7 ms·
Automakers try to scuttle Massachusetts ‘right to repair’ law
- not2b 3y agoWe (in the US) need a national right to repair law. There are too many legal tactics companies can use to defeat state laws.
- sidewndr46 3y agoBS? I thought at least one Federal agency suggested that compliance is in fact a Federal crime.
- ceejayoz 3y agoI was not aware of this. Citation: https://www.thedrive.com/news/feds-tell-automakers-to-ignore-massachusetts-right-to-repair-law https://www.thedrive.com/news/feds-tell-automakers-to-ignore...
- 1MachineElf 3y agoIf only it were that simple... The federal agency is NHTSA. The lawyer there who signed the letter about it being a federal crime is Kerry E. Kolodziej. Kolodziej also works at Mayer Brown, the same law firm that fought in court against the Massachusetts law on behalf of Alliance for Automotive Innovation. It is believed the NHTSA letter to automakers was a veiled attempt to circumvent the court battle. It fits squarely into the BS category, subcategory Monumental. Tagged with Regulatory Capture.
- tetrep 3y agoHere's a source to support some of the above the above claims (including a link to PDF of NHTSA letter): https://www.techspot.com/news/99079-biden-administration-car-companies-ignore-right-repair-law.html https://www.techspot.com/news/99079-biden-administration-car... There's some interesting context missing from the explanation too, which is that apparently the feds were consulted years ago and they said "it's fine." The Massachusetts Right to Repair Coalition's response to the NHTSA letter: On behalf of two million voters and thousands of independent auto repair shops across Massachusetts, we are outraged by the unsolicited, unwarranted, and counterproductive letter from NHTSA that conflicts with the Department of Justice's statement submitted two years ago in federal court stating that there was no federal preemption. NHTSA's letter is irresponsible, having been transmitted without any new evidence and after the conclusion of the federal trial, despite having been asked by the judge to participate in the court proceeding and declining. NHTSA's letter fails to acknowledge the evidence and testimony presented at the trial that demonstrated the viability and security of an open access platform. This is yet another delay tactic the manufacturers are using to thwart the will of their customers, Massachusetts voters who voted 75-25 in favor of their right to get their car repaired where they choose. The FTC, the Biden Administration, and many members of Congress have all come out in support of Right To Repair.
- RealityVoid 3y agoCurrent cybersecurity standards enforced in the automotive industry will probably completely kill the possibility of after-market car parts and the usage of used parts in cars. I say this as someone working in this field that has asked a couple of people doing work in this exact direction. I point blank asked them if this will happen, and they just shrugged their shoulders and said... yeah, kinda'.
- technofiend 3y agoFrom the article: "federal regulators claim that malevolent third parties could "utilize such open access to remotely command vehicles to operate dangerously, including attacking multiple vehicles concurrently." Which really means auto makers built a terribly insecure system and hope to hide the fact behind security as obscurity? If so, that's the real problem. The vulnerabilities described should not be there in the first place.
- RealityVoid 3y agoIt's an open secret in the industry that the CAN bus is not authenticated. If you connect, you can read the data on the bus and inject the data on bus. But, that does require physical access to the car and hooking to the wires. Nobody complains that if you hook to the buses on a PC you can own it. Now they have this security concept where every ECU on the car will have their own private key in their own secure enclave. You need that key to put authenticated data on bus and it can only be updated by the OEM's. The authenticated bus infra will probably not protect against remote attacks ( since if you own the ECU SW you have the cert and you will still be able to publish signed messages) but will kill ability to change HW. I really would not like to kill our ability to fix our vehicles but I feel this is the thing that is going to happen.
- harambae 3y ago> Now they have this security concept where every ECU on the car will have their own private key Not just a concept, on vehicles you buy today (from, for example, Ford and VW) https://cdn.vector.com/cms/content/products/VectorCAST/Events/Symposiums/4_Securing_Communications_-_Things_I_Wish_Someone_Had_Told_Me.pdf https://cdn.vector.com/cms/content/products/VectorCAST/Event...
- forgetfreeman 3y agoHere's a hot take: legislate an airgap between operation control and infotainment/convenience horseshit.
- Loughla 3y agoExactly. The infotainment bullshit should be in zero way connected to the actual operation of the vehicle. There is zero reason why the laggy, nonsensical software that controls my radio should control my engine. Someone correct me if I am wrong, please.
- sidewndr46 3y agoThe reason is optimizing for lower cost.
- PeterisP 3y agoIt's not as simple. For example, look at the distance sensors used for parking and the data coming from them over the CAN bus. That bus needs to be able to (at least indirectly) reach the brakes so that automatic emergency braking can take their measurements as inputs. And that bus needs to be able to reach the audio system to provide audible feedback to the driver when parking, and also mute the radio. Ergo, you have a bus that reaches both brakes and radio. Now, you might want to prevent the radio firmware from sending data to the brakes over that bus, but physically you have to have a connection between them, as we don't really want to make many separate buses for reasons of complexity, cost and maintenance; moving from a separate end-to-end wire for each specific purpose towards a shared bus was a great improvement.
- RealityVoid 3y agoCurrent cars usually have gateways that route messages around different busses. This would protect you from having unwanted messages arriving on secured buses, but pass through the wanted messages.
- Tangurena2 3y ago
- teeray 3y ago> For now, Massachusetts’ law is tied up by lobbying and legal fisticuffs. It’s depressing that the will of the people that passed this ballot measure can get pre-empted like this. Before it passes? Sure. But afterward you’re just disenfranchising the voters.
- brnaftr361 3y agoDirect democracy is a threat to order, the unwashed masses know nothing, they're protecting us. I think the saddest part is there probably isn't an auto manufacturer that isn't a participant in the lobbying campaign against bills like this. I can't even vote with my wallet in this situation. At this point I'm hoping I'll be able to buy an electric kit car that can satisfy my minimal needs in the near future so I don't have to deal with modern vehicles and their shithead manufacturers.
- burkaman 3y agoYou can vote with your wallet by either not buying a car or only buying used cars.
- bethly 3y agoDirect democracy is easier to buy than representative democracies for two reasons: first, voters have other things to do with their time than become experts on every bit of law that comes before them. And second, they don’t have the ongoing interest in rule-making, implementation & enforcement an interested legislator does. Reading the book Street Level Bureaucrats was eye-opening for me on why seemingly “common-sense” solutions like Direct Democracy end up either just not working or having the opposite of the intended effect. Laws are less like writing software for a computer and more like designing processes for a team writing software.
- mrguyorama 3y agoState governments pretty regularly ignore citizen initiatives if they don't like it. Our state voted to decriminalize weed and our republican governor filibustered it for the remaining 4 years he was in office and even the democrat governor who replaced him took her sweet time. Right now if you look it up, GOP state governments are working hard to kill the ability for citizens to enact initiatives that could allow them to implement things they want that the state representatives do not want.
- markdeloura 3y agoInsurance companies should get behind Right to Repair. We've so far waited three months and have an $11,0000 price tag to the insurance company on a minor collision that bent our car's front fascia and broke a sensor -- no frame or metal damage. I would have happily repaired on my own if possible just to avoid being without the car for so long. If only I could get those parts and have a decent service manual.
- vlovich123 3y agoInsurance companies (of any kind) are not incentivized to find the cheapest service. Anything they pay out is passed on via premiums. Indeed, the more expensive service is better because a 2% profit on $1000 makes them 10x more profit than 2% profit on $100. There’s some competition here in that a marketplace of insurance companies can compete on the premiums so there can be downward pressure, sometimes. But for things that impact all insurance companies like this equally, then insurance companies would also be opposed because more expensive repairs = more money in their pocket. That’s why you see things like medical insurance not being aligned with lowering medical costs.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoThe facts in your post are wrong. Insurance companies establish rigorous processes to steer repairs to the low cost provider and push that provider to make only necessary repairs. Policy holders might go along with it and might not, same as other insurance scenarios.
- kwhitefoot 3y ago> steer repairs to the low cost provider and push that provider to make only necessary repairs. That's not my experience in the UK and Norway. At least with the good insurance companies. I creased the rear passenger door of my Tesla S in the UK three years ago. It was purely cosmetic damage confined to a 10 cm diameter area at the front bottom corner. My Norwegian insurance paid 4 kUSD for a new door skin and a repaint of almost the whole side of the car at the Tesla recommended body shop and ten days of car rental. It's interesting to see how such things differ from country to country and insurer to insurer.
- axus 3y agoThe car keys should probably contain the master private key , and the mechanic could use that to authorize third-party components and modifications to the car.
- VectorLock 3y agoThere is no simple and secure technical reason car makers can't do this, they just want to fight it because they make tons of money off making fragile cars, charging exorbitant fees at their dealers service department and for parts, and they see MA's Right to Repair bill as a threat to their revenue stream and how much they can extract from customers while providing no value back to them.
- josephcsible 3y agoWhat would people do when they lose their keys? Isn't that a common thing?
- FloatArtifact 3y agoWhy can't the owner set up their own private key when the car is purchased or transfer ownership? It's the owner that needs it protection from unauthorized use and not the manufacturer.
- COGlory 3y agoRight to repair os starting to reach a boil. The car companies have lost. The combat has changed and they're well on their back foot. The sooner they realize this, the less painful it will be for them. Legal loopholes and dirty tactics will only get them so far now.