if inflation adjusted electricity would have been X$/kWh in 2070 it’s now at least X + 4c / kWh whatever the baseline would have been. Europes average electricity prices for the year aren’t that far above average, across 50 years it’s a tiny blip by comparison.
- Raphaellll 3y agoTell me more about that coal burning record in Germany.
- blibble 3y ago> Oh, fun fact; the largest producer of nuclear power in Europe is suing its government because it was forbidden from selling at that market rate. It had to sell at 40 cents per kWh. Not to consumers of course, to the fucking glorious private sector, aka resellers, who did sell it to consumers at market rate. don't you all love the European Union's Single Electricity Market?
- _hypx 3y agoYour own math points out that this is a cost effective technology. 4 cents per kWh is quite cheap electricity.
- arh68 3y ago2 units, both 1,100 MW each. So 2 cents / kWh.
- Retric 3y agoThe second unit isn’t online and the total overrun is more than 17 billion.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adrr 3y agoStill cheaper than commercial solar or wind.
- Retric 3y agoIf by cheaper you mean 5x more expensive… That 17 billion isn’t total construction cost it’s how far they went over budget so far. They still need to pay the initial estimate + ongoing operating costs + decommissioning costs.