9 ms·
Plans to plant billions of trees threatened by undersupply of seedlings
- pologreen1978 3y ago[flagged]
- Tempest1981 3y agoThey're aware of the need for species diversity - it's mentioned 5 times in the article. > U.S. tree nurseries don’t grow close to enough trees—nor have the species diversity needed—to meet ambitious planting goals What are you finding "kinda stupid"?
- mistrial9 3y agoagree, but the article talks about that directly.
- pologreen1978 3y agoIt’s talks about planting a whole bunch of trees in an area, It doesn’t bring in the fact that you also need to bring in animals, and small plants to kickstart the rewilding process
- aydyn 3y agoProvide some empirical studies to back up your claim. What you're saying sounds like the "Appeal to Nature" fallacy.
- warent 3y agoMark this as one of the first times I've heard forest restoration categorized as "stupid"
- HideousKojima 3y agoNah,it is pretty stupid. If there were plans to actually manage the growth of the new forests as opposed to the "plant and forget" methodology used by a lot of tree planting efforts it wouldn't be so stupid: https://www.vox.com/down-to-earth/22679378/tree-planting-forest-restoration-climate-solutions https://www.vox.com/down-to-earth/22679378/tree-planting-for...
- pologreen1978 3y agoThank you!
- aydyn 3y agoIs it? A lot of northern forests are comprised of only a handful of Fir species.
- devindotcom 3y agoThis is an interesting problem area, I recently talked with Mast about it - they started as Droneseed, and soon realized the whole seed-seedling-planting-managing process (not to mention funding) was pretty busted. https://techcrunch.com/2023/05/17/from-root-to-crown-mast-reforestation-is-regrowing-the-tree-economy-for-the-21st-century/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/05/17/from-root-to-crown-mast-re... It's also really data-intensive, or it is if you want it to be effective. There's a lot of forestry and climate science that goes into whether a planting effort will be successful, not to mention a hell of a lot of back-breaking labor. But hopefully this sector will get the attention it needs now that people are seeing how badly it's been neglected in recent decades.
- mistrial9 3y agoquick - bio-engineered seedlings must be the answer! The article does ask important questions, but also repeatedly mentions "investment" and "investors". People, the forests do not grow money. "Thirty-five million dollars" is a fortune in the forest, yet our living world is dying for lack of simple things, and death by a thousand cuts. How can one billion dollars be spent on a single recreation facility[0], and no money for forestry? Because the system is not reflecting real value, it reflects self-referential money value. Beware of investors. These science people are lining up for what? -- [0] New Athletics stadium in Las Vegas to reportedly cost ... Sportsnaut https://sportsnaut.com https://sportsnaut.com › las-vegas-athletics-stadium-cost May 27, 2023 — The total stadium cost is estimated at $1.5 billion, for a new ballpark that will have a retractable roof and seat 30,000 people.
- asdff 3y agoEven better would be a drone that can irrigate, limb a tree, spread compost, and use directed energy on unhelpful pests while ignoring beneficial insects. We have the technology today to build a drone that can do all of these things, there's just no market for it so it doesn't exist or else it would already.
- SoftTalker 3y agoEven in the best of circumstances, a tree takes years if not decades to mature. That isn't a timeline that many investors are attracted to.
- swifthesitation 3y agoWith careful planning and initial human upkeep for the first few years, it's been shown this can be accelerated and have a self-sustaining forest in ~10 years. Akira Miyawaki (29.01.1928 - 07.16.2021) [0], a botanist who studyied plant ecology, seeds, and natural forest restoration methods, introduced a "reforestation" algorithm known as the "Miyawaki method" in the early 1970s [1]. It has been adopted throughout the world with great success. And also prompted a viral TED talk by Shubhendu Sharma [2] who then produced a 12 video series on YT on how to create your own forest [3]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akira_Miyawaki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akira_Miyawaki [1] https://www.af-info.or.jp/en/blueplanet/assets/pdf/list/2006essay-miyawaki.pdf https://www.af-info.or.jp/en/blueplanet/assets/pdf/list/2006... [2] https://youtu.be/mjUsobGWhs8 https://youtu.be/mjUsobGWhs8 [3] https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDw6OmGaV5rnOCATIho19IcvpF2eqsG_6 https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDw6OmGaV5rnOCATIho19Icvp...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hosh 3y agoI’m glad planting trees is happening. And yet, I think the execution will not be that great. In my neighborhood park, there were a bunch of new trees planted this year. And yet, it looked like someone just sprinkled trees without a care about the specific species, sun, and water. There were places that were great ideas for planting — west sides of pathways to help block the blazing afternoon Phoenix sun. And yet, there places they planted too close to existing trees, where they won’t even get sun (plants compete for sunlight, not root space). They didn’t bother to dig basins or to mulch (both harvests water, helps retain moisture, and feed the trees). The species are not appropriate for the lower Sonoron, but it is what people expect for “trees” in the cultural idea of “parks”. There were no concept of designing for canopy layers (at least, overstory vs understory), much less adding shrubs or flowers to help round out the ecosystem. (“Diversity” is not really about different species of trees, but rather, the ecological function of each plant at the different canopy layers, working together to form a stronger, more resilient ecosystem). Instead, they got their planting numbers up and everyone can pat themselves on the back for Doing Something.
- nickserv 3y agoThis won't get resolved until collectively we move from "planted X millions of trees" to "X millions of trees have flourished for 5/10/15 years". The problem of course is that it's a) much more difficult and expensive to keep track of survival rates, and b) provides no immediate green-washing credentials (politicians, corps, looking at you). Thankfully there are some NGOs that are doing it right, proper analysis of the site, selection of diverse species, and yearly visits to measure survival rates. It's just that presently, these are the minority.
- hosh 3y agoHave you ever heard of Scientific Forestry? It was something documented in James C Scott's Seeing Like a State. Here's a long-form essay summerizing the ideas in the book: https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2010/07/26/a-big-little-idea-called-legibility/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2010/07/26/a-big-little-idea-call... These forests were planted during the late colonial era by the French and German. The great naval powers at the time were running out of trees tall and straight enough to make masts. They cut down natural old-growth forests, and planted trees in a way that makes it easier to count. They grew better, and called it a success. However, that first generation grew well because they used up the nutrients banked by the natural forest. The subsequent generations did not grow as well. So over the centuries or so of trying this, they tried things like, adding in insects, and measuring their rate of growth. But it all stems trying to force a complex system into something that is legible, but the results are its own folly.[1] Frankly, our climate and global ecosystem is a complex, adaptive system [2][3][4], and to think that we can reduce solutions based on a single metric, such as atmospheric CO2 numbers, is a disaster in the making from our collective hubris. [1] https://www.science.org/content/article/germany-s-trees-are-dying-fierce-debate-has-broken-out-over-how-respond https://www.science.org/content/article/germany-s-trees-are-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cynefin_framework#Complex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cynefin_framework#Complex [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_adaptive_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_adaptive_system [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaia_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaia_hypothesis
- eimrine 3y agoHaven't read the article but who plants trees like that? If you want to grow a tree, you must go to forest, dug out the baby tree which is not going to survive, like when you see a big number of instances of the tree in relatively small area, then you go in wiser place and dug the baby tree in. Here is how I do it.
- agilob 3y agoI read somewhere that birds and squirrels are better at planting trees because they do it at random, their forests grow faster, are more diverse, provide better shelter and are more resistant to fires and bugs. Can't find the study or news anymore. Anyone help? Could they plant a border of tress for squirrels and birds, so they would do the rest of the job and fill the square?
- burnished 3y agoGod, I hope this is a genius plan. Something about bird and squirrel labor for reforestation pleases me
- jnmandal 3y agoIt's true, but also takes way too long for the mission at hand. Trees already grow slowly, and squirrels/birds were going to eat a lot of the seeds which -- as we can see here -- is counter to incentive when there is a dearth of seed. This is not even to mention the ungulates, which will eat most of the young trees. Simply put, a managed plantation will produce better outcomes than "hands-off" rewilding or even a hybrid model. It is better still if the wildlife are managed or contained. Healthy forests have predators to provide pressure on herbivore populations; predators were often intentionally removed in many of the places we are now considering for afforestation. But that said, theoretically: yes, absolutely, a tree planted as a seed by a squirrel, if it survived to old-age, will likely have grown faster and healthier than the equivalent nursery product tree, which would have endured lots of handling and some shocks at a young age. If I were to guess at the type of innovation we might see in this space, I would say GMO trees that grow at enhanced speed is more in the vein of what might be deployed. If land were more readily available, like in boreal regions, then you might see some sort of innovation in the form of novel rewilding techniques, like you are suggesting.
- wizofaus 3y agoWouldn't the big advantage of GMO trees be ones that grow in non-boreal regions? But I gather genetic engineering for most tree species is limited by the slow reproductive cycle (oak trees take 40 years to produce acorns, and they're not even close to the slowest to reach maturity).
- 1letterunixname 3y agoThis is as absurd as it is futile because of forest fires, decay, and math. "TeamTrees vs REALITY!!" https://youtu.be/gqht2bIQXIY https://youtu.be/gqht2bIQXIY
- nverno 3y agoTrees have a big impact on local climate. The carbon sequestering part might be futile (but forests play other roles in climate change, like promoting cloud cover which is good for cooling), but reforesting is worth doing for a million reasons- plus everyone likes trees.
- 1letterunixname 3y ago1. Show me the evidence. 2. "Local". You're not going to plant a million trees in Manhattan or almost anywhere where people already are.
- SoftTalker 3y ago[flagged]
- jjk166 3y agoI feel like the important part of these tree-planting initiatives is setting aside land for trees to grow. If you leave a plot of land alone, climate-appropriate plants will grow soon enough. You might have to do more in special scenarios like reversing desertification, but that's not generally the point o these initiatives, and the number of trees needed for that is much less.
- danbruc 3y agoA trillion trees by 2030, each fixating 30 kg of CO₂ per year [1], with a global CO₂ emission of about 40 trillion kg by 2030 - roughly linearly extrapolated from [2] - that would capture about 75 % of global emissions, much more than I would have guessed. A billion trees on the other hand are just 0.075 % of global or 0.6 % of US emissions [3]. Also according to [1] a billion trees will need 20,000 km², a trillion 20,000,000 km², that are 0.2 % and 200 % of the US land area. And a trillion trees till the end of 2030, that are 369 million trees per day every day, that seems quite ambitious. The numbers used are the first thing a search turned up, I hope they are at least good enough for the orders of magnitude. [1] https://www.encon.eu/en/calculation-co2-offsetting-trees https://www.encon.eu/en/calculation-co2-offsetting-trees [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/276629/global-co2-emissions/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/276629/global-co2-emissi... [3] https://www.statista.com/statistics/183943/us-carbon-dioxide-emissions-from-1999/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/183943/us-carbon-dioxide...
- abeppu 3y agoI think the 30kg/tree varies widely both by species and conditions, and critically given the timeline you've mentioned (by 2030) by _maturity_. E.g. this source estimates 10kg/year for the first 20 years, but if much of that is after year 6-7, even if we could plant a trillion trees by 2030, they would not be close to the levels of carbon fixation you're mentioning. It's ambitious, but _even if we succeed_, it won't be impactful in the time horizon you're discussing. In 2030 we may have a large proportion of 1-3 year old tiny saplings that may each weigh only a few kg (wet). (update: forgot the link for source mentioned) https://onetreeplanted.org/blogs/stories/how-much-co2-does-tree-absorb https://onetreeplanted.org/blogs/stories/how-much-co2-does-t...
- danbruc 3y agoI intentionally picked the favorable numbers as I was expecting even with those it would turn out to be a pretty futile endeavor, even ignoring things like forest fires. And it pretty much is, at least with a billion trees. And for a trillion trees I can not see how this could realistically happen. I would have to plant a tree every three weeks for the next seven and a half years, 125 trees in total, that sounds not too impossible. But once you consider that everyone in your city will have to the same - and every other human on earth - I don't think it would be too long before I would no longer be able to find a spot for the next tree where it interferes with nothing and can grow for a couple of decades.
- digitalsushi 3y agoOne time a farmer-turned-software guy told me a wild claim once that Earth could carry about a billion humans tops, until someone figured out how to suck nitrogen from the air and make ammonia. I wonder if we're fertilizing all these new trees we wanna plant with air manure.
- bluGill 3y agoIt doesn't have to be trees. Grass can also take CO2 out of the air. Then you burn it off next spring, which leaves behind a layer of sequestered charcoal. Keep doing this for decades and you will have removed a lot of CO2 - all in natural prairie fashion. If you live in the typical single family house you can make a small difference by mowing your law as little as you can get by with (use an electric power). You can also try to mow paths to make it look like the tall grass is intentional as an end run around demands you mow. Let the wild flower grow (but you do have to to watch for and remove invasive plants that will grow and take over destroying the effect you are trying to do). I don't know how to convert your suburban grass to charcoal in a way that won't get the neighbors after you for pollution though.
- morninglight 3y agoWe need a program for training people to rake leaves.
- thinkingemote 3y agoTrees almost everywhere will create more trees if left to themselves. One oak tree produces lots of acorns. The problem is mankind. We like to interfere. In a way many tree planting schemes are an indicator of this interference (hubris?). We just need to let nature do its thing in most places. There are of course some places that need help and people can help here (watering, stopping logging, species diversity, grazing animal protection etc) but generally nature will do it for us if we let it. Small scale planting schemes are great for community and education too.
- wizofaus 3y ago> One oak tree produces lots of acorns. But takes 40+ years to do so...
- knewter 3y agoGrowing up there was an ad on the radio each year around arbor day. A grizzled old man's voice says "when I was growing up, my dad and I would go to the forest each year on arbor day to plant some trees." It encouraged the same behaviour. A forest is kind of by definition at capacity for how many trees will grow there. Planting a tree elsewhere means it will not suffer from the canopy blocking all it's light. So many saplings senselessly murdered by well-meaning wordcels.
- jshprentz 3y agoThe final quote, "... but often, on the ground, it’s one old farmer walking around to collect acorns. ..." reminded me of the the book The Man Who Planted Trees [1] in which a shepard single-handedly reforests a desolate valley by planting acorns and other seedlings. The book inspired an animated film of the same name [2], which won an Academy Award in 1988. I remember seeing this at an animated film festival about 35 years ago in the Biograph Theater in Washington, DC. Today I rewatched it on YouTube [3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Planted_Trees https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Planted_Trees [2] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0093488/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0093488/ [3] https://youtu.be/epTqUnKsuUY https://youtu.be/epTqUnKsuUY
- PlunderBunny 3y agoInteresting fact: The government agency responsible for the national roads in New Zealand (i.e. big roads that aren't the responsibility of the local government) is the largest purchaser of native tree seedlings in New Zealand (I can't find a source for this online, but I am reliably informed it's true). I've seen a lot of motorway berms that were previously grass, converted to native plants. This not only captures carbon, but reduces carbon emissions by taking away the need to mow the grass, and it doesn't require 'new' land.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- g3ger1ub 3y agoI'm glad this is happening because there is a lot of desertification going on with a lot of establishments globaly