2 ms·
The researchers don't have a trusted relationship with schools. They have a contractual relationship with the state government. The fundamental issues underlyin
by nradov 3y ago
The researchers don't have a trusted relationship with schools. They have a contractual relationship with the state government. The fundamental issues underlying the lawsuit are First Amendment freedom of expression and contract law; expert witness fees and researchers' motives are irrelevant.
Whether student data de-identification is good enough or not is a total red herring. No one has accused the researchers in this case of violating privacy rules. The comments here about such privacy issues are largely hypothetical and tangential.
If you think that California needs a new law expanding research access to educational data then feel free to suggest that to your state legislators, or sponsor a ballot initiative.
- ke88y 3y agoLOL what? I'm so confused. It's not a red herring. It's a side conversation about a different but related topic. Someone proposed just releasing all the data. Someone else replied with why that wouldn't work. Ie, a conversation happened and the topic of discussion shifted. FWIW I agree with you on the object level question. No idea why you're being so abrasive, especially when you're the one who initiated/continued the conversational thread about deanonymization and even prefaced with "We're getting a little off topic here". Presumably at that point you understood that the topic of conversation had shifted, and people's agreement/disagreement didn't necessarily have anything to do with the original topic... since you literally said so and no one disagreed... so your reaction here is pretty odd and off-putting.
- gopher_space 3y agoNeutral bystander here, I didn’t get any of that from op.