17 ms·
Hugging Face, GitHub and more unite to defend open source in EU AI legislation
- roenxi 3y agoThe EU have regulated themselves into a corner where all they can do is shout at American and Asian tech companies who decide how computers will be used. Based solely on past performance this regulation is likely to be another nail in the coffin ensuring that innovation happens on different continents and then trickles back to the EU at some later date. The economic upsides of AI look like they will be huge. Therefore the odds are good that this regulation will be a crushing economic own-goal.
- southerntofu 3y ago> The economic upsides of AI look like they will be huge. There are many ways to interpret this sentence. What did you mean? If you mean a stupid robot can automate most office jobs, i don't disagree (most of these jobs are entirely useless to begin with, anyway). However is that an upside? History has shown our State/corporate overlords are not too fond of ensuring jobless people have a decent life.
- malermeister 3y agoI think it's time we accept the fact that AI will mean the end of capitalism. The system won't be viable anymore once there's no more need for labor. Where we go from there is up to us. If we don't do anything, we'll end up with neofeudalism, with the already rich concentrating power more and more, no longer kept in check by pesky labor movements. Alternatively, we can fight to try to establish a kind of star trek space socialism, where everyone's needs are met and nobody needs to work anymore - people would be free to follow their passions while computers do all the busywork. Dystopia or Utopia, that's the decision we'll be making over the next few years. The status quo will disappear either way.
- lionkor 3y agoI'm pretty sure we've been through this kind of thing before, and I'm also pretty sure AI will just be a part of the future, not replace it.
- malermeister 3y agoHave we? I can't think of any previous development that threatened pretty much every form of employment available. Sure, computers removed a lot of jobs, but they also created a whole new class of them (the ones most people on this site have). AI will remove that entire class of jobs, too, with nothing new to replace it. For a while, there'll be new opportunities for AI research, but if they actually succeed at improving AI, they'll eventually make themselves redundant, too.
- bongobingo1 3y ago> AI will remove that entire class of jobs, too, with nothing new to replace it Shit. Are you saying this prompt engineer bootcamp I'm doing is worth squat?
- smokel 3y agoDon't you think this reasoning is a bit black and white?
- 3y ago
- junofan 3y agoI think most people are just gonna ignore whatever this law is. There’s fatigue for sure.
- troupo 3y ago> ensuring that innovation happens on different continents Where by "innovation" you mean "pouring endless VC money into privacy-invasive practices with no external access or oversight". As for AI... Altman claimed that he welcomes regulation in AI space. When EU came out with a regulation which, among other things, requires companies to fully document their foundational models, he immediately said that he will not work in the EU. So much for innovation.
- gattilorenz 3y ago> “[…] privacy-invasive practices with no external access or oversight" Hey, let’s not forget “while totally disregarding copyright law (and code licenses)” here!
- antonvs 3y agoWell, Altman is CEO of a company called OpenAI, after all - it makes sense he wouldn't be in favor of transparency. Wait that doesn't make sense...
- mrd3v0 3y agoAside from mishits like backdoors in E2EE, which are also being considered in the US, UK and already law in places like China, these regulations will affect privacy-invasive monopolies and oligopolies. They will not affect 'innovation.' Innovation comes from publicly-funded organisations and projects. Even profit-driven startups that innovate are eventually bought out and destroyed by these monopolies and oligopolies EU is actively prosecuting.
- oytis 3y agoUhm... No? Transformer architecture comes from Google, and it's most impressive applications are developed in OpenAI. Public institutions are seemingly just trying to catch up (like Stable Diffusion developed in LMU a year after OpenAI released Dall-E)
- rpastuszak 3y agoI don’t think I’m getting your point here, SD is superior to Dall-e almost in every way.
- nologic01 3y agoThe pattern academia -> commerce is well known (and not in itself evil). At some point in the past decade any ML/AI academic that could spell backpropagation got poached (many from European universities). Once a domain proves short-tern lucrative, business is more than happy to invest but typically with very pragmatic targets. The recent reorgs in said commercial teams being point in case.
- oytis 3y agoThat's what called innovation I guess. Innovation introduced by public institutions is rather an exception than a rule - e.g. development of the internet infrastructure was funded publicly at first. What happens normally is that public institutions do fundamental research and businesses innovate. In case of AI businesses seem to be ahead even in fundamental research presently.
- 3y ago
- oakpond 3y agoCool story bro
- vasco 3y agoI think a lot of people believe much of the regulations introduced by EU are a way the EU found of taxing US global tech companies that operate within it without paying taxes. There's obviously examples of targeted European companies and some privacy regulations were and are needed still, but the motivation is likely at least partially motivated by this in my opinion.
- lewhoo 3y agoOr maybe the USA has deregulated itself into a corner where there is no more privacy. Any piece of data can be used for virtually anything as long as big corporations pat you on the back and ensure no "human eyes" will see/process it. If you think the EU is a market that's easily ignored then I guess we'll see in a few years whether easily replaceable batteries come back or not. >The economic upsides of AI look like they will be huge. The economic and social downsides might be also huge. Remains to be seen and I'm glad the EU isn't diving head first into murky waters.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." It's just the ultimately realization of the founding father. Most people long stopped caring about privacy. >If you think the EU is a market that's easily ignored then I guess we'll see in a few years whether easily replaceable batteries come back or not. I do truly want to see this result. I can honestly see it going either way. Apple has a long history of simply paying off EU fines.
- popcorncowboy 3y ago> Most people long stopped caring about privacy. Nah. This is only because the effect for most people of the LOSS of their privacy is usually unseen to them. So it feels like privacy/no-privacy is the same thing, no consequence. So, no outcry. No big deal. That apathy is not endorsement or abdication of caring. IT is the same psychological effect as smoking. We all hear "how bad it is". But then you have one. And... nothing. Actually it feels good. And another. Nothing. And another and so on. What are people whining about? Years later, consequences.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoUnseen sure, maybe back in 2010. Nowadays all this is taught in Grade school. If people want to still use Meta or Tiktok or whatnot despite supposedly being taught this growing up: I don't know what to say. >IT is the same psychological effect as smoking. I think smoking is a great analogue for this. It did take decades, but we did slowly get people to care about this without needing to suffer the consequences firsthand. I was hoping we could streamline that a bit quicker this time, but alas. I guess we need to let it spin for a few more generations to get the ball rolling.
- hnlmorg 3y agoAs a manager at a European tech company specialising in AI, I call BS on your statement. EU legislation doesn’t stifle innovation. It stifles abuse of technology. If the only innovation America and Asia can muster is abuses of technology (I know this isn’t the case but I’m borrowing from your statement) then I’m perfectly fine with the EU lagging behind.
- thrown1212 3y agoThe “EU bad” line gets rolled out so often on HN it has become its own truth. “Everyone knows” that the EU tech industry is getting strangled by its technocratic regulators and that’s why the EU fails at tech har har look at these idiots. Etc.
- carom 3y agoWhere are their datacenter scale computing companies? How many decades did it take for that to arrive there? It will be the same story with AI. European developer brain drain will continue with the brightest minds coming to America.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>European developer brain drain will continue with the brightest minds coming to America. No need to deal with all the US emigration issues and challenges. US big-tech already have offices in Europe where European devs, scientists and researchers contribute to the prosperity of the US tech sector because they get paid more than at EU companies, while still getting to enjoy the benefits of living in Europe vs the US.
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoPaying 1/3rd for the same cost of living.
- jdthedisciple 3y ago
- hliyan 3y ago> The EU have regulated themselves into a corner where all they can do is shout at American and Asian tech companies I think you may have this backwards. Consider the Brussels Effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_effect I used to think of the EU as stagnant compared to the US. But now I realise (especially in light of COVID) that some things we consider inefficiencies are actually safety margins. The EU may not move fast and break things, but I'm starting to view them as slow, steady and generally robust over the long term (think multi-generational).
- thrown1212 3y agoAnd more precisely: “Safety margins are inefficiencies” This short statement is profound and bears repeating slowly and often to people in any kind of power.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>bears repeating slowly and often to people in any kind of power. They don't care. And they aren't paid to care. That's the issue. If they can make $100m profit at the cost of being fined $10m and some financially useless metric like environmental impact, that's still $90m profit and makes the shareholders happy. It's not incompetence, it's a calculated risk. At this point the question should shift more to making those sharehoolders care about this stuff so they can tank companies for being incompetent. But they also have short sighted trigger hairs, and it's easy for them to pull out either way.
- beebeepka 3y agoThe game they play is all about money, so the only way to make them care is threaten the money.
- hliyan 3y agoThis has got me wondering: what if all publicly listed companies are required to have an ethics officer whose job is to point out ethical concerns regarding management decisions (whereas management is usually only concerned about legal compliance, no more, no less)? The recommendations of the ethics officer are non-binding -- i.e. management is free to ignore them, but they do so at their peril: if an issue arises and management is found to have ignored the recommendations, then they are accountable. If the ethics officer fails to raise the concern, then they are accountable. What form that accountability takes, is something I haven't thought about.
- latexr 3y agoComments like this always remind me of Tom Toro’s cartoon: > Yes, the planet got destroyed. But for a beautiful moment in time we created a lot of value for shareholders. https://www.newyorker.com/cartoon/a16995 https://www.newyorker.com/cartoon/a16995 Technology and innovation should serve the greater good. Unbridled growth for a few companies at the expense of the people is not a positive goal.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>Unbridled growth for a few companies at the expense of the people is not a positive goal. but "the people" like it and consume it. So what can you do?
- latexr 3y agoWe can regulate what’s harmful. That’s the topic we’re discussing. Consuming something doesn’t make it good nor does it mean people like it. Addiction is a real thing and it is no secret companies exploit that. Even if you do like one aspect of a thing (e.g. talking with friends on social media, gambling, smoking) it does not mean you like other aspects (e.g. constant anxiety, bullying, financial issues, having your data mined, lung cancer). One of the most meaningful steps we can take to improve society is to not just shrug our shoulders and say “Oh well, private companies lie, push harmful products on individuals, and spend millions on disinformation campaigns to keep raking in profits. But people buy these products under false pretences so what can you do?” Let’s not become Matt Bors’ Mister Gotcha. https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/ https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI'm just tired of relying on people in power to make people care about something that they should intrinsically care about. Sure, you can regulate it, but I feel like it's the equivalent of a parent saying "because I told you so" instead of properly teaching why this regulation exists.
- dleeftink 3y agoWhile protectionism may be detrimental, it is good to question innovation for innovation's sake. Is an economy largely displaced by LM-like systems a welcome one? The (slight) lagged rollout gives EU-countries some wiggling room regarding what works and what doesn't elsewhere across the pond.
- sensanaty 3y agoIf innovation for you == infinite privacy invasive data hoovering in order to make some rich asshole in a suit able to earn infinity + 3 pennies worth of money more, then you can keep it sequestered to the US and Asia. AI is a cancer that deserves to be burned down before it leads us all into doom for the sake of making shareholders some cash.
- stavros 3y agoWhat has the better mean quality of life, the US or the EU?
- j1elo 3y ago> shout at American and Asian tech companies who decide how computers will be used If that were like so, EU would be the one closest to shout how computers _should_ be used. It's like what happens with industry development vs. the environmental damage it causes: it's faster and easier to progress if you cheat and do it in an unsustainable way. But the "cheating" is not free of cost. Both in the example and in the real case of AI, you're paying with a different currency than time or money. We'll see how it ends up.
- TacticalCoder 3y agoI agree with your comment and I have this to say to those disagreeing: list me the biggest EU software companies and their sizes compared to the SV-behemots. For a quick googling and the top 10 EU software companies generate 131 billion of revenues combined, which is ridiculously low. SAP and Siemens AG together (the two biggest in the EU) have a market 1/10th (!!!) of the size of Microsoft. Can we please get real?
- troupo 3y ago> list me the biggest EU software companies and their sizes compared to the SV-behemots. List me the biggest SV-behemoths that (any combination of any three or four below below is true for 99% SV "behemoths"): - are profitable - don't rely on unlimited investor money to survive in hopes to corner the market - don't rely on lax privacy laws to collect and sale user data en masse - don't exist to be absorbed by a megacrop at a large price
- squarefoot 3y agoRegulation has nothing to do with progress. You're comparing a single country of over 330 million people mostly coming from a common culture, speaking one language, so big and isolated that it was never invaded from the outside, to an entity only 30 years old consisting of 27 different countries with completely different cultures and languages (currently 24) whose inhabitants saw some of their countries at war multiple times. What the EU has accomplished is a miracle to me.
- southerntofu 3y agoThe article is very low on details: what does the regulation contain? what are github and huggingface lobbying against specifically? > we really redoubled our efforts to make sure that they were not inadvertently imposing expectations (...) onto open source developers who are often hobbyists, nonprofits or students That's about as much info as we get. Personal/controversial opinion: neural network approach to technology should be entirely banned as it has very bad results and very high computational cost. I don't care that the LLM model hallucinating answers to my serious questions is open source (whatever that means in the context of neural nets, that's another debate), the harm is done anyway. I still do appreciate that "open-source" neural nets could continue to exist as a research field, but that any regulator considers allowing Google/Microsoft/OpenAI to clearly lie to the public using their artificial stupidity is way beyond me.
- janosdebugs 3y agoAs much as I tend to lean towards your standpoint, you do know that there's ML/AI beyond LLMs, right? A lot of it is fairly mundane stuff like being able to analyze a human-written sentence for grammatical structure (NLP).
- rhdunn 3y agoAnd in applications like text-to-speech/speech synthesis and speech recognition. Then there are the gray areas like training statistical models that are not ML/ANNs, but are things like Hidden Markov Models and the Vertibi algorithm. While not using ANNs, they work in a similar way in that they are statistical models trained on a large corpus of data, and those models are then used to predict various things like the part of speech, end of a sentence, or the pitch of a phoneme.
- southerntofu 3y agoI personally believe most of these applications bring net negative to society. I personally see two exceptions that i don't have strong opinions about: machine translation, and ML firmware for camera output quality. There's probably more i'm not aware of. The former has dubious quality but can be useful in certain contexts where human translation is unavailable. The latter has anecdotally already failed spectacularly in at least two cases: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6156238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6156238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29739235 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29739235 For example, what are positive applications of NLP you can think about? Most applications i hear about would be to replace human customer support with chatbots (very negative) or for intelligence gathering purposes (very negative). There's probably a lot i don't know about.
- troupo 3y agoI'll keep posting this article again and again. The FUD around EU AI Act is extremely strong: https://softwarecrisis.dev/letters/the-truth-about-the-eu-act/ https://softwarecrisis.dev/letters/the-truth-about-the-eu-ac...
- Hendrikto 3y agoThis guy is neither an AI expert nor a lawyer. I don‘t think we can count on his opinion too much.
- tticvs 3y agoTerribly written article full of bluster and arrogance. Falls into the typical European cognitive trap of thinking that what is most important is to follow procedure regardless of where the it leads, and completely ignores the fact that the AI tools that are about to be regulated out of the EU are wildly useful. These companies are not trying to take something from you but are in fact trying to give something to you. > This means that, yes, GitHub and other code repositories are still allowed to host AI model code. Hosting providers don’t have any additional liability under the AI Act, only the providers of the models themselves and those who deploy them. This is technically correct but ignores that overnight an unknown set of existing github repositories will become illegal in the EU, meaning that github will have to provide tools for users to block their repository from being pulled by EU users in order to prevent the users from accidentally committing crimes. This is wildly disruptive and will be an absolute negative for European technology. All in the name of nebulous "safety" concerns, "data protection", and protecting copyright.
- randunel 3y ago> overnight an unknown set of existing github repositories will become illegal in the EU Overnight? Is this proposal not known ahead of time? Is it being kept a secret until enters into force suddenly, at midnight? > These companies are not trying to take something from you but are in fact trying to give something to you. Copyrighted materials have been stolen, and that's exactly why the creators are keeping secrets, and exactly why they're trying to influence people like you into lobbying on their behalf.
- PeterStuer 3y agoDirect link to the position paper https://huggingface.co/blog/assets/eu_ai_act_oss/supporting_OS_in_the_AIAct.pdf https://huggingface.co/blog/assets/eu_ai_act_oss/supporting_...
- oytis 3y agoI would appreciate a read about people behind EU technology regulation rage. Are there any specific lobbying group behind that or is it just some form of collective thinking? I might be bad at web search, but I couldn't find a single human name on EU AI act - and, FWIW, GDPR.
- nologic01 3y agoIts a shadowy groupthink behavior that encompasses the european parliament, the eu member state government executive branches and the EU commission itself (as all must agree for EU wide legislation). A cunning trick to spread responsibility widely so that you can not hold anybody to account. I believe they call it democracy or some other such arcane and outdated term.
- oytis 3y agoDemocracy requires transparency about how decisions are made, so that I could vote based on whether I support representative's and parties' actions. E.g. if a law is proposed in German parliament it's pretty much open information who introduced it, who objected with what arguments, who supported it with what arguments etc. Either I am missing something or EU structures are much less transparent
- nologic01 3y agohttps://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/ https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/ and other similar links. There is vast amount of transparency available online, even in real time. Certainly who proposes what, which party groups vote for what etc. Its not perfect but you original comment way of the mark.
- pravus 3y agoIt is the iron law of oligarchy.
- troupo 3y ago> I might be bad at web search, but I couldn't find a single human name on EU AI act - and, FWIW, GDPR. Because you're bad at search I believe. 1. Many laws "don't have a human face" because they are more often than not the result of committees working for several years. Who then presents the law in the parliament is largely irrelevant. Do you believe US laws have a human face? 2. If you go to https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20230505IPR84904/ai-act-a-step-closer-to-the-first-rules-on-artificial-intelligence https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20230505IP... you can do the following: - click on "Legislative train" to see people: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/theme-a-europe-fit-for-the-digital-age/file-regulation-on-artificial-intelligence https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/theme-a-eur... - click on "Draft reports, amendments tabled in committee" and see people: https://emeeting.europarl.europa.eu/emeeting/committee/en/agenda/202305/LIBE https://emeeting.europarl.europa.eu/emeeting/committee/en/ag... And there you can click on each person and see who they are and where they come from.
- nologic01 3y agoCeteris-paribus, i.e for the same amount of "application risk", an open source model should actually be a less risky position than a proprietary model. Even more so if the dataset on which it was trained is also public. But on the other hand, being open source does not by itself negate the risks emerging when applying models in sensitive domains. So if played right, open source AI should have a regulatory edge. But not a free pass.
- onlypositive 3y agoGitHub? Ah, they owned by Microsoft? Microsoft not speaking up?
- nrvn 3y agoIs it only me who finds the term “AI” misleading? What we have been dealing so far with is large neural networks that are amusing, unusual, are great at mimicking humans but that’s it. Intelligence is not the ability to respond to queries and entertain laymen. My natural intelligence does not sit idle waiting for some kind of a master to come and tell me what to do. This is chatgpt 3.5: - When noone sends queires to you what do you do? - When there are no queries to respond to, I remain idle and await new questions or prompts from users like you. Feel free to ask anything you'd like, and I'll be here to assist you! Why should I be worried about it? On the other hand, all these amusement boxes must be transparent and open source or auditable. And standards and criteria for audit and assessment must be clear.