9 ms·
The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the real danger all around us
- ericmay 3y agoBikes and sidewalks are subtractive solutions and don’t “grow the GDP” like brand new EVs and associated infrastructure do [1]. Of course EVs are a better solution than ICE cars but to address a lot of problems in society we don’t need better versions of existing things but entirely new solutions altogether (sidewalks, bike lanes, better density and zoning). As the author of this article mentioned and I agree, it’s disappointing to see other articles come out that do in fact blame bike riders for problems caused by reckless car drivers [2] and overall infrastructure mismanagement that can be placed solely at the feet of city leaders, state departments of transportation, and federal agencies. This car-only infrastructure is beyond stupid, and the drivers themselves (a leading cause of unnecessary death and injury in America) are themselves victims. [1] They actually grow the GDP in less direct ways like increasing amounts of entrepreneurial activities, less obesity, less deaths and injuries (more capable workers), and instead of money going to department of highways budgets, oil and gas, tires, the vehicles themselves, and parking lots families can instead invest or spend on other much needed items - this particularly affects the poor. [2] I’m reminded of an article I saw previously and don’t have on hand where I believe a child or perhaps a few people were killed by someone who was drinking and driving and had 38 fucking speeding tickets and was still allowed to drive.
- DrThunder 3y agoNO... something going 20mph + that easily doesn't belong on a pedestrian bike path either. I've seen way too many zooming by me and my infant in a stroller at speeds that are too dangerous to be on paths. If it has a motor it belongs on the road. Just like a motorcycle you accept the risk of being hit by a bigger vehicle that also uses the road.
- jakelazaroff 3y agoWhy are you walking with your stroller in the bike path?
- SkipperCat 3y agoIn NYC, there are a lot of shared bike/pedestrian paths, so the commenter may be legit in their use of the path.
- throw1234651234 3y agoAbsolutely. They cross over all the time and there is way too much going on to always be aware of your surroundings.
- jakelazaroff 3y agoWhere, Riverside Drive? The parks? The vast majority of bike lanes I see either A) do not exist, so bikers are forced to share space with either cars or pedestrians, or B) a narrow lane in the road demarcated by only paint. Plus, bike lanes are often blocked by delivery trucks, taxis, etc, so bikers end up having to share space with cars or pedestrians anyway.
- fnfjfk 3y agoNot really? It’s mostly the uptown section of the greenway and the Jamaica bay path that are shared, and the latter is mostly used by enthusiasts (distance runners and roadies) that are aware, it’s not a big problem. The other “paths” in NYC are split, greenway down/midtown, Flushing/Kent path, Brooklyn Bridge Park, Red Hook path. And of course the vast majority of bike lanes are on the street rather than “paths”.
- DrThunder 3y agoPaths in the US are usually multi-use. Almost no where has a dedicated bike lane, and if they do it's just a line on the side of the road. If you're going to be speeding along at 20mph the side of the road works just fine.
- agloe_dreams 3y ago> Just like a motorcycle you accept the risk of being hit by a bigger vehicle that also uses the road. Hahaha. You do not see the irony at all do you? You and a stroller have zero business being on a bike path to begin with. The solution everyone is talking about here is Roads for Cars + Bike paths + Pedestrian-only Sidewalks. The issue of having bikes near people is the same as having cars near bikes.
- manzanarama 3y agoPedestrian bike path is a bit of an oxy moron. Bikes and e-bikes generally aren’t allowed on the sidewalk or where people are walking. I agree with that. A bike trail seems fair game. I could agree with a 20 or 25 mph speed limit for all types of bikes on a trail as well.
- afavour 3y agoYeah, I'm going to say "no" in response to your "no", sorry. For one, I've seen plenty of non-motorized bikes go over 20mph in bikes lanes, particularly down hills. > zooming by me and my infant in a stroller at speeds that are too dangerous to be on paths To be clear: you and your infant are not sharing the path with this bike, right? It's on a bike path, you're on a pedestrian path. I don't understand what a "pedestrian bike path" is. If a car drives past the sidewalk at 25mph do you have a similar reaction? If not, why not? And just so we don't get too many "won't somebody please think of the children!" accusations thrown around: I own a cargo e-bike and I take my kids to school on it every day, via a separated bike path. If I were required to bike on the road instead I simply wouldn't do it, it's far too dangerous. So we'd probably end up having to get a car and if, heaven forbid, I were to get in any kind of an accident a pedestrian would be considerably worse off. EDIT: From the replies I can see many cities do have shared paths so I take that back. Seems like a very unwise choice and goes back to the original point: 90+% of of road space being dedicated to cars is the core problem, not bikers. And plenty of non-motorized bikers travel at unsafe speeds so I maintain a blanket ban on e-bikes feels like it isn't coming from anywhere logical.
- throw1234651234 3y agoI was just in NYC (not a resident, so it's fresh). You cross a "bike" path any time you cross a street. On the West side "health run path thing" there isn't enough space for both bikes and pedestrians and there is constantly a chance of collision. It's pretty unsafe. Guessing it's not too fun for kids, the elderly, or anyone who can't react IMMEDIATELY both physically and mentally. I guess "that's just the city", but there is nothing safe about it.
- fnfjfk 3y agoThe west side greenway is segregated downtown and in midtown, but joggers and tourists often go in the bike part anyways. There are some pretty clear signs and bikes painted on the ground there, but they get ignored. Uptown, around the 80s I think, it is shared, but it’s less crowded and it’s more New Yorkers that know what’s up rather than tourists.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adrianN 3y agoIn Germany electric bicycles are limited to 25km/h (assisted). But the real solution is bike paths that are sufficiently wide to allow safe overtaking. Many people can do 30+km/h on a regular bike.
- DrThunder 3y agoThat sounds like a motorway.
- nxx788 3y ago[dead]
- apisandapisand 3y ago[dead]
- jmclnx 3y agoIf you are worried about safety, ride your e-bike/bike in the middle of the lane. That is legal in the state were I live and probably most other states. Yes, NYT is victim blaming, plus if you are driving an auto, penalties for killing some is almost non-existent if you are not impaired. At the very least, you should lose your license for a few years.
- cies 3y agoCar industry hit-piece. They did it before, they'll do ti again. Remember "jay-waking"?
- afavour 3y ago> ride your e-bike/bike in the middle of the lane It's legal, certainly. But where I live at least (NYC) it's as likely as anything to exacerbate dangerous driving as cars try to pass you anyway. I don't mean to sound alarmist but driver entitlement is a helluva drug and police enforcement for traffic offenses is incredibly low. It's the Wild West out there.
- Gigachad 3y agoWhen they do pass you will have plenty of room to move to the side, unlike if you were already on the side and they run you off the road.
- polygamous_bat 3y agoI have tried that before, only resulting in a truck aggressively trying to pass me and finally pushing me off onto the sidewalk in the middle of downtown Mountain View. Legality doesn't matter if the drivers who think they own the streets don't know the law or aren't willing to abide by it.
- redler 3y agoThe cyclist’s epitaph: “He had the right of way”.
- asoneth 3y ago
- fnfjfk 3y agoAt this point it’s the e-bikes and the mopeds that are the worst. Drivers will behave like oblivious idiots, but they are predictable idiots. We need an NYPD crackdown on e-bikes/mopeds (mostly delivery riders) to get them off the road, so that drivers can reclaim their rightful first place (EDIT: 1st place at being idiots!!). The mopeds and e-bikes will fly out around a corner and start riding the wrong way (“salmoning”) in a protected bike lane. Gothamist has an article today covering the recent Manhattan Bridge crash caused by two mopeds illegally riding in the bike lane: https://gothamist.com/news/cyclists-say-e-bikes-scooters-are-making-nyc-bridges-more-dangerous-with-laughable-enforcement https://gothamist.com/news/cyclists-say-e-bikes-scooters-are...
- agloe_dreams 3y agoThe irony in this thread is hilarious. You know what the correct solution in Manhattan is? Kill the cars. They do absolutely nothing good for the city unless they are delivery vehicles. The city was built without them and basically nobody local uses them. Then just crack down on the bad bike riders on the now much-larger bike lanes.
- SkipperCat 3y agoNYC can walk and chew gum at the same time. We can reduce car traffic (I'm for the midtown congestion pricing) and crack down on ebike/scooter violators. I'm tired as a pedestrian dodging motorized vehicles on the sidewalk. I'm also tired having to look both ways when crossing a one way street because of a salmon-ing bike. Plus, when I'm crossing with the light, many times bikes have come up between the cars and ran the light, just barely dodging me in the crosswalk. Ebikes and scooters are a real problem in NYC. If they'd just follow some of the basic road safety rules, everything would be peachy.
- fnfjfk 3y ago> NYC can walk and chew gum at the same time. We can reduce car traffic (I'm for the midtown congestion pricing) and crack down on ebike/scooter violators. Well, I wish, but we can’t even get the obviously good Mcguinness blvd redesign done, the 59th street bridge south pathway conversion has been not happening for years, heck they can’t even trim back the weeds that have been overgrowing the bike path on Kent by the navy yard. Not sure nyc can walk or chew gum at separate times.
- SkipperCat 3y agoI live in NYC and the situation with ebikes is very different from many other parts of America. We have a huge population of delivery drivers on ebikes (and also elec/gas scooters). They ride on sidewalks, against traffic and constantly run stop signs and red lights. They're not just a danger to pedestrians, but also creating an awful risk for themselves (I just saw one hit by a car next to Barclays in BK this weekend). I'm an avid biker and have slow rolled my way thru many stop signs, but I've never put myself or other pedestrians at risk in the manner as many ebikes riders do. The NYPD has ignored this problem, as they do most quality of life issues in the city. I'm not sure how we resolve it but there does need to be dialog among everyone to fix this issue. This is not just an issue of car vs. bike, its an issue of pedestrian safety too.
- mholm 3y agoI've lived in a few cities over the past two years, and am currently in NYC and you're right on the money. E-bikes are a very positive change in every other city. E-bikes in NYC have gone too far. I was riding the bus to Red Hook and the driver had to slow down several times because delivery riders were swerving between the sidewalk, road, and bike path at any given many moment. Stop signs didn't even exist to them.
- mistrial9 3y agoat the same time, other cultures around the world with big, urban centers have adopted to the more chaotic traffic. Big, safe, 4-wheel vehicles have brought gridlock to the core city, and with that is waste. Its a challenge for sure, but strict traffic enforcement in a 1960s way seems gone in 2023.
- the_snooze 3y agoI wish states would regulate Class 2+ e-bikes as motor vehicles restricted to motorways only. E-bikes with throttles (instead of just pedal assist) are just motorcycles with electric motors and should be regulated accordingly. They have no business being on trails and sidewalks.
- 3y ago
- screye 3y ago> subtractive solutions and don’t “grow the GDP” like brand new EVs Maybe GDP is a bad metric. In any other field, a metric this naïve would be laughed out the door. If GDP is trying to capture net effective productivity, then let's stop using a metric that's 2 degrees of aggregated abstraction away from this metric of interest. Cars are middlemen. They allow labor to reach a location that performs a productive activity. They produce no productivity of their own. IE. Cars are network IO. Whichever transport method maximizes throughput and minimizes latency for the least cost is ideal. Any decent engineer knows that the key to better network IO is to: * improve locality - (keep things near each other) * batch things together - (buses and trains) * reduce size of individual packets - (cycles instead of huge cars) * no lossy transmission - (maintain worker productivity, stave off obesity) * avoid waits as much as possible, let actions happen async (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqQSwQLDIK8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqQSwQLDIK8)
- fnimick 3y agoAnd like any system, middlemen will attempt make themselves mandatory in order to preserve their status and profits. Look no further than car dealers lobbying for laws that all sales must go through dealers, for example. Or car companies lobbying for laws that incentivize people to own private cars by making alternatives infeasible and unsafe.
- kingds 3y agoi think you’re misunderstanding what GDP (gross domestic product) means. it’s basically a measure of the total revenue in a country’s economy. it has nothing to do with “productivity” in the sense of efficiency.
- chayesfss 3y ago[dead]
- dumbfounder 3y agoBikes shouldn't be sharing the road when the speed limit is 55mph. That is crazy talk. Ebikes are a problem in NYC because no one follows rules in NYC. People act in any way they want because it's tough to police a city with so many people packed in so densely. This isn't a one thing or the other, you need better rules, and you need to be able to enforce those rules. If you can't enforce them and the rules don't work then you need to change the rules until they do.
- jrochkind1 3y ago> it's tough to police a city with so many people packed in so densely Why would density make policing more difficult?
- dumbfounder 3y agoGood point, maybe that makes it easier. At a high enough density I guess you could put a cop on every corner.
- gmadsen 3y agotraffic?
- HDThoreaun 3y agoAs police forces approach NYPD size bureaucracy becomes completely debilitating. Extremely hard to have accountability at that scale and once the rank and file realizes that they stop working as hard.
- fnfjfk 3y agoIMO cycling Route 9W (closer to 55mph, not certain of speed limit) in Jersey is much safer than cycling Manhattan (25mph)
- lokar 3y agoThe NYPD just does not care
- Ylpertnodi 3y ago
- AlexandrB 3y agoLouis Rossmann also had a recent video on e-bike safety: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nrtLWilSoNI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nrtLWilSoNI Seems like there have been a few shocking/tragic e-bike related incidents lately in NYC.
- JTbane 3y agoI'd much rather be struck by an e-bike than a car or truck.
- Justsignedup 3y agoI would like to note about NYC... I see bikers, and ebikers. And holy hell the raod and road rules mean nothing to these people. They see bikes as the priority in every situation and drive on the sidewalk, drive on roads, ignore street lights, ignore stop signs, ignore cars moving backwards. I almost hit an ebike yesterday because I was reversing and had zero space for another car to surprise me, so a biker decides to squeeze in whatever space was available to get by. I almost missed them as they were in my blind spot and flew an inch away from my wheels as they were gonna back into them. Not saying it is all victim blaming here, but ebikers riding at 25mph ignoring road rules is a massive problem in addition to everything.
- ambyra 3y agoE-bikes need to be registered and plated. They won’t be on sidewalks if they’re getting ticketed. If ny is good at anything, it’s issuing tickets. They’re the same as motorcycles, scooters, mopeds. They need to be more powerful, not less, to keep up with traffic. We don’t need separate bike lanes for e-bikes, it’s called lane splitting. Every Asian country has this already. Bike lanes are for bicycles.
- asoneth 3y agoA pet peeve of mine is the lack of clarity over terminology has resulted in journalists and marketers branding electric mopeds and motorcycles as "e-bikes". On one end of the spectrum are regular-looking pedal bicycles with assistive motors that cut out at 20 mph and weigh around 40 pounds. On the other end of the spectrum are electric mopeds, motorcycles, and dirt bikes (some street legal, some not) with fat tires and vestigial or removed pedals that can reach 35+ mph and can weigh 200+ pounds. Both have valid use cases and both can be ridden well or poorly, but they are qualitatively different vehicles in terms of weight, power, riding style, and safety risks. The fact that both of these vehicle types are often simply referred to as "e-bikes" without specifying their class makes discussions more difficult than necessary. Edit: Electrek is particularly egregious about this, referring to anything with a battery and pedals as an "electric bike" or "e-bike", for example: https://electrek.co/2023/07/18/british-soldiers-electric-bikes-with-rocket-launchers/ https://electrek.co/2023/07/18/british-soldiers-electric-bik... https://electrek.co/2023/04/13/eunorau-flash-launched-as-220-mile-triple-battery-e-bike/ https://electrek.co/2023/04/13/eunorau-flash-launched-as-220... https://electrek.co/2023/05/28/wau-project-cyber-cryptically-teased-as-high-performance-electric-bike/ https://electrek.co/2023/05/28/wau-project-cyber-cryptically... https://electrek.co/2023/07/07/police-crackdown-on-illegally-fast-electric-bikes/ https://electrek.co/2023/07/07/police-crackdown-on-illegally...