5 ms·
> There were initially concerns about potentially dangerous toxins leaking from the object if it was found to be part of a rocket. From the photo - the object
by bell-cot 3y ago
> There were initially concerns about potentially dangerous toxins leaking from the object if it was found to be part of a rocket.
From the photo - the object is a cylindrical tank, with a huge hole in one badly-damaged end of it. It was adrift at sea long enough for barnacles to be growing over much of its surface.
IANARS (not a rocket scientist)...but I'd bet that there are absolutely zero carried-in-tanks-on-rockets toxins which are barnacle-friendly. Ditto ones which would not have been washed away in the first hour of the sea water sloshing in & out of that big hole. And IIR, the intersection of two empty sets is also empty.
- fit2rule 3y ago[dead]
- orbital-decay 3y agoThe tank in the photo looks like the second stage pressurization tank. If that's the case (I could be wrong), it carries helium.
- elteto 3y agoI don't think it's a helium tank. A high pressure tank (helium or otherwise) in a rocket is normally a COPV [0]. Those are welded, don't have rivets/bolts, and are wrapped in carbon fiber. To me it looks like a regular fuel or oxidizer tank. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_overwrapped_pressure_vessel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_overwrapped_pressure...
- Turskarama 3y agoThe pictures of the vessel when close up DO look like it's overwrapped, the rivets around the outside look like theyre from the structure which held the tank rather than the tank itself.
- elteto 3y agoYou typically see COPVs attached from the top and bottom with linkages. And a regular tank can be overwrapped in a composite as well. The top looks like a regular tank dome to me, maybe a common dome.
- mlindner 3y agoIANARS but I play one on the internet. Depending on exactly where it came from on the rocket and which rocket it came from there could be smaller tanks embedded within larger tanks and fuel lines that are still pressurized behind closed valves. That wouldn’t be known until they confirmed its origin. Finally the content of what could be pressurized is some pretty toxic and carcinogenic chemicals like nitrogen tetroxide or monomethyl hydrazine.
- stolen_biscuit 3y agoYes in hindsight it's obvious the tank is non-harmful, but when it was a complete mystery it's important to do due diligence to ensure it is safe.
- rozab 3y agoIt was positively identified in the reddit thread about half an hour after it was posted, not sure how the media has managed to drag the story out for so long
- mulmen 3y agoReddit has been wrong.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYeah but there are plenty of experts to ask about the single specific claim.
- nhinck2 3y agoAnd how many different claims are there?
- Dylan16807 3y agoI didn't look but it would be easy to toss the top three credible claims at them.
- mulmen 3y agoBut how does a non-expert determine credibility?
- Dylan16807 3y agoTaking their best guess is fine. Or just taking the top three comments that don't seem ridiculous. In this case the top comment on /r/whatisthisthing is "Looks to be a perfect match for India’s PSLV third stage." with comparison photos, the second-top comment is "Looks like a fuel tank for a rocket of some type.", and the third-top comment is "looks very similar to the Delta IV heavy fuel tank". It's a nice plausible answer and about as straightforward a question you can get for asking an expert.
- boringuser2 3y ago>IANARS (not a rocket scientist) The concept of you actually typing this is more interesting than what you posted.
- notatoad 3y agoIANARS either, but testing for various known or likely causes of toxicity [or other harms] is generally a good thing to do with an unidentified object, regardless of how likely it is that test comes back positive. if it was toxic, and nobody had bothered to test it because there were barnacles on it, that'd be pretty dumb.
- coder543 3y ago> I'd bet that there are absolutely zero carried-in-tanks-on-rockets toxins which are barnacle-friendly. Plenty of rockets have used hydrogen as a fuel, and most rockets carry tanks of oxygen. These would be gone just about as soon as a hole appears in the tank, but the traces would probably be considered barnacle friendly.