6 ms·
Waymo puts the brakes on self-driving trucks program
- londons_explore 3y agoBrings their potential market from $$$$$$$ to just $$. Transportation is a huge industry compared to just ridehailing (which is perhaps just 1% by value). And investors care about potential market size.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoI don't know where you're getting your numbers from, but I'm privy to internal industry estimates for both. The TAM for consumer transportation is vastly larger than commercial logistics, and you can address large/profitable parts of the latter market with solutions designed for the former. Both markets could probably be made profitable, but their consumer transportation efforts are further along. If you have to cut one, trucking is the better choice.
- Loughla 3y agoI'm assuming that consumer transportation also includes train, plane, and boat. The OP talked about ride-hailing/car transportation like cabs and what-not. Those are two vastly different things. Unless you're saying that self-driving cars/personal vehicles will replace the other things?
- fullshark 3y agoYeah i think they are including personal vehicles. Presumably the tech could be licensed to car manufacturers, I can see a lot of potential there. Not so sure about "we are going to turn all car owners into ride hailers."
- algo_trader 3y agoWhich do you think has a stronger moat? I have a toy model for e-trucking + autonomy + middle mile. But its a long hard slog to roll out (ha! pun!)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bluGill 3y agoMaybe. Or maybe a focus can get something working sooner and then they can expand back. Transport is a larger market, but it may be harder (obvious: transport implies backing the truck/trailer up to the loading dock, rideshare can avoid that - though the above is just a guess)
- bastawhiz 3y agoWaymo doesn't really need investors. And they're arguably at the very bleeding edge of self driving tech (at least in terms of quality). I can't see anyone else dominating the self driving truck market in the meantime.
- avree 3y agoI was on the founding team of a transportation company. Personal transit is projected to be a much larger industry than what you are calling "transportation" which is actually "freight/commercial logistics", and is already growing faster.
- alphabetting 3y agoI doubt this was a major factor but the optics and blowback from unions that come with putting truckers out of work are a lot worse than uber drivers.
- darkclouds 3y agoI could believe the union force, but Waymo have a controlled environment in which to carry on testing, namely depots. Alot have their own purpose built shunter's a specially adapted vehicle to pick up trailers and put them on the loading bays, and to take them off. Why do these exist? A lot of truck drivers cant reverse onto a bay to save their life! The depot will already have copious amounts of cctv in which to enhance the AI driving systems, whilst also being able to keep track of all trailers coming into the yard and leaving via a gatehouse. So just like warehouses have become automated, to me, it seems like the next step in automation is to handle the trailer movements in the depot. They will still need a human, to wind up or down the wheels, and plug the air in, when moving a trailer on or off the bay, but the warehouse can get busy at peak time, and the demand for a shunter to move trailers off the bay so the warehouse doesnt slow down is a real need.
- kotaKat 3y agoThat's where Phantom Auto pivoted to. They moved away from most on-road products even though they're under development and turned over to driving terminal tractors and forklifts remotely.
- sfpotter 3y agoJust use freight trains. Way more efficient.
- squarepizza 3y agoAnd instead of robotaxis, just invest in public transport. AVs exemplify technosolutionism: technology solving a problem caused by a prior technology.
- simmonmt 3y agoMy goodness are those "just"s doing a lot of work.
- squarepizza 3y agoLess than AVs "just" being a few years away.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoGadgetbahn: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gadgetbahn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gadgetbahn
- soco 3y agoWaymo is an US company and public transport is not really a thing in the US, so they'd probably struggle to find funding for that. In Switzerland autonomous buses are being tested already since 2016 on different locations as pilot projects: https://www.astra.admin.ch/astra/en/home/topics/intelligente-mobilitaet/pilotversuche/erkenntnisse-aus-pilotversuchen.html https://www.astra.admin.ch/astra/en/home/topics/intelligente...
- aiisjustanif 3y ago> Waymo is an US company and public transport is not really a thing in the US, so they'd probably struggle to find funding for that. I think that is the point, we should be doing better by the citizens.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoI see 18 wheelers do illegal maneuvers all the time, but as a society we understand that they have no better option most of the time. If I had to encode things like "park in a busy street" and "pull out into the road even though cars are still coming," and document that as company policy/codebase, I think I might get a bit nervous.
- warning26 3y agoThe robotaxis struggle with dropoffs and pickups for this reason I think. In a dense city, there’s often nowhere you can legally stop. Real taxi drivers will often just stop in the middle of the street, or double park temporarily.
- twic 3y agoWalking home the other day, i saw a taxi which had stopped to pick up on the northeast corner of a crossroads. The passengers were taking their time. A southbound bus was trying to turn off that corner, but couldn't, because of the taxi, so it pulled out into the street and waited. Then the lights changed, and traffic started coming from the east and west; the traffic from the west piled up behind the stopped bus, and a vehicle in the traffic from the east wanted to turn north, and got stopped by the stopped traffic. The entire junction was filled with immobile vehicles because one taxi had stopped. In the UK, this is legal. Black cabs can stop wherever they like to pick up and set down. It's an extraordinary privilege.
- _ea1k 3y agoAt some point, we will need to define which of the illegal maneuvers are expected vs which ones are unexpected. In the mean time, I expect a lot of lawsuits and weird insurance decisions.
- taneq 3y agoThis is why you have a human driver do the “busy local street” part and then have the truck drive itself for the “follow the speed limit on an almost-featureless highway for 16 hours” part.
- JimtheCoder 3y agoI don't follow this space, so forgive me for the ignorance... But, wouldn't interstate trucking be one of the easiest self driving applications? Use a driver to get the truck onto the interstate, pull over to the shoulder, set truck in autonomous mode, get out, truck drives close to destination on interstates only, pulls over to shoulder, human driver gets back in... Seems like a good stop gap solution... --- Edit: So, maybe not the shoulder, but even a truck stop or an easy to navigate to area. Basically, removing the complexity of surface streets...
- Kon-Peki 3y agoIf you plan to regularly drop people off on the side of the interstate, your business insurance is probably going to eat up any cost savings...
- leetcrew 3y agothe shoulder of the interstate is not a parking lane. merging back into traffic from the shoulder is one of the riskier maneuvers in driving, and leaving an unprotected human there is even worse. it's okay to pull onto the shoulder from time to time when there's a legitimate need, but it shouldn't be SOP for every trip.
- ziml77 3y agoThat's not how the shoulder of the road is meant to be used. You can pull into it for emergencies but it is illegal to stop there otherwise.
- reaperducer 3y agoThat's not how the shoulder of the road is meant to be used. The shoulder has many uses, depending on where the road is located. In Chicagoland, Pace transit buses use the shoulder, and have giant "Authorized to use the shoulder" signs on them. In the southeast, driving in the shoulder lanes is encouraged during evacuations, and they're painted with hurricane symbols. Shoulders can be easily repurposed for other uses. Never assume that where you are is how things are everywhere.
- 3y ago
- seltzered_ 3y agoWorth noting remote trucking startups like Starsky Robotics have also shut down (2020): https://medium.com/starsky-robotics-blog/the-end-of-starsky-robotics-acb8a6a8a5f5 https://medium.com/starsky-robotics-blog/the-end-of-starsky-...
- navi0 3y agoOne has to imagine the build, test, release iteration cycle for consumer-grade transportation is quicker than commercial trucking. Most trucks have an expected life of 30-40yrs vs 3-10yrs for passenger vehicles (yes, the used auto market exists but luxury buyers always buy the new model). Electrification is a major component in any fleet-based strategy going forward, and that’s going to happen quicker on passenger vehicle platforms than commercial trucks as well. Also, the potential damage and liability differential between a 90,000lb freight truck and a 4000lb passenger vehicle has to factor in, too. All collisions and fatalities are unfortunate, but better to limit the liability early on in the scaling phase and come back to commercial trucking later once the company and tech are further along.
- gazelle21 3y agoAnyone who actually has experience with 18 wheelers knew this was never going to work. A lot of my extended family own or operate big rigs. I have been along for a few rides, and it is shocking the amount of focused multi tasking it takes to operate one of those leviathans. I rode for a week with an uncle in in my early 20's, I was lost in life and thought maybe being a truck driver would be a good choice. In a single week I witnessed, multiple near fatal collision's that had my uncle not been 100% locked in to the road he would have caused. Everything from people texting on the highway at 70+ miles, a person almost crossed 4 lanes of traffic to not miss an exit, and they were applying make up at the same time, people cutting in front him with literal inches away, people don't understand the sheer weight of these vehicles and can't comprehend why they can't break like they do. Funny enough, he preferred the highways vs normal roads. Highway traffic was somewhat predictable even with all of the insane issues, but normal roads ? Try moving an 18 wheeler through a residential neighborhood (yes hn this was the only way) or pull out of a Wallmart, those were those most dangerous maneuvers.