8 ms·
Actors take to the internet to show their residual checks, some in the negative
- serf 3y agoit's weird to hear a famous actor/actress complaining about work and then saying that the boss is too busy yachting while they bust their hump. it's very much a turtles-all-the-way-down feeling.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy should they get residual checks? Most other professionals get paid for the hours they work and then we either have to keep working or invest some of our earnings to have enough to live on. Of course in the startup world, you may be willing to take a lower compensation for equity that will pay our later. But hopefully you understand the risk. If anything they should negotiate a higher up front payment.
- esalman 3y agoWhy do authors receive royalty every time their book is sold?
- Crunchified 3y agoLikely because it's less risky for the publisher, as opposed to a big up-front payment for something that might not sell as well as expected. As an author, which approach would you prefer?
- esalman 3y agoDefinitely I'd want residual income. To avoid the opportunity cost in case one of my works become bestseller.
- scarface_74 3y agoWould you take less money up front in exchange?
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd that’s something that everyone here fails to understand. For me there are three levels of risk. 1. Getting all of my compensation in cash (least downside/least upside) 2. Working for a publicly traded company where part of my compensation comes from RSUs vested over a schedule 3. Working for a startup where I get “equity” instead of my market value in cash. The writers are negotiating based on 3. I would be negotiating based on 1.
- lapcat 3y ago> The writers are negotiating based on 3. I would be negotiating based on 1. Are you, anonymous internet rando "scarface_74", claiming to know the interests of the Hollywood writers better than the writers themselves?
- scarface_74 3y agoNo I’m anonymous scarface_74 who knows finance and risk/rewards ratios based on being an MBA drop out. I have had the same choices: 1. Being risk averse by taking cash up front and choosing to negotiate based on a maximum up front payment 2. Taking less up front and dealing with a higher risk/reward return like accepting lower payer for equity by working for a startup
- lapcat 3y ago> No I’m anonymous scarface_74 who knows finance and risk/rewards ratios based on being an MBA drop out. It's truly a wonder that you haven't been made the President of the Writer's Guild of America. > Taking less up front and dealing with a higher risk/reward return like accepting lower payer for equity by working for a startup Hollywood studios are not startups, and residuals are not like startup equity. Writers and actors are not hoping for some BigCo to come along and buy the Hollywood studios, or for the studios to go public, leading to a massive single payday. The studios are the BigCos, and they're already public. Residuals are more analogous to BigCo stock than to startup equity.
- 3y ago
- scarface_74 3y agoBecause that’s the contract they sign and they own the rights to the book. Actors don’t own the rights to the movies.
- esalman 3y agoActors and writers deserve meaningful residual income just like the authors. And they actually did, as a result of a similar strike in the 60s. The model was disrupted due to the advent streaming as the dominant media, so they are merely asking for a correction.
- scarface_74 3y agoAre the writers of the libraries software developers used owed a continuous royalty based on how profitable the software built using it makes? The author of a book could just as easily negotiate a large payment up front to give up rights to their book in exchange of one lump sum and invest their money and let the publisher both take all of the upside. But get all of the downside.
- Draiken 3y agoYou keep repeating this as if it was actually an easy feat. No, aside from already famous established actors you won't just "negotiate a way better perfect contract upfront". This is where the capital power imbalance cannot be defeated. They always have the upper hand against any single individual.
- madsmith 3y agoI would think it has to do with the IP owners using the likeness of the actors to continue to market the show year after year.
- scarface_74 3y agoDoes your employer get to use code you wrote after they pay you? Do they get to market features you worked for after you leave? Do landlords get to collect rent on buildings after the architects are paid to design it?
- aezart 3y agoBoth of those things are also bad.
- scarface_74 3y agoSo you are saying that landlords should have to pay the original architects of the buildings part of their rental income? Are you okay with paying residuals to every library author when you use an npm package?
- aezart 3y ago1. There shouldn't be landlords. 2. Copyright shouldn't exist at all, but until it's abolished I am not opposed to a system where revenue is shared with the developers of any libraries you use. Although I think such a system would be difficult to manage and track.
- pluto_modadic 3y agobecause once made, distributing the thing and making more money is trivial. So, getting an ongoing cut of the proceeds is important. side note, this also means software engineers at large companies are getting screwed and should unionize. imagine it takes $2M to make something, and in the first year it makes $4M. Then, every year after it, it's made $.5M. Either: A) we give actors residuals or B) copyright should expire and movies should be free after the initial crowdfunding.
- gruez 3y ago> because once made, distributing the thing and making more money is trivial. So, getting an ongoing cut of the proceeds is important. But why are you so fixated on "getting an ongoing cut"? Thanks to finance, we can calculate the net present value of any perpetual income stream. There's nothing really different between getting paid $1000, and getting paid $500 + perpetual income stream that has a net present value of $500.
- angmarsbane 3y agoI’ve always viewed it that replays keep their face in the public arena disrupting privacy. If you film something 20 years ago, and then all of a sudden it becomes hugely popular again via streaming you will also be propelled back into the public arena which can have negative effects on your life (unable to go out without paparazzi, interference from strangers etc).
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd that’s also a choice that should be factored in.
- feoren 3y ago> Most other professionals get paid for the hours they work and then we either have to keep working or invest some of our earnings to have enough to live on When people talk about the rich pitting the working class against each other, this is exactly what they're talking about. Rather than saying "yeah, fuck the man, we're all in this together!", you've chosen "why should they get out of eating the shit of our owners? They should learn to eat shit just like the rest of us!"
- scarface_74 3y agoIt’s not “the man” who all should get residuals? Building architects every time someone stays in a building they designed? Software engineers every time you use a library? Are you okay with software patents and licensing? Do you think library makers should get a residual every time you pull a library down from npm?
- jrockway 3y agoWe should start asking for residuals on software we write!
- toomuchtodo 3y agoEquity? Are y'all not asking for that? Travolta Confused Meme here Royalties are equity distributions, "dividends" if you will.
- intelVISA 3y agoNo less than 49% I hope!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DANmode 3y agoWhat's the largest equity role you've held?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIn a YC unicorn, ~%0.15 give or take (out of 0.2% granted, employee 10-15). In other orgs, various amounts depending on how my contribution is valued (grinding on a keyboard, advising, etc). In my most recent role, they gave me a ton of RSUs for essentially "head of security" at a fintech reporting to a CISO. My point is that if you're not asking about ownership, you should be. My personal financial situation is not representative of the broad working class. Lots of luck involved too, but asking is mostly free. Resources I've previously posted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28405708 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28405708 Parent thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28401655 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28401655 u/JoshDoody's submissions are also great on the comp negotiation topic (although he has not been around lately): https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=JoshDoody https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=JoshDoody https://www.amazon.com/NEW-Never-Split-Difference-Lead-Title/dp/B09VCPNDH3/ https://www.amazon.com/NEW-Never-Split-Difference-Lead-Title... (Never Split the Difference: Negotiating as if Your Life Depended on It) (I learned the hard way, I hope to help others not have to by sharing my thoughts and experiences)
- causality0 3y agoMan I'd be living the life if I could show up to work one time and then get paid for it over and over as long as my work was still benefitting the company. I don't understand how Disney and Netflix and HBO decide it makes financial sense to strip major series like Westworld off their streaming services because the residuals are costing them more than the series is earning but actors are on strike because they don't get paid enough. What's going on?
- intelVISA 3y agoNot too unthinkable when SaaS exists :)
- pluto_modadic 3y agobecause companies continue to sell the thing you already made, ballooning the profit vs cost to make ratio... if actors only got paid the one time, companies and stockholders would eat an increasingly larger percentage of the true revenue of the IP.
- lapcat 3y ago> I don't understand how Disney and Netflix and HBO decide it makes financial sense to strip major series like Westworld off their streaming services because the residuals are costing them more than the series is earning That's not exactly the sole explanation: "Warner Bros. Discovery plans to license the series, and several others, to free ad-supported streaming television services" "On top of that, it'll be able to fully write down the future amortization costs of those series." https://www.fool.com/investing/2022/12/22/westworld-no-longer-on-hbo-max-why-important/ https://www.fool.com/investing/2022/12/22/westworld-no-longe...
- feoren 3y ago> get paid for it over and over as long as my work was still benefitting the company. You say this like it's laughably unrealistic. Yet it sounds completely reasonable to me. Why shouldn't you get paid in proportion to the value you create?
- scarface_74 3y ago
- Crunchified 3y agoResiduals are fine if you can negotiate them. More power to you! But to complain about not getting paid for something without having to lift a finger to earn it is the height of conceit. Do The Work! Entertain us with new and interesting creations! The move towards rewarding work (such as the trends of musicians touring and performing instead of relying solely on recording) is a healthy one!
- aezart 3y agoIf the publishers are continuing to make money off selling the work, why shouldn't the people who actually made it get their share?
- Crunchified 3y agoBecause the publishers/producers took the risk. They paid you for your work, didn't they? Move on instead of complaining. Yes, it's hard finding work in the entertainment biz (much like sports and arts), but having to pay more residuals than bargained-for only takes away opportunities for you and others to get more work. Again, I am not against residuals, but a contract is a contract and the right to contract is between individuals. Any "force" (unions, government) that twists and turns the right to contract is anti-individual, anti-freedom, and most certainly a group vs group powerplay that does not give the average individual any advantages - only the empowered individuals gain anything (at the expense of the unempowered).
- causality0 3y agoMandy Moore has a net worth of $14 million. Kamil McFadden is worth $5 million. Kellee Stewart $3 million. William Stanford Davis $5 million. In fact Jana Schmieding is the only person in the article who isn't a known millionaire. The amount of privilege these people have is unreal.
- lapcat 3y agoWhat's the net worth of the film and TV studios, their executives, and their major shareholders? Famous actors can use their fame to highlight the issue, and that's how it becomes a news story, but the issue affects all actors, especially the ones who are not rich and famous. They won't get their names in a news story.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- glimshe 3y agoI don't think the executive pay matters all that much in this discussion, and is a marxist argument ultimately. If they are well compensated and have proper work conditions, what the shareholders and bosses are making is irrelevant. Market forces should determine their pay; otherwise, why do we think that they should make more money than anyone else?
- lapcat 3y ago> If they are well compensated and have proper work conditions, what the shareholders and bosses are making is irrelevant. So why does the net worth of Mandy Moore, et al., matter? > Market forces should determine their pay Residuals are due to market forces. It feels like you should be arguing against causality0, not me.
- gorbachev 3y agoThe producers and financiers of the films, and the companies who own the intellectual property of the films the actors made have net worth of billions.
- majormajor 3y agoHopefully instead of just jealousy this prompts some thinking in those of us wwho don't get residuals about why the systems of the world favor having money so much more than having the product of labor. Or rather, if you do the labor, you don't get to have it. Only a few people (like here) have had the ability to negotiate an ongoing right to the output) at all. But the world is built so that if you have the money, you expect to be able to perpetually benefit from things you put it towards. Sure, you might lose investments sometimes, but you have limited liability so you likely aren't losing everything. And you can also lose your ability to do more labor in certain jobs, so it's not like the risk is higher if you're an owner. And the expectation is that you just work work work work, and you'll get snarky shots fired at you from the other poor suckers out there if you try to challenge that.
- gruez 3y ago>Or rather, if you do the labor, you don't get to have it. Labor is just another input that goes into making a product. I don't see why they should be entitled to perpetual income any more than the company that supplied the film should be entitled to perpetual income. If you want perpetual income, create your own enterprise, or become an investor yourself. Most of the headline members of the AMPTP are public companies.
- pluto_modadic 3y agothis is a good argument for not letting companies have perpetual IP based income :)
- gruez 3y ago1. Outside of trademarks, "IP" typically isn't "perpetual". Copyrights last a long time, but they're not perpetual either. 2. If you sell a widget, that item gets irreversibly transferred to the buyer. If you sell your time (ie. what you're doing as an employee) the same thing happens with your time. If you "sell" a movie, that doesn't happen. Well, technically that happens all the time between companies, but doesn't apply to the typical consumer transaction. "perpetual IP based income" is a way to make products that are infinitely copyable have a viable business model. Otherwise if you want to watch a movie, you'll have to pay for the whole thing.
- CaliforniaKarl 3y agoIt’s interesting seeing the first three comments; from scarface_74, jrockway, and causality0. Movies are often their own corporate entities, with actors investing their time in hopes of a good return. When you choose to work at a startup, you invest your time, and take a lower cash salary, in hopes that your equity will make it worth it. Same with actors. If you sympathize for the founders who get screwed out of big returns because of the machinations of others, the situation isn’t that different here. Hence the strike, and this story.
- scarface_74 3y agoI work in cloud consulting for a the river company based in Seattle. My base pay is far lower than I could get working for another consulting company. The difference is made up by RSUs which by definition give me rights to the future value of the company. If you work for a company that pays dividends like Apple and Microsoft, the RSUs they give you do give you a residual right to income.
- twittertrends 3y ago[flagged]
- cjbgkagh 3y agoI know people are hoping that this strike will show the power of unions and encourage others to unionize in a similar manner... but what if they fail? Wouldn't that demonstrate the opposite? It feels like hollywood is on the precipice of a gig economy. There is always someone waiting in the wings to do the same for less. I think big name actors are a function of branding, you roughly know what you're getting with a Tom Cruise or a Ryan Reynolds movie, which makes the money spent on them more of a marketing expense than an acting expense. There are other ways to create and maintain brands. I think if people believe they are owed more than someone is willing to pay them should instead compete. Maybe make an actor owned studio / production company? There are already quite a few of them and it does appear to be a growing trend. I hit a ceiling in my own compensation and had to instead create my own software company in order to capture more of the value that I create.
- WorkerBee28474 3y agoYeah. There are so many people who move to LA with the dream of becoming a movie star, why isn't it possible to just fire the entire union and hire new actors? I'm sure it's more difficult than that, but if there were one industry where it was possible, due to massive lines of people waiting to fill those roles and become famous, I think it would be acting.
- nradov 3y agoIt's not as easy as just hiring new non-union actors. Quality matters, and most of the actual good actors that audiences want to see are union members. And other unions will usually refuse to cross a picket line or work with scabs so producers would also have to hire non-union crews, drivers, and writers. There are non-union productions. But those are mainly smaller independent projects which never bring in much revenue.
- gochi 3y agoWhy would it demonstrate the opposite? It's one union in a particular field. We have plenty of other unions out there, look at cops.
- legitster 3y agoIt's hard not to see this as some sort of niche Los Angeles fight. I don't think the average American tracks on the issue of getting free money for your personhood rights. > SAG-AFTRA also asked for revenue sharing, which means actors would get a fixed residual and also a separate residual tied to the amount of money a show brought in once it hit streaming platforms. The numbers are just not going to line up here the way people expect. These shows are only on streaming because the rights are cheap. And hollywood has been pumping out low quality shows in such excess that they are essentially commoditized. If it comes to pay or pull, these streaming services are going to start pulling a lot more shows. Shows that never even made it to physical media. I think we are seeing a collapse of an era. Even if SAG pulls together a deal, the industry is just not going to carry on in the same way it has.
- gochi 3y agoThat doesn't really make sense. The shows aren't only on streaming because the rights are cheap, because what's the point of buying them at that point when you can spend that money on your own IP? Streaming buys licenses because they are valuable, this value is only transferring between the service and the network. Further, I don't think they're really against the real numbers being shown so they can more accurately get a sense of what's happening. Keeping numbers a secret here only benefits two groups: networks and streaming services. Even the music industry is more transparent.
- scarface_74 3y ago> Streaming buys licenses because they are valuable, this value is only transferring between the service and the network. When I had my house built for $335K in 2016, I paid the builders for building my house and the labor involved. They have no right to any of the value I’ve derived from my house by renting it out when we moved or when I sell it for hopefully twice the price. When I paid them for my house, my business with them was done.
- eesmith 3y agoYour analysis is incomplete. The value you've derived from your house is a subset of total value derived from the process of constructing your house. Did you have an architect design the house? If so, who owns the copyright for the design: you or the architect? For example, AIA Document B105TM – 2017 "Standard Short Form of Agreement Between Owner and Architect" says "The Architect shall retain all common law, statutory and other reserved rights, including the copyright". This means the architect could make a new house which is a copy of your house, or (more importantly) re-use architectural elements in other houses. If you negotiated that you own the copyright, how much more did you pay the architect? Did the architect still got a royalty-free, non-exclusive, worldwide license to use parts of the plans elsewhere? Even if you didn't have an architect, you must surely realize that others do hire architects to design their house. By narrowing the analogy to just the builders and the rental of a single physical structure, your analysis necessarily excludes copyright issues which are much more directly relevant to the current negotiation. The set caterers aren't negotiating for residuals either.
- glimshe 3y agoI get 0 cents of residual for continuing use of the software I built for hire. I think the discussion needs to shift to lifetime pay per hour worked than random residual checks. Maybe they have good reasons to be upset, but the residual amounts isn't the right piece of evidence.
- eesmith 3y agoI don't see why your personal experience is all that relevant. Just because you haven't been able to negotiate a contract with residuals shouldn't prevent anyone else from getting better terms. Maybe you should join a union and collectively bargain for a better contract? Or get an agent to negotiate for you? Residuals in acting are the rough equivalent an employee stock option for software developers. They are part of the total compensation, and help align the interests of the actor/developer with the interests of the company. Work hard, and if the show/product does well, the worker gets an extra reward. Remove stock options, remove residuals, and total compensation drops, leaving you with angry employees. The argument about the amount of residuals support the strikers' argument that they are getting less total compensation, which is one of several major points made by the unions.
- scarface_74 3y ago> Just because you haven't been able to negotiate a contract with residuals shouldn't prevent anyone else from getting better terms Residuals are nothing magical. You can calculate the net present value of the future expected value of your work and negotiate based on that.
- eesmith 3y agoOf course they aren't magical. Neither are options. Your point, while valid, doesn't change my total compensation argument at all. Just because glimshe doesn't get residuals (or presumably employee stock options) doesn't mean others should be prevented from negotiating for residuals or stock options as part of their total compensation.
- RickJWagner 3y agoHorse and Buggy Drivers show pay stubs, rant against cars!