6 ms·
Insect memories may not survive metamorphosis
- amelius 3y agoSo from the insect's perspective, this is like dying?
- rf15 3y agoNow I wonder what it's like for sea stars and sea urchins as they grow from their larval bilateral symmetry to the adult 5-way version, in which everything is also reabsorbed/rearranged to an absurd degree.
- mannykannot 3y agoIt is extremely unlikely that these animals have any sense of self, in which case they would be completely unaware of what's happening to themselves.
- _Microft 3y agoWhy is it unlikely in your opinion?
- quonn 3y agoIt‘s unlikely because decades of experiments suggest so and also because it‘s unlikely that animals with a very basic neural system can have a sense of self. The burden of proof is on those claiming differently.
- guerrilla 3y agoThe burden of proof is on anyone claiming anything because the polarity of propositions is irrelevant to standards of proof, which is why you brought up the studies, because you know that intuitively if not formally.
- adammarples 3y agoThat's seems backwards. Everything is highly unlikely, a priori. To say that something isn't unlikely is the assertion which requires evidence.
- simonh 3y agoThere’s been a lot of research on self identification in many species. One paper I’m aware of did an analysis of 50 years worth of research on over 30 species. So we have a fairly decent idea about the development of theory of mind and self identification in animals. For example self identification has only been found in social animals, and lacking in all the solitary animals studied. It seems like there’s a progression from simple organisms with sense/response behaviour but little or no cognitive modelling of the environment. Then organisms that can model and reason about their environment in fairly sophisticated ways. Then some animals develop the ability to model the knowledge, intentions and responses of other creatures. That’s what evolutionary psychologists call theory of mind. Finally there’s development of a sense of self, and then further on the ability to reason about one’s own thoughts, motivations, intentions and cognitive abilities, and act to change those. That’s us. It’s a continuum though, with various species at different points along the line.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quonn 3y agoI would say, subjectively yes, but these insects are incapable of worrying about that. Furthermore, biologically not quite, because they can reproduce with 100% their original DNA afterwards (unlike offspring which has less and less overlap).
- MrBodangles 3y agoHas it even been proven that insects retain “memories” as we know them? The question always leads back to 1 of 2 options. 1) insects are biological robots and their “instinct” is akin to a program executing code based on the I/O of their senses, or 2) the information required to perform their “instinctual” actions is carried genetically. Option 1 has significant implications for humanity; are we just more complex machines who believe we’re different (due to a complexity beyond our understanding), but are ultimately just deterministically executing code like a spider? Are we genetically/chemically pre-determined to learn, think, feel and decay the way we do based on the I/O of our lives, and everything we’ve ever done would be repeated identically if we were rebooted and exposed to the exact same I/O (down to the planck unit). Option 2 indicates more of an inherent “free will”… but even then, are the memories just a more complex form of input, but still inescapably deterministic. Personally, I believe in determinism — that another universe which started in the EXACT same way (down to the most miniscule detail), exposed to the exact sane external forces (if any) would lead through the EXACT same events to the EXACT same end.
- int_19h 3y agoMechanical determinism is actually somewhat orthogonal to free will - a quantum process, for example, is inherently unpredictable, but I don't think that randomness of choices automatically implies free will.
- andrewflnr 3y agoYour 1) and 2) both describe biobots, and neither description relates to memory.
- mock-possum 3y agoYeah I think unfortunately it’s just option 1.
- pfdietz 3y agoI have no clear conception of what "the insect's perspective" is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- getarofilter 3y ago[dead]
- jeffrallen 3y agoKafka was wrong.
- ggm 3y agoYet, across both sides of morphogenesis and reproduction, some remarkably complex behaviour persists: food preferences, predatory and predator evading behaviours, mating, signalling for mating, epigenetic or not, so something cellular and mechanistically related to "memory" in a linguistic sense persists. How is this so? The problem of english: we call it "memory" but it encompasses more than just overt neuronal knowledge acquisition, it includes the gut brain relationship and intracellular activity. Maybe all the things I list are not in fact "memories" but then..
- mannykannot 3y agoWhat you are contemplating here is a question of English-language semantics and usage, not biology. It is commonplace for words previously used in one restricted sense to be adopted to talk about other situations that are merely analogous in some sense. This is useful and probably inevitable, but it does not mean we can take these disparate uses to imply a sameness, where the expanded usage is merely the consequence of a similarity (and sometimes the similarity is quite abstract.) In this case, neuronal information storage and retrieval, which is the biological basis of memory as the word is ordinarily used, is quite different and separable from the genetic storage and use of information.
- ggm 3y agoQuite right. I argue this point frequently in connection with AI. Undoubtedly artificial, no intelligence!
- mannykannot 3y agoThank you for another example of where arguments from language semantics and usage fails to address a complex issue! This example happens to contain all there is to Searle's "Chinese Room" argument.
- weard_beard 3y agoYou just lost, “The Game”.
- derbOac 3y agoI thought it had already been demonstrated that butterflies retain memories acquired premetamorphosis? Eg, https://www.wired.com/2008/03/butterflies-rem/ https://www.wired.com/2008/03/butterflies-rem/ The article is odd because it's written as if this hasn't been tested and it has, or I thought it had. Towards the end they acknowledge butterflies might be different, but don't mention any of the prior research at all. The whole article is structured very strangely given the existing literature.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stevenwoo 3y agoIt is odd they don't mention that paper, but there is a caveat buried near the bottom in about prior studies showing it in higher insects and how fly brains are more primitive than butterflies. IIRC only about 2/3 to 3/4 of butterflies of the type tested retained the aversion response, and only if they were of a certain age - they needed to have certain cells developed in caterpillar form to be able to remember. It is possible that the species they studied simply does not retain memories or that they missed the development window or that the method they used would not detect memories - the butterfly study showed aversion behavior to smell, this one does not measure behavior at all - it's possible that some behavior was retained but they did not measure it, though I think the particular cells they studied in flies is the same one the butterfly studies relied upon existing to work. Off the top of my head, monarch butterflies taking multiple generations to travel up and down the west coast to and from Mexico each year implies if not conscious memory as we think of it, some sort of genetic imprint of how and where to travel that is mind blowing to me.
- taneq 3y agoTo sidetrack the original story slightly, and not aimed at this particular paper, but this kind of chicanery is what made me give up on academia. The basic foundation of academic science is sound enough, but this style of cooking results by omitting critically relevant comparisons or including semi-irrelevant approaches just because they make yours look good is pervasive and unbearable.
- momirlan 3y agomore importantly : does their soul survive metamorphosis ?
- Juliate 3y agoFirst, you need to define what a soul is, and how to spot one.
- romusha 3y agoSomehow reminds me of that story where our form right now is actually human larvae form, and we'll metamorphosize into "adult" humans once we eat the "apple of eden"
- falcor84 3y agoThat's interesting. I'll just nitpick that the bible never actually mentions an apple, but rather "the fruit ... of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil ... the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened, and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil". I suppose this could actually fit your story very well, except for the fact that the biblical story is considered aetiological - we are the way we are now *because* our ancestors ate that fruit.
- robinduckett 3y agoThe OC is maybe referring to Larry Niven’s ring world, in which a race of humanoids called the Pak which resemble real life elderly people, only with armoured joints and immortal, have a life cycle where their offspring are humans. Once reaching old age, pheromones given off by a certain type of tree that bear a fruit similar to an apple, cause the humans to be overcome until they eat the fruit, at which time they metamorphize into an adult Pak, increasing intelligence massively and lifespan. In the book, the humans of earth stay as the larval stage as the “Tree of Life” were never planted (or never produced the correct fruit, I can’t recall) on our planet as there wasn’t the right kind of minerals to support it. The Pak went about colonising planets and they left their offspring on earth when they discovered radiation coming from the centre of the galaxy that was changing the genetic makeup of their offspring, causing the adult Pak to murder their own offspring and all sorts of wars. The Pak built a massive ringworld (think Halo) because that’s easier than colonising a planet apparently, but their offspring started to mutate wildly into different offshoots of humans, pygmies, humans with gills, etc. It’s a good series and enjoyable to read but it’s not a particularly serious story. One of the aliens is depicted as being some sort of hand puppet with legs. Super odd stuff.
- andrewflnr 3y ago
- wonderwonder 3y agoAs a lay person, Metamorphosis is the strangest biological process I am aware of. Somehow they have evolved to almost completely break down and then reform as a new creature. How did something like this even come to be? Just a fascinating process that I struggle to understand. Insects, specifically social insect as a whole are just incredibly interesting to me as far as how completely alien they are to us.
- sandworm101 3y agoHuman embryos go through some crazy changes too. Parts grow and are reabsorbed (tails). Many animals also shed hard exoskeletons regularly (lobsters, spiders). That involves softening up the inner animal. Perhaps that was a part-way step towards full metomorphosis.
- usrusr 3y agoAnother interesting perspective is to look at it not as a more elaborate form of exoskeleton shedding, but as hatching from a very sophisticated egg.
- derefr 3y agoOr as similar to a two-generation-cycle parasite that alternates between a host-A form creating eggs that grow into a host-B form (creating eggs that grow into a host-A form, etc.) The pupa internally "gestates" the adult as a parthenogenetic clone-child; the adult being gestated, absorbs the pupal parent's entire body for nutrients — and, crucially, the pupal parent's body allows this absorption of its entire body, producing no immune response to it, because they have the same DNA. As with a cyclic parasite, you get two different complete lifecycles, that are each born, live, and die from the same genetic program, given a different epigenetic kickstart, in a back-and-forth cycle.
- cvwright 3y agoThis sounds strangely similar to the code for the Morris worm.
- bennyschmidt 3y ago> Insect memories That time a flea saw the Eiffel Tower - gone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ryanblakeley 3y agoThe title of the article says "Insect", the first few paragraphs are about lacewings, but the study being cited only looked at fruit flies. The study didn't test memory. It looked at neuron location and activation, which could indicate something about memory, but that's a journalistic leap.
- retrocryptid 3y agoTo be fair, most human politician's memories don't survive election, so let's not go throwing stones in that glass house.
- seeknotfind 3y agoHow do we know metamorphosis evolved from a single organism, as opposed to a parasitic relationship (like mind controlling wasps) that developed into these multiple life stages? Has anyone researched the origin?
- koeng 3y agoYou don't even need genetic testing to see holes in that hypothesis (though there is no proof of a parasitic relationship genetically) - it is pretty easy to see phylogenetically the evolution of metamorphosis. Ie, hemimetabolous insects vs homometabolous insects.
- smileykenziekv 3y agoThe way insect brains completely disintegrate and then reconstruct into entirely new neural circuits is simply mind-boggling, and it makes me appreciate the wonders of nature even more.