3 ms·

I'm shocked at folks' willingness to use a browser that has a history of tampering with a user's URL input (among other shenanigans). See https://news.ycombinat

I'm shocked at folks' willingness to use a browser that has a history of tampering with a user's URL input (among other shenanigans). See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23442027&p=2 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23442027&p=2 for more. That's the bare minimum a browser is expected to do. Not touch my URLs.

constantcrying 3y ago
>See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23442027&p=2 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23442027&p=2 for more. Did you read the comments?
NayamAmarshe 3y ago
A few things: - It was a URL auto-suggestion bug. - It was fixed in a day after release. - The PR is on GitHub, this isn't a closed source browser. - The bug appeared when Brave was like a few months old. - The URLs that were being overwritten were only a few crypto exchange websites that partnered with Brave. The affiliate URL was supposed to be a suggestion but the bug made it overwrite the URL. - The affiliate program was shutdown right after the PR was merged. - Nothing of that sort happened again. - Even the CEO apologized for an issue that was blown way out of proportions.
- halJordan 3y ago
  Thats the joke, they changed the browser to harm the user and help the business. You and them have the gumption to act like wei isnt the same thing they've been shipping.
- syncbehind 3y ago
  > The URLs that were being overwritten were only a few crypto exchange websites that partnered with Brave. The affiliate URL was supposed to be a suggestion but the bug made it overwrite the URL. I'm sure the outcry from folks who recognized this was happening did not have anything to do with the affiliate program being canned and this 'bug' being patched ASAP. It's quite an egregious thing for a browser to screw up. That kind of trust can't be bought back by saying "Nothing of that sort happened again", because now that statement is permanently "Nothing of that sort happened again...yet" because that trust is gone. If this issue wasn't "blown way out of proportions", one can only theorize how how long this bug would have stayed. The way I see it, the CEO apologizing is basically an apology that they got caught with their hand in the cookie jar.
  - NayamAmarshe 3y ago
    and yet everybody seems fine with advertisements in the address bar on Firefox, Chrome, Edge and other browsers. Brave is the only mainstream browser right now that is not serving ads in the address bar. So before anybody has a problem with a bug that was fixed a couple of years back, they should be talking about their favorite bug-free browser.
    - syncbehind 3y ago
      I am not here to engage in whataboutisms. This was my critique on Brave, not my critique on every other browser. Do you work for Brave? Otherwise, I am unsure why you are being this defensive.
phone8675309 3y ago
[flagged]
sam_goody 3y ago
Chrome does a lot of tampering to the URL, and people seem fine with that. Even when they were redirecting to AMP pages, and hiding the prefix so you couldn't tell, it barely elicited a yawn. But, yeah, I agree that you should use FF and not Brave.
- NayamAmarshe 3y ago
  Firefox and all the other browsers serve ads in the address bar. Brave is the only mainstream browser that doesn't do that.

constantcrying 3y ago

>See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23442027&p=2 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23442027&p=2 for more. Did you read the comments?

NayamAmarshe 3y ago

A few things: - It was a URL auto-suggestion bug. - It was fixed in a day after release. - The PR is on GitHub, this isn't a closed source browser. - The bug appeared when Brave was like a few months old. - The URLs that were being overwritten were only a few crypto exchange websites that partnered with Brave. The affiliate URL was supposed to be a suggestion but the bug made it overwrite the URL. - The affiliate program was shutdown right after the PR was merged. - Nothing of that sort happened again. - Even the CEO apologized for an issue that was blown way out of proportions.

halJordan 3y ago
Thats the joke, they changed the browser to harm the user and help the business. You and them have the gumption to act like wei isnt the same thing they've been shipping.
syncbehind 3y ago
> The URLs that were being overwritten were only a few crypto exchange websites that partnered with Brave. The affiliate URL was supposed to be a suggestion but the bug made it overwrite the URL. I'm sure the outcry from folks who recognized this was happening did not have anything to do with the affiliate program being canned and this 'bug' being patched ASAP. It's quite an egregious thing for a browser to screw up. That kind of trust can't be bought back by saying "Nothing of that sort happened again", because now that statement is permanently "Nothing of that sort happened again...yet" because that trust is gone. If this issue wasn't "blown way out of proportions", one can only theorize how how long this bug would have stayed. The way I see it, the CEO apologizing is basically an apology that they got caught with their hand in the cookie jar.
- NayamAmarshe 3y ago
  and yet everybody seems fine with advertisements in the address bar on Firefox, Chrome, Edge and other browsers. Brave is the only mainstream browser right now that is not serving ads in the address bar. So before anybody has a problem with a bug that was fixed a couple of years back, they should be talking about their favorite bug-free browser.
  - syncbehind 3y ago
    I am not here to engage in whataboutisms. This was my critique on Brave, not my critique on every other browser. Do you work for Brave? Otherwise, I am unsure why you are being this defensive.

phone8675309 3y ago

[flagged]

sam_goody 3y ago

Chrome does a lot of tampering to the URL, and people seem fine with that. Even when they were redirecting to AMP pages, and hiding the prefix so you couldn't tell, it barely elicited a yawn. But, yeah, I agree that you should use FF and not Brave.

NayamAmarshe 3y ago
Firefox and all the other browsers serve ads in the address bar. Brave is the only mainstream browser that doesn't do that.