7 ms·
US offices are sitting empty – business owners will have to adapt
- seydor 3y agoHm ... how about we tax work from home? Like, tax homes for doubling as office space. I think it's a brilliant idea
- bcrosby95 3y agoYou might be joking but we already tax the extra space you need for work from home because the larger amount of space results in a more expensive home.
- ambrose2 3y agoExcept I’ve already been in a 1 bedroom apt since before COVID and I’m still stuck working remotely because people don’t want to go into the office.
- FpUser 3y agoStop treating people and business separately. Problem solved. Otherwise get lost. Not your business what I do inside my house.
- throwanem 3y agoWe already do that. The home office tax deduction used to be available for W2 employees, but it was suspended in 2018 under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. Theoretically it's meant to resume in 2025, but I'll be surprised if that actually happens.
- evilduck 3y agoHow about employers compensate me for supplying their office space, utilities and cleaning, or let me deduct it as an operating expense on my personal taxes just like the businesses get to do?
- renewedrebecca 3y agoHow about we tax you for having bad ideas?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- user6723 3y agoThere are other ways to get on the internet than a crowded "open office floor plan" where you're smelling each others' farts all day and have to remind people to message you on Slack instead of walking across the room to tap you on the shoulder when you already have headphones on.
- BenFranklin100 3y ago[flagged]
- akira2501 3y agoGetting the most out of talented people requires reasonable compromise.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoAre most talented people misanthropes?
- akira2501 3y agoIs it actually misanthropic to be annoyed with bad smells and physical disruptions in an office? In particular, as part of an effort to be undistracted and to make as much value from their own labor as is possible? I think just showing up to work means you are likely _not_ a misanthrope. Further, would applying mean spirited labels out of misplaced hyperbole do anything to change or to help the situation?
- softwaredoug 3y agoIt’s weird going to downtown SF these days. Everyone seems from out of town. Or if they live nearby, just downtown for their teams onsite. It’s like a decrepit city district that exists for the sole purpose of flying people in to meet in person. Less a thriving center for tech. More a default place for leadership to get everyone together. Obviously the vicious cycle of nimbyism, lack of affordability, and homelessness only continue a downward spiral that existed pre pandemic. But there doesn’t seem to be a lot of original thinking on a solution other than “get people back to offices” from those that CAN afford to live nearby and pretend the world hasn’t changed.
- latchkey 3y agoSF should have turned some of that office space into more affordable housing long ago. This would have created a community. The Castro is cool, because people live there. There is a little central downtown area and then it is surrounded by housing. Downtown SF is completely devoid of that.
- Animats 3y ago> exists for the sole purpose of flying people in to meet in person. Less a thriving center for tech. More a default place for leadership to get everyone together. Right. In which case you may as well meet at an airport hotel with good meeting rooms. Maybe there is a market for that. Repurpose under-utilized indoor malls as business conference centers where teams meet once or twice a week. Malls have plenty of space, plenty of parking, good HVAC, food facilities, and some shopping. All you need to make an unused store into a meeting space is furniture.
- leetrout 3y agoA few malls are trying this. I called my local mall to use their little event space (think 60 folding chairs and a podium in a 900 sqft box). No call back. I am continually surprised at how hard it is to find a place to hold a small meetup in the evenings
- jareklupinski 3y ago
- TeffenEllis 3y agoI’ve been a remote engineer for over a decade, but only recently switched to a hybrid schedule on Tuesdays and Thursdays. IMO, these two days are effectively useless for any kind of productive technical work. There are simply too many visual distractions, interruptions, and a complete lack of comfort in an office. …But I do enjoy these in-office days for what they make up for in remote work: Face to face chats; Real time human bonding; A sense of place. The office is just a socially accepted excuse to get everyone out of their homes and together for a few hours. I’m especially grateful that our cofounders understand why we should actually be at the office, and that any expectation of “being more productive” is nothing more but a polite fiction. Ironically, our two days in the office are mostly spent just outside the building. Technical chats over lunch, 1 on 1 meetings as a walk around the neighborhood, and drinks in the evening. That’s what hybrid should be. I’ll send my pull requests at 3 am while in my comfy chair at home. As for the commercial real estate market, I truly believe they’re fucked in the long run. There aren’t enough jobs like my Montessori arrangement that justify all the buildings in their portfolio. Hell, we couldn’t even go back to full-office because our team is so distributed! Personally, I think this is commodification coming back to bite short-term economics applied to financial districts. We don’t need a Chipotle on every corner. We don’t need another $20 box salad store. We need neighborhoods that people want to be in for reasons other than work! I’m guessing that in the coming months there’s gonna be talks of a real estate bailout. Investors have entwined their holdings into everyone’s retirement plans, and will no doubt appear on the nightly news wearing a vest made out of dynamite. They will threaten to take us all down with them. Such a shame that they’ve over-leveraged their position. Did they forget that we already have nothing to lose? The irony will be lost on them.
- latchkey 3y ago> We don’t need a Chipotle on every corner. We don’t need another $20 box salad store. These are the only types of business that can afford the rents though. Even if you get another lower cost place in there, they have to cut corners on quality and end up going out of business or just being really bad food. How do you overcome that?
- lotsofpulp 3y ago
- zeroCalories 3y agoI think one thing people aren't considering is how remote work makes people more easily substitutable. Why live in SF if you can live in a small Colorado town? Why pay for a remote developer in SF when you could pay for a remote developer in Arizona? Why hire in the U.S when you can get a good dev in South America? There used to be a geographic monopoly on labor, but making remote the norm moves us away from that. Maybe that's a good thing, as it will make NYC affordable, but NYC is also experiencing huge budget shortages from the drop in land value. I suspect these will only get worse over time in all major U.S cities.
- tekla 3y agoThis is what programmers wanted right? The right to work from wherever they wanted. Except, that includes cheap areas where salary requirements tend to be much lower and pushes down wages.
- Tade0 3y agoAs someone hailing from a popular outsourcing destination, the lower the costs of living in a location, the higher IT salaries are in comparison to the median. I moved to a smaller (population 600k vs 1.7mln) city and my salary didn't change much working remotely, while costs, especially real estate, are approximately 30% lower. All my friends who stayed there did so simply because they had someone to finance their housing.
- HWR_14 3y agoNot everyone. I'm smart enough to want to limit my competition.
- softwaredoug 3y agoTo some degree yes, However living in the same city is only one aspect of substitutability. There’s also specialized skills, organizational tenure, time zone, how easily legally a company can hire in a country, language barrier and many others.
- 3y ago
- JHorse 3y agoRezone for mixed residential, remodel into loft space. Done and done.
- RyanAdamas 3y agoUltimately, the money for these projects comes from the government. Major works projects which have revolutionized how we live never begin as private enterprise; those are relegated to products and services with incremental contributions to our advancements. The USA needs State-based Socialism and not this consumeristic crony capitalism that is killing our humanity in every respect. Global socialism is just other countries stealing from each other and calling it equity. Strong nations are the basis for production and when incentives don't exist to engage people in those nations because of international influence, money, and elitism the outcome is stagnation and degradation of the system. Real estate speculation has gone absolutely wild over the last sixty years as the Federal Government, the Federal Reserve, and its agents, sit on hundred of millions of acres of livable land, and hundreds of thousands of homes, as a means of maintaining investor value. Which is a complete affront to social government and the purpose of this nation - the ability to choose how we live. None of us choose this save for the inheritors of massive capital who are generally "citizens of the world" because they are liquid enough to owe no loyalties. This has to end.
- AntiRemote 3y ago[dead]
- Animats 3y agoBusiness owners are adapting just fine. Commercial real estate owners are in big trouble.[1] That article says that most office real estate is leased for five years with an option to renew. Many of those renewals are not happening. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jimscheinberg/2023/07/26/dont-look-up--why-a-commercial-real-estate-crash-might-be-streaking-toward-us/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jimscheinberg/2023/07/26/dont-l...
- dageshi 3y agoIt might ultimately be the banks who are in trouble. "For an office landlord, abandoning a building can be the best of bad options. Commercial mortgages on offices are usually structured as “nonrecourse” loans, which means that only the building is forfeited in a default. " https://www.curbed.com/article/nyc-office-real-estate-rechler-rxr-project-kodak.html https://www.curbed.com/article/nyc-office-real-estate-rechle... This is a great article on the situation in New York, I highly recommend it.
- Animats 3y ago> It might ultimately be the banks who are in trouble. Commercial real estate landlords keep saying that, in hopes of a bailout. Whether it's a real problem for banks remains to be seen. It's a slow problem, and banks can generally deal with slow problems.
- bombcar 3y agoBanks can also do silly accounting tricks, like claiming the $1m building is the same as the $1m loan they foreclosed on, and carefully not update it or worry about cashflow.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoThey neglect one of the biggest ways we can revitalize downtown areas: build lots of new homes on underdeveloped properties. Not only will this drive demand for downtown office space, it will provide foot traffic for small businesses. It also shortens commutes and is good for the environment.
- errantmind 3y agoThis depends on other conditions being good as well, like being bike/pedestrian friendly and reasonably safe. There's no amount of new homes they could build that would revitalize Houston's downtown because it sucks. Most of the people I know who live and work inside the loop go out of their way to avoid downtown. I live adjacent to downtown and haven't been there for anything, including events, for years.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoA reason downtown Houston may “suck” is because there are too few homes and thus it becomes a wasteland on the weekends and evenings. Mixed use districts with high density of residential will draw in stores, nightlife venues, and restaurants. It will also drive demand for bike and mass transit. Moreover, there are many urban downtowns that don’t “suck’, such as Boston and NYC that are still facing a challenging commercial real estate market. Additional residential in this metros will be quickly snapped up and drive demand for nearby offices.
- bombcar 3y agoDowntowns have been revitalized and saved, it's quite possible and there are examples. Often it involves something like building a stadium or convention center or other attraction, which makes dwelling units nearby desirable. San Diego's gaslamp quarter is an example.
- fragmede 3y agoWhere is Detroit in this example?
- samhuk 3y agoBeen almost solely a remote software engineer for ~5 years. The last couple of offices I've seen just have terrible equipment. This of course could just be my own anecdotal coincidental experience or just me being picky, but I do wonder if it's actually, at least in part, due to companies just not giving two sh*ts about equipment because fewer and fewer workers are actually going into the office. If that hypothesis is true, then it's a really vicious and rapid positive feedback doom-spiral: worse equipment -> fewer on-site workers -> less motivation for better equipment -> even worse equipment -> even fewer on-site -workers... ...repeat ad nauseam. Also, slightly tin-foil-hat-like (however I bet many will relate), but in the country I'm currently living in (UK), the government sold off all of the transport services to private soulless demons and political cronies, causing a runaway price surge that means a yearly pass for one ~30 minute route is >£5,000 (around $6,000?). So, yeah, each on-site for me equals getting scammed by profiteering demons, having my back eviscerated by the knock-off-of-a-knock-off of a Herman Miller that has foam crushed into a slab of diamond, spending 30 minutes finding a HDMI/whatever cable, and of course losing 1-2 hours of my life to transport there and back. Nah. EDIT: What would make on-site a viable possibility for me would just be: Nicer transport (e.g. >70% chance of seat, instead of 1E-300% chance at the moment), cheaper transport, and better equipment. EDIT2: I forgot biggest on-site downside of them all: bad tea and coffee :P
- tschellenbach 3y agoThere's a big gap in these trends between SF & everywhere else. - For companies in SF, rents are extremely high, local salaries are super high and the city is in bad shape so nobody wants to go there. - In most other places rents are affordable, local and remote salaries are similar, and cities are pleasant SF office space is going to get crushed. Most other places will partially recover.
- softwaredoug 3y agoAffordability, nimbyism, and chronic homelessness occur in a lot more places than SF. Yes SF is kind of the poster child, but these are issues in a lot of places My small, east coast college town has a YIMBY oriented movement for more affordable living options. https://livablecville.org/ https://livablecville.org/ (and a homeless problem https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/newsletter/the-number-of-people-experiencing-homelessness-is-rising-faster-than-shelters-can-keep-up/ https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/newsletter/the-number-of-peop...) Our zoning is stuck in some old NIMBY ideals and is really hard to change. Development of new projects is stalled. Housing is more expensive than ever. > Shelter workers say there are many reasons more people might be seeking shelter this year. One is that inflation is making it difficult for people who earn low incomes to afford their homes.
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoEverybody is talking about office spaces being empty, but at least in my area the office rent is at all time high which doesn't seem to hint people are using office less(unless office has been repurposed to something else which I don't know about).
- jlokier 3y agoIn my town, most office rents are all time high and there are a lot of empty units, at the same itme. It's been like this for years, even before Covid. However, in the few years before Covid there were more spaces advertised than there are now, and that number went up a little in 2020. But now, there's not much on the local the market, even tbough I can see plenty of empty buildings when I walk around. We have a lot of landlords here who, I'm told, don't care that much about the rent, which is also why they don't try particularly hard to entice tenants. It can be remarkably hard to rent a space even when it's been empty for years and advertised as available, as the agents come up with all sorts of reasons and incompetencies. I am part of an organisation that tried to rent a business unit that was advertised and which we'd been enthusiastically shown around, and after a year of trying we gave up on it because we just couldn't get sane responses from the agent. The unit was still empty when we gave up on it. There are quite a few that are not advertised but have been empty for years. Some of those are actually available, but you have to talk with property agents and ask for the lists of properties they have on file which are available if you really want to pursue them, but are not advertised. If you don't know, you don't know. I currently rent a small office in a larger office building. The rent I'm paying is relatively low for the area, but it's inching up citing "market rates", i.e. high, even though most of the units in the building how now been empty for multiple years. The property agent told me my particular landlord doesn't really care about the rent as they have other long-term plans for the building. So it's disappointing they still charge as much as they do for that rent they don't really care about. I'd love to take the empty unit next door to expand my office; it's likely to remain empty for another year anyway. I was told a few years ago, before Covid, this dynamic is for two reasons. (1) The big landlords often prefer to hold out for a large, higher-paying tenant with a long lease, even if it means no rent for a year or two by turning down lower-paying tenants meanwhile. This makes little sense to me as they could presumably offer flexible terms where they can give notice at any time, but hey I'm not a landlord. And (2) some of them intend to wait for the building to be empty for long enough (20 years) that they eventually obtain automatic permission to demolish the building and replace it with a new build, either apartments or a new building with more floors and maximum footprint. I don't know if either of these reasons are true.
- vr46 3y agoAbout three or four years ago, I asked the owners of a closed-down department store if we could turn a big chunk of the 4-5 storey section into a climbing wall and was told to F-off as they had bigger plans for a new commercial centre with mixed-work and retail. Anyway, it’s still shuttered, so good luck with that plan.
- bombcar 3y agoThey do not want to deviate from the standard because it might possibly threaten something, so they're very conservative. Find one that's willing to have a Spirit Halloween store in it and you might find them more receptive.
- vr46 3y agoThey’re avaricious bastards, it’s what they are. Huge, vast amounts of money flows through businesses and straight to landlords in London, strangling investment in small businesses, their employees and the wider economy. Businesses with high margins, low inventory and low unskilled staffing costs win. In Germany, I note that thousands of small businesses flourish that vanished from London’s streets - I have a choice of places to have a kitchen knife sharpened, for example - and while London holds vast opportunity, I fear that its breadth is severely constricted and whole areas of industry, skills and expertise are effectively extinct as the startup Capex is too high, and the Opex is vampiric.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's the definition of rent-seeking, literally. And it's hard to counter-act in high-density areas; without deliberate action everything becomes McDonalds or financial businesses.
- cududa 3y agoIn my city, an office building was converted to an apartment. The windows don’t open, given it’s an old apartment building. The AC has been out for two weeks. Not at all saying we should let office buildings stay vacant, just, never considered how much it would suck to not be able to open windows. https://fox8.com/news/unbearable-residents-in-lakewood-high-rise-apartment-without-ac-for-nearly-2-weeks/amp/ https://fox8.com/news/unbearable-residents-in-lakewood-high-...
- softwaredoug 3y agoAre we the baddies? > unfortunately modern HVAC systems work off a computer motherboard. Apparently, through zero fault of ours, that motherboard was fried by an electrical surge.
- bombcar 3y agoOften the computer is just to make it more efficient, it should be designed to have a low-efficiency backup control mechanism that is simply "on/off" on a basic mercury thermostat.
- birdyrooster 3y agoMy company thought it would be cute to have us return to cubicles instead of our old offices. It's terrible, now I have nowhere good to work at home or in the office. I suppose my poor performance was part of their calculations of value.
- Blaire285 3y ago[dead]