4 ms·
Among other things, there's no way to add a log bot to private messages.
by Dylan16807 3y ago
Among other things, there's no way to add a log bot to private messages.
- Zetice 3y ago[flagged]
- Dylan16807 3y agoHuh? Supposed to what? I was just listing a way that Discord is worse than an IRC client, in a way that you can't solve with a log bot. You're imagining whatever standard you think I'm setting. Anyway, the main "other things" are needing direct moderator permission and button-pressing on every server you want to join your log bot to.
- Zetice 3y agoDiscord isn’t worse than an IRC client because it doesn’t log private chats, it’s superior because it doesn’t log private chats. And if you thing your “other things” are unique to Discord you’re kidding yourself.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Discord isn’t worse than an IRC client because it doesn’t log private chats, it’s superior because it doesn’t log private chats. I would say that having it stored indefinitely on third party servers, but not stored on my local computer, is the worst of both worlds. > And if you thing your “other things” are unique to Discord you’re kidding yourself. Some IRC channels may have the same policies around bots, but IRC doesn't force you to use a bot to have logs.
- Zetice 3y agoYou have no clue how Discord stores private messages, and IRC absolutely forces you to use a bot to have logs.
- Dylan16807 3y agoOh, are you trolling? I mean maybe you thought I meant "third party to discord" when I actually meant "third party to the conversation". But there's no way you actually think you need a bot to log an IRC channel.
- Zetice 3y agoNo, you said third party and meant Discord, falsely presuming Discord stores the content of your private conversations in an accessible way, and in this context in a way that makes it… harder? To publish as documentation (you know, the original topic). And since you’ve apparently never joined an IRC channel before, you don’t get any history of the channel at all, you only get the messages that are sent while you’re in there, and IRC servers don’t log every message to some file. If you knew how these servers worked you’d know how that wouldn’t work very well.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> falsely presuming Discord stores the content of your private conversations in an accessible way What do you mean presuming? I can log in from anywhere and access them, and they're not encrypted with any key I'm the controller of. > and in this context in a way that makes it… harder? To publish as documentation (you know, the original topic) You can't add a bot to an existing direct chat. You can only make new group chats. So you can't export it with a bot. So bots can't solve everything. > And since you’ve apparently never joined an IRC channel before, you don’t get any history of the channel at all, you only get the messages that are sent while you’re in there, and IRC servers don’t log every message to some file. Sure? But I didn't say you got history on IRC. Being a bot is neither necessary nor sufficient for getting every message. The real requirement is staying connected constantly, which is a completely separate issue. > If you knew how these servers worked you’d know how that wouldn’t work very well. It's not 1993 anymore, it would work fine. It's a good chunk of the IRCv3 efforts.
- Zetice 3y ago